I think the new system will have a large impact on the scrambling QB's. Just seems like it will be eaiser to do tbh.
Forum > Suggestions > New Plays/Playbooks
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
You'll see HB's who have QB as their position instead of HB. I guess QB's wouldn't get all the SA's to head fake and power through, etc, though. Could make "Demoralize" really good though.
Does Demoralize work on QB run plays? It mentions plays made outside of the pocket, and in running plays there isn't really a pocket to make a play outside of.
You'll see HB's who have QB as their position instead of HB. I guess QB's wouldn't get all the SA's to head fake and power through, etc, though. Could make "Demoralize" really good though.
Does Demoralize work on QB run plays? It mentions plays made outside of the pocket, and in running plays there isn't really a pocket to make a play outside of.
GG
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
What we will see then though, is QB's being made specifically for running to fill that backup, running QB position.
I guess you're right. It would still be open to exploitation in a roundabout way. Teams with a pocket QB will just have to build up his running abilities. And those with scrambling QBs will just have to build up their throwing abilites. Not identical, just enough to make the pocket able to run and the scrambler able to throw. And just leave it as only one QB slot??
What we will see then though, is QB's being made specifically for running to fill that backup, running QB position.
I guess you're right. It would still be open to exploitation in a roundabout way. Teams with a pocket QB will just have to build up his running abilities. And those with scrambling QBs will just have to build up their throwing abilites. Not identical, just enough to make the pocket able to run and the scrambler able to throw. And just leave it as only one QB slot??
Football Genius
offline
offline
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by GG
Having HB3 is not important. Having QB1 (restricted to QBs only) is important.
That idea sounds pretty cool. A specialized QB only position would be good for the QB running plays, because QB's will usually still have SOME passing ability instead of being completely, 100% based on running.
What we will see then though, is QB's being made specifically for running to fill that backup, running QB position.
Well isn't that the point? Having a X factor player when he comes in, you dont know if he is going to pass or run. If a team wants to hire 3 QB's 2 Pocket passer and 1 Running QB,
The team still has to pay his salary and the Running QB will understand that most of the game he will standing next to the Kicker and punter. Seems like a fair trade, less PT but the ability to catch the defense sleeping at the wheel.
Bort would not have to go nuts to open exploits, just add 1 QB slot. If you want to make it a QB only allowed slot thats fine with me. Just want to be able to run the QB runs with a player that has more than 25 speed and 35 agi, and 18 for carrying.
I mean Think about it really, A running QB will have to build in such a way that he has good Carrying (to avoid Fumbles), obviously Speed and Agi. HE would also need the vision for both throwing and running.
If a agent wants to sacrifice some throwing and Pocket passer Sa's to be a running QB, Bort should at least allow the Oc to ensure that he is in when the run play comes out.
Originally posted by GG
Having HB3 is not important. Having QB1 (restricted to QBs only) is important.
That idea sounds pretty cool. A specialized QB only position would be good for the QB running plays, because QB's will usually still have SOME passing ability instead of being completely, 100% based on running.
What we will see then though, is QB's being made specifically for running to fill that backup, running QB position.
Well isn't that the point? Having a X factor player when he comes in, you dont know if he is going to pass or run. If a team wants to hire 3 QB's 2 Pocket passer and 1 Running QB,
The team still has to pay his salary and the Running QB will understand that most of the game he will standing next to the Kicker and punter. Seems like a fair trade, less PT but the ability to catch the defense sleeping at the wheel.
Bort would not have to go nuts to open exploits, just add 1 QB slot. If you want to make it a QB only allowed slot thats fine with me. Just want to be able to run the QB runs with a player that has more than 25 speed and 35 agi, and 18 for carrying.
I mean Think about it really, A running QB will have to build in such a way that he has good Carrying (to avoid Fumbles), obviously Speed and Agi. HE would also need the vision for both throwing and running.
If a agent wants to sacrifice some throwing and Pocket passer Sa's to be a running QB, Bort should at least allow the Oc to ensure that he is in when the run play comes out.
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort
You'll see HB's who have QB as their position instead of HB. I guess QB's wouldn't get all the SA's to head fake and power through, etc, though. Could make "Demoralize" really good though.
Does Demoralize work on QB run plays? It mentions plays made outside of the pocket, and in running plays there isn't really a pocket to make a play outside of.
Oh yeah, you're right - it only activates in "scrambling" mode.
Originally posted by Bort
You'll see HB's who have QB as their position instead of HB. I guess QB's wouldn't get all the SA's to head fake and power through, etc, though. Could make "Demoralize" really good though.
Does Demoralize work on QB run plays? It mentions plays made outside of the pocket, and in running plays there isn't really a pocket to make a play outside of.
Oh yeah, you're right - it only activates in "scrambling" mode.
Football Genius
offline
offline
Also While I am asking for a QB1 slot, maybe in the future there could be a SA for QB's slide feet first ! You give up 2-3 yards in your gain but you reduce the chance of fumbling Greatly !! or not all.... Hmmm think about it 
Please

Please
GG
offline
offline
What should probably be done is even with the one QB slot, to forbid people putting non-QBs there. I can still see a team just starting their HB there all game and running it 90% of the time off those QB run plays, as they do look quite devestating. Especially if they build a HB and throw enough SPs into their throwing ability (just enough to get by).
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 02:46:50
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by GG
What should probably be done is even with the one QB slot, to forbid people putting non-QBs there. I can still see a team just starting their HB there all game and running it 90% of the time off those QB run plays, as they do look quite devestating.
Few pages late on that discovery
I think we have moved to the "Pure Running QB" and their effectiveness, with a little bit of baseball slide action to reduce fumbles.
Edit:
Their HB wouldn't need any throwing...use the passing QB for passing plays, use the HB for QB run plays. Alternate them on normal runs so they both get decent play time.
What should probably be done is even with the one QB slot, to forbid people putting non-QBs there. I can still see a team just starting their HB there all game and running it 90% of the time off those QB run plays, as they do look quite devestating.
Few pages late on that discovery

I think we have moved to the "Pure Running QB" and their effectiveness, with a little bit of baseball slide action to reduce fumbles.
Edit:
Their HB wouldn't need any throwing...use the passing QB for passing plays, use the HB for QB run plays. Alternate them on normal runs so they both get decent play time.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 02:48:09
Football Genius
offline
offline
Originally posted by GG
What should probably be done is even with the one QB slot, to forbid people putting non-QBs there. I can still see a team just starting their HB there all game and running it 90% of the time off those QB run plays, as they do look quite devestating.
I am ok with that, I am not looking for an Exploit Just looking for a way to use a running QB specifically. Like a slash player...Randle El, Cordell Stewart (sucked but you get the point)
Restrict it to QB's only, I am all for it, just need a QB 1 Slot to use it.
What should probably be done is even with the one QB slot, to forbid people putting non-QBs there. I can still see a team just starting their HB there all game and running it 90% of the time off those QB run plays, as they do look quite devestating.
I am ok with that, I am not looking for an Exploit Just looking for a way to use a running QB specifically. Like a slash player...Randle El, Cordell Stewart (sucked but you get the point)

Restrict it to QB's only, I am all for it, just need a QB 1 Slot to use it.
GG
offline
offline
I mean right now, I could transfer all my EQT into one of my RBs throwing, and with their high vision and throwing up to about 30 now, that would do them well enough to throw when needed (short/med passes) and just run the ball all game from QB rush plays. That kind of thing is too cheesey but will be done by some GMs out there.
GG
offline
offline
Originally posted by Football Genius
Originally posted by GG
What should probably be done is even with the one QB slot, to forbid people putting non-QBs there. I can still see a team just starting their HB there all game and running it 90% of the time off those QB run plays, as they do look quite devestating.
I am ok with that, I am not looking for an Exploit Just looking for a way to use a running QB specifically. Like a slash player...Randle El, Cordell Stewart (sucked but you get the point)
Restrict it to QB's only, I am all for it, just need a QB 1 Slot to use it.
I know what you mean. One team I GM we have a pure pocket QB and a pure scrambling QB (built for running) and I envisioned using the QB and QB1 slots that way....but now that I think about it, it still opens it up for cheese. Unless someone can devise a clever method to prevent that??
Originally posted by GG
What should probably be done is even with the one QB slot, to forbid people putting non-QBs there. I can still see a team just starting their HB there all game and running it 90% of the time off those QB run plays, as they do look quite devestating.
I am ok with that, I am not looking for an Exploit Just looking for a way to use a running QB specifically. Like a slash player...Randle El, Cordell Stewart (sucked but you get the point)

Restrict it to QB's only, I am all for it, just need a QB 1 Slot to use it.
I know what you mean. One team I GM we have a pure pocket QB and a pure scrambling QB (built for running) and I envisioned using the QB and QB1 slots that way....but now that I think about it, it still opens it up for cheese. Unless someone can devise a clever method to prevent that??
Originally posted by GG
I mean right now, I could transfer all my EQT into one of my RBs throwing, and with their high vision and throwing up to about 30 now, that would do them well enough to throw when needed (short/med passes) and just run the ball all game from QB rush plays. That kind of thing is too cheesey but will be done by some GMs out there.
OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.
I mean right now, I could transfer all my EQT into one of my RBs throwing, and with their high vision and throwing up to about 30 now, that would do them well enough to throw when needed (short/med passes) and just run the ball all game from QB rush plays. That kind of thing is too cheesey but will be done by some GMs out there.
OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by GG
I know what you mean. One team I GM we have a pure pocket QB and a pure scrambling QB (built for running) and I envisioned using the QB and QB1 slots that way....but now that I think about it, it still opens it up for cheese. Unless someone can devise a clever method to prevent that??
As Bort said on the previous page...pure running QB's will not have as many SA's as HB's. Granted, it is still kind of cheesy, because you can get away with a QB having ZERO throwing ability running the ball. I hate using real life to argue a point, but in real life, if a QB subs in only to throw, or only to run, the defense will be all over you like flies on shit.
The only real way I can think to not have cheesy situations is to forgo the QB1.
I know what you mean. One team I GM we have a pure pocket QB and a pure scrambling QB (built for running) and I envisioned using the QB and QB1 slots that way....but now that I think about it, it still opens it up for cheese. Unless someone can devise a clever method to prevent that??
As Bort said on the previous page...pure running QB's will not have as many SA's as HB's. Granted, it is still kind of cheesy, because you can get away with a QB having ZERO throwing ability running the ball. I hate using real life to argue a point, but in real life, if a QB subs in only to throw, or only to run, the defense will be all over you like flies on shit.
The only real way I can think to not have cheesy situations is to forgo the QB1.
ron2288
offline
offline
I just logged on and looked at the new stuff....it looks awesome
I have a question. I have not read thru this whole thread so if it has been discussed forgive me.
If I want my back HB to run a sweep I would set it to run the sweep then set it for HB2?
I have only 2 HB's on the roster. Again I just saw the title of this thread and posted this so if this has been discussed sorry to bring it back up
I have a question. I have not read thru this whole thread so if it has been discussed forgive me.
If I want my back HB to run a sweep I would set it to run the sweep then set it for HB2?
I have only 2 HB's on the roster. Again I just saw the title of this thread and posted this so if this has been discussed sorry to bring it back up
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.



























