User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #1 > SEC is the Best Conference and Big East is the worst
Page:
 
mcallero
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by marauder22
Here's one more for you. Do you recall Freddy Millons? In 2000 Bama traveled west and brought his heisman hype. Bama was ranked 3rd in the country and got beat at the Rose Bowl by UCLA.


Do you remember the year that Cal was all that, supposedly deserving of being in the the National Championship game, but got their ass handed to them by that "gimmick" offense of TT?
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcallero
Using that exact same logic everyone beats everyone... should I go through it? Nah... that Arkansas team was waaay different in beginning of the season than the one at the end.

And Oregon last year would not have been a top tier SEC team. No way. In the SEC they play spread offenses all the time, and wouldn't get all thrown off by it the way that SC did. With that same logic, LSU with Ryan Perriloux would be the best team in the country this season


Oregon's spread worked better than most spreads because of Dennis Dixon. No one in the SEC had his running skills or speed. Nor did anyone in the SEC have a HB like Johnathan Stewart to run the read option like Oregon. Bring up an SEC team that had that kind of a duo. The only one that compares is Arkansas, and they would have to bring in Mcfadden to run the read option. How many teams in the SEC stopped it? Auburn and Tennessee and thats it. Arkansas also didn't have the WR's or TE's that matched Oregon's offense. You would have to leave Oregon's WR's and TE's man to man. We didn't even mention how McFadden isn't a better thrower than Dixon.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcallero
Originally posted by marauder22

Here's one more for you. Do you recall Freddy Millons? In 2000 Bama traveled west and brought his heisman hype. Bama was ranked 3rd in the country and got beat at the Rose Bowl by UCLA.


Do you remember the year that Cal was all that, supposedly deserving of being in the the National Championship game, but got their ass handed to them by that "gimmick" offense of TT?


You mean to the Rose bowl game. The year was 04. USC won the championship game, and beat Cal that year. Cal probably had a let down from not going to a BCS game. Mack cried to the media to get into that game.
Last edited Oct 14, 2008 17:12:43
 
Link
 
Originally posted by mcallero
ASU, Oregon, Cal = middle tier SEC team


Tennessee, Auburn, Ole Miss - middle tier PAC 10 Team - if not bottom Pac 10 team no?

Tennessee lost to fricken UCLA! UCLA I SAY! 59-0 BYU UCLA.... Yet Tennessee is still a middle of the tier SEC THIS YEAR
Last edited Oct 14, 2008 17:13:13
 
mcallero
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Originally posted by mcallero

ASU, Oregon, Cal = middle tier SEC team


Tennessee, Auburn, Ole Miss - middle tier PAC 10 Team - if not bottom Pac 10 team no?

Tennessee lost to fricken UCLA! UCLA I SAY! 59-0 BYU UCLA.... Yet Tennessee is still a middle of the tier SEC THIS YEAR


Are they really? Bottom third imo, plus when they get up for a game they can play with good teams.
 
mcallero
offline
Link
 
Oregon? Scrub IMO
 
Link
 
Originally posted by mcallero
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell

Originally posted by mcallero


ASU, Oregon, Cal = middle tier SEC team


Tennessee, Auburn, Ole Miss - middle tier PAC 10 Team - if not bottom Pac 10 team no?

Tennessee lost to fricken UCLA! UCLA I SAY! 59-0 BYU UCLA.... Yet Tennessee is still a middle of the tier SEC THIS YEAR


Are they really? Bottom third imo, plus when they get up for a game they can play with good teams.

When they get up for a game? YOu can say that about any team. I can say IF Cal got up for a game they would run the table. I could say IF Utah got up for every game then they would be undefeated year in and out.

Also Oregon = Scrub? They are on their 4th string QB let alone all the other injuries.

In the same sentence people here will talk about Clemson and how they were #6 I want to say to start the year (I am sure I am wrong here) but they were legit then right?

In the same breath as Oregon = Scrub I will say SEC = Overrated and average with the exception of 3 to 4 teams year in and out just like the Pac 10 most years, Big 10 Most years, Big 12 Most years.

Shit... I would put BYU, Utah, and TCU in the SEC this year from the MWC and I bet they would be in the 'top tier' or at worst the top of the 'middle' tier.
 
kobby
offline
Link
 
ok here's what obviously settles this discussion: matchup the teams. u guys are dwelling on the past or living in some fantasy world. i'm from freaking iowa and have no east coast bias or favoritism to any conference, i'm just not blind.

usc/bama: close one, i'll give sc the edge just so i don't get killed by one of the usc nuthuggers.
florida/cal: florida in a blowout
georgia/oregon: georgia in a blowout
lsu/stanford: lsu in a blowout
arizona/vandy: close one but i'd have to give it to vandy
oregon state/south carolina: have to give it to sc
ucla/auburn: auburn in a blowout by auburn's standards 17-0
ole miss/arizona state: arizona state in a close one
kentucky/washington: kentucky in a close one
arkansas/wazzou: arkansas just because wazzou's pathetic

so by my count it's 8-2 sec if they matched up by ranking/record. and what does ucla's win matter over a team that doesn't even make the top 10 sec teams? oregon and cal are 2/3 in the pac 10 and would be 5/6 at best in the sec. and here's a comparison, just by looking which schedule looks tougher top or bottom?

at (23) UCLA
UAB
(4) Florida
at (15) Auburn
Northern Illinois
at (10) Georgia
Mississippi State
(2) Alabama
at South Carolina
Wyoming
at (22) Vanderbilt
Kentucky


at Virginia
(5) Ohio State
at Oregon State
(23) Oregon
Arizona State
at Washington State
at Arizona
Washington
(25) California
at Stanford
Notre Dame
at UCLA
 
Link
 
How is UCLA ranked in 1 but not the other
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
How is UCLA ranked in 1 but not the other

LMAO the guys an obvious idiot.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kobby


usc/bama: close one, i'll give sc the edge just so i don't get killed by one of the usc nuthuggers.
florida/cal: florida in a blowout (Only game I agree with. Florida is the best team in the SEC IMO)
georgia/oregon: georgia in a blowout (Georgia didn't blow out ASU. What makes you think they would blow out Oregon? Have you seen Oregon play this year when healthy? Oregon at 100 percent healthy would make this game a toss up. Oregon with half their team injured UGA wins by 14.)
lsu/stanford: lsu in a blowout
arizona/vandy: close one but i'd have to give it to vandy (Toss up)
oregon state/south carolina: have to give it to sc (Oregon State would win this game. South Carolina can't score.)
ucla/auburn: auburn in a blowout by auburn's standards 17-0 (LMAO....Auburn-UCLA would be much like the Tennessee game. Neither team would win by more than 10. I'd give the edge to Auburn but a blow out? WTF do you know about football? You must be an ESPN follower.)
ole miss/arizona state: arizona state in a close one
kentucky/washington: kentucky in a close one (Depends where the game is played. This is a toss up game.)
arkansas/wazzou: arkansas just because wazzou's pathetic (Their isn't a word to describe how pathetic Wazzou is this year.)


*
Last edited Oct 14, 2008 22:37:22
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
As far as the nut huggery. I grew up around the USC program. My uncle has been the equipment manager since 90, and as kids. We would go to their spring practices and set up the cones and watch practices. I've traveled with the team in prior seasons to Cal, Stanford and Washington. Only because one of my Uncle's helpers didn't go.
Last edited Oct 14, 2008 22:40:15
 
mcallero
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell
Originally posted by mcallero

Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell


Originally posted by mcallero



ASU, Oregon, Cal = middle tier SEC team


Tennessee, Auburn, Ole Miss - middle tier PAC 10 Team - if not bottom Pac 10 team no?

Tennessee lost to fricken UCLA! UCLA I SAY! 59-0 BYU UCLA.... Yet Tennessee is still a middle of the tier SEC THIS YEAR


Are they really? Bottom third imo, plus when they get up for a game they can play with good teams.


When they get up for a game? YOu can say that about any team. I can say IF Cal got up for a game they would run the table. I could say IF Utah got up for every game then they would be undefeated year in and out.

Also Oregon = Scrub? They are on their 4th string QB let alone all the other injuries.

In the same sentence people here will talk about Clemson and how they were #6 I want to say to start the year (I am sure I am wrong here) but they were legit then right?

In the same breath as Oregon = Scrub I will say SEC = Overrated and average with the exception of 3 to 4 teams year in and out just like the Pac 10 most years, Big 10 Most years, Big 12 Most years.

Shit... I would put BYU, Utah, and TCU in the SEC this year from the MWC and I bet they would be in the 'top tier' or at worst the top of the 'middle' tier.

wrong wrong wrong

when does the pac 10 ever have more than 1 serious `title contender? By your logic... PSU(-28) > Oregon State(-6) > USC= PSU -34> USC?
 
kobby
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by marauder22
Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell

How is UCLA ranked in 1 but not the other

LMAO the guys an obvious idiot.


it's the rankings when the teams played. i just wanted to emphasize that when tennessee played ucla they weren't playing what ucla turned out to be but at the time the 23rd ranked team in the nation. seems so long ago with how they've turned out but yes tennessee lost in OT on what i call a fluke all the way across the country to then the 23rd best team in the nation. it was only after that, that ucla turned out to be terrible. i also sort of wanted to help u guys out by giving usc credit for a win against a top 5 team but i can change it so they play no top 10 teams if you'd like. of course after cal gets beat by somebody terrible the pac 10 won't have a second ranked team so that would look pretty bad, whereas the sec will go 7-1 in bowl games like they always do against equal level teams from other conferences and end up with 5-6 "overrated" ranked teams like they do every year.

here's sec vs. pac 10 bowl records, teams ranked in the final AP poll to end the year, and teams ranked in the top 5 or 10 in the nation to end the year. as you'll notice for the last 10 years!, the pac 10 has never once had more bowl wins or as many top 25 teams to finish the year as the sec:

2007: sec 7-2, 5 ranked teams, 2 top 2 teams, won national title
pac 10 4-2, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team

2006: sec 6-3, 6 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, 3 top 10 teams, won national title
pac 10 3-3, 3 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team

2005: sec 3-3, 5 ranked teams, 3 top 10 teams
pac 10 3-2, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team

2004: sec 3-3, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams
pac 10 3-2, 3 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams, won national title

2003: sec 5-2, 5 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams, won 1/2 national title
pac 10 4-2, 2 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams, won 1/2 national title

2002: sec 3-4, 3 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team
pac 10 2-5, 2 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams

2001: sec 5-3, 5 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, 3 top 10 teams
pac 10 2-2, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams

2000: sec 4-5, 6 ranked teams, 1 top 10 team
pac 10 3-1, 3 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, 3 top 10 teams

1999: sec 4-4, 6 ranked teams, 2 top 10 teams
pac 10 1-4, 1 ranked team #19

1998: sec 4-4 4 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, won national title
pac 10 1-4 2 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams


and this brings me to my next point, u guys were arguing that the sec always has up teams and down teams and that's why it's not as good, well the only up team in the pac 10 is usc. the only team to finish in the top 5 in the country since 2001 is usc. since that time, the sec has had 5 teams finish in the top 5 (tennessee, georgia, florida, lsu, and auburn).

also the pac 10 hasn't had a team win at least a share of the national title other than usc since 1991 when washington won a share. in that time usc won 1 1/2, while the sec won 5 1/2 with 4 different teams all of which they won outright except for the one lsu split (lsu twice, florida twice, tennessee, and alabama). the last national title the pac 10 won outright was way back in 1972 by...u guessed it usc, then 1967 by again usc. but then it's...well no my list only goes back to 1936. aww shucks, so that's 1 split national title for the pac 10 not including usc for the past 72 years. the sec has 11 outright and 16 including splits from 6 different teams (lsu, florida, tennessee, bama, georgia, and auburn).

zing. sec>pac 10 /discussion.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 08:13:59
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kobby
Originally posted by marauder22

Originally posted by Ronald McDonyell


How is UCLA ranked in 1 but not the other

LMAO the guys an obvious idiot.


it's the rankings when the teams played. i just wanted to emphasize that when tennessee played ucla they weren't playing what ucla turned out to be but at the time the 23rd ranked team in the nation. seems so long ago with how they've turned out but yes tennessee lost in OT on what i call a fluke all the way across the country to then the 23rd best team in the nation. it was only after that, that ucla turned out to be terrible. i also sort of wanted to help u guys out by giving usc credit for a win against a top 5 team but i can change it so they play no top 10 teams if you'd like. of course after cal gets beat by somebody terrible the pac 10 won't have a second ranked team so that would look pretty bad, whereas the sec will go 7-1 in bowl games like they always do against equal level teams from other conferences and end up with 5-6 "overrated" ranked teams like they do every year.

here's sec vs. pac 10 bowl records, teams ranked in the final AP poll to end the year, and teams ranked in the top 5 or 10 in the nation to end the year. as you'll notice for the last 10 years!, the pac 10 has never once had more bowl wins or as many top 25 teams to finish the year as the sec:

2007: sec 7-2, 5 ranked teams, 2 top 2 teams, won national title
pac 10 4-2, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team

2006: sec 6-3, 6 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, 3 top 10 teams, won national title
pac 10 3-3, 3 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team

2005: sec 3-3, 5 ranked teams, 3 top 10 teams
pac 10 3-2, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team

2004: sec 3-3, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams
pac 10 3-2, 3 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams, won national title

2003: sec 5-2, 5 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams, won 1/2 national title
pac 10 4-2, 2 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams, won 1/2 national title

2002: sec 3-4, 3 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team
pac 10 2-5, 2 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams

2001: sec 5-3, 5 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, 3 top 10 teams
pac 10 2-2, 4 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams

2000: sec 4-5, 6 ranked teams, 1 top 10 team
pac 10 3-1, 3 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, 3 top 10 teams

1999: sec 4-4, 6 ranked teams, 2 top 10 teams
pac 10 1-4, 1 ranked team #19

1998: sec 4-4 4 ranked teams, 2 top 5 teams, won national title
pac 10 1-4 2 ranked teams, 1 top 5 team, 2 top 10 teams


and this brings me to my next point, u guys were arguing that the sec always has up teams and down teams and that's why it's not as good, well the only up team in the pac 10 is usc. the only team to finish in the top 5 in the country since 2001 is usc. since that time, the sec has had 5 teams finish in the top 5 (tennessee, georgia, florida, lsu, and auburn).

also the pac 10 hasn't had a team win at least a share of the national title other than usc since 1991 when washington won a share. in that time usc won 1 1/2, while the sec won 5 1/2 with 4 different teams all of which they won outright except for the one lsu split (lsu twice, florida twice, tennessee, and alabama). the last national title the pac 10 won outright was way back in 1972 by...u guessed it usc, then 1967 by again usc. but then it's...well no my list only goes back to 1936. aww shucks, so that's 1 split national title for the pac 10 not including usc for the past 72 years. the sec has 11 outright and 16 including splits from 6 different teams (lsu, florida, tennessee, bama, georgia, and auburn).

zing. sec>pac 10 /discussion.

Your arguing the exact point that we are making... Do you realize that? The SEC beats up on non conference teams that are weak.. then a few teams each year beats up on the other shitty teams.... yet the word out there is the SEC is SOOOO tough top to bottom which is incorrect year in and out
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.