User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA #2 > Zeta: Season 5 Power Rankings
Page:
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ultrajer
Are you really accusing us of having a copy of your playbook?


So you're telling me you never looked at http://goallineblitz.com/offense_plays.html ? If so, why not? Bort posted it out there for every player to see with an Announcement that you have to scroll past on your main page.
Last edited Oct 8, 2008 22:17:33
 
ultrajer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
Originally posted by ultrajer

Are you really accusing us of having a copy of your playbook?


So you're telling me you never looked at http://goallineblitz.com/offense_plays.html ? If so, why not? Bort posted it out there for every player to see with an Announcement that you have to scroll past on your main page.


And doesn't the rest of GLB have that too? What makes us so special? Because we beat you?
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
No offense Zurai but what is your problem with losing to Offtopica? They are the toughest team we have played by far. And under what grounds are you requesting a re-sim?
 
ultrajer
offline
Link
 
You know what, I'm going to have to go back and check but I believe this is the first time we've ever beat you, ever. That might have something to do with it.
 
ultrajer
offline
Link
 
yep, we were 0-4 against you dating back to season 2, closest game 6-9 in season 3. I am not sorry we beat you, or anyone else for that matter. We are a focused team right now and are putting more into scouting and planning than we ever had before. Some teams do that.
Last edited Oct 8, 2008 22:40:27
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ultrajer
And doesn't the rest of GLB have that too? What makes us so special? Because we beat you?


Ah, so you admit you DO have 'our' playbook. Yes, we have access to it too. I wasn't saying it was unfair because you have it and we don't. I was saying it's unfair because there's no counter to it. There are plays in it that, if run, the defense is guaranteed to stop. And, without being able to actually physically specify which plays the offense runs, that creates a huge imbalance.

Before, you might have suspected that, for example, there was only one play out of the Weak I formation - but you had no way to know for sure, no way to prove the negative. Now you know for a certainty, so you can load your defense with a specific counter-formation that is guaranteed to succeed because you know exactly how the play is going to develop before the offense has even broken the huddle.

However, as I stated, that wasn't the reason I'm upset and complaining about this game. My complaint is about the "LB HB hurdle" as johnbarber put it. There's no other example anywhere in the game of two players that are not being blocked completely ignoring each other like that. It's an obvious bug, and I firmly believe that the 6 or 7 sacks it cost us lost us the game. I'm not blaming you guys or saying you exploited or anything like that. I hold you utterly blameless in this whole deal. I still maintain that it's a bug.

As for your "because you beat us" comment, I'm not even going to dignify that with any comment except for this one:

This is the first time I have ever complained about the result of a sim. Ask dpell, ask sxwesley, ask Polished Rock, etc. They'll all tell you that I've taken my losses just as well as I've taken my wins. I'm not complaining because we lost. I'm complaining because we lost as the result of what I believe to be a bug.

Originally posted by Modok
And under what grounds are you requesting a re-sim?


I already covered your other question, but let me respond to this one real fast:

I said that in the heat of the moment. I'll admit I was steamed after watching the LB/HB bug and I didn't quite restrain myself enough before posting. I never requested a re-sim and I don't plan to. OffTopica played well. They didn't, IMO, play well enough to beat us without the bug, but the fact that a bug helped them isn't their fault. I'm not going to contest their victory. I'm sure as hell going to push for that bug to get fixed ASAP, though.
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ultrajer
yep, we were 0-4 against you dating back to season 2, closest game 6-9 in season 3. I am not sorry we beat you, or anyone else for that matter. We are a focused team right now and are putting more into scouting and planning than we ever had before. Some teams do that.


The fact that it's your first victory over us didn't factor into it at all. Believe me, I recognize that you guys are a much-improved team this season (not that you've ever been a total pushover, mind!). I'm truly and honestly sorry if you think that I'm trying to say that you didn't deserve the win. I think that the Princes should have won the game and didn't because of a bug, but you guys won nonetheless and it's not like the bug directly contributed to the score - there were no WRs warping into the endzone with the ball or anything. You beat us, and good on you.

I'm just steamed because of the bug. Please accept my apologies for going about my complaints the wrong way, and especially for the comment about the re-sim.
 
Connection20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zurai
This is the first time I have ever complained about the result of a sim. Ask dpell, ask sxwesley, ask Polished Rock, etc. They'll all tell you that I've taken my losses just as well as I've taken my wins. QUOTE]

I'll back him up on this, always been a class owner.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
1) There are a lot of bugs right now that are exploitable, and if they aren't bugs they're oversights in the game that make for easy sacks, tackles, stops. I won't list them all. Some are really easy to exploit, others are somewhat dependant on the team you're playing and the tactics they run. There are several plays where defenders are completely unblocked out of certain formations and it's simply a risk/reward for the defense on whether they want to go for the sack and risk getting burned or play it straight. For the most part my teams plays it straight, but we know what they are and if we see other teams running them on film we will too.

2) Zurai has been a good guy about losses. I do think it's hard to see teams you're used to beating beat you. Funny enough, when JB did his first preseason rankings I PM'd him that some teams have always outplayed their rosters (Sydney) and others seem to have lots of talent on paper but don't play up to their levels or have bad tactics. OffTopica was one of the teams I've always thought had good players but seemed to not get 100% out of them. This season they obviously are.
Last edited Oct 8, 2008 23:18:49
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Zurai, so I pose this to you.

If Offtopica and ultrajer knew about these, isnt it your job to know them as well? Also, there are ways to counter these plays by what you call in your AI. If a play is being blown up by the defense, study the plays, ask around, etc...and find out how to NOT call plays with those particular formations.

If everyone is playing under the same set of circumstances, your complaint holds no water.

I believe this has more to do with being 5-4 than anything else. You have beaten 3 gutted or partially gutted teams, one good team (G-Conn), and one average team (Dragons). Every team above you in the standings has beaten you except G-Town, who you beat, and the Tigers, who you havent played.

I dont know you Zurai and I hope you do not take what I am saying as offensive. I am just giving you an subjective view from the outside looking in.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
It's almost impossible to avoid a lot of those plays. Unless you want to only throw short some of those pass plays are unavoidable.
 
Draven
offline
Link
 
GG today dpell. That was closer then I thought it would be. I hope we get another shot at you guys come playoffs. Boy im getting tired of saying that. If I have to say that a few more times I will find ourselves not in the playoffs. LOL !!!
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
I don't want to completely show our hand, but we guessed wrong on your gameplan and you did a great job shutting down our running game. I'm just glad we found some big plays to win there.
Last edited Oct 9, 2008 00:28:24
 
Zurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
Zurai, so I pose this to you.

If Offtopica and ultrajer knew about these, isnt it your job to know them as well?


Yes. However, it's apparently my job to know everything about the game, because I've had a HELL of a time finding anyone willing to be an OC or DC on my team. I've have to do all the advanced tactics myself, and I'm a casual armchair quarterback at best. I honestly am utterly clueless when it comes to defensive formations. Last season's 15-1 performance was done entirely without using the Defensive AI (and I was as amazed as anyone else by it).

Originally posted by
If everyone is playing under the same set of circumstances, your complaint holds no water.


That's actually not true. For example, two of the three possible pitches (or is it draws? I forget offhand) are telegraphed by the offensive formation. This makes it almost impossible to actually run that type of play. That means that a team that has players built to use that type of play is unfairly punished.

Originally posted by
I believe this has more to do with being 5-4 than anything else.


It has absolutely nothing to do with being a 5-4 team. Our first season we went 1-5. Our second season we were only 6-3 at this point. Our third season we practically didn't even have an offense; our highest score was 61-0 against a deeply gutted team. We somehow managed to go 13-3, but to this day I have NO clue how. Season 4 was really the outlier here; we went almost undefeated and had an astounding offense. Again, I have NO clue how. We really didn't change that much between seasons 3 and 4.

So, trust me, I'm no stranger to having a mediocre record or playing mediocre games. I'm also not upset at losing to any of the teams we've lost to; I think we've lost to Sydney as frequently as we've beaten them, Guadalcanal is obviously a very high quality team, and DPell knows what I think of his Convicts OffTopica played their asses off and deserved their win today; I just wish it wasn't using buggy plays, is all. You wouldn't have heard the hint of a complaint out of me if those ROLB blitzes hadn't completely ignored my power backs. Even if the ROLBs had bowled over my RBs and still gotten the exact same sacks and the game was otherwise identical, I would have accepted that as a combo of shitty luck and stuff that needs worked on build-wise. The thing that got me was that the two players just seemed to completely phase through each other without losing any speed or momentum.
Last edited Oct 9, 2008 00:28:50
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
BTW, I have to give a shout out to my QB's agent Deek. 9 games in and he just threw his first pick.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.