User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Defense AI Interface
Page:
 
ggnringo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VenomCoach
Actually the problem with zones isn't the outside receiver it is the inside receiver. CB1 for example will follow WR1 inside and leave WR3 wide open in the flats. Now when WR2 is running wide open down the sideline technically that is what happens in a Cov 2 zone, when the WR clears their zone he is released to the safety.

The problem is the zone drops and how deep they extend. Right now a Zone Long only drops to 10 yards deep....a standard drop in football is 12. Zone Med is about 8 and Zone short is 5. I think Zone Med should be 10 and Zone Long should be 15. In doing so adjust the back end depth of the zone up. Those yardages I don't know.

There is a secondary problem in that the zones are not designed properly in a 34. When you run a 34 Zone the Corners have deep flats, the OLB have short flats and the ILB have Curl. If you blitz an ILB no one covers curl.

My suggestion is the following.

1. Break the choice into 2 parts, DB underneath and and LBs underneath. This would allow you to run man with the corners and zone with the LBs.
2. When calculating zones split the field into zones with 3-6 underneath defenders. Once the AI calculates how many underneath defenders there are it makes the appropriate drop. The reason I said minimum of 3 is that if there are less than 3 underneath defenders they would just drop to the middle. This at least lets you direct those defenders.
3. Increase the drop and depth of the Med and Long Zones.

Well also in Cov 3 I've seen my deep 1/3 CB's let the WR go.....he should be covering deepest in his zone.

+1
 
beersy
offline
Link
 
i am all on board with the custom D tool i have been playing around with it and i love it...make it happen captain!!!!!
 
Donovan Tatum
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ggnringo
Originally posted by VenomCoach

Actually the problem with zones isn't the outside receiver it is the inside receiver. CB1 for example will follow WR1 inside and leave WR3 wide open in the flats. Now when WR2 is running wide open down the sideline technically that is what happens in a Cov 2 zone, when the WR clears their zone he is released to the safety.

The problem is the zone drops and how deep they extend. Right now a Zone Long only drops to 10 yards deep....a standard drop in football is 12. Zone Med is about 8 and Zone short is 5. I think Zone Med should be 10 and Zone Long should be 15. In doing so adjust the back end depth of the zone up. Those yardages I don't know.

There is a secondary problem in that the zones are not designed properly in a 34. When you run a 34 Zone the Corners have deep flats, the OLB have short flats and the ILB have Curl. If you blitz an ILB no one covers curl.

My suggestion is the following.

1. Break the choice into 2 parts, DB underneath and and LBs underneath. This would allow you to run man with the corners and zone with the LBs.
2. When calculating zones split the field into zones with 3-6 underneath defenders. Once the AI calculates how many underneath defenders there are it makes the appropriate drop. The reason I said minimum of 3 is that if there are less than 3 underneath defenders they would just drop to the middle. This at least lets you direct those defenders.
3. Increase the drop and depth of the Med and Long Zones.

Well also in Cov 3 I've seen my deep 1/3 CB's let the WR go.....he should be covering deepest in his zone.

+1


This is true. playing a deep thirds in football the first rule is do not let any player get deeper than you

And in a 34 Cvr 2 zones are actually ILB split middle hook, OLB hook to curl and the corners still play the flats they just ride the WR out of their zone(that's saying if no backers blitz

In a 335 Cr 3 CB1/CB2 take deep 3rds, MLB takes middle hook, OLB hook to curl, the SS is walked down and CB3/SS play curl to flat with the FS playing over the top

 
Tom2277
offline
Link
 
Hey Bort,

it looks great!
Will you includ stunts for the D-line (inside, outside)?
 
vt_dolfan
offline
Link
 
Im on board with the creator....

But...its gonna really cause alot of problems I fear.....mosly because of the way it can be exploited. Every season we have a change..then we see a handful of exploits and alot of complaining. Because we cant adjust mid game...someone can run the same blitz that works over and over, and then it gets stupid.

There are way more things that can be done to improve the game before this....
 
Link
 
I love it!

Some suggestions:

Make the zones draggable instead of the drop down menu. Will make it easier when setting them.
Label CB1, CB2, CB3 etc so there is no confusion about where a CB will be when the play starts.
 
Plaxico17NYG
offline
Link
 
where can u look at this?
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Plaxico17NYG
where can u look at this?


You're not a team owner or GM so you wont have access to anything, but I've uploaded a couple of screenshots for you to look at:

Before
http://img229.imageshack.us/img229/4299/defenseplaybuilderzu6.jpg

After
http://img232.imageshack.us/img232/3739/defenseplaybuilder1zu1.jpg
 
Tman2008
offline
Link
 
I love it. I wish there was the same thing for offense.
 
Plaxico17NYG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Originally posted by Plaxico17NYG

where can u look at this?


You're not a team owner or GM so you wont have access to anything, but I've uploaded a couple of screenshots for you to look at:

Before
http://img229.imageshack.us/img229/4299/defenseplaybuilderzu6.jpg

After
http://img232.imageshack.us/img232/3739/defenseplaybuilder1zu1.jpg


cool thanks man
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
The D play builders is great.
Some additions that should be made:

1) When assigning blitz, you should be assign a gap to blitz through.

2) DL should have 3 options:
a) Pass rush (a DL cannot blitz) where he hits a gap and try to go through
b) Cover zone - no change
c) Gap control - the DL is less trying to go through his gap, but more trying to push the OL backward and control him (not moving around him). You should choose which OL the DL will attempt to push backward.

3) Among the possible zones there should be a run contain zone (mostly useful for DE, but maybe some will want other players doing that). where the defensive player will place himself to prevent outside runs. In madden this is described by curved black arrows. This zone is similart to the flat, but with the player closer to the cebter of the field, and also 2 yards inside the backfield.
 
stevenj54
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of being able to essentially "build" my own defense, but this still doesn't allow me to do it.

I want to run a 4-2-5 defense that only has two CB's and three safties, but I can only get it to work with 3 cb's and 2 safeties.

I can't adjust it that way with the DC either because there will be times I will run a dime or nickel and want the 3rd CB slot filled with a CB.

I would like to be able to insert any position into the build, rather than being stuck with 3 corners and trying to build a 4-2-5 from a nickel set.
 
easycheez
offline
Link
 
I've been discussing this on the other d play creator forum. The play creator for the defense really opens up a ton of new strategy that appeals to football guys who got into this game for the football aspects instead of the RPG aspects.

In my opinion, any play creator that doesn't allow you to select a gap to blitz is a complete waste. There are plenty of other things I'd like to see added, but the ability to have my NT line up in a 1-technique and fire the strong A gap in one situation and then fire the strong B gap in another situation seems obvious. the zone coverages, man assignments, and the other stuff is great but that is key.

Plus, free the coaches to drag-and-drop more freely. If you want to use the SS in deep mid 1/3, send the FS to cover the side deep 1/3, and then blitz a CB you should be able to slide those players around without being forced to stop at one point. The DE can shade the inside shoulder of the OT, sure, but why not allow him to line up on the outside shoulder of the TE?

I agree with stevenj54... If I have a bunch of good CBs but I'm thin elsewhere I try to line up with those CBs on the field. If I have plethora of stud DTs why can't I line up in a 50? Maybe a guy on my team has a stud SS available as a free agent... Why can't I have 3 or 4 SSs on my roster and then use 2 SSs on the field? We should be free to be able to adjust our personnel.

Remember, anything that anybody does on defense CAN be exploited. If a defense runs something it should be the responsibility of the opposing OC to find a way to exploit the holes that the specific defense opens up. And, if the offense can't take advantage of those holes, then the defense will win the game. Anything the defense does opens a hole somewhere, force the opposing OC to try to out-think you as much a you're trying to out-think him.
Last edited Jan 22, 2009 22:56:54
 
skotskipole
offline
Link
 
I've been tinkering with it and like it quite a bit. However, I sometimes am unable to properly save the play. Today I was trying to play with a custom Strong 3-4 man-to-man coverage blitz, but when I would save it, it would revert to a Strong Nickel 3-3-5 set with all the coverage men on WR1. That kinda wouldn't work too well...
 
flynn
offline
Link
 
Is the D play creator being scrapped for this off season at the moment? or is it still set to come out at some point?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.