User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by tigerbait22

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by tigerbait22



It's not that I don't believe Mike, but would is the guy to say? Yeah I learned this and that? Maybe Mike did not run as many tests as some others? Ever think of that. Mike is very PC in his post and kinda has to be right?


Yep, they have to watch what they say, but look at his post to Jrry, what is the first thing he says?

He did not learn anything that a regular GLB user could not have figured out.


And you believe this? So if thats the case then why have testers? Mike learned NOTHING... all testers learned nothing? Come on SJ


That's not what he said.

He said he did not learn anything THAT any other GLB user could not have ascertained, he never said he learned nothing.


Okay, so how can i learn what he learned? Explain that to me. Anything he learned is SOMETHING that I have no way of learning without putting money into the game and building new players.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by tigerbait22


I know of about 10 and about 3 that have received inside info, but am sworn to secrecy on this issue.

Bort used really bad judgement here. It's not the testers fault, I would have accepted.. Would love to test some crap out and not have to spend hundreds of bucks before I find what works. This is favortism at its best.

To really think that these guys will not pass on good advice to his/her teams is laughable, it will surely impact the way THEY build their personal players.. How could it not. I don't consider it cheating, just a huge perk that they became privy to over other guys who play the game.


Agreed, I have heard from multiple sources that they know testers who gave away info(not maliciously but they said in the team forum, you may want to think about doing this next year) but that's still very dumb in the first place that you put people in the position where they can do that and try to keep it a secret. Obviously since I have heard it from other people, it's hearsay and it might not be true but the people I have heard it from are trustworthy and have no motives to lie. Wouldn't it suck if the Team A gets a heads up from the tester that certain changes are being made to certain atts and SAs while Team B has to sit back and figure it out on their own? That's a HUGE advantage after both teams boost.(if Team B boosts before figuring it out and put the boost points in other places while Team A puts the points in the right places)



jrry you know me well enough to know if this is BS or not.

Right now, I cannot think of one single thing which I could tell you that would give you an advantage next season, that I know of specifically because of the Test Server.

Of course there is a idea of what might be changing, but no firm knowledge on how it will change.

But almost everything being tested is a direct response to an exsisting Bug, and ANY good GM will keep half an eye on 'Bugs' to get a feeling of what might change next season.

In terms of player builds, there is too much difference between Testing and the lice Game Ai to really translate anything of value, other than the obvious (Better carrying = less fumbles etc.)



Ok, so I didn't get the exact quote right, but the gist of it and the sentiment of it is pretty accurate.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by tigerbait22


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by tigerbait22




It's not that I don't believe Mike, but would is the guy to say? Yeah I learned this and that? Maybe Mike did not run as many tests as some others? Ever think of that. Mike is very PC in his post and kinda has to be right?


Yep, they have to watch what they say, but look at his post to Jrry, what is the first thing he says?

He did not learn anything that a regular GLB user could not have figured out.


And you believe this? So if thats the case then why have testers? Mike learned NOTHING... all testers learned nothing? Come on SJ


That's not what he said.

He said he did not learn anything THAT any other GLB user could not have ascertained, he never said he learned nothing.


Okay, so how can i learn what he learned? Explain that to me. Anything he learned is SOMETHING that I have no way of learning without putting money into the game and building new players.


He tells you in his post, watch the bugs forum continuously, ok, I added continuously but watch that and see what happens, you then have an idea of what will be going on.
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by tigerbait22

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by tigerbait22




It's not that I don't believe Mike, but would is the guy to say? Yeah I learned this and that? Maybe Mike did not run as many tests as some others? Ever think of that. Mike is very PC in his post and kinda has to be right?


Yep, they have to watch what they say, but look at his post to Jrry, what is the first thing he says?

He did not learn anything that a regular GLB user could not have figured out.


Do you believe that statement?


No I do not.. I saw the changes of personnel, and equipment changes. Believe me or don't believe me.. Up to you.


Changes to what personnel, equipment, not aware of that


Of course you are not... A team with inside knowledge that changed equipment around after the testing... I'm telling you that the advantages are real. Not some trumped up thing for people to gripe about. Most here will find anything to argue about, but I'm not one of them. I'm on record for thanking Bort for some changes and on record for complaining about some changes. I call a spade a spade. I'm not Pro GLB and Bort, nor am I anti GLB and Bort. I enjoy this game like everyone else, but I play to win, and want a level playing field and shit like this takes all of that away whether you want to see the truth or not.
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by tigerbait22

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by tigerbait22



Originally posted by sjmay




Originally posted by tigerbait22





It's not that I don't believe Mike, but would is the guy to say? Yeah I learned this and that? Maybe Mike did not run as many tests as some others? Ever think of that. Mike is very PC in his post and kinda has to be right?


Yep, they have to watch what they say, but look at his post to Jrry, what is the first thing he says?

He did not learn anything that a regular GLB user could not have figured out.


And you believe this? So if thats the case then why have testers? Mike learned NOTHING... all testers learned nothing? Come on SJ


That's not what he said.

He said he did not learn anything THAT any other GLB user could not have ascertained, he never said he learned nothing.


Okay, so how can i learn what he learned? Explain that to me. Anything he learned is SOMETHING that I have no way of learning without putting money into the game and building new players.


He tells you in his post, watch the bugs forum continuously, ok, I added continuously but watch that and see what happens, you then have an idea of what will be going on.


Also says more carrying less fumbles... Obviously he carefully chose one with common sense, but how about the ones that lay in the gray area? Confidence capped, or vision to 70, strength on a QB to 80... Lots of shit was learned.
 
marauder22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by tigerbait22


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by tigerbait22




Originally posted by sjmay





Originally posted by tigerbait22






It's not that I don't believe Mike, but would is the guy to say? Yeah I learned this and that? Maybe Mike did not run as many tests as some others? Ever think of that. Mike is very PC in his post and kinda has to be right?


Yep, they have to watch what they say, but look at his post to Jrry, what is the first thing he says?

He did not learn anything that a regular GLB user could not have figured out.


And you believe this? So if thats the case then why have testers? Mike learned NOTHING... all testers learned nothing? Come on SJ


That's not what he said.

He said he did not learn anything THAT any other GLB user could not have ascertained, he never said he learned nothing.


Okay, so how can i learn what he learned? Explain that to me. Anything he learned is SOMETHING that I have no way of learning without putting money into the game and building new players.


He tells you in his post, watch the bugs forum continuously, ok, I added continuously but watch that and see what happens, you then have an idea of what will be going on.


Also says more carrying less fumbles... Obviously he carefully chose one with common sense, but how about the ones that lay in the gray area? Confidence capped, or vision to 70, strength on a QB to 80... Lots of shit was learned.


How could any tester learn anything? I mean there only testing out any build imaginable
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Malachorn
Is it possible to be as retarded as sjmay seems to be and still know how to post on a forum?


Best post all day imo.
 
tseif
offline
Link
 
not just the things learned but WHEN the tester's learned it.

a game or two in advance is a HUGE thing.

and what about what bort said. they can manipulate the attributes of player.

imo it is more about what you learned that DIDN'T work. if you did then you will avoid it. the faster you avoid it the better, right?

now THAT is an advantage
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tseif
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

Originally posted by jrry32


Originally posted by tigerbait22



I know of about 10 and about 3 that have received inside info, but am sworn to secrecy on this issue.

Bort used really bad judgement here. It's not the testers fault, I would have accepted.. Would love to test some crap out and not have to spend hundreds of bucks before I find what works. This is favortism at its best.

To really think that these guys will not pass on good advice to his/her teams is laughable, it will surely impact the way THEY build their personal players.. How could it not. I don't consider it cheating, just a huge perk that they became privy to over other guys who play the game.


Agreed, I have heard from multiple sources that they know testers who gave away info(not maliciously but they said in the team forum, you may want to think about doing this next year) but that's still very dumb in the first place that you put people in the position where they can do that and try to keep it a secret. Obviously since I have heard it from other people, it's hearsay and it might not be true but the people I have heard it from are trustworthy and have no motives to lie. Wouldn't it suck if the Team A gets a heads up from the tester that certain changes are being made to certain atts and SAs while Team B has to sit back and figure it out on their own? That's a HUGE advantage after both teams boost.(if Team B boosts before figuring it out and put the boost points in other places while Team A puts the points in the right places)



jrry you know me well enough to know if this is BS or not.

Right now, I cannot think of one single thing which I could tell you that would give you an advantage next season, that I know of specifically because of the Test Server.

Of course there is a idea of what might be changing, but no firm knowledge on how it will change.

But almost everything being tested is a direct response to an exsisting Bug, and ANY good GM will keep half an eye on 'Bugs' to get a feeling of what might change next season.

In terms of player builds, there is too much difference between Testing and the lice Game Ai to really translate anything of value, other than the obvious (Better carrying = less fumbles etc.)



mike

as i've said, at the very least the testers get to know what doesn't work right there and then (when testing).

the other teams need to adjust during live games. the result will be advance knowledge, at least a game or 2. that is huge for most leagues.

and i don't know you and you don't know me but if the matter was such an insignificant one, why the secrecy? now if it's true that it was insignificant then announcing it wouldn't have been a big deal



What doesnt work in testing may very well work on the live site, it differs so significantly that this is actually the norm.

We are not testing the version that is currently being used or even the final version of what WILL BE released.

I'm not going to say its not a minimal advantage, thats indefensible, but the people involved are not in my opinion, gaining a significant unfair advantage or enough of a increase in their knowledge that it becomes a problem.

I fully understand that most people will not care for my opinion.



The reason for secrecy is not really something I can answer, I dont know the reason anymore than you, I could guess and speculate, but that doesnt serve any purpose.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
I'm not going to say its not a minimal advantage, thats indefensible, but the people involved are not in my opinion, gaining a significant unfair advantage or enough of a increase in their knowledge that it becomes a problem.


So there would be no downside to making the entire thing public?
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers

I'm not going to say its not a minimal advantage, thats indefensible, but the people involved are not in my opinion, gaining a significant unfair advantage or enough of a increase in their knowledge that it becomes a problem.


The reason for secrecy is not really something I can answer, I dont know the reason anymore than you, I could guess and speculate, but that doesnt serve any purpose.


Thats all that I was trying to say SJMAY.. Mike confirms that it is an advantage even if small. ANY advantage gained for a select few is NOT fair to the general GLB population.

Mike has to say PC stuff here. If I were a tester and was trusted enough to test, you can bet your ass I wouldn't blow the whole thing up in this thread.

Mike is as honest as anyone on this game, I have no issue with any testers, My issue lies with Bort's horrible judgement. It's not the first time and won't be the last.
 
tseif
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by Mike Rogers


I'm not going to say its not a minimal advantage, thats indefensible, but the people involved are not in my opinion, gaining a significant unfair advantage or enough of a increase in their knowledge that it becomes a problem.


The reason for secrecy is not really something I can answer, I dont know the reason anymore than you, I could guess and speculate, but that doesnt serve any purpose.


Thats all that I was trying to say SJMAY.. Mike confirms that it is an advantage even if small. ANY advantage gained for a select few is NOT fair to the general GLB population.

Mike has to say PC stuff here. If I were a tester and was trusted enough to test, you can bet your ass I wouldn't blow the whole thing up in this thread.

Mike is as honest as anyone on this game, I have no issue with any testers, My issue lies with Bort's horrible judgement. It's not the first time and won't be the last.


an advantage is an advantage is an advantage.

you want fairness. give everyone access and you can truly say that there is no advantage
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
So would anyone here feel they were getting a fair chance against a tester's team in a league finals?

That's the basic question.... testers were getting things both ways and were doing it anonymously. We still don't know who we faced that because they kiss Bort's ass just right might have had an advantage.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 12:58:05
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smallbugger
So would anyone here feel they were getting a fair chance against a tester's team in a league finals?

That's the basic question.... testers are getting things both ways


OP add

 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
It's not that I don't believe Mike, but what is the guy to say? Yeah I learned this and that? Maybe Mike did not run as many tests as some others? Ever think of that. Mike is very PC in his post and kinda has to be right?


I have been responsible for running about 40% of all the tests completed, Far more than any other Tester.

Again learning what works on the Test Server really doesnt translate into what works on the Live site easily. Some of it will of course, but that info is not very 'elusive' its more like confirmation of generally held suspicions (Like Better Carrying = Less Fumbles, etc)

The testing is more centred around changing the Sim Rules to see how thats effected, than changing the players involved to find the best ones.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.