User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Please stop posting that DE's are to strong
Page:
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Saris

If you discount games against the Houston Hookers(the one gutted team in USA PRO), the current sack leader for the league has 7. In the end game, the system is about right.

Of course an NFL caliber DE playing against a HS JV O-line would get an insane number of sacks. But when the pro's play the pro's you don't see that many sacks at all.



How many yards would an NFL running back with an NFL O-line get against a HS JV defense? How many yards per carry do you think he would average?

Let's take a look at college records
Most rushing yards per game over a season 238.9
Most rushing yards in a season 2,628

Most passing yards in a season 5,833

Most sacks in a season 27


Now NFL
Most sacks in a season 22.5. Number of times over 20 = 4.
Most rushing yards in a season 2,105. Number of times over 2,000 = 3.
Most passing yards in a season 5,084. Number of times over 4,500 = ? (more than 3)


I don't have the time to go look up HS numbers all over the country. However, at just about any level of football, a sack = 100 rushing yards and roughly 280 passing yards.

If the best DEs are getting over 100 sacks because of matchups, then the best HBs should be getting over 10,000 rushing yards and the best QBs should be getting 28,000 passing yards.



My point was that you can't cater the game towards horrible matchups in sub par leagues with poorly built players. If they did you'd never see another sack in the pro leagues unless a team was gutted, the O-line's there are simply too good. And it penalizes the good OT's if just any OT can stop an elite DE consistently, shouldn't the good OT's stand out?

Also, GLB isn't a perfect representation of reality. How many kickers or punters in the NFL can bench press a freight train or are the most confident players on their team, or make as much or more than the QB? How often do pump fakes from a QB cause a corner to stand in place for a second or two with his feet rooted to the ground? Are there corners in the NFL who magically are 30% faster and more agile when playing man to man versus when they're playing a zone? Or safeties who are far faster when the ball carrier is far off than they are at any other time? The list goes on and I'm not complaining, GLB is a good game.

If we try too hard though to turn it into a perfect representation of reality, or try to make all of the players too equal in a football version of Harrison Bergeron with Bort as the Handicapper General, it's going to be the downfall of the game.




 
kr0n
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Rage Kinard



Maybe the Beans should try and schedule them to a scrimmage.


I'm out of invites right now, but if they sent me one, I would surely accept


and proceed to get your teeth kicked in tbh
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
ITT: SteelersInsider still doesnt know WTF he's talking about.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kr0n
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by Rage Kinard




Maybe the Beans should try and schedule them to a scrimmage.


I'm out of invites right now, but if they sent me one, I would surely accept


and proceed to get your teeth kicked in tbh



lol. not quite
 
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
ITT: SteelersInsider still doesnt know WTF he's talking about.


Islander is my stalker. He's madly in love with me. He has to talk about me all the time.
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by Rage Kinard

Originally posted by Saris


If you discount games against the Houston Hookers(the one gutted team in USA PRO), the current sack leader for the league has 7. In the end game, the system is about right.

Of course an NFL caliber DE playing against a HS JV O-line would get an insane number of sacks. But when the pro's play the pro's you don't see that many sacks at all.



How many yards would an NFL running back with an NFL O-line get against a HS JV defense? How many yards per carry do you think he would average?

Let's take a look at college records
Most rushing yards per game over a season 238.9
Most rushing yards in a season 2,628

Most passing yards in a season 5,833

Most sacks in a season 27


Now NFL
Most sacks in a season 22.5. Number of times over 20 = 4.
Most rushing yards in a season 2,105. Number of times over 2,000 = 3.
Most passing yards in a season 5,084. Number of times over 4,500 = ? (more than 3)


I don't have the time to go look up HS numbers all over the country. However, at just about any level of football, a sack = 100 rushing yards and roughly 280 passing yards.

If the best DEs are getting over 100 sacks because of matchups, then the best HBs should be getting over 10,000 rushing yards and the best QBs should be getting 28,000 passing yards.



My point was that you can't cater the game towards horrible matchups in sub par leagues with poorly built players. If they did you'd never see another sack in the pro leagues unless a team was gutted, the O-line's there are simply too good. And it penalizes the good OT's if just any OT can stop an elite DE consistently, shouldn't the good OT's stand out?

Also, GLB isn't a perfect representation of reality. How many kickers or punters in the NFL can bench press a freight train or are the most confident players on their team, or make as much or more than the QB? How often do pump fakes from a QB cause a corner to stand in place for a second or two with his feet rooted to the ground? Are there corners in the NFL who magically are 30% faster and more agile when playing man to man versus when they're playing a zone? Or safeties who are far faster when the ball carrier is far off than they are at any other time? The list goes on and I'm not complaining, GLB is a good game.

If we try too hard though to turn it into a perfect representation of reality, or try to make all of the players too equal in a football version of Harrison Bergeron with Bort as the Handicapper General, it's going to be the downfall of the game.






Nobody's saying they need to completely stop them. If the best built DE's were getting 3 or 4 sacks a game against equal level OTs with bad builds and 1 or 2 sacks a game against same level OTs with decent builds and 0 to 1 sacks against equal level OTs with good builds it would be fine.

However, when OTs have double capped agility and single capped speed and the DEs still run right around them without being touched and get to a QB before he can finish his 3 step drop, sometimes even with a back trying to help the OT block, it is beyond ludicrous.

 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
My OT has given up like 3 or 4 sacks in his career, including these "ridic DE seasons." It's not hard to build to stop them, but the solution ISN'T just to get your agility to 70 and say "omg now I can stop the DEs." There are a lot of things you can do, including utilize the new AI settings, to put DEs in check. We're still having problems with our LOT, though, but working on it with him.
 
kr0n
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by kr0n

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by Rage Kinard





Maybe the Beans should try and schedule them to a scrimmage.


I'm out of invites right now, but if they sent me one, I would surely accept


and proceed to get your teeth kicked in tbh



lol. not quite


those are some nice trophies that the lima beans have wo-

oh wait
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
My OT has given up like 3 or 4 sacks in his career, including these "ridic DE seasons." It's not hard to build to stop them, but the solution ISN'T just to get your agility to 70 and say "omg now I can stop the DEs." There are a lot of things you can do, including utilize the new AI settings, to put DEs in check. We're still having problems with our LOT, though, but working on it with him.



He's having trouble with slow DEs. Hate to see what a fast one did with him.


Here's the slow DE pwning your teams LOT
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219378&pbp_id=1245975

Here is a fast DE
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=219378&pbp_id=1245975


I'd hate to think how many sacks a fast DE would get against your team. Watch those replays. You can start the one where your LOT gives up a sack, then start the other one wait for the sack and go back to the first before the sack happens.

Perhaps one reason your OT isn't giving up sacks is because the RDEs can beat the LOT before the LDEs can beat yours. Plus, if the problem is only with the LOT build why not move your OT to LOT?
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by kr0n
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Maybe the Beans should try and schedule them to a scrimmage.

I'm out of invites right now, but if they sent me one, I would surely accept

and proceed to get your teeth kicked in tbh

lol. not quite


I know last year you seemed to think USA AAA was legit. I gotta stand by my QB on this one... challenge sent.

No playing around with tactics on this one, now - purely bragging rights one way or the other.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Saris

If you discount games against the Houston Hookers(the one gutted team in USA PRO), the current sack leader for the league has 7. In the end game, the system is about right.

Of course an NFL caliber DE playing against a HS JV O-line would get an insane number of sacks. But when the pro's play the pro's you don't see that many sacks at all.



How many yards would an NFL running back with an NFL O-line get against a HS JV defense? How many yards per carry do you think he would average?

Let's take a look at college records
Most rushing yards per game over a season 238.9
Most rushing yards in a season 2,628

Most passing yards in a season 5,833

Most sacks in a season 27


Now NFL
Most sacks in a season 22.5. Number of times over 20 = 4.
Most rushing yards in a season 2,105. Number of times over 2,000 = 3.
Most passing yards in a season 5,084. Number of times over 4,500 = ? (more than 3)


I don't have the time to go look up HS numbers all over the country. However, at just about any level of football, a sack = 100 rushing yards and roughly 280 passing yards.

If the best DEs are getting over 100 sacks because of matchups, then the best HBs should be getting over 10,000 rushing yards and the best QBs should be getting 28,000 passing yards.



+100,000.

The key to balance is maintaining the same balance as in real football.

All the records are going to be broken often each GLB season if things work right, but the key is keeping a balance between by how much they're broken.

Otherwise, OT/DE matchups become an unrealistically large focus of the game.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
Originally posted by Saris

If you discount games against the Houston Hookers(the one gutted team in USA PRO), the current sack leader for the league has 7. In the end game, the system is about right.

Of course an NFL caliber DE playing against a HS JV O-line would get an insane number of sacks. But when the pro's play the pro's you don't see that many sacks at all.



How many yards would an NFL running back with an NFL O-line get against a HS JV defense? How many yards per carry do you think he would average?

Let's take a look at college records
Most rushing yards per game over a season 238.9
Most rushing yards in a season 2,628

Most passing yards in a season 5,833

Most sacks in a season 27


Now NFL
Most sacks in a season 22.5. Number of times over 20 = 4.
Most rushing yards in a season 2,105. Number of times over 2,000 = 3.
Most passing yards in a season 5,084. Number of times over 4,500 = ? (more than 3)


I don't have the time to go look up HS numbers all over the country. However, at just about any level of football, a sack = 100 rushing yards and roughly 280 passing yards.

If the best DEs are getting over 100 sacks because of matchups, then the best HBs should be getting over 10,000 rushing yards and the best QBs should be getting 28,000 passing yards.






You can't make that a linear comparison. A sack is a great performance on a single play. It is physically possible to reach the QB on any or in fact every play. It's not physically possible for WRs to run 28,000 yards in 60 minutes, assuming you had possession of the ball the entire game and successful passed to guys running 'go' routes the entire time.

Should the game be focused on trying to accurately simulate football at the level of how players move during plays, or how the end-of-game stats should look? Because the two aren't necessarily going to be consistent when you have matchups all the time between teams who would never, ever face off against each other in real life. I think gameplay comes first and the stats should follow as a natural outcome. Using stats to guide changes to gameplay seems like a backwards approach to me.

Not saying nothing's broken, just saying it's not a valid assumption that the box score between grossly mismatched teams should be bounded by what we are used to seeing in "normal" competition. All the weird stats show is that something's not right, but they don't necessarily point directly to the root of the issue. One more useful fix to pursue would be to stop wasting limited game opportunities with obvious mismatches that entertain no one. Then not only would we not be having this discussion, but people would have more to look forward to every other day. Another good fix would be to make sure people understand what makes a player effective under different circumstances. That understanding has improved over time but most players made in Seasons 1 and 2 used some extremely bad advice being passed out freely (in many cases by people with Bort's tacit endorsement of a moderator title).

Last offseason's reorg and other relatively recent changes (CPU player improvements, mechanics for selling teams) went a long way toward reaching the goal of competitive scheduling but much remains to be done. And player development gradually improves as people have more of a performance history to judge build advice upon. So it's possible that the box scores being out of whack is an artifact of old problems which are already being addressed effectively. That's why I'd focus any analysis of whether there is a specific gameplay problem on studying how individual plays simulate and not on cherry-picked anomalies in single-game or even season/career statistics. Those are lagging indicators that don't tell you where the problems lie today.
 
kr0n
offline
Link
 
bump for SI to accept the scrimmage from the 'weak' USA AAA #2 team
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.