User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defense AI occasionally not followed
Page:
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Originally posted by SteelersInsider



I think the 4th and goal one didn't always happen because sometimes it really was 4th and 1 or 4th and 2 like teams wanted to go for it. Then there weren't many teams that went for it anyway. So you are narrowing down the teams alot.

Then most took that out of their play book altogether. So the situations where it could possibly still happen are 4th and goal from the 4.5 to the 2.5 yard line (if the condition was to go if 4th and less than 2). So now we are talking about very few situations where the "bug" could arise. That is why you don't hear about it anymore. People have their AI set up better.

And for me, it wasn't "occasional", it happened wrong every time and I easily figured out what happened the 2nd time it screwed up and went for it on 4th and goal from the 8.

Not even close to the same problem.


Maybe it happened every time to you, but certainly not for others and Bort. If you read the link, Bort had trouble reproducing the bug at the time. It is not as reproducible as you claim.

Again, back to the topic, do you see any input wrong that OP provided? If not, this is a legit bug when defense AI tester shows something different to in-game play under same situation.



I hear what you are saying, your point is, the user is saying he didn't make a mistake. Based on the fact that he didn't make a mistake, it must be a bug. Everyone else has used the same logic.

It is unfortunate that hazy thinks his gameplans are so valuable that he doesn't trust his GM to take a look when he is having an error.

There really are no secrets to AI plays in this game though. You can watch other teams and copy exactly what they are doing.


One, you won't lose the players.

Two, I know I didn't make a mistake.

Three, if you want to view my game plan to get my defense, that's fine. I'm not handing it to anyone on a silver platter, bug examination or not. Besides, my base defense has changed from the time of this initial post.

I haven't gone over my game today yet, I'll do so with a fine tooth comb and report back if there was any anomalies. If there was, I'll make sure to list everything in precise and exact detail from how long it took me to click the enter button when hitting the TEST button.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


why would I want to give away the info I know?


Because you can't explain why a 3-4 cover 0 can be illegal under a blitz package like you claimed. Even you can, you still can't explain why everything works fine most of the time and inconsistency only happens once in a while.


1.) that has never been proven (that it works fine most of the time)
2.) I gave you an example of why it might only screw up part of the time: if someone sent an illegal blitzer only a % of the time
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Originally posted by SteelersInsider



I hear what you are saying, your point is, the user is saying he didn't make a mistake. Based on the fact that he didn't make a mistake, it must be a bug. Everyone else has used the same logic.

It is unfortunate that hazy thinks his gameplans are so valuable that he doesn't trust his GM to take a look when he is having an error.

There really are no secrets to AI plays in this game though. You can watch other teams and copy exactly what they are doing.


Again, you misunderstand the two different things:

(1) What OP thought his AI would do
(2) What defense AI tester reported what play should be called

The case here is (2). It's not what OP thought, it is what defense AI tester reported that was different to in-game play. Other than inputting wrong data, defense AI tester should be consistent to in-game play, shouldn't it? Again, do you see any inputs wrong that OP provided? Do you have to see a snapshot of something to agree that his defense AI tester inputs are correct?



The error is almost always in the dropdown boxes in the play that the AI tester chooses.

I don't think the OP ever shared what those fields were. Even if he did, it doesn't mean that they are correctly selected.

What if he blitzed all 8 guys? The AI would reject that and say that isn't possible and run the next play in the list.

What if he has 6 guys that could each blitz 30% of the time? What happens when 5 of those guys are chosen or all 6? This would explain why a chosen field only gives an "error" part of the time - because the OP is only choosing a scenario that is impossible part of the time.

One thing it could be is that he is blitzing someone that can't blitz in the sceme he wants to run.

Did he list the blitzing %'s? I didn't see them.

Explain why this couldn't be the user error here.


I always select an exact number of blitzers and set the specific positions I want to blitz to 100.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Did you guys know that there are certain formations that you can't blitz out of?

If you try, it will negate the output and move to the next output on the list.

In that case, then the AI tester will point to the wrong play.

You have to figure out on your own what you can do and can't do though. Bort isn't going to give it to us. Just like he didn't tell us in detail what the SA's do exactly or the formula to get INT's.

Figure it out on your own. The OP sounds like he is lightyears ahead of many teams in AI, but he doesn't know everything yet.

Starting a thread like this only serves to have others copy what he has learned on his own. The goal line thing was an advantage for the people who found it first because they could avoid it. I suggest the OP does the same with this one and move on.


And again, I'll say refer to the original post.

The CORRECT play was called numerous times in the game. One time it was not.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Originally posted by buffalobills_tw


Originally posted by SteelersInsider




I think the 4th and goal one didn't always happen because sometimes it really was 4th and 1 or 4th and 2 like teams wanted to go for it. Then there weren't many teams that went for it anyway. So you are narrowing down the teams alot.

Then most took that out of their play book altogether. So the situations where it could possibly still happen are 4th and goal from the 4.5 to the 2.5 yard line (if the condition was to go if 4th and less than 2). So now we are talking about very few situations where the "bug" could arise. That is why you don't hear about it anymore. People have their AI set up better.

And for me, it wasn't "occasional", it happened wrong every time and I easily figured out what happened the 2nd time it screwed up and went for it on 4th and goal from the 8.

Not even close to the same problem.


Maybe it happened every time to you, but certainly not for others and Bort. If you read the link, Bort had trouble reproducing the bug at the time. It is not as reproducible as you claim.

Again, back to the topic, do you see any input wrong that OP provided? If not, this is a legit bug when defense AI tester shows something different to in-game play under same situation.



I hear what you are saying, your point is, the user is saying he didn't make a mistake. Based on the fact that he didn't make a mistake, it must be a bug. Everyone else has used the same logic.

It is unfortunate that hazy thinks his gameplans are so valuable that he doesn't trust his GM to take a look when he is having an error.

There really are no secrets to AI plays in this game though. You can watch other teams and copy exactly what they are doing.


One, you won't lose the players.

Two, I know I didn't make a mistake.

Three, if you want to view my game plan to get my defense, that's fine. I'm not handing it to anyone on a silver platter, bug examination or not. Besides, my base defense has changed from the time of this initial post.

I haven't gone over my game today yet, I'll do so with a fine tooth comb and report back if there was any anomalies. If there was, I'll make sure to list everything in precise and exact detail from how long it took me to click the enter button when hitting the TEST button.



the things that are most important in finding errors are the settings inside the play (shifts, man/zone under, LB settings to run/pass/balanced, number of blitzers, and blitz %'s........ not the play itself.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Originally posted by SteelersInsider



why would I want to give away the info I know?


Because you can't explain why a 3-4 cover 0 can be illegal under a blitz package like you claimed. Even you can, you still can't explain why everything works fine most of the time and inconsistency only happens once in a while.


1.) that has never been proven (that it works fine most of the time)
2.) I gave you an example of why it might only screw up part of the time: if someone sent an illegal blitzer only a % of the time


(1) Yes, the problem only happens once in a while. OP, jdbolick, and I see this pheonomenon.
(2) Define "illegal blitzer", for example, do you mean MLB is an illegal blitzer in 3-4? Do you mean if anyone set blitz percentage at MLB in a 3-4, the output will be skipped?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone


I always select an exact number of blitzers and set the specific positions I want to blitz to 100.


Fair enough. I'll go back and look at the play and see who you blitzed.

 
Link
 
this thread is so long.....maybe I missed it, but.....


Did you say you had it set to "3-4" or "4-3" base defense in the top dropdown menu?


I'm going to add that I can only speak for the 4-3 base defense.

The "3-4" base did all kinds of weird stuff the first time I tried it and I've never used it since. There could be a million bugs in it for all I know.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
The 3-4 defense is not filled with piles of bugs. I'm running 4-3 and 3-4 (different teams) with no issue. BTW, if you set max blitzers to 2 and have %'s for 5 different guys to blitz, it will get 2 of them (checking in an order) and send them and noone else. It doesn't make the AI barf.

I don't think I have seen Hazy's problem, but since he's one of the better at the game I've seen, and he's got another extremely knowledgeable GM, I'm going to start looking even more closely for this kind of anomalous behaviour myself.

 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
this thread is so long.....maybe I missed it, but.....


Did you say you had it set to "3-4" or "4-3" base defense in the top dropdown menu?


I'm going to add that I can only speak for the 4-3 base defense.

The "3-4" base did all kinds of weird stuff the first time I tried it and I've never used it since. There could be a million bugs in it for all I know.


I have 4-3 selected, but that shouldn't impact my use of a 3-4 for a particular formation. If it had not called the correct play numerous times (and this has been the case each time this error has been popped up), then I would think it was an error on my part but the thing is, it has called the correct play countless times but for some reason, sporadically, it will default to the last play call in my AI.

Seriously, my team is undefeated and these errors have never cost my team a game. I could have just blew it off and not said anything as it wasn't that big of a deal, but to me it has the potential to be a big deal and I'm about as positive as I can be that it is a bug. I'd hate for this to be the reason a team lost a big game, so that's why I posted the bug and that's why I continue to try to get it corrected (I even sent support a message since Bort has not popped his head into this thread).
Last edited Oct 13, 2008 22:16:31
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
BTW, if you set max blitzers to 2 and have %'s for 5 different guys to blitz, it will get 2 of them (checking in an order) and send them and noone else. It doesn't make the AI barf.



Who said it did?

I just said you can't blitz certain players from certain formations or it would barf as you put it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by thehazyone
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

this thread is so long.....maybe I missed it, but.....


Did you say you had it set to "3-4" or "4-3" base defense in the top dropdown menu?


I'm going to add that I can only speak for the 4-3 base defense.

The "3-4" base did all kinds of weird stuff the first time I tried it and I've never used it since. There could be a million bugs in it for all I know.


I have 4-3 selected, but that shouldn't impact my use of a 3-4 for a particular formation. If it had not called the correct play numerous times (and this has been the case each time this error has been popped up), then I would think it was an error on my part but the thing is, it has called the correct play countless times but for some reason, sporadically, it will default to the last play call in my AI.

Seriously, my team is undefeated and these errors have never cost my team a game. I could have just blew it off and not said anything as it wasn't that big of a deal, but to me it has the potential to be a big deal and I'm about as positive as I can be that it is a bug. I'd hate for this to be the reason a team lost a big game, so that's why I posted the bug and that's why I continue to try to get it corrected (I even sent support a message since Bort has not popped his head into this thread).



Well if you are unwilling to have anyone look at the actual code, then the only person who can help you is Bort.

If all 2,000 teams followed your lead though and did the same, Bort would have alot of code to look through to find everyone's bugs and would only be doing that all day long.

Best of luck to you.

I don't use the 3-4 defense because it is too easy to run on from my experience. And if I wanted a pass defense, I'd rather have an extra DB (or 2) than a LB.

 
Link
 
I don't claim to know everything.

For instance, I don't even understand why there is even a "base defense" option. What does it matter? You can call a 3-4 out of the 4-3 base and a 4-3 out of the 3-4 base, right?

 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
I don't claim to know everything. For instance, I don't even understand why there is even a "base defense" option. What does it matter? You can call a 3-4 out of the 4-3 base and a 4-3 out of the 3-4 base, right?

For instances where not all situations are covered by the AI and the defense has to default to something against a 2 WR set.
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by kurieg

BTW, if you set max blitzers to 2 and have %'s for 5 different guys to blitz, it will get 2 of them (checking in an order) and send them and noone else. It doesn't make the AI barf.



Who said it did?

I just said you can't blitz certain players from certain formations or it would barf as you put it.


I probably misinterpreted this comment:
Originally posted by SI

What if he has 6 guys that could each blitz 30% of the time? What happens when 5 of those guys are chosen or all 6? This would explain why a chosen field only gives an "error" part of the time - because the OP is only choosing a scenario that is impossible part of the time.


Originally posted by
For instance, I don't even understand why there is even a "base defense" option. What does it matter? You can call a 3-4 out of the 4-3 base and a 4-3 out of the 3-4 base, right?


Remember that Bort didn't originally intend for everyone to use the new AIs to call every play. He was just giving people some situational control. It didn't really get to be an every down thing for defenses until people started realizing formational stuff (well, blitz control is nice, too.)

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.