User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > How to improve Pass Blocking Assignments and still allow realistic levels of Pass Rush Pressure
Page:
 
Ilok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by Koncorde

This game isn't the NFL. What's the record for sacks in the High School and College systems?


Even that is not a fair comparison, to tell the truth.

What would the record be in a 16 team Conference where 6 teams are from the NFL, 6 are NCAA Div I , and 2 are from High School?

Thats what 90% of the leagues are like here in GLB.


yes this year, but there are changes being made to make competition more competitive.
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
I posted this in another thread. Perhaps it would be better here

The key feature missing in the blocking scheme is control. Ie allow the OC to be able to control the blocking scheme adjusting it for his player and the opponents. As happens in real life, a fast agile lines will be moving more using a zone blocking (or power zone). While a larger stronger line will be more head up blocking.

My suggestion: Allow to choose the blocking scheme. The same scheme should apply to the whole game (this is the usual way in real life) - either zone blocking or man blocking. Also you should be able to assign distance between the OL (separately for run or pass), and the defense should be able to read that.

* In pass protection:
- When in zone blocking the OL hand-off defenders from one to the other to pick up blitz.
- When in man blocking each OL will his designated man, in case their is a blitz only a free OL will attempt to pick it up (this is the current scheme, as far as I can tell).
- In a passing play you like smaller gaps between OL (of course risking that the defense will key on that)

* The same principle apply to run blocking:
- When in zone blocking a OL will try to handoff defenders away from the hole in order to get to the second level.
- When in man blocking each OL has is own target to focus on, and he will change only if his target is far from the play.
- The ideal gaps are larger now allowing for more room for the runner.

This change will allow to better use the personnel of the team and will match the way the game is played in real life. It is also needed to recheck the blocking scheme in run plays, since many time the OL are engaged with useless double team and away from the point of attack battle. Instead of blocking into the second level (LB, SS).
 
greengoose
offline
Link
 
Actually it's not.

If you saw the Vikings/Lions game they tried running with a Zone Blocking scheme early and weren't getting much done. They switched to man power blocking on their 3rd possession (which the Lions struggle against) and started making headway.

Why on earth the Vikings would want to zone block with McKinnie, Hutch and Birk on the left side anyway defies common sense - just let them maul the Lions undersized D-line right out of the picture.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by Koncorde

This game isn't the NFL. What's the record for sacks in the High School and College systems?


Even that is not a fair comparison, to tell the truth.

What would the record be in a 16 team Conference where 6 teams are from the NFL, 6 are NCAA Div I , and 2 are from High School?

Thats what 90% of the leagues are like here in GLB.


No, but some Highschools are vastly bigger than others which does result in such blow-outs and mismatches and presumably there have been some, somewhat onesided matches as we see in GLB.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Koncorde
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by Koncorde


This game isn't the NFL. What's the record for sacks in the High School and College systems?


Even that is not a fair comparison, to tell the truth.

What would the record be in a 16 team Conference where 6 teams are from the NFL, 6 are NCAA Div I , and 2 are from High School?

Thats what 90% of the leagues are like here in GLB.


No, but some Highschools are vastly bigger than others which does result in such blow-outs and mismatches and presumably there have been some, somewhat onesided matches as we see in GLB.


NCAA Div I teams, while not anywhere near similar in resources in terms of player quality, still wont replicate the lopsidedness of GLB.

GLB has 5th season players going against first or second season players.

Would be like Preimiership teams playing Championship teams, not Ryman League teams.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 08:24:39
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Here is what I would do, keep the line in their "zone" for a few "ticks" before releasing them to follow the current code. This will allow the RG to stay home and tack care of a speed DE on their side. This could be as short as a few ticks of game code just enough for the DE rushing to the inside becomes the biggest "threat".

That's it...that's all that needs to be done. The rest of the belly aching is by OT's that aren't built that well. Fix the RG bug, and I'd consider everything balanced.

This is coming from the owner of a L32 OT...I love seeing my guy battle a stud DE! It's a blast!
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by greengoose
Actually it's not.

If you saw the Vikings/Lions game they tried running with a Zone Blocking scheme early and weren't getting much done. They switched to man power blocking on their 3rd possession (which the Lions struggle against) and started making headway.

Why on earth the Vikings would want to zone block with McKinnie, Hutch and Birk on the left side anyway defies common sense - just let them maul the Lions undersized D-line right out of the picture.


That is rare (I haven't seen the game), basically explains why the Vikings under Childress cannot raise to their full potential (it is true that a QB would help ;-) ). Changing the blocking scheme is a major change involving player types and re-doing of the whole playbook.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Here is what I would do, keep the line in their "zone" for a few "ticks" before releasing them to follow the current code. This will allow the RG to stay home and tack care of a speed DE on their side. This could be as short as a few ticks of game code just enough for the DE rushing to the inside becomes the biggest "threat".

That's it...that's all that needs to be done. The rest of the belly aching is by OT's that aren't built that well. Fix the RG bug, and I'd consider everything balanced.

This is coming from the owner of a L32 OT...I love seeing my guy battle a stud DE! It's a blast!


Thats the general consensus of this thread as well, and likely what Bort is looking into, from his quotes.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers


NCAA Div I teams, while not anywhere near similar in resources in terms of player quality, still wont replicate the lopsidedness of GLB.

GLB has 5th season players going against first or second season players.

Would be like Preimiership teams playing Championship teams, not Ryman League teams.


This is a major point. It's not even like NFL against High School. It's NFL against goddamn Little Leaguers. Seriously, put your 4th grader up against Jared Allen and see what happens.


The only convincing argument I've seen so far is the G responsibilities. Guards should definitely backpedal on the snap and not fire out/across. In fact, 2 things need to happen to the actual sim on pass protection IMO-

1) Guards need to stop attacking while the OTs are falling back defending. Offensive line is a unit.
2) Better pass protection AI to shift the midpoint of the blocking scheme against overload blitzes. Someone's Vision comes to play here, either the C or the QB.

Here are somethings that shouldn't happen -
1) HB/FB looking to block outside to inside. Wrong. There are middle blitzers, and middle blitzers are the first thing that need to be picked up. The most direct lines to the QB are the first responsibility.
2) Nerfing Tunnel Vision. It doesn't need nerfing. Fix the poor protection schemes and take stock.

Here are some things players should be looking at doing -
1) Build better athletes for offensive linemen.
2) Dump the ball off more often against heavy blitzing teams. Trying to throw 15+ yard passes against 6+ man blitzes is insane.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Additional suggestion:

After (combined) 5 hurries/sacks within 20 pass plays, cancel all RB routes and make them stay for blocking. After another 5 hurries/sacks, cancel the TE routes too and make the TE stay home / run short routes only if no blitzing.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg


The only convincing argument I've seen so far is the G responsibilities. Guards should definitely backpedal on the snap and not fire out/across. In fact, 2 things need to happen to the actual sim on pass protection IMO-

1) Guards need to stop attacking while the OTs are falling back defending. Offensive line is a unit.
2) Better pass protection AI to shift the midpoint of the blocking scheme against overload blitzes. Someone's Vision comes to play here, either the C or the QB.

Here are somethings that shouldn't happen -
1) HB/FB looking to block outside to inside. Wrong. There are middle blitzers, and middle blitzers are the first thing that need to be picked up. The most direct lines to the QB are the first responsibility.
2) Nerfing Tunnel Vision. It doesn't need nerfing. Fix the poor protection schemes and take stock.

Here are some things players should be looking at doing -
1) Build better athletes for offensive linemen.
2) Dump the ball off more often against heavy blitzing teams. Trying to throw 15+ yard passes against 6+ man blitzes is insane.


1) HB/FB looking outside is in response to the issue of OGs having the inside blitz, its just a possible way to easily stop the DE shooting inside IF there is no way to stop the OGs firing off.

Basically the outside pressure is instant, while the inside pressure takes a few ticks, which allows the HB/FB to look outside first, as then the rest of the OLs pick up inside (In the current scheme.)

just a way to avoid triple teams inside while the DE is uncontested.

But agree fix the OGs first and foremost, and that should sort out the majority of issues.

If the blocking is designed properly then the HB/FB should be looking inside.
Last edited Oct 20, 2008 08:50:36
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Ok, I understand your thinking. I'm just not a fan of bandaids in game solutions, as it tends to let Devs slide on bad solutions.


Fixing the headhunting Guards would be nice... frustrating for my D, but good for the game.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Additional suggestion:

After (combined) 5 hurries/sacks within 20 pass plays, cancel all RB routes and make them stay for blocking. After another 5 hurries/sacks, cancel the TE routes too and make the TE stay home / run short routes only if no blitzing.


I have this on the Front page, Cant remember who posted it first,

Originally posted by

Possibility of keeping the HB/FB/TE in on pass plays, set via tactics screen.

Maybe even have this as a 'AutoAdjust' feature where the following logic is followed...
If sacks+hurries = [x] in [z] plays, then keep HB/FB/TE in to block?

Where x and z are set by the user, and who stays in set by the play design.


Did you have something specifically different to this you want pinned in there?
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
I think the HBs having the ability to make a decision (possibly based on vision/confidence, or QB dump pass settings) to not run their route and stay in and block in case of a blitz might help, especially with plays like this:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=154129&pbp_id=8998572
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=154129&pbp_id=8999161

etc
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Additional suggestion:

After (combined) 5 hurries/sacks within 20 pass plays, cancel all RB routes and make them stay for blocking. After another 5 hurries/sacks, cancel the TE routes too and make the TE stay home / run short routes only if no blitzing.


great idea! Perhaps make this a OC-AI setting. Both the amount of plays needed to trigger the blitz settings and the option order.

QB Protection Scheme:
First Option: HB Protect
Second Option: Early Dump
Third Option: TE Protect

# Sacks to trigger QB Protection: _3_
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.