User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Wow, I've got to focus on work. You don't understand and it's obvious you're not going to.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Man people are really making this into more than it is. The system is working as intended. There are no "conflictions." Your base attribute is what it is, decimals or not, it is what it is, and your training is simply a matter of raising it in chunks of one. I'm failing to see where people are able to form some kind of problem in this.


The problem is that the numbers are arbitrary. Having two fractions to keep track of doesn't make sense in an intuitive sense. Interfaces should be as intuitive as possible.


I have 82.7 speed. Am I 70% between 82 and 83? No....yes...well...kind of.

If you're going to move things in chunks, they should be stored in increments of those chunks. The fractions just confuse things, and don't add anything to the game.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Wow, I've got to focus on work. You don't understand and it's obvious you're not going to.


No, I do understand. I just think a clear concise interface is more important than you BETA player getting screwed out of 2/3 of a percent of his speed.

This game is in BETA. your player is irrelevant. Making the game not have stupid hacked interfaces, IS relevant.
 
joeflex73
offline
Link
 
I didnt mind the old way, adding the new training way was fine, but the bars didn't have to be added at all. I liked seeing improvement in players every night.

I don't think anything has to be done...but for the sake of those with OCD or whatever, round everything UP to the nearest integer, no one gets worse and the decimals disappear.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by OSU_Ed

Wow, I've got to focus on work. You don't understand and it's obvious you're not going to.


No, I do understand. I just think a clear concise interface is more important than you BETA player getting screwed out of 2/3 of a percent of his speed.

This game is in BETA. your player is irrelevant. Making the game not have stupid hacked interfaces, IS relevant.


Hey.

the interface is CONSISTENT.

All that is changed is the baseline attribute of players that have been grandfathered into the new system from the old. Every player that is created going forward will NEVER train decimals.

Like I said, if you can show me a good reason why decimals are not good then I'll agree we should remove them. Telling me that its inconsistent is not a reason. I can't train decimals today, you can't train decimals today, an agent that made his first player today can't train decimals. 100% consistent.

 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by OSU_Ed

Wow, I've got to focus on work. You don't understand and it's obvious you're not going to.


No, I do understand. I just think a clear concise interface is more important than you BETA player getting screwed out of 2/3 of a percent of his speed.

This game is in BETA. your player is irrelevant. Making the game not have stupid hacked interfaces, IS relevant.


We're arguing for the same side. I'm just trying to keep our side true and not tell people it affects everyone exactly the same if you stop using fractions in the sim.

It doesn't need to stop using fractions. It needs the training to be part of the same fraction. It can be displayed as a fraction or a bar. It should be used in the sim if it was before. As long as it's consistent.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio

Man people are really making this into more than it is. The system is working as intended. There are no "conflictions." Your base attribute is what it is, decimals or not, it is what it is, and your training is simply a matter of raising it in chunks of one. I'm failing to see where people are able to form some kind of problem in this.


The problem is that the numbers are arbitrary. Having two fractions to keep track of doesn't make sense in an intuitive sense. Interfaces should be as intuitive as possible.


I have 82.7 speed. Am I 70% between 82 and 83? No....yes...well...kind of.

If you're going to move things in chunks, they should be stored in increments of those chunks. The fractions just confuse things, and don't add anything to the game.


You can throw out as many re-wordings of the same issue you're suggesting as you like, none of them represent a clear and present hindrance of the player's ability to plan/build their own player or observe the stats of other players. Our human minds can easily comprehend parts of one hundred. Hell, we've been doing it since the beginning of this game. I don't know how else to explain it to you. The new training system works. It just does. And quenching a few people's obsessions will be a lot more cumbersome than them learning to live with it.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716

Like I said, if you can show me a good reason why decimals are not good then I'll agree we should remove them. Telling me that its inconsistent is not a reason. I can't train decimals today, you can't train decimals today, an agent that made his first player today can't train decimals. 100% consistent.



No, you can't TRAIN decimals, but you can GET decimals. That just doesn't make any sense. If you're only going to allow improvements of +1, you should keep it to even numbers.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OSU_Ed
Originally posted by Synovia

Originally posted by OSU_Ed


Wow, I've got to focus on work. You don't understand and it's obvious you're not going to.


No, I do understand. I just think a clear concise interface is more important than you BETA player getting screwed out of 2/3 of a percent of his speed.

This game is in BETA. your player is irrelevant. Making the game not have stupid hacked interfaces, IS relevant.


We're arguing for the same side. I'm just trying to keep our side true and not tell people it affects everyone exactly the same if you stop using fractions in the sim.

It doesn't need to stop using fractions. It needs the training to be part of the same fraction. It can be displayed as a fraction or a bar. It should be used in the sim if it was before. As long as it's consistent.


That's fine. As long as everything that has been earned, is accounted for in the sim, and no "make-up training" needs to be done to raise my formerly 58.83 attribute up to 59 from 83% progress. See Catullus13's suggestion.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 14:52:11
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
why is having to train once such a big deal? Everyone would have to do it.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
why is having to train once such a big deal? Everyone would have to do it.


All else being equal, if you could have to do it, or not have to do it, why choose to have to do it?
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Synovia
why is having to train once such a big deal? Everyone would have to do it.


it wouldn't be once. I would need to train some things 3 or 4 times to get from .7 to 1.0.
 
Synovia
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Originally posted by Synovia

why is having to train once such a big deal? Everyone would have to do it.


All else being equal, if you could have to do it, or not have to do it, why choose to have to do it?


You could say the same thing about the whole training system.
 
OSU_Ed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
Originally posted by Synovia

Originally posted by Jack Del Rio


Man people are really making this into more than it is. The system is working as intended. There are no "conflictions." Your base attribute is what it is, decimals or not, it is what it is, and your training is simply a matter of raising it in chunks of one. I'm failing to see where people are able to form some kind of problem in this.


The problem is that the numbers are arbitrary. Having two fractions to keep track of doesn't make sense in an intuitive sense. Interfaces should be as intuitive as possible.


I have 82.7 speed. Am I 70% between 82 and 83? No....yes...well...kind of.

If you're going to move things in chunks, they should be stored in increments of those chunks. The fractions just confuse things, and don't add anything to the game.


You can throw out as many re-wordings of the same issue you're suggesting as you like, none of them represent a clear and present hindrance of the player's ability to plan/build their own player or observe the stats of other players. Our human minds can easily comprehend parts of one hundred. Hell, we've been doing it since the beginning of this game. I don't know how else to explain it to you. The new training system works. It just does. And quenching a few people's obsessions will be a lot more cumbersome than them learning to live with it.


It works as designed. Design/Requirements were poor.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Is this the same people argueing that care about the color of their advanced equipment pieces?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.