The more I think about this pyramid idea the more I like it. There are a lot of strong teams being but for the long haul. Owners and GM's are forming strong ties to each other and putting together some great teams. What I'm getting at is there are teams on all the continents that eventually may be able to compete with USA Pro so there needs to be some way to leave a place like Africa if your good enough.
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Interpreting the Polls
The Suthrner
offline
offline
Oh and to chime in on the Mod vs. Player argument. Are all mods testers because its possible for a mod to play the game with the intent to patrol the forums to make the game experience better. On the other hand, how can game tester be able to compete right along side of normal players. If we paying money to play a game, be competitive, and have fun we should not have to compete with those who have access to inside information. IMO USA Pro is League filled with mods and testers and therefore cannot be compared to rest of leagues. The game has shown this when some teams get promoted to USA Pro, they were good enough to get there, but then get blown away in every game and are demoted the next year.
OttawaShane
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jim Mora
I still think tearing apart the community of some of these leagues is a horrible idea. Increased promotion might work, it's not ideal, but it could be the lesser of two evils. As you've seen, Canada AA2 is a great community - it would be a shame to see those teams flung to far reaches of the globe, and I'm sure it will lead to increased gutting.
Canada AA2 is pretty much universally opposed to our league blowing up.
Meanwhile, South America seems to be girding itself for another roit.
Two things:
Bort Inc. needs to be careful in how it interprets the poll results, as the OP says.
Also...be careful with any poll result where the choices are always presented in the same order, and the first choice is ahead. The proper way to conduct a poll, whether online or by phone, is to shuffle the order the options are presented for every respondent.
I still think tearing apart the community of some of these leagues is a horrible idea. Increased promotion might work, it's not ideal, but it could be the lesser of two evils. As you've seen, Canada AA2 is a great community - it would be a shame to see those teams flung to far reaches of the globe, and I'm sure it will lead to increased gutting.
Canada AA2 is pretty much universally opposed to our league blowing up.
Meanwhile, South America seems to be girding itself for another roit.
Two things:
Bort Inc. needs to be careful in how it interprets the poll results, as the OP says.
Also...be careful with any poll result where the choices are always presented in the same order, and the first choice is ahead. The proper way to conduct a poll, whether online or by phone, is to shuffle the order the options are presented for every respondent.
datongw
offline
offline
I think the poll will give Bort an idea of what people are thinking, but I don't think he can act upon them unless one option is the overwhelming majority (over 70%). 47% is high, but not high enough. Think of it this way, 53% of the people will be upset.
Precisionist
offline
offline
This may have already been suggested, but here goes:
If there is a League restructure, what about doing a region preference menu similar to when you are on the waiting list for teams. Maybe it would need to have more choices than 3 like 5 or 10, but at least it would give the staff an ability to appease somewhat the desires of people to get in the region they want when the restructuring goes. There could also be an option "Dont care" which would make sorting easier.
If there is a League restructure, what about doing a region preference menu similar to when you are on the waiting list for teams. Maybe it would need to have more choices than 3 like 5 or 10, but at least it would give the staff an ability to appease somewhat the desires of people to get in the region they want when the restructuring goes. There could also be an option "Dont care" which would make sorting easier.
Phantom_Opera
offline
offline
Originally posted by Precisionist
This may have already been suggested, but here goes:
If there is a League restructure, what about doing a region preference menu similar to when you are on the waiting list for teams. Maybe it would need to have more choices than 3 like 5 or 10, but at least it would give the staff an ability to appease somewhat the desires of people to get in the region they want when the restructuring goes. There could also be an option "Dont care" which would make sorting easier.
pfft, I don't want every tom dick and harry getting in to SA.
This may have already been suggested, but here goes:
If there is a League restructure, what about doing a region preference menu similar to when you are on the waiting list for teams. Maybe it would need to have more choices than 3 like 5 or 10, but at least it would give the staff an ability to appease somewhat the desires of people to get in the region they want when the restructuring goes. There could also be an option "Dont care" which would make sorting easier.
pfft, I don't want every tom dick and harry getting in to SA.
ChicagoTRS
offline
offline
bleh...hate the results thus far...would much prefer increased promotions/relegations. 2/4 or even 4/8 for a season.
Tito716
offline
offline
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
bleh...hate the results thus far...would much prefer increased promotions/relegations. 2/4 or even 4/8 for a season.
I would have preferred if Bort would have increased the promotions/relegations 3 seasons ago when I suggested it...
bleh...hate the results thus far...would much prefer increased promotions/relegations. 2/4 or even 4/8 for a season.
I would have preferred if Bort would have increased the promotions/relegations 3 seasons ago when I suggested it...
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
You either knew about the cheating (just like the rest of us did/do - and let's recap what we are talking about, but are not limiting our discussion to - gutting teams
What mod gutted teams?
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
collusion
What mod is involved in collusion?
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
buying accounts/players and then merging them when merging wasn't allowed
What mod did this once Bort decided to disallow it (it used to be allowed)?
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
multiple accounts for one user
Serenity had an extra account, but no players or teams on it (i.e. she did not create it for the FPs). She used it to browse the forums anonymously, and she was reprimanded once she admitted to having it.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
multiple teams
Sorry but this was never illegal. Users with multiple teams, mods and non mods have been allowed to keep the extra ones. I think I am the only mod with multiple teams, and I have gotten rid of 3 already. But it is not in any way against the rules to keep teams you had before the limit was imposed and 95% of multiple team owners are not mods.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
day trading
Sorry but mods have always been opposed to this, many of us have a very high level of roster stability, and it was because of our suggestions that many rules have been implemented to prevent day trading from being effective (e.g. you can only cut two people per day, minimum roster, the waiting period between signing and cutting or trading, the inability to trade between 2 teams more than every 12 days, the inability for a player to return to a team he left within 20 days, etc.).
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
using loopholes to win playoff games and then closing the loophole so it couldn't be used against you
Loopholes? If you mean pump fake we have complained about it for a long time and Bort did not have time to fix it because he was working on training. We had a thread of offensive and defensive bugs about 15 pages long with examples in the beginning/middle of season 4 which Bort is starting to catch up to. The reason people were not so cool with what davitrav said after the Bullets lost was that one, he was being a sore loser, and two it was ironic for a team that used pump fake so much during the season to complain about it in the post season, and three because you lost by 28 points - i.e. it wasn't even close. If Pump Fake is not what you are talking about then I have no idea what you are talking about.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
min roster/max xp
I am not sure what the problem is that you are referring to. The rule is you have to have 40 players (human + CPU) on your roster. If you don't have 40 humans the computer generates CPU of appropriate level and puts them on your team to get you up to the required 40. It is not possible to circumvent or "break" this rule because if you have fewer than 40 people the system will generate CPUs for you at day change to bring your roster up to 40. Thus it is not even possible during the regular season to have fewer than 40 players or to "break" this rule. Also it is because of moderator suggestions (mine) that Bort either has or will tie trading into this (not just releasing players) so that it is no longer possible to trade in such a way that your roster would fall below 40 people. It is permissible for everyone to go below 40 during the ofseason.
In general it isn't that Bort doesn't listen to people, only mods. We pass things alomg to him and organize them. Last season he was working on the new training and as I said, every suggestion you guys made, we also made to him and many more about bugs in the game, but he was so focussed on the training that he did not even respond to our threads, or not much. Now that the new training is out he has started addressing problems in the sim and in the game as you can see with the Pump Fake, gutting and collusion, and many other things he is working on right now.
You either knew about the cheating (just like the rest of us did/do - and let's recap what we are talking about, but are not limiting our discussion to - gutting teams
What mod gutted teams?
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
collusion
What mod is involved in collusion?
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
buying accounts/players and then merging them when merging wasn't allowed
What mod did this once Bort decided to disallow it (it used to be allowed)?
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
multiple accounts for one user
Serenity had an extra account, but no players or teams on it (i.e. she did not create it for the FPs). She used it to browse the forums anonymously, and she was reprimanded once she admitted to having it.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
multiple teams
Sorry but this was never illegal. Users with multiple teams, mods and non mods have been allowed to keep the extra ones. I think I am the only mod with multiple teams, and I have gotten rid of 3 already. But it is not in any way against the rules to keep teams you had before the limit was imposed and 95% of multiple team owners are not mods.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
day trading
Sorry but mods have always been opposed to this, many of us have a very high level of roster stability, and it was because of our suggestions that many rules have been implemented to prevent day trading from being effective (e.g. you can only cut two people per day, minimum roster, the waiting period between signing and cutting or trading, the inability to trade between 2 teams more than every 12 days, the inability for a player to return to a team he left within 20 days, etc.).
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
using loopholes to win playoff games and then closing the loophole so it couldn't be used against you
Loopholes? If you mean pump fake we have complained about it for a long time and Bort did not have time to fix it because he was working on training. We had a thread of offensive and defensive bugs about 15 pages long with examples in the beginning/middle of season 4 which Bort is starting to catch up to. The reason people were not so cool with what davitrav said after the Bullets lost was that one, he was being a sore loser, and two it was ironic for a team that used pump fake so much during the season to complain about it in the post season, and three because you lost by 28 points - i.e. it wasn't even close. If Pump Fake is not what you are talking about then I have no idea what you are talking about.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
min roster/max xp
I am not sure what the problem is that you are referring to. The rule is you have to have 40 players (human + CPU) on your roster. If you don't have 40 humans the computer generates CPU of appropriate level and puts them on your team to get you up to the required 40. It is not possible to circumvent or "break" this rule because if you have fewer than 40 people the system will generate CPUs for you at day change to bring your roster up to 40. Thus it is not even possible during the regular season to have fewer than 40 players or to "break" this rule. Also it is because of moderator suggestions (mine) that Bort either has or will tie trading into this (not just releasing players) so that it is no longer possible to trade in such a way that your roster would fall below 40 people. It is permissible for everyone to go below 40 during the ofseason.
In general it isn't that Bort doesn't listen to people, only mods. We pass things alomg to him and organize them. Last season he was working on the new training and as I said, every suggestion you guys made, we also made to him and many more about bugs in the game, but he was so focussed on the training that he did not even respond to our threads, or not much. Now that the new training is out he has started addressing problems in the sim and in the game as you can see with the Pump Fake, gutting and collusion, and many other things he is working on right now.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 10:26:22
jester76
offline
offline
why not take away regions names and just make divisions like NCAA?
D-1 = pro
D-2 = AAA
d-3 = AA
and so on. And establish sections to divide all of the teams with in the Divisions. I think folks get to caught up on the names of section, rather than if their team fits at that level. Or a player doesnt want to play in the South America area, and rather sit at the USA section.
D-1 = pro
D-2 = AAA
d-3 = AA
and so on. And establish sections to divide all of the teams with in the Divisions. I think folks get to caught up on the names of section, rather than if their team fits at that level. Or a player doesnt want to play in the South America area, and rather sit at the USA section.
GP1
offline
offline
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
long post that Im not requoting
Oh man. This drives me wild when someone has to chime in and has no idea what s/he's talking about. The first 4 issues were huge here on GLB over the last 2 months.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
long post that Im not requoting
Oh man. This drives me wild when someone has to chime in and has no idea what s/he's talking about. The first 4 issues were huge here on GLB over the last 2 months.
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
You either knew about the cheating (just like the rest of us did/do - and let's recap what we are talking about, but are not limiting our discussion to - gutting teams
What mod gutted teams?
The one that is extremely conspicuously absent from your list (nicely played, btw...I'm sure most newbies actually bought your playing stupid). No longer a mod, but not because of gutting a team.
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
collusion
What mod is involved in collusion?
see above
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
multiple teams
Sorry but this was never illegal. Users with multiple teams, mods and non mods have been allowed to keep the extra ones. I think I am the only mod with multiple teams, and I have gotten rid of 3 already. But it is not in any way against the rules to keep teams you had before the limit was imposed and 95% of multiple team owners are not mods.
Your appology is accepted.
I was going to leave this alone, but you know damn well what VB was talking about and who he was referring to in his original posts, and you had to go out of your way to act like he's nuts. Nearly everyone that was playing at the end of season 1 remembers all 3 of the stunts a former mod pulled, that virtually nothing was done to correct it and that both his actions and Bort's inactions sent an extremely powerful message that mods are above the law. Is that true that they are? That's highly debatable, but it still doesn't change the message that was sent to users, and you know that as well as anyone. Pls, stop trying to insult everyone's intelligence or pull the wool over the newbie's eyes.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
You either knew about the cheating (just like the rest of us did/do - and let's recap what we are talking about, but are not limiting our discussion to - gutting teams
What mod gutted teams?
The one that is extremely conspicuously absent from your list (nicely played, btw...I'm sure most newbies actually bought your playing stupid). No longer a mod, but not because of gutting a team.
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
collusion
What mod is involved in collusion?
see above
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
multiple teams
Sorry but this was never illegal. Users with multiple teams, mods and non mods have been allowed to keep the extra ones. I think I am the only mod with multiple teams, and I have gotten rid of 3 already. But it is not in any way against the rules to keep teams you had before the limit was imposed and 95% of multiple team owners are not mods.
Your appology is accepted.
I was going to leave this alone, but you know damn well what VB was talking about and who he was referring to in his original posts, and you had to go out of your way to act like he's nuts. Nearly everyone that was playing at the end of season 1 remembers all 3 of the stunts a former mod pulled, that virtually nothing was done to correct it and that both his actions and Bort's inactions sent an extremely powerful message that mods are above the law. Is that true that they are? That's highly debatable, but it still doesn't change the message that was sent to users, and you know that as well as anyone. Pls, stop trying to insult everyone's intelligence or pull the wool over the newbie's eyes.
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
min roster/max xp
I am not sure what the problem is that you are referring to. The rule is you have to have 40 players (human + CPU) on your roster. If you don't have 40 humans the computer generates CPU of appropriate level and puts them on your team to get you up to the required 40. It is not possible to circumvent or "break" this rule because if you have fewer than 40 people the system will generate CPUs for you at day change to bring your roster up to 40. Thus it is not even possible during the regular season to have fewer than 40 players or to "break" this rule. Also it is because of moderator suggestions (mine) that Bort either has or will tie trading into this (not just releasing players) so that it is no longer possible to trade in such a way that your roster would fall below 40 people. It is permissible for everyone to go below 40 during the ofseason.
Sorry, I missed this one. Do I need to remind you what Canadian Pro team was the one that caused all the fuss about this and who owned it at the time? Hint, it was the team that had almost all of it's players playing Special teams, O & D in their PO game because all the rest had been moved to their USA pro team for their PO game. I'll give him this, that former mod is responsible for more rules being created in this game than any other player (changes to stamina, trade deadline and roster mins, to name a few). Shame it was to stop him from pimping the system, instead of based on his suggestions. Remind me pls, what was done again to punish him for all of these acts? I'm pretty sure that the answer to that ? was nothing. Yeah, VB is WAY off base.
Originally posted by tpaterniti
In general it isn't that Bort doesn't listen to people, only mods. We pass things alomg to him and organize them. Last season he was working on the new training and as I said, every suggestion you guys made, we also made to him and many more about bugs in the game, but he was so focussed on the training that he did not even respond to our threads, or not much. Now that the new training is out he has started addressing problems in the sim and in the game as you can see with the Pump Fake, gutting and collusion, and many other things he is working on right now.
I thought Bort has said already that it only took him a couple of days to do the training thing, that it was relatively quick and easy. As a matter of fact, he's said that at least twice that I've seen, and both times he was saying that to discredit the posters complaining that he spent too much time on it.
Sorry, tp, but I've never cared for ppl that know better trying to BS others. It just bugs me. I'll make a deal with ya. I'll refrain from making any more comments on any of this, if you stop spewing BS.
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
min roster/max xp
I am not sure what the problem is that you are referring to. The rule is you have to have 40 players (human + CPU) on your roster. If you don't have 40 humans the computer generates CPU of appropriate level and puts them on your team to get you up to the required 40. It is not possible to circumvent or "break" this rule because if you have fewer than 40 people the system will generate CPUs for you at day change to bring your roster up to 40. Thus it is not even possible during the regular season to have fewer than 40 players or to "break" this rule. Also it is because of moderator suggestions (mine) that Bort either has or will tie trading into this (not just releasing players) so that it is no longer possible to trade in such a way that your roster would fall below 40 people. It is permissible for everyone to go below 40 during the ofseason.
Sorry, I missed this one. Do I need to remind you what Canadian Pro team was the one that caused all the fuss about this and who owned it at the time? Hint, it was the team that had almost all of it's players playing Special teams, O & D in their PO game because all the rest had been moved to their USA pro team for their PO game. I'll give him this, that former mod is responsible for more rules being created in this game than any other player (changes to stamina, trade deadline and roster mins, to name a few). Shame it was to stop him from pimping the system, instead of based on his suggestions. Remind me pls, what was done again to punish him for all of these acts? I'm pretty sure that the answer to that ? was nothing. Yeah, VB is WAY off base.
Originally posted by tpaterniti
In general it isn't that Bort doesn't listen to people, only mods. We pass things alomg to him and organize them. Last season he was working on the new training and as I said, every suggestion you guys made, we also made to him and many more about bugs in the game, but he was so focussed on the training that he did not even respond to our threads, or not much. Now that the new training is out he has started addressing problems in the sim and in the game as you can see with the Pump Fake, gutting and collusion, and many other things he is working on right now.
I thought Bort has said already that it only took him a couple of days to do the training thing, that it was relatively quick and easy. As a matter of fact, he's said that at least twice that I've seen, and both times he was saying that to discredit the posters complaining that he spent too much time on it.
Sorry, tp, but I've never cared for ppl that know better trying to BS others. It just bugs me. I'll make a deal with ya. I'll refrain from making any more comments on any of this, if you stop spewing BS.
Last edited Sep 25, 2008 11:48:25
Whatsdafus
offline
offline
I voted but the option i wanted wasnt there...
Leave the system as is and do what 1000's have been saying since the end of season 1. Increase the amount of teams that get promoted (from 2 to 4) and regulated.
That way the teams that suck fail faster and the power teams that are good rise faster.
As for gutted teams, or teams that were sold. they should go back down to the B level. and replaced with a team from the lower conf. As for a mid season change of guard or a gutting, let them stay in that league till the season is over then regulate em.
Leave the system as is and do what 1000's have been saying since the end of season 1. Increase the amount of teams that get promoted (from 2 to 4) and regulated.
That way the teams that suck fail faster and the power teams that are good rise faster.
As for gutted teams, or teams that were sold. they should go back down to the B level. and replaced with a team from the lower conf. As for a mid season change of guard or a gutting, let them stay in that league till the season is over then regulate em.
phthalatemagic
offline
offline
PP laying the knowledge down!
I do think it's possible that tpat just isn't as informed as he thinks he is. (not a dig, it's just a possibility) If that really is the case, I think he should stop speaking so authoritatively.
I do think it's possible that tpat just isn't as informed as he thinks he is. (not a dig, it's just a possibility) If that really is the case, I think he should stop speaking so authoritatively.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























