well, after reading about 50ish pages of this thread (can't stomach the rest) ...
All I have to say is it's about frikkin time something was done. Players have been begging for this for at least 5 seasons now.
This system basically screws over the the cap 14 leagues, but at least it's only the cap 14 leagues.
As long as the system is kept in place for a few seasons, the leagues should be sorted out by the time teams get up into the 30 caps. SSB teams will get a couple of free trophies, and then they'll all be together, for the rest of their careers.
Eventually all the SSB teams will be together in the gold leagues, the legit teams will all be in the silvers, and the umm... rest? will be in the bronze. (more or less)
This change basically has little effect on SSB except to guarantee that if you want to be the best of the best in the gold leagues, you will have to SSB... which is the way it is now anyways.
Legit teams will have to wait until the Pros and WL to have a shot at gold leagues -- by then the SSB teams have declined a significant amount, because of their over-aged players.
I guess time will tell if it will be worth promoting a silver league team into a gold league... I guess it's possible that they'd be better than the worst of the SSB teams, but it'll take some convincing to show that they can compete against the best of the SSBs in the gold leagues. I can see a great silver team getting caught up in a yo-yo of promoting to gold then demoting back to silver.
Stopping SSB is a whole other issue, that has nothing to do with this thread.
fwiw, i'd suggest going with different labels than Gold, Silver, Bronze just because of the connotation.
How about good old Red White and Blue?
All I have to say is it's about frikkin time something was done. Players have been begging for this for at least 5 seasons now.
This system basically screws over the the cap 14 leagues, but at least it's only the cap 14 leagues.
As long as the system is kept in place for a few seasons, the leagues should be sorted out by the time teams get up into the 30 caps. SSB teams will get a couple of free trophies, and then they'll all be together, for the rest of their careers.
Eventually all the SSB teams will be together in the gold leagues, the legit teams will all be in the silvers, and the umm... rest? will be in the bronze. (more or less)
This change basically has little effect on SSB except to guarantee that if you want to be the best of the best in the gold leagues, you will have to SSB... which is the way it is now anyways.
Legit teams will have to wait until the Pros and WL to have a shot at gold leagues -- by then the SSB teams have declined a significant amount, because of their over-aged players.
I guess time will tell if it will be worth promoting a silver league team into a gold league... I guess it's possible that they'd be better than the worst of the SSB teams, but it'll take some convincing to show that they can compete against the best of the SSBs in the gold leagues. I can see a great silver team getting caught up in a yo-yo of promoting to gold then demoting back to silver.
Stopping SSB is a whole other issue, that has nothing to do with this thread.
fwiw, i'd suggest going with different labels than Gold, Silver, Bronze just because of the connotation.
How about good old Red White and Blue?






























