User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > FAQ's, Player Guides and Newbie Help > My slow build strategy good?
Page:
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
Jack Del Rio's results are interesting. I think his point is that skills with low natural gains reduce the efficiency of softcapping vs super slow building.

I have a question about your test Jack Del Rio. When did you hit your first cap. I was helping a friend plan a build for a new WR. I noticed while searching open builds for WRs that a new WR created yesterday boosted 3 times to level 4. For some reason this WRs speed rounded up leaving a whole number. While the older WRs who were level 4 had a X.99 for speed.

I wonder if you were able to do this same test but softcap speed at level 4 with 49 with 90% to 99% trained. Then train it one last time to make 50 in speed at level 4. Maybe then the natural gains would be enough to make softcapping more efficient with a skill that has a .33 natural gain.

edited to complete the sentence.


If you do a 3x-chunk boost, it takes 1/3 (0.33333333333333333333) and multiplies that by 3 and then awards you the full 1.00 speed. But with individual level-ups, it'll just give you the rounded version, 0.33. I forgot what a 2x-chunk boost gives you, but I figure it gives 0.67? Not 100% sure, and I've even done this in the past, I just forgot how much it gives loool.

I don't know about your training to 90% suggestion... I guess it has a slight advantage over my First Cap WR, but doesn't it then share the same fate as First Cap, being left to 5SP/level, 0.33/level, and 1SP every 10 days of intense training? It'll get to the third cap sooner than First Cap, and I'm really too lazy to do the math but I don't think it'd get there sooner than Second Cap (it might, who knows? that's why I'm doing this test - but it won't matter if the difference between First Cap and Second Cap is more than 1-2 SP by the time one of them hits the third cap).
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio


If you do a 3x-chunk boost, it takes 1/3 (0.33333333333333333333) and multiplies that by 3 and then awards you the full 1.00 speed. But with individual level-ups, it'll just give you the rounded version, 0.33. I forgot what a 2x-chunk boost gives you, but I figure it gives 0.67? Not 100% sure, and I've even done this in the past, I just forgot how much it gives loool.

I don't know about your training to 90% suggestion... I guess it has a slight advantage over my First Cap WR, but doesn't it then share the same fate as First Cap, being left to 5SP/level, 0.33/level, and 1SP every 10 days of intense training? It'll get to the third cap sooner than First Cap, and I'm really too lazy to do the math but I don't think it'd get there sooner than Second Cap (it might, who knows? that's why I'm doing this test - but it won't matter if the difference between First Cap and Second Cap is more than 1-2 SP by the time one of them hits the third cap).


Ok thanks I did not know that about boosting. So that kind of kills my plans. I think you may be right about the efficiency of super slow building vs softcap building strategies when it comes to skills with low natural gains and if you only work on 1 skill at a time. It will be useful to see the results of all the experiments in this discussion. This is a very interesting discussion IMO.

One other factor that can mess with results is training breakthroughs. They have put a few of my players ahead of schedule which is a good problem to have.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
The main thing that should be taken from this is there's no "train to X level" or "wait until you can get to X cap and then cap" rule. It all depends on the level bonus being out weighed by the training. If training is providing you less SP gain than the level bonus gain it's time to cap. This will be different by build and level and requires agents to run the calculations with leveling estimates.

And Jack, do you mind sharing at what level you soft-capped speed on WR "First Cap"?
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 15:04:49
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
The main thing that should be taken from this is there's no "train to X level" or "wait until you can get to X cap and then cap" rule. It all depends on the level bonus being out weighed by the training. If training is providing you less SP gain than the level bonus gain it's time to cap.

And Jack, do you mind sharing at what level you soft-capped speed on WR "First Cap"?


I don't remember when I soft capped First Cap's speed. You can probably mathematically narrow it down to level 4 or 5. He would have need to train like 3-4 points in speed to cap it at level 4, and I don't know if that's possible on intense, even starting out at 13 speed, I leveled up so damn fast that I was level 4 after not having much of an opportunity to train at all. I just checked my XP log and it was only nine nights from creation date to level 4. There were 3 more nights of XP after that before I hit level 5.

You can probably ask anyone out there how long it takes and get a decent response, I just didn't record the date because it wasn't important to me, didn't seem relevant to the experiment. Just capped it and then continued to pump it.
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 15:24:53
 
DarkVirtue
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FatNasty
I've got a few new players I want to slow build. I have them 1) on CPU teams which will provide 35+ plays/game and 2) have them set for relaxed play intensity, and 3) will train them on intense. 4) I will soft cap skills to 48 ASAP then maybe go to second before training and capping next skill.

Are these four premises sound and productive? Advice?


thats not slowbuilding lol
 
bubbaballin
offline
Link
 
I've never slow-builded before, but I'm thinking of starting with either a WR or HB. Are either of these positions better for slow building? If not, what positions are good for slow building (that is, positions that are either glamour or defense)?
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio

I don't remember when I soft capped First Cap's speed. You can probably mathematically narrow it down to level 4 or 5. He would have need to train like 3-4 points in speed to cap it at level 4, and I don't know if that's possible on intense, even starting out at 13 speed, I leveled up so damn fast that I was level 4 after not having much of an opportunity to train at all. I just checked my XP log and it was only nine nights from creation date to level 4. There were 3 more nights of XP after that before I hit level 5.

You can probably ask anyone out there how long it takes and get a decent response, I just didn't record the date because it wasn't important to me, didn't seem relevant to the experiment. Just capped it and then continued to pump it.


Well, it's relevant to a WR, because the ideal times for a WR to cap a primary is level 4,7,10, etc. This means that if you cap at level 5, you've wasted two levels' worth of training. What I mean is:

Level 1 speed: XX.00
Level 2 speed: XX.33 (+.33 SP from level bonus)
Level 3 Speed: XX.66 (+.33 SP from level bonus)
Level 4 Speed: XX.99 (+.33 SP from level bonus)
Level 5 Speed: XX.32 (+.33 SP from level bonus)
... (and so on)

Since the first cap is 48.07, if you cap at level 5 (to 48.32), you essentially waste two level's worth of training because you can wait and cap at 7 (48.98) without losing any of your level bonus.

If you capped speed on First Cap on a level other than 4 or 7 you've essentially messed up your test. Since you're not sure when you capped it will be hard to correct the error to make up for the missed training. And I don't know how much of an effect this would have on your numbers.

Mathematically to cap at 4 he'd have 13.99 with level bonus so he would need to train up speed 5 SPs (to 18.99) to cap with 30 SPs at 48.99. In 12 days of training you can train intense 4 times which gives you approx 2.5 SPs (and a +1 from bonus token). My guess is you capped at 5.
Last edited Nov 30, 2008 22:16:31
 
TJ Spikes
online
Link
 
OG1 - Block 25.02, 33% complete, 33% gain => Block 25.02, 66% complete

==
 
TJ Spikes
online
Link
 
Originally posted by bubbaballin
I've never slow-builded before, but I'm thinking of starting with either a WR or HB. Are either of these positions better for slow building? If not, what positions are good for slow building (that is, positions that are either glamour or defense)?


Generally Speaking, the less Major attributes a position has, the more it will favor slow building.

As far as better for slow building goes the order would probably be

DT > FB/TE/DE > QB/FS/SS > HB/WR/LB/CB

Since you seem to be a player interested in stats, I suggest the DE. If you are leaning more towards offense then a QB would probably be the best choice.

The key to slow building is not spending SPs until you get your target attribute (whatever it is) to the point where it's value + your skill points equal the soft cap you want to hit.

Like if you are aiming for the 60 cap, your attribute could be 25 and your saved SPs could be 35 points worth (edit: 47-ish skill points, depending on decimals) to give you your 60. The advantage of not spending the SPs is higher training gains. The trick comes in knowing what attributes are completely important to your position. It might not do you a lot of good to raise 1 attribute into the stratosphere, if your other key attributes will be handicapped.

In the mean time, if you want to see this kind of building in all it's glory go roll a Center with a Strength of 21+.





Last edited Dec 1, 2008 18:48:27
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
To take an attribute from 25 to the second cap (60.52) would actually cost you 48 skill points:

25 to 49 (24 SP - first cap is 48.07)
49 to 61 (12 X 2 per = 24 SP - second cap is 60.52)
Last edited Dec 1, 2008 10:08:13
 
TJ Spikes
online
Link
 
OG1 - L8 - Block 25.69, 66% complete, 30% gain => Block 25.69, 96% complete
----- Block 25.69, 96% complete, 31% gain => Block 26.69, 27% complete
----- Block 26.69, 927% complete, 30% gain => Block 26.69, 57% complete


OC - L5 - Block 26, 42% complete, 37% gain => Block 26, 79% complete
------ Agility 13.8, 26% complete, 59% gain => Agility 13.8, 85% complete
---------- Block 26, 79% complete, 38% gain => Block 27, 17% complete
---------- Agility 13.8, 85% complete, 59% gain => Agility 14.8, 44% complete

OT - L5 - Block 16.6, 1% complete, 53% gain => Block 16.6, 54% complete
------ Agility 18.6, 49% complete, 50% gain => Agility 18.6, 99% complete
---------- Block 16.6, 54% complete, 54% gain => Block 17.6, 7% complete
---------- Agility 18.6, 99% complete, 50% gain => Agility 19.6.8, 49% complete

==

took a couple days off - 3 trains on the OG1. Could have capped his block skill, but I need it for this list. So he's sitting on 24 SPs. I decided to push the OCs strength to the second cap. He'll have a natural strength of 60 at L6. If no more points are invested he'll have a natural strength of 86 and change by the time he hits the L38 barrier. The OT is still chugging along. I still can't get a clear projection on him yet. My gut is telling me to cap Blocking next because of the intense training combos, but I'd really like to cap Agility next. I don't know how the training numbers will end up versus the SPs I'll have. Also the OC and OT are both sitting on 3 bonus tokens so next update they'll be getting their 2nd free SP.
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DarkVirtue
Originally posted by FatNasty

I've got a few new players I want to slow build. I have them 1) on CPU teams which will provide 35+ plays/game and 2) have them set for relaxed play intensity, and 3) will train them on intense. 4) I will soft cap skills to 48 ASAP then maybe go to second before training and capping next skill.

Are these four premises sound and productive? Advice?


thats not slowbuilding lol


Hah, hah, hah, hah. Hah, hah, hah, hah. Hah, hah, hah. Wait a minute ... heh ... what are we laughing at?

Yes, yes it is. But I see I was unclear with #4. I would train something else while pumping to second cap on original attribute. Is this what you are disputing? I'm not really concerned, however, as I'm pretty comfortable with my strategy now. It's recognized and I'd bet one of the more popular methods to slow build a player with few primary attributes.
 
IIAMLEGEND
offline
Link
 
no
 
TJ Spikes
online
Link
 
OG1 - L9 - Block 27.36, 57% complete, 30% gain => Block 27.36, 87% complete
----- Block 27.36, 87% complete, 29% gain => Block 28.36, 16% complete
----- Block 28.36, 16% complete, 29% gain => Block 28.36, 45% complete


OC - L6 - Block 28, 17% complete, 35% gain => Block 28, 52% complete
------ Agility 15, 44% complete, 56% gain => Agility 16, 0% complete

OT - L6 - Block 18, 7% complete, 51% gain => Block 18, 58% complete
------ Agility 20, 49% complete, 47% gain => Agility 20, 96% complete

 
TJ Spikes
online
Link
 
OG1 - L10 - Block 29.03, 45% complete, 28% gain => Block 29.03, 73% complete
----- Block 29.03, 73% complete, 27% gain => Block 30.03, 0% complete
----- Block 30.03, 0% complete, 26% gain => Block 30.03, 26% complete
----- Block 30.03, 26% complete, 40% gain => Block 30.03, 66% complete*


OC - L7 - Block 29, 52% complete, 33% gain => Block 29, 85% complete
------ Agility 16.2, 0% complete, 55% gain => Agility 16.2, 55% complete


OT - L8 - Block 18.8, 58% complete, 50% gain => Block 19.8, 8% complete
------ Agility 20.8, 96% complete, 46% gain => Agility 21.8, 42% complete

==

so that was one complete regular season for the OG1. Created on Day 1, he Hit L10 with 600+ XP. Got the list from 10 to 30 for normal training, and I think that will do it. I'll try to compile it at some point in time.

OC and OT were created on day 10 and will both be L8 when XP shuts off. That leads me to belive day players created on day 15 would be mid L6 when the XP shuts off for the season. That would have them sitting at L7 when the following season starts --perfect for signing another contract with a CPU team for another season (if you could become a free agent again).

I'll check the list for intense training and see if there's any holes to fill in.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.