User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
hiimjake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Demboyz
Originally posted by methomps

Originally posted by CinTex


Originally posted by methomps





What? So Carrying should be 100+ for RBs, which means that we don't have elusive backs or power backs, we have carrying backs? If carrying is getting pumped up with equipment (and being 3rd capped), then elusives will be slower and less agile than the defenders they're trying to elude. Power backs will be less strong than a lot of defenders and as strong as many others. Every back will be the same: 3-cap+equip carrying and 3-cap spd/agi/str.



Elusive = 100+ Carrying... 70+ Speed and Agility

Power = 100+ Carrying... 70+ Strength and Agility

You just want it all and are crying because of it ....


I don't have a fumbling problem currently so there is no crying, and I have just as many defensive players as offensive players so I have no bias. A 70 spd/agi elusive back is not elusive. It is slow and will be caught by LBs with ease. At least he won't fumble though, only suffer a shit ypc.

A 70-strength back is not a power back. There are LBs out there with 100sp and 70 str/agi/tkl. Those LBs will be able to eat both of your HBs every play.


ppl need to stop throwing out numbers like its the truth. obviously your(ppl that are complaining) carry is not good enough anymore so raise it until it becomes sufficient for you.


Those numbers are the truth. A 70 speed/agility elusive back or 70 strength/speed powerback is useless. No competitive team would even give a build like that a 2nd look. Any back built like that is either sitting in the FA market or playing 3rd string behind backs 10+ levels lower than that.

And whoever made the WR comparison, that doesn't really work. With really high catching like that you're able to pull down passes in traffic even if your WR is completely blanketed. Really high carrying isn't going to do anything comprable tothat.
 
DONKEIDIC
pinto
offline
Link
 
Miss read.
Last edited Apr 28, 2009 13:53:08
 
hiimjake
offline
Link
 
Last edited Apr 28, 2009 13:55:01
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks


HBs now have about 80 in carrying. They forced one fumble on them today, but I think that was a result from the repeat play penalty, which kicked in because of a flaw w/ the play randomizer.


For the record, the OP implies here what most have said all along: It can be fixed by correcting the build.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Demboyz
Originally posted by boognish

Originally posted by Jason Cash


give the guy some carrying and you wont have that problem. No need in nerfing defense against if you're too fuckin lazy to actually build a decent HB


Don't be such a douchebag. He said they had over 60 in carrying, which is higher than most HB's currently have, and should certainly be good enough to avoid that many fumbles.




like i said earlier 30,40,50,60+ carry is not enough anymore because Defenders are switching to power tackling. this is not rocker science. y cant ppl understand this.


And why can't you understand that you have no clue what you're talking about?

In the higher levels of the game, DEs/DTs/LBs WERE playing on power tackling! The only time they reduced it to Balanced or Wrap-up was when they were playing a stud power back. This isn't the issue.

And so many of the ball-carriers saw this coming and increased Carrying and Strength, even moreso than LBs increased Str/Tackling. So it's not that either.

But yet, here we are two games in, and there are ball-carriers who will eclipse their total career fumbles by a large, large margin in a single season. PR/KR who have barely fumbled in 8 Seasons are fumbling on more than 25% of their returns.

Did there need to be an increase in fumbles? Yes! Did it need to be this drastic? No!

These wild swings from season to season are terrible. And I would think we've all learned by this point that the intense changes need to be softened at the very beginning of the season. If you didn't learn that from last season, then there is no hope for you.

And don't even get me started on interceptions...
 
Sharrow
offline
Link
 
Why is it that every season there is something else that ruins it? I'm glad I never wasted so much money boosting a ton of players like a lot of you have. I feel sorry for you guys getting ripped off by paying to beta test such a flawed game.
 
boognish
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Originally posted by Demboyz

Originally posted by boognish


Originally posted by Jason Cash



give the guy some carrying and you wont have that problem. No need in nerfing defense against if you're too fuckin lazy to actually build a decent HB


Don't be such a douchebag. He said they had over 60 in carrying, which is higher than most HB's currently have, and should certainly be good enough to avoid that many fumbles.




like i said earlier 30,40,50,60+ carry is not enough anymore because Defenders are switching to power tackling. this is not rocker science. y cant ppl understand this.


And why can't you understand that you have no clue what you're talking about?

In the higher levels of the game, DEs/DTs/LBs WERE playing on power tackling! The only time they reduced it to Balanced or Wrap-up was when they were playing a stud power back. This isn't the issue.

And so many of the ball-carriers saw this coming and increased Carrying and Strength, even moreso than LBs increased Str/Tackling. So it's not that either.

But yet, here we are two games in, and there are ball-carriers who will eclipse their total career fumbles by a large, large margin in a single season. PR/KR who have barely fumbled in 8 Seasons are fumbling on more than 25% of their returns.

Did there need to be an increase in fumbles? Yes! Did it need to be this drastic? No!

These wild swings from season to season are terrible. And I would think we've all learned by this point that the intense changes need to be softened at the very beginning of the season. If you didn't learn that from last season, then there is no hope for you.

And don't even get me started on interceptions...

Exactly. If Bort wants to make carrying more important by raising the number of fumbles players with low carrying have, that's fine, but do it incrementally. As you said, to have players who fumbled only a handful of times in multiple seasons now fumbling a half dozen times in two games is just not realistic or fair.
Last edited Apr 28, 2009 14:25:10
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BartRock
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks



HBs now have about 80 in carrying. They forced one fumble on them today, but I think that was a result from the repeat play penalty, which kicked in because of a flaw w/ the play randomizer.


For the record, the OP implies here what most have said all along: It can be fixed by correcting the build.


By "correcting" the build, you're forcing players to make HB's that are impotent. Any decent built Speed/Elusive back won't be able to bring carrying to 68+ until level 48+.

I don't believe this change in occurrence of FFUMs has as much to do with changes in builds/attributes than it does people using the Sure Tackler and Power Tackler VAs. This isn't a "natural" adjustment in builds, so you say, it's a large adjustment in the availability of tackling/ffum VAs.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by BartRock

Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks




HBs now have about 80 in carrying. They forced one fumble on them today, but I think that was a result from the repeat play penalty, which kicked in because of a flaw w/ the play randomizer.


For the record, the OP implies here what most have said all along: It can be fixed by correcting the build.


By "correcting" the build, you're forcing players to make HB's that are impotent. Any decent built Speed/Elusive back won't be able to bring carrying to 68+ until level 48+.

I don't believe this change in occurrence of FFUMs has as much to do with changes in builds/attributes than it does people using the Sure Tackler and Power Tackler VAs. This isn't a "natural" adjustment in builds, so you say, it's a large adjustment in the availability of tackling/ffum VAs.


Yeah, we don't know for sure if the drastic rehaul on the HBs had any effect, because we don't know if any of the defenders on the team we played today had PT and ST Vas. I do know that our MLB has both and he's forced 5 fumbles in the 1st two games (3 in today's game).

 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Originally posted by BartRock

Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks




HBs now have about 80 in carrying. They forced one fumble on them today, but I think that was a result from the repeat play penalty, which kicked in because of a flaw w/ the play randomizer.


For the record, the OP implies here what most have said all along: It can be fixed by correcting the build.


By "correcting" the build, you're forcing players to make HB's that are impotent. Any decent built Speed/Elusive back won't be able to bring carrying to 68+ until level 48+.

I don't believe this change in occurrence of FFUMs has as much to do with changes in builds/attributes than it does people using the Sure Tackler and Power Tackler VAs. This isn't a "natural" adjustment in builds, so you say, it's a large adjustment in the availability of tackling/ffum VAs.




While true, this brings up an interesting point:


What you are talking about is the slow build method of creating a player. Part of the disadvantage of slow building is the gaping holes it leaves in your build until you reach some level of balance in attributes.

I am not sure this is a good argument for the case in point.

Also, level 40 HBs don't really need nearly as much carrying...it is the level 50+ defenders who seem to really have the tools to cause rampant fumbles (in my experience)

 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=260271 1 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=101128 0 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=60183 0 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=60183 0 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=321831 0 fumbles

5 leading rushers on the unbeated pro teams in usa pro western conference. Why havent these guys fumbled yet? They are playing hb in a pretty tough conference. and they don;t seem to have the fumbleitis the weaker players, playing vs more inferior competition have. Why is that? Dunno but fumbling isn't a problem for the top agents, so maybe go look in the mirror ;(
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by taurran

Originally posted by BartRock


Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks





HBs now have about 80 in carrying. They forced one fumble on them today, but I think that was a result from the repeat play penalty, which kicked in because of a flaw w/ the play randomizer.


For the record, the OP implies here what most have said all along: It can be fixed by correcting the build.


By "correcting" the build, you're forcing players to make HB's that are impotent. Any decent built Speed/Elusive back won't be able to bring carrying to 68+ until level 48+.

I don't believe this change in occurrence of FFUMs has as much to do with changes in builds/attributes than it does people using the Sure Tackler and Power Tackler VAs. This isn't a "natural" adjustment in builds, so you say, it's a large adjustment in the availability of tackling/ffum VAs.




While true, this brings up an interesting point:


What you are talking about is the slow build method of creating a player. Part of the disadvantage of slow building is the gaping holes it leaves in your build until you reach some level of balance in attributes.

I am not sure this is a good argument for the case in point.

Also, level 40 HBs don't really need nearly as much carrying...it is the level 50+ defenders who seem to really have the tools to cause rampant fumbles (in my experience)



Trust me, with the slow built defenders (mostly DB's) that run speed HB's down like bloodthirsty cheetas, you need as much speed as you can get.

I have a HB with 103 speed that consistently gets run down by sub-40 db's. From what I imagine, things are a bit off balance (see thread about lower speed CBs covering high speed WRs), or else they're all pumping closing speed which lets them drag down these HB's.

Basically, you can't expect to make long gains past level 40 without 75+ base speed. Then there's agility, if you actually plan on using those elusive SAs.
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpride59
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=260271 1 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=101128 0 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=60183 0 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=60183 0 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=321831 0 fumbles

5 leading rushers on the unbeated pro teams in usa pro western conference. Why havent these guys fumbled yet? They are playing hb in a pretty tough conference. and they don;t seem to have the fumbleitis the weaker players, playing vs more inferior competition have. Why is that? Dunno but fumbling isn't a problem for the top agents, so maybe go look in the mirror ;(


Anyone care to answer that question?
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
43 carrying and 5 cover up and I have 3 fumbles in 10 carries.

This versus 4 fumbles in my last 650 rushes prior to this season

wut?
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zadith
Originally posted by dpride59

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=260271 1 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=101128 0 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=60183 0 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=60183 0 fumble
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=321831 0 fumbles

5 leading rushers on the unbeated pro teams in usa pro western conference. Why havent these guys fumbled yet? They are playing hb in a pretty tough conference. and they don;t seem to have the fumbleitis the weaker players, playing vs more inferior competition have. Why is that? Dunno but fumbling isn't a problem for the top agents, so maybe go look in the mirror ;(


Anyone care to answer that question?


" OMG THOSE GUYS ARENT ELUSIVE BACKS WITH 35 confidence, 50 carrying, and 110 speed getting sent into the line vs 15 power tackler, snarl line backers" Better answer is why are your low confidence Cb's, and hb's getting smashed into 15 snarl lbs with maxed out power tackler.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.