User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
Agility isn't the "savior" for linemen, you still need speed.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Porch
Originally posted by SCACE

Originally posted by jetsfan0327


I agree that there seems to be no way to combat this which is the real problem. We can't set blocking assignments to double team and the backs don't seem to have the awareness to block instead running right by the rusher as they go out for a pass.
There is still a lot that needs to be implemented to make this sim complete.
I was just pointing out that the DE may just be really good, but I acknowledge every one of your points as truth Warlock (except for the rugby sim comment, we can't lateral the ball yet



You do realize you can choose to keep the back in to block now, right? You can keep the TE, HB and FB in as long as they aren't the primary receiver. Plan accordingly.



You do realize that we only had 3 guys out on the pass play and they rushed 4. We had 7 blockers vs 4 rushers and no one touched him including the HB who does have great speed and agility. Yet no one even seems touch him.

So the solution to stop a 4 man rush takes 8 blockers and they can triple team both WR's?


Similar situation with my team today, as well. Since an OC can't send a TE in motion to block on the weak side (even with GLB's super-effective advances), all a team has to do is have an all out blitz to the defense's right, and an O-line is absolutely powerless to stop it.

Not only that, I was taught as an offensive lineman to shift with the blitz on passing plays. GLB doesn't have a similar concept, because the lines I've been a part of, even with second-capped agility and speed, do not shift to pick up an outside blitz.

Here's a prime example of what an O-line should do: LT-LB, LG-DE, C-DT, HB/FB-chip in for the LT/LG
Here's what GLB does: LT-LB and DE, LG-DT, C-looks up at the sky. HB/FB-stands there feeble and helpless

Just a few beefs I've had lately

Last edited Nov 11, 2008 18:55:38
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
This thread is hilarious, just like every other DE vs OT whine.

And the degree of mis-information being spread around is staggering.

I often wonder if folks are putting this garbage out there to keep people in the dark, or if they really believe the nonsense they are spewing....

lmao!
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
This thread is hilarious, just like every other DE vs OT whine.

And the degree of mis-information being spread around is staggering.

I often wonder if folks are putting this garbage out there to keep people in the dark, or if they really believe the nonsense they are spewing....

lmao!


Hey, I'm the first to jump on people when they post bug issues that are easily attributable to user error, don't get me wrong.
But with the issues I listed above, it's not as much an OT-DE build comparison as it is poor pathing in the AI (like having OLBs blitz to stop an outside run and having them run right into a G or C when they're supposed to go off-tackle) and the lack of seemingly simple additions left out of the AI (like audibling TEs to the weak side to block)
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
SO let me get this right. A lineman needs str, blocking, speed, agility, vision, and some confidence/stamina in the mix. The first 4 past the soft-cap, significantly past it seems. A DE needs speed, agility and a maybe bit of strength though not really. Doesn't really need confidence since never get's touched so morale is fine nor vision since they can pack up in first step and tunnel vision or something.

Hmmm, that equation doesn't seem to work to well. Did I get that right?

Let's see. A lvl 32 OT vs. a lvl 28 DE (none are mine as I don't run either, so I'll just wait for someone to come around and tell me I don't know what I'm talking about because I don't have players at these positions. )

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=250107&pbp_id=1361352

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=250107&pbp_id=1361860

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=250107&pbp_id=1362126

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=250107&pbp_id=1362374

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=250107&pbp_id=1362527

Judging by last seasons stats, this DE had 2 sacks in 16 games. All of a sudden he's superman? Something is seriously out of whack with whatever Bort has done to appease the "don't nerf my DE" crowd.

But, hey, OTs just need more speed! The solution to it all. Maybe Bort should instead make the blocking skill matter more. Make it so that a high blocking allows the OT to get his hands on these elusive superman, unrealistic DEs.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Toriq
But, hey, OTs just need more speed! The solution to it all. Maybe Bort should instead make the blocking skill matter more. Make it so that a high blocking allows the OT to get his hands on these elusive superman, unrealistic DEs.


Wiser words have seldom been spoken. And I'm generally not one to support such things. The blocking skill is NOWHERE near as important as it should be. My first words about the ongoing OT-DE debate.
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 19:03:37
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Wrong.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Wrong.


About what?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cdcollins
Originally posted by tautology

This thread is hilarious, just like every other DE vs OT whine.

And the degree of mis-information being spread around is staggering.

I often wonder if folks are putting this garbage out there to keep people in the dark, or if they really believe the nonsense they are spewing....

lmao!


Hey, I'm the first to jump on people when they post bug issues that are easily attributable to user error, don't get me wrong.
But with the issues I listed above, it's not as much an OT-DE build comparison as it is poor pathing in the AI (like having OLBs blitz to stop an outside run and having them run right into a G or C when they're supposed to go off-tackle) and the lack of seemingly simple additions left out of the AI (like audibling TEs to the weak side to block)


Your comments on the possilities of a more sophisticated O-line blocking algorithm are well taken...though i fear it would unbalance the game.

When my OTs start getting owned by DEs, I *might* join the whining....but more likely I will simply adjust their builds to make them do their job again.

OTs are not broken, DEs are not broken, builds are the problem.
 
Agent Z
offline
Link
 
These Againest a RT

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=861867

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=863591

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=865449

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=865992


These Againest LT same game

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=864244

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=864567


Mind you i own the DE here, i think it's a bit too easy for sacks atm and with changes seems like my guy doing better ...unless these guys builds are really bad =P

Z

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
The biggest problem is that a lot of people know how to build a pretty good DE, but it seems very few people know how to build a good OT.

The number of quality DEs has grown enormously, the number of quality OTs has stayed roughly the same.
 
SWVAHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by cdcollins

Originally posted by tautology


This thread is hilarious, just like every other DE vs OT whine.

And the degree of mis-information being spread around is staggering.

I often wonder if folks are putting this garbage out there to keep people in the dark, or if they really believe the nonsense they are spewing....

lmao!


Hey, I'm the first to jump on people when they post bug issues that are easily attributable to user error, don't get me wrong.
But with the issues I listed above, it's not as much an OT-DE build comparison as it is poor pathing in the AI (like having OLBs blitz to stop an outside run and having them run right into a G or C when they're supposed to go off-tackle) and the lack of seemingly simple additions left out of the AI (like audibling TEs to the weak side to block)


Your comments on the possilities of a more sophisticated O-line blocking algorithm are well taken...though i fear it would unbalance the game.

When my OTs start getting owned by DEs, I *might* join the whining....but more likely I will simply adjust their builds to make them do their job again.

OTs are not broken, DEs are not broken, builds are the problem.


Likewise, your comments are well-taken. I just have a fundamental difference in some philosophies, I suppose.

I don't see a more advanced algorithm for O-line blocking to be as much unbalancing the game as I see it rectifying the game and placing the game in the position it should've been in in the first place. It's rudimentary that an O-Line shifts with the direction of a pass rush. They teach us this in middle school, and we perfect it in high school. GLB does absolutely nothing of the sort, and it leads to DCs just stacking the right side and going for broke with the blitz.

Of course, ideally you'd call a TE or HB screen to counterbalance this, but if your line can't adequately shift and block in the first place, it's all for naught. I don't care if an OT had blocking, strength, agility, speed, vision, and confidence all at the third cap or higher, if an OT is faced with the task of blocking both a LB and DE, the OT will fail 100 out of 100 times. You see this occasionally, but seldom, in RL football as an OLB will come untouched on a blitz. But it happens only when a OT absolutely butchers his blocking assignment, <10% of the time. By NO means as frequently as it does on GLB.

I agree on the whole that builds are the problem. However, I think it's more in the manner Toriq suggested above. All these speed DEs need are bascially slighly-better-than softcapped strength, and massive amounts of speed/agility. An OT has to counterbalance this by putting points into vision, blocking, speed, agility, and confidence. That's a 5-3 disadvantage skewed against the OT, and it's part of (but not the only, for reasons I've stated above) the reason for the whole DE-OT debate. And this is spoken from someone who has a pass-rushing DE and a pass-blocking OT. If this is not changed outright, blocking needs to be made much more a part of the equation. I think it's a bit obtuse that a pass-blocking OT with 75 in blocking, 50 in speed/agility, and 5+ in "Pass Block" and "Protect" can't even slow down a DE with 65 in both speed/agility and 5+ in "First Step" and "Tunnel Vision".
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 19:43:22
 
imking27
offline
Link
 
on the right tackle it looks like somthing to do wtih him lining on the te maybe glitch maybe the ot vision.
 
imking27
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bndmn56
These Againest a RT

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=861867

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=863591

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=865449

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=865992


These Againest LT same game

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=864244

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=262892&pbp_id=864567


Mind you i own the DE here, i think it's a bit too easy for sacks atm and with changes seems like my guy doing better ...unless these guys builds are really bad =P

Z



sorry this is what i meant
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
I have a really hard time understanding all of the crys about the OT's being broke or the the DE's being to good.Our team the Hitmen in 5 seasons of play have given up a total of 27 sacks.We built our OT's the right way from the start and have never had this problem even against the best DT's in our league.One of those recorded 60 sacks in a season but recorded 0 against us.This is not a bug but a build problem and just as soon as people realize that strength and pancake SA's are not the ideal build for an OT the better off the game will be.
Last edited Nov 11, 2008 19:37:18
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.