User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > World Championship Playoff vs. Champions' League
Page:
 
geturembedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Changing regions?


Why not? What's the big deal with changing regions? The lower you finish the less choice you have in where you go.

 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
If the World League happens, I like that system for moving the 8 that don't make it back down.

Thinking about it the Tournament seems easier, but that doesn't mean the World League is bad. I actually like the World League idea too. It would be interesting to see what Region ends up sending the most people up to it and how the best teams around do against each other. People say there is a huge gap between the regions in terms of team quality, something like this would eliminate the speculation and start us on answers.

Further, maybe the league is the better choice too. I say this because teams usually need time to get to know each other and to scout each other. Its much easier and much more accurate to do that in the same league where you play the same teams.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I think it would take way too much shaking up. Besides, in real life, teams who play in international league competitions qualify based on their record in their national league the prior year, but still play in that league at the same time as the international one. If FC Barcelona played in the Champions' League one year instead of La Liga and didn't re-qualify, they wouldn't end up playing in the Italian Serie A the next season.
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I think it would take way too much shaking up. Besides, in real life, teams who play in international league competitions qualify based on their record in their national league the prior year, but still play in that league at the same time as the international one. If FC Barcelona played in the Champions' League one year instead of La Liga and didn't re-qualify, they wouldn't end up playing in the Italian Serie A the next season.


Yeah. It is an awkward way to do it, but I don't mind. However its done I want an overall GLB crown to be created and awarded. Also, while weird it would be kind of fun if a team got knocked out of the World League then shifted into a new region. They'd begin on a new quest to get to the top against new competition. Always nice to shake thing up for the players and GMs like that. Plus you'll get the funny names like Berlin Ballers of Brazilia Brazil if you get thrown around, like from WEPL to World to South America Pro.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
As long as there's an overall GLB champion and a cap to the pyramid, I'd be satisfied. I just think the 3-round playoff would be much less of a mess and wouldn't require the creation of any more leagues or filling in however many holes promotion to a world champions' league would create.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Well thought out, pretty thoroughly discussed, interesting idea.

Might take quite a bit of effort to implement and code it, though. I don't know.
 
cromagnon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nixx
Well thought out, pretty thoroughly discussed, interesting idea.

Might take quite a bit of effort to implement and code it, though. I don't know.



Well, my team is not close to making it pro but it would be a league I would watch closely, watching all the big boys playing each other.
 
geturembedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by

I like the world league better.

1st year all conference champions go.

Next year 8 that make the playoffs stay, 8 that do not go back. Team 9 gets their first choice of which league to go to and down the list, till team 16 goes to the last spot left.

Simple.


Too add to this, even if people don't want to change regions (say stadium issues) there are always enough gutted or sold teams everywhere to where if 5 Africa teams got knocked out of the World League 5 can go back into Africa, and 5 of the now CPU teams that get reset anyway can just go fill out other regions.

I prefer that the number 9 team gets their first choice of new digs, but either way will work.

It will make going to the Pros a fight.

The World Bowl should be held on its own day with plenty of Hype from GLB Radio and a Wikipedia page, with a World Bowl MVP and the works. Interviews with team owners and some agent and coordinator promotion. That can be handled by users and I am sure will be. Front page announcement and everything.


It would be held at a neutral site with revenue and TV share's being split among the winners.

There should be TV type additional revenue to World teams, as well as Pro.

Reason being is that all the highest level players should be in these leagues, and these teams should be able to pay for them.

It would be a source of pride to stay in this league, and when your team managed to get in there and stay you know you have accomplished something.

Hall of Fame Players can eventually come out of this league as all time records can be kept for this league and this one alone.
Even if say a HOF potential RBs team gets kicked out and he is good enough to join another team the following season it should be all good. If you are good enough to play here then more power to you.

And it WOULD be nice to see which conference ends up sending the most teams into it after a few seasons.

Really there is no downside. Oh, and just because soccer teams play two leagues simultaneously doesn't mean football players should. That just should not happen with a world league.
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
I don't think we should change regions. You should stick with the same one you came from; I don't see any point in allowing teams to change.

If people insist on a league format of 4 teams from each region, 2 in each conference (I'd still prefer the 3-round playoff of regional champs), then:
- Have the lowest-placed team from a region play that region's champion for the 4th spot, or
- Have the lowest-placed team from a region replaced with that region's champion for the 4th spot, and the second-lowest-placed team play the region's runner-up for the 3rd spot, or
- Always to relegate at least one from each region so the regional champions could still be promoted, and then relegate the remaining 8 from the bottom-up in exchange for the next highest teams from that region.

I don't think there would be a fair way to do regional-based promotion/relegation with only two teams from each region since it's possible that the two top teams could be from the same region, and each regional champion should be allowed to ascend.
Last edited Jan 14, 2009 12:51:12
 
geturembedder
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
I don't think we should change regions. You should stick with the same one you came from; I don't see any point in allowing teams to change.

If people insist on a league format of 4 teams from each region, 2 in each conference (I'd still prefer the 3-round playoff of regional champs), then:
- Have the lowest-placed team from a region play that region's champion for the 4th spot, or
- Have the lowest-placed team from a region replaced with that region's champion for the 4th spot, and the second-lowest-placed team play the region's runner-up for the 3rd spot, or
- Always to relegate at least one from each region so the regional champions could still be promoted, and then relegate the remaining 8 from the bottom-up in exchange for the next highest teams from that region.

I don't think there would be a fair way to do regional-based promotion/relegation with only two teams from each region since it's possible that the two top teams could be from the same region, and each regional champion should be allowed to ascend.


Yeah but you are talking about a two conference 32 team league.

I was talking about a 16 team league. One world conference and that's it. Of course they would end up only playing 15 games, but hey.

The first season of course all conference champions go to split up the league. After that only league champions move up, and all teams who missed the playoffs move down.

I don't see a downside in letting team number 9 have their first choice of conferences to go to, all the way down to where team 16 gets the last one left. I know it isn't because of team name, because we have all kinds of misplaced team names in every regon.

Besides, it would be fun to clown on the Hong Kong Nunchucks who end up in South America.
And you can see which conference is truly the strongest by how many reps it has in the top 8 year after year.

Anyway, you have the World Bowl on Day 41, the lone sim.

It will be even better if the weather idea gets implemented, and we eventually have geographic weather climates. But that's a long way off.

For now we need a true champion.

It doesn't matter. So long as it's done.
Last edited Jan 14, 2009 17:38:09
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geturembedder
For now we need a true champion.

It doesn't matter. So long as it's done.


I like that attitude.

We could leave it up to the Designer or a site-wide poll if he decides to take notice.
 
geturembedder
offline
Link
 
Actually I just reread what I wrote, yikes. Let me clarify.

I meant that each team would play one team twice.

So the opening week would every one would play their double seed. The team that finished first would play the team that finished second the season before, 3 would play 4, 5 plays 6, and seven plays 8.

The new comers would get a random draw to play twice from a different conference.

That gives the conference 16 games to play.

8 stay 8 go 8 come up. Pretty simple.

As far as Bort taking notice, your idea is here in epic, so there must be something about it he likes.
 
Archeon
offline
Link
 
epic +1
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of each team playing each other twice in the regular season. Also, 16 teams is all I would want to have considered as the supreme elite of GLB. 32 teams is too many. Also, football is about adaptation, be interesting to see what happens in the championship when teams are playing for the third time.

Further, the league structure lends itself to 16 teams. You take 2 from each pro league and that won't cripple them for a while. And injecting 8 teams into the Pro Leagues when you relegate out of the World League is easier to manage.

Finally, changing regions is not the worst thing ever. I feel its safe to assume that teams don't plan on ever returning to their Regions if they make it into the World League.

---------------------------------------------

One thing to add: Ensuring competitive balance.

Come up with an emergency promotion method in case a team in the World League goes CPU and doesn't return after a season. Can include keeping some World League teams around by not relegating them or promoting conference champions from the Pro Leagues via some sort scheme where you try and determine who is best or make it an honest to goodness random choice. There should never ever be a CPU team in the World League.

If someone does something crazy like not selling their team but signing nothing but Level 20s to play their World League games that team can be deemed "unfit" and relegated. This has to be an extreme and utterly obvious case of tanking your team.

------------------------------------

Noting the competitive balance issues.. that's a good argument against a League and in favor of a tournament. Cause that would be a severe head ache.
Last edited Jan 17, 2009 01:34:01
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Whoops. Sorry.
Last edited Jan 17, 2009 01:33:22
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.