User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Why doesn't Bort address absurd sack totals?
Page:
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Actually... to fix this somehow it would help a lot if the RG and RBs got the ability to "remember" what guy caused hurries or sacks.

I recently saw how no less than 4 (!) blockers went for the NT in a 3-4 (C, both guards and FB) - while the LOT gave up a sack.

So if Bort just changes the blocking assignments to more realistic behavior ("watch the DE first, for he already managed to get a sack and/or a hurry"), quite a couple of games would turn out more realistic. I've seen my LG take on the NT in a 3-4 ALL the time. When facing speed rushers, why not allow or "order" the LG to double the RDE?

If done right, even the play-logic needs to change. A HB (and even a TE in some cases) going on a route should stay home if the LDE already managed to get 3 sacks vs. the obviously overmatched ROT - or the QB would watch out for the LDE all the time and dumb off the pass to the HB immediately. Same call for more than 2 blitzers. Right now, the plays don't consider that option.


Agree - the real problem is the G AI going for the NT against a 3-4

If the G would just stay 'home' to cutoff the inside route, the speed DE exploit (yes, it is one) would be negated.

Trying to get the players to learn and all would be nice, but I'd settle for the Gs staying home against a 3-4 for now
 
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by RAPB

Actually... to fix this somehow it would help a lot if the RG and RBs got the ability to "remember" what guy caused hurries or sacks.

I recently saw how no less than 4 (!) blockers went for the NT in a 3-4 (C, both guards and FB) - while the LOT gave up a sack.

So if Bort just changes the blocking assignments to more realistic behavior ("watch the DE first, for he already managed to get a sack and/or a hurry"), quite a couple of games would turn out more realistic. I've seen my LG take on the NT in a 3-4 ALL the time. When facing speed rushers, why not allow or "order" the LG to double the RDE?

If done right, even the play-logic needs to change. A HB (and even a TE in some cases) going on a route should stay home if the LDE already managed to get 3 sacks vs. the obviously overmatched ROT - or the QB would watch out for the LDE all the time and dumb off the pass to the HB immediately. Same call for more than 2 blitzers. Right now, the plays don't consider that option.


Not only do you see this all the time, there are ways to set up the defensive AI to draw in most or all of the blockers into the middle on passing downs, leaving the DEs 1v1.

This suggestion would go a long way in reducing sack totals and would make the pass blocking more realistic.


I've seen many plays where the NT is blocked by four guys while the DEs or OLBs run freely to the QB. It's really awful....
 
sonto
offline
Link
 
So to these guys that say the builds are bad. What kind of agility are you guys saying the OT's need? An OT on one of my teams has 56 agility and 41 vision and gave up 6 sacks to that one DE that was linked in this post. Or does he need more speed? Because that is only at 35.
 
keedon
offline
Link
 
-1

It's fine, if your OT has a shitty build, you're going to get beat by good build DEs. Likewise, if you have a good OT build, but bad DE build, you're not going to get sacks.

It's fine. This ain't like the NFL where EVERYBODY is good. This is GLB where build matters a lot.
 
Link
 
I thought this should have been "toned down" a little last season or even the season before. I'm now to the point where I think it doesn't matter.

Fast DE's are hitting the 4 for 1 mark on speed and agility and there isn't really anyway they can get much better. OT's with bad builds for pass protecting are finally realizing that there is more than blocking and strength that a OT needs and are putting their points in the right areas (finally). With OT's putting their points in 1 for 1 and 2 for 1 while DE's have to go 4 for 1, OT's are almost caught up to where these 5-10 sack games aren't going to happen much.

Too late to swing the balance now. DE's and OT's will be on an even playing field before the playoffs in season 6. It's too late to change things now.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by sonto
So to these guys that say the builds are bad. What kind of agility are you guys saying the OT's need? An OT on one of my teams has 56 agility and 41 vision and gave up 6 sacks to that one DE that was linked in this post. Or does he need more speed? Because that is only at 35.



We can't *give* you the answer. We still want to get our sacks on you.

 
Link
 
The REAL problem isn't the speed rushers.

The REAL problem is that the super strong OT's don't pancake the super weak DE's immediately on even play. In fact, the pure speed DE's get off the blocks just as well or better than super strong DE's.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
The REAL problem isn't the speed rushers.

The REAL problem is that the super strong OT's don't pancake the super weak DE's immediately on even play. In fact, the pure speed DE's get off the blocks just as well or better than super strong DE's.


Actually, the just avoid the blocks using first step, quick cut...and when that doesn't work they use their super pumped shed block ability..then the super pumped tunnel vision to sack the QB before a throw.

It really isn't a hard formula. But I agree that fast & agile OT's with pumped blocking but not strength will do just fine long-term.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.