User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drazz00
Bort, definitely noticing the power back emasculation. I realize that power backs were TOO powerful last season, but its way too far the other way this season. i see elusive backs breaking more tackles, power backs not hitting the hole, and all the power backs I work with have dropped their YPC by at least half and have only about 1/4 of the broken tackles per game that they had last year.

Any chance to find a middle ground here?


Drazz you sure bro? My FB and Power HB(Earl Campbell) have averaged about 4-6 BTKs in the scrimmages and have averaged around 5-6 YPC. But yes tackling and FFs have gotten better.
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 15:10:59
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Den


Curious if this isn't something that could be fixed with a 'formation' choice in the AI.

First, as stated by another, isn't it min/max builds causing this generally? If your FB is slower than your OT's....then ya...you SHOULD have plays break down....imho

If Coord's could choose to run out of diff sets...they could choose to run FB lead block plays out of sets where the HB starts an extra yard or so back? (EDIT added) When playing with a backfield where the agility/speed difference between the HB/FB are bad. Teams with proper ratio's of speed/agility in the backfield could make use of sets the others couldn't.


I suppose it could help, but we would need more plays added, obv.

My main concern with the current state of the plays (since we don't have those other plays yet) is that people who have a huge discrepancy will complain about how bad the pathing for their HB is because he doesn't follow his blocker who is slower than dirt.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lawdawg95
The problem is we have a HB who averaged 7.5yds/carry last season and another who averaged over 5yds/carry. NEITHER of them has the "Power" back build that everyone bitches about and now they can't seem to do jack this pre-season.

It gets real damn old having everthing "fixed" all the time if a player does well.


So...you'd rather have broken stutter stepping?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Bort I have a question for you...is there a way where you can have the RB just hit the hole or find the open hole? They do way too much dancing in the backfield. In real life a RB will usually hit the open hole then try to make moves...they won't take the handoff, stop in the backfield and try to juke around until they find an opening.
 
Sledge
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Sledge

Originally posted by Bort


Run pathing got an update this offseason (as mentioned in my announcement).

It's now a combination of the double-pass algo and new path calculation only every so many ticks instead of each tick, frequency depending on elusive/combo/power settings.

Only change I made to the off tackle play, though, is the short RB pause at the beginning to give the FB time to get moving and get to the hole.


Dont understand why you would need to make the change for the FB Bort. There is no problem with the sim related to the FB. The problem lies in peoples builds of the FB in relation to the speed of the HB.

If a team employees a power fullback then they need to understand the limitation they are under for the Hb rushing. Shrug same goes for a pass recieving TE. If a team starts one then there running game will suffer.

These 2 issues wont be resolved until we can assign players to specific plays.

A player that has a blocking Fb must always be aware of what the Hb is doing with his skill points..The FB an Hb on a team need to communicate. If a FB is late hitting the hole the HB shouldnt be increasing his speed with his points he should be working on other things while the Fb brings up his speed.

This fix kinda smacks of the cookie cutter type variety. Everyones Fb no matter how badly built will be able to perform.



Problem is that the HB is set to follow the FB as a lead blocker on many plays. If the FB is super slow in comparison, he will get ahead of him almost right away and the play will break down every time. If the FB gets 2-3 ticks to get going, the HB will actually have a lead blocker at least for a moment, no matter how quick he is.


So wouldnt it be up to the owner to release the under performing FB and pick up another. Or for example use some boosts in order to correct the FB. If players use there boosts right away without even seeing where the need is...umm should the game have a built in safe guard for their screw up.. I'm guess what I am asking is if the players will have any responsiblity at all. This is suppose to be a competitive League. So I guess where I am coming from is how do we seperate the good players from the bad if we keep making changes to help bad builds.

You do realize that this change does affect the Fb's that had no problem hitting the hole. Matter of fact they are having to hold their blocks now for alot longer. So this could have a negative effect on those Fb's who may have a toon slip off their block now that they are holding it for a longer period of time.

 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
My main concern with the current state of the plays (since we don't have those other plays yet) is that people who have a huge discrepancy will complain about how bad the pathing for their HB is because he doesn't follow his blocker who is slower than dirt.


That's their fault. We had this problem 2 seasons ago, our HB was overrunning the FB, and we fixed it ourselves.

It's up to the players and team coaches/owners to assemble a team that makes sense. If they don't, tough.

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Bort I have a question for you...is there a way where you can have the RB just hit the hole or find the open hole? They do way too much dancing in the backfield. In real life a RB will usually hit the open hole then try to make moves...they won't take the handoff, stop in the backfield and try to juke around until they find an opening.


That's what the update was supposed to help do - only recalculating the position of threats every few ticks instead of every tick. Elusive still calculates every 3 ticks, though, so they have more of a chance to change their mind on where to go.

I guess I could update some of the definitions to have a longer "move to a point" part at the beginning, before releasing them to "find your path" mode, but that's what following the FB kind of does for you anyway (assuming he's not slow as dirt).
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by Bort

My main concern with the current state of the plays (since we don't have those other plays yet) is that people who have a huge discrepancy will complain about how bad the pathing for their HB is because he doesn't follow his blocker who is slower than dirt.


That's their fault. We had this problem 2 seasons ago, our HB was overrunning the FB, and we fixed it ourselves.

It's up to the players and team coaches/owners to assemble a team that makes sense. If they don't, tough.



Did you run into problems with the HB taking terrible approaches to the line when the FB was too slow, not following him, etc? If people can accept that as being their "problem" to fix, then I have no problem getting rid of the delay.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by jrry32

Bort I have a question for you...is there a way where you can have the RB just hit the hole or find the open hole? They do way too much dancing in the backfield. In real life a RB will usually hit the open hole then try to make moves...they won't take the handoff, stop in the backfield and try to juke around until they find an opening.


That's what the update was supposed to help do - only recalculating the position of threats every few ticks instead of every tick. Elusive still calculates every 3 ticks, though, so they have more of a chance to change their mind on where to go.

I guess I could update some of the definitions to have a longer "move to a point" part at the beginning, before releasing them to "find your path" mode, but that's what following the FB kind of does for you anyway (assuming he's not slow as dirt).


If the fullback is remarkably slow, then its user error...
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 15:23:04
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Possibly a player option in HB tactics would be good, a choice to hit the hole full speed as fast as possible or delay to follow the FB, or a balanced one, where he'd delay if he seems to need the FB or would go through a "good enough" hole without delay.

To some degree, a choice then about whether to behave more like last season and possibly get ahead of the FB, or to delay to make sure to follow the FB.
 
Noirlecroi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Bort I have a question for you...is there a way where you can have the RB just hit the hole or find the open hole? They do way too much dancing in the backfield. In real life a RB will usually hit the open hole then try to make moves...they won't take the handoff, stop in the backfield and try to juke around until they find an opening.


Actually, i think it is the opposite, you always hear coaches preaching patience to RB in terms of allowing the o-line and TE/FB to set blocks, then once the hole is recognized, make that burst. In looking at GLB skills, I am assuming that the skill flow chart might go vision, agility (which accounts for speed burst, Burt) and then speed.

If you watch adrian peterson, sometimes his first several steps seem almost slow until he recognizes the hole and then hits it. In fact, it has been reported that it is his preference to be six yards behind the LOS to give him time to read the blocks as he is building up speed. Other less discipline players, including my patriots L. Maroney, often runs into his blockers. Also, shanahan's one cut system requires the RB to recognize which of several possible holes which opened up in the zone blocking scheme actually is there and then commit to it.

so it seems to make sense to have that initial pause of a tick where the RB is making his initial read. But perhaps more in line with what has been discussed in this thread, it also recognizes that FB are slower than RB in real life
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Possibly a player option in HB tactics would be good, a choice to hit the hole full speed as fast as possible or delay to follow the FB, or a balanced one, where he'd delay if he seems to need the FB or would go through a "good enough" hole without delay.

To some degree, a choice then about whether to behave more like last season and possibly get ahead of the FB, or to delay to make sure to follow the FB.


There's a decent idea
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
While you're in here Bort, you might wanna have a look at pitches.

I've had to eliminate them from game plans all together. It's a guaranteed -2.5 yards against teams who know how to shift LBs and defend against the pitch.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by jrry32


Bort I have a question for you...is there a way where you can have the RB just hit the hole or find the open hole? They do way too much dancing in the backfield. In real life a RB will usually hit the open hole then try to make moves...they won't take the handoff, stop in the backfield and try to juke around until they find an opening.


That's what the update was supposed to help do - only recalculating the position of threats every few ticks instead of every tick. Elusive still calculates every 3 ticks, though, so they have more of a chance to change their mind on where to go.

I guess I could update some of the definitions to have a longer "move to a point" part at the beginning, before releasing them to "find your path" mode, but that's what following the FB kind of does for you anyway (assuming he's not slow as dirt).


If the fullback is remarkably slow, then its user error...


This.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j4mzf0rm0d
While you're in here Bort, you might wanna have a look at pitches.

I've had to eliminate them from game plans all together. It's a guaranteed -2.5 yards against teams who know how to shift LBs and defend against the pitch.


Yep, especially the weakside pitch out of the weak I since that's the only play in that formation. You just stack up and blitz with no fear of being passed on. At least on the off tackle play out of the strong I there are passing plays you have to counter for.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.