User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The new promotion system
Page:
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose


I support the idea of promoting the team that makes it through the playoffs and promotes that way, since a lucky team is likely not going to hit the luck jackpot three times in a row. But if they hit it once, against a good team, they are not the better team overall -- they were the better team that one game.


Who cares? They're better than the CPU team they're replacing.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01


Well then, why have the playoffs? Clearly the #1 seed is the best and should be promoted without all that messy championship stuff.


Are you guys even reading what is being said, let me spell it out for you.

It should go like this:

Playoffs>Regular Season>Scrimmages
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami


All of your arguments fall short and aren't really hitting the point, this system is/was said/should be designed to bring the best teams up, and make leagues the most competitive.


No, it's designed to improve the competitiveness of the higher leagues. It's not vital that only the absolute "best" by whatever subjective criteria you have in mind get promoted, only that they be competitive with the best (as they clearly must be, since they beat 'em) and better than those they replace.


 
BuddyHorn
offline
Link
 
record in the regular season is so variable. some teams go unboosted and only get a 9-7 record, come in as the 8th seed with a last second boost, and at that time they are easily the best team.


This was our plan on CWM, but we just accidentally wound up being very good.
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Sarg01



Well then, why have the playoffs? Clearly the #1 seed is the best and should be promoted without all that messy championship stuff.


Are you guys even reading what is being said, let me spell it out for you.

It should go like this:

Playoffs>Regular Season>Scrimmages


You don't get it. The end of the season "scrimmages" ARE playoffs.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01


Who cares? They're better than the CPU team they're replacing.


The whole idea of the system is to make the leagues as competitive as possible, we are simply suggesting a way to do that. Why not put a team of lvl 14s up in the pros, I mean they are better than the CPU team.
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Sarg01



Who cares? They're better than the CPU team they're replacing.


The whole idea of the system is to make the leagues as competitive as possible, we are simply suggesting a way to do that. Why not put a team of lvl 14s up in the pros, I mean they are better than the CPU team.


Sure, as long as they beat the team of 32s that the proposed method is nominating, I'm cool with that.
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01


You don't get it. The end of the season "scrimmages" ARE playoffs.



They ARE playoffs now because of this rule, they make the regular season even more meaningless.

Originally posted by BuddyHorn
record in the regular season is so variable. some teams go unboosted and only get a 9-7 record, come in as the 8th seed with a last second boost, and at that time they are easily the best team.


I think this is another issue, the regular season should matter, in every sport it matters and teams take every game seriously, now they mean less than "scrimmages" turned playoffs.
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
I believe the scrimmages can determine more than the regular season with boosting and teams that have became better throughout the season with key additions and improved tactics.


It'll be a rarity but high level day 40 contracts just became valuable to non playoff teams with a chance of being promoted through scrimmages, although more than likely won't be an issue.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 20:04:22
 
douglasiv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Summary:

http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Promotion_and_Relegation


The wiki seems to use the words conference and league interchangeably in some areas.

Originally posted by The wiki
However if the conference above yours had more then one team moved up or get gutted then more teams from your conference will be promoted in the order that Bort listed.


The Bort announcement today said leagues and didn't mention anything about conferences. Is this coming from another source or is this a mistake?
 
Groucho
offline
Link
 
Yes, I would like clarification on whether teams can be promoted across conferences or not. The announcement implies that they can, but a post by Bort in this thread implies that that they'll stay in the same conference.
 
Nixx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by douglasiv
The Bort announcement today said leagues and didn't mention anything about conferences. Is this coming from another source or is this a mistake?


The wiki can be wrong. This was just announced a few hours ago, so maybe some of the stuff on the wiki has incorrect wording.
 
McMichael
offline
Link
 
The promotion/Relegation system happens each season. If a "Lucky" team gets promoted over a "Better" team this season, then ends up being unable to compete next season they will be relegated back down while the "Better" team will likely get promoted the next season.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami
Originally posted by Sarg01



You don't get it. The end of the season "scrimmages" ARE playoffs.



They ARE playoffs now because of this rule, they make the regular season even more meaningless.

Originally posted by BuddyHorn

record in the regular season is so variable. some teams go unboosted and only get a 9-7 record, come in as the 8th seed with a last second boost, and at that time they are easily the best team.


I think this is another issue, the regular season should matter, in every sport it matters and teams take every game seriously, now they mean less than "scrimmages" turned playoffs.


Think of the scrimmages as the consolation bracket. Playoff Round 2 losers play other Round 2 losers, etc. It's still the postseason if you're vying for promotion and the opportunity is there (which it may or may not be depending on the specific situation that season).
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort

5. Avg playoff game points differential
6. Avg postseason scrimmage points differential
7. Avg playoff points scored
8. Avg postseason scrimmage points scored
9. Avg playoff points allowed (lower is better)
10. Avg postseason scrimmages points allowed (lower is better)


I may just be overgeeking here (OK I know I am), but what it the point of #9/10 after running #5-8? Looks to me like #9/10 will never decide anything - so now it just bugs me that I may be missing something.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.