User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by tigerbait22


I know of about 10 and about 3 that have received inside info, but am sworn to secrecy on this issue.

Bort used really bad judgement here. It's not the testers fault, I would have accepted.. Would love to test some crap out and not have to spend hundreds of bucks before I find what works. This is favortism at its best.

To really think that these guys will not pass on good advice to his/her teams is laughable, it will surely impact the way THEY build their personal players.. How could it not. I don't consider it cheating, just a huge perk that they became privy to over other guys who play the game.


Agreed, I have heard from multiple sources that they know testers who gave away info(not maliciously but they said in the team forum, you may want to think about doing this next year) but that's still very dumb in the first place that you put people in the position where they can do that and try to keep it a secret. Obviously since I have heard it from other people, it's hearsay and it might not be true but the people I have heard it from are trustworthy and have no motives to lie. Wouldn't it suck if the Team A gets a heads up from the tester that certain changes are being made to certain atts and SAs while Team B has to sit back and figure it out on their own? That's a HUGE advantage after both teams boost.(if Team B boosts before figuring it out and put the boost points in other places while Team A puts the points in the right places)



jrry you know me well enough to know if this is BS or not.

Right now, I cannot think of one single thing which I could tell you that would give you an advantage next season, that I know of specifically because of the Test Server.

Of course there is a idea of what might be changing, but no firm knowledge on how it will change.

But almost everything being tested is a direct response to an exsisting Bug, and ANY good GM will keep half an eye on 'Bugs' to get a feeling of what might change next season.

In terms of player builds, there is too much difference between Testing and the lice Game Ai to really translate anything of value, other than the obvious (Better carrying = less fumbles etc.)



Mike, I know you to be a honest guy but can you vouch for every tester that none of them might have learned some priveleged info when reporting something to Bort? Like say, 10 in Spin does nothing and Bort says, yeah I'll have to make that better...now you have priveleged info and you know Spin is going to work better and maybe it slips to a teammate that spin will be better and he tells another teammate and so on...that's where you can have problems.

 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by tigerbait22

It's not that I don't believe Mike, but what is the guy to say? Yeah I learned this and that? Maybe Mike did not run as many tests as some others? Ever think of that. Mike is very PC in his post and kinda has to be right?


I have been responsible for running about 40% of all the tests completed, Far more than any other Tester.

Again learning what works on the Test Server really doesnt translate into what works on the Live site easily. Some of it will of course, but that info is not very 'elusive' its more like confirmation of generally held suspicions (Like Better Carrying = Less Fumbles, etc)

The testing is more centred around changing the Sim Rules to see how thats effected, than changing the players involved to find the best ones.


I would love to be a tester... No way that I wouldn't have learned some things.. All I'm saying. It's not your fault you were chosen at all Mike.. Was a good choice if anyone was chosen, just saying that in no way is it possible that some things were learned by you that I wouldn't like to know. You are a very smart guy, and GLB genius on your defenses and such, you can't tell me here or in private that there is things you learned that I can obtain without having the same testing advantage.

NOT your fault Mike.. Just my opinion that any edge gained was an unfair one.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by tigerbait22

It's not that I don't believe Mike, but what is the guy to say? Yeah I learned this and that? Maybe Mike did not run as many tests as some others? Ever think of that. Mike is very PC in his post and kinda has to be right?


I have been responsible for running about 40% of all the tests completed, Far more than any other Tester.

Again learning what works on the Test Server really doesnt translate into what works on the Live site easily. Some of it will of course, but that info is not very 'elusive' its more like confirmation of generally held suspicions (Like Better Carrying = Less Fumbles, etc)

The testing is more centred around changing the Sim Rules to see how thats effected, than changing the players involved to find the best ones.


If you wanted to though, could you exploit the system?
(ie stray from what Bort wanted you to test, and for your own personal gain)
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 13:08:57
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32


Mike, I know you to be a honest guy but can you vouch for every tester that none of them might have learned some priveleged info when reporting something to Bort? Like say, 10 in Spin does nothing and Bort says, yeah I'll have to make that better...now you have priveleged info and you know Spin is going to work better and maybe it slips to a teammate that spin will be better and he tells another teammate and so on...that's where you can have problems.



Well stated Jrry. Whether intentional or not the advantages are bigger than some want to admit.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
can you vouch for every tester that none of them might have learned some priveleged info when reporting something to Bort? Like say, 10 in Spin does nothing and Bort says, yeah I'll have to make that better...now you have priveleged info and you know Spin is going to work better and maybe it slips to a teammate that spin will be better and he tells another teammate and so on...that's where you can have problems.


OP add

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by tigerbait22


It's not that I don't believe Mike, but what is the guy to say? Yeah I learned this and that? Maybe Mike did not run as many tests as some others? Ever think of that. Mike is very PC in his post and kinda has to be right?


I have been responsible for running about 40% of all the tests completed, Far more than any other Tester.

Again learning what works on the Test Server really doesnt translate into what works on the Live site easily. Some of it will of course, but that info is not very 'elusive' its more like confirmation of generally held suspicions (Like Better Carrying = Less Fumbles, etc)

The testing is more centred around changing the Sim Rules to see how thats effected, than changing the players involved to find the best ones.


I would love to be a tester... No way that I wouldn't have learned some things.. All I'm saying. It's not your fault you were chosen at all Mike.. Was a good choice if anyone was chosen, just saying that in no way is it possible that some things were learned by you that I wouldn't like to know. You are a very smart guy, and GLB genius on your defenses and such, you can't tell me here or in private that there is things you learned that I can obtain without having the same testing advantage.

NOT your fault Mike.. Just my opinion that any edge gained was an unfair one.


People are honestly kidding themselves if they judge people that accepted the tester role to be bad guys because I'd be willing to bet almost any GLBer that owns or GMs teams would have accepted the tester job if offered especially if they are a GLB addict.

 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

I'm not going to say its not a minimal advantage, thats indefensible, but the people involved are not in my opinion, gaining a significant unfair advantage or enough of a increase in their knowledge that it becomes a problem.


So there would be no downside to making the entire thing public?


I have split feelings there.

On prinicpal testing really shouldn't ever be done in public in any circumstances, game development, business, hell even Football Pratice is not generally held out in public.

You test behind closed doors, then publish the results as required. I'm sure everyone on GLB was fairly surprised to hear Bort does it all on his own for the first time.

The way GLB works, as soon as one test appears, everyone will change their builds, not realising that its got pretty much nothing to do with what is happening or will happen on the main site.

But after the horrible way this was handled, by which I mean the cover up maybe it needs to be.

I dont see that it will add anything of value to the game, or balance anything in terms of advantage, but I have no objections to it.

My only concern is Bort always tries to make everyone happy, and that generally leads to GLB following the direction of the most obnoxious poster with the loudest voice.
I'd rather see a prorper vote on any actions taken OR Bort to just say This is the way it is, live with it.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Complete silence and lack of full disclosure from Bort on this issue doesn't help things. I can't fathom why he wouldn't be addressing this issue more aggressively instead of letting the wildfire burn.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Mike I don't think it ever would have been as big of a deal if Bort had said from the start, I have gotten these people to test on the sim because...reasoning...these are the things they are looking for and doing. It would not have been such a huge problem.(people would still be mad they weren't chosen though)
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by tigerbait22



I know of about 10 and about 3 that have received inside info, but am sworn to secrecy on this issue.

Bort used really bad judgement here. It's not the testers fault, I would have accepted.. Would love to test some crap out and not have to spend hundreds of bucks before I find what works. This is favortism at its best.

To really think that these guys will not pass on good advice to his/her teams is laughable, it will surely impact the way THEY build their personal players.. How could it not. I don't consider it cheating, just a huge perk that they became privy to over other guys who play the game.


Agreed, I have heard from multiple sources that they know testers who gave away info(not maliciously but they said in the team forum, you may want to think about doing this next year) but that's still very dumb in the first place that you put people in the position where they can do that and try to keep it a secret. Obviously since I have heard it from other people, it's hearsay and it might not be true but the people I have heard it from are trustworthy and have no motives to lie. Wouldn't it suck if the Team A gets a heads up from the tester that certain changes are being made to certain atts and SAs while Team B has to sit back and figure it out on their own? That's a HUGE advantage after both teams boost.(if Team B boosts before figuring it out and put the boost points in other places while Team A puts the points in the right places)



jrry you know me well enough to know if this is BS or not.

Right now, I cannot think of one single thing which I could tell you that would give you an advantage next season, that I know of specifically because of the Test Server.

Of course there is a idea of what might be changing, but no firm knowledge on how it will change.

But almost everything being tested is a direct response to an exsisting Bug, and ANY good GM will keep half an eye on 'Bugs' to get a feeling of what might change next season.

In terms of player builds, there is too much difference between Testing and the lice Game Ai to really translate anything of value, other than the obvious (Better carrying = less fumbles etc.)



Mike, I know you to be a honest guy but can you vouch for every tester that none of them might have learned some priveleged info when reporting something to Bort? Like say, 10 in Spin does nothing and Bort says, yeah I'll have to make that better...now you have priveleged info and you know Spin is going to work better and maybe it slips to a teammate that spin will be better and he tells another teammate and so on...that's where you can have problems.



In that example,
1) Tester would not know how much more effective it is.
2) It wont be made more powerful with it being 'announced' in the Change Log.
3) Normally this would be a response to a known Bug or complaint, so its not as privilieged info as it seems.

If this did happen, the most insight I would get is basically "Something which I always thought was pretty underpowered actually is, but will be fixed somehow. And everyone will know about it at the same time as it goes live."

I wouldnt be able to say OK the difference is going to be it ?x more powerfully or its now more important than x attribute/SA.

So yes its an advantage, but not really a usable.

The way I see it, anything we know of useable value should be public knowledge immediately, and so far thats been what I have experienced.
 
TerrellOwns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Mike I don't think it ever would have been as big of a deal if Bort had said from the start, I have gotten these people to test on the sim because...reasoning...these are the things they are looking for and doing. It would not have been such a huge problem.(people would still be mad they weren't chosen though)


 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Mike Rogers


I'm not going to say its not a minimal advantage, thats indefensible, but the people involved are not in my opinion, gaining a significant unfair advantage or enough of a increase in their knowledge that it becomes a problem.


So there would be no downside to making the entire thing public?


I have split feelings there.

On prinicpal testing really shouldn't ever be done in public in any circumstances, game development, business, hell even Football Pratice is not generally held out in public.

You test behind closed doors, then publish the results as required. I'm sure everyone on GLB was fairly surprised to hear Bort does it all on his own for the first time.

The way GLB works, as soon as one test appears, everyone will change their builds, not realising that its got pretty much nothing to do with what is happening or will happen on the main site.

But after the horrible way this was handled, by which I mean the cover up maybe it needs to be.

I dont see that it will add anything of value to the game, or balance anything in terms of advantage, but I have no objections to it.

My only concern is Bort always tries to make everyone happy, and that generally leads to GLB following the direction of the most obnoxious poster with the loudest voice.
I'd rather see a prorper vote on any actions taken OR Bort to just say This is the way it is, live with it.


I agree with the "live with it" part. Tired of nerfs and constant whining by avg builds. Tired of midseason changes as well, but this is the First thing that has really made me question whether to spend money on the game or not anymore. This was handled like most things on GLB, shady at best. There is simply not enough communication by Bort with his customer base. Few privy guys get access to test servers. Funny thing is, some of the same guys are already at the top of the game, further increasing their knowledge on the average GLB user. Take Havoc for example. Another very quality player and great guy, BUT his team is already unstoppable, (was before the testing, his record and accomplishments can't be taken away) so how do you think the KrazyMonkeys feel or other teams in Havoc's conference feel about him having tester access?

I GM Death Valley, and have many players on that team. Why would I like the fact that Havoc has testing access?
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Complete silence and lack of full disclosure from Bort on this issue doesn't help things. I can't fathom why he wouldn't be addressing this issue more aggressively instead of letting the wildfire burn.


Because he wants to sweep it under the rug. He simply does not do well or right by his customer base, but we do have a treasure hunt, and a new tournament introduced to take away focus on this issue.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Mike Rogers


Originally posted by jrry32



Originally posted by tigerbait22




I know of about 10 and about 3 that have received inside info, but am sworn to secrecy on this issue.

Bort used really bad judgement here. It's not the testers fault, I would have accepted.. Would love to test some crap out and not have to spend hundreds of bucks before I find what works. This is favortism at its best.

To really think that these guys will not pass on good advice to his/her teams is laughable, it will surely impact the way THEY build their personal players.. How could it not. I don't consider it cheating, just a huge perk that they became privy to over other guys who play the game.


Agreed, I have heard from multiple sources that they know testers who gave away info(not maliciously but they said in the team forum, you may want to think about doing this next year) but that's still very dumb in the first place that you put people in the position where they can do that and try to keep it a secret. Obviously since I have heard it from other people, it's hearsay and it might not be true but the people I have heard it from are trustworthy and have no motives to lie. Wouldn't it suck if the Team A gets a heads up from the tester that certain changes are being made to certain atts and SAs while Team B has to sit back and figure it out on their own? That's a HUGE advantage after both teams boost.(if Team B boosts before figuring it out and put the boost points in other places while Team A puts the points in the right places)



jrry you know me well enough to know if this is BS or not.

Right now, I cannot think of one single thing which I could tell you that would give you an advantage next season, that I know of specifically because of the Test Server.

Of course there is a idea of what might be changing, but no firm knowledge on how it will change.

But almost everything being tested is a direct response to an exsisting Bug, and ANY good GM will keep half an eye on 'Bugs' to get a feeling of what might change next season.

In terms of player builds, there is too much difference between Testing and the lice Game Ai to really translate anything of value, other than the obvious (Better carrying = less fumbles etc.)



Mike, I know you to be a honest guy but can you vouch for every tester that none of them might have learned some priveleged info when reporting something to Bort? Like say, 10 in Spin does nothing and Bort says, yeah I'll have to make that better...now you have priveleged info and you know Spin is going to work better and maybe it slips to a teammate that spin will be better and he tells another teammate and so on...that's where you can have problems.



In that example,
1) Tester would not know how much more effective it is.
2) It wont be made more powerful with it being 'announced' in the Change Log.
3) Normally this would be a response to a known Bug or complaint, so its not as privilieged info as it seems.

If this did happen, the most insight I would get is basically "Something which I always thought was pretty underpowered actually is, but will be fixed somehow. And everyone will know about it at the same time as it goes live."

I wouldnt be able to say OK the difference is going to be it ?x more powerfully or its now more important than x attribute/SA.

So yes its an advantage, but not really a usable.

The way I see it, anything we know of useable value should be public knowledge immediately, and so far thats been what I have experienced.


Mike, you know as well as I do that Bort sometimes doesn't announce things right away. So if everything you said did happen and Bort did his usual wait to announce things stance, you'd have AT LEAST a few days prior knowlledge which could get you extra points in it. This is all assumptions but it's going to be pretty hard for you to argue the fact that testers do get prior knowlledge to certain changes or certain things being fixed before the GLB player base learns it. And I doubt I'd have as big of problem with it had Bort not tried to hide it and sweep it under the rug. Had he come out from the get-go and described everything, I'd probably be a little bit like, why didn't I get picked but I wouldn't be questioning the game's integrity as much as I am right now and I probably wouldn't be as to convince that certain testers have given away info because right now, I am question much of Bort's decision making.

Last edited Feb 15, 2009 13:30:16
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by drifter

Complete silence and lack of full disclosure from Bort on this issue doesn't help things. I can't fathom why he wouldn't be addressing this issue more aggressively instead of letting the wildfire burn.


Because he wants to sweep it under the rug. He simply does not do well or right by his customer base, but we do have a treasure hunt, and a new tournament introduced to take away focus on this issue.


Obviously that won't happen. It boggles the mind that someone so smart can be so bad at fundamental business decisions.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.