User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Mike88
offline
Link
 
Mark's post is the best. And those bazongas, man! You've convinced me.
 
jroyal73
offline
Link
 
soooo can he just fix the fumbling?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jroyal73
soooo can he just fix the fumbling?


it isn't broken, it is HBs builds that are messed up now
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps


What? So Carrying should be 100+ for RBs, which means that we don't have elusive backs or power backs, we have carrying backs? If carrying is getting pumped up with equipment (and being 3rd capped), then elusives will be slower and less agile than the defenders they're trying to elude. Power backs will be less strong than a lot of defenders and as strong as many others. Every back will be the same: 3-cap+equip carrying and 3-cap spd/agi/str.



Elusive = 100+ Carrying... 70+ Speed and Agility

Power = 100+ Carrying... 70+ Strength and Agility

You just want it all and are crying because of it ....
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
NERF THE NEWBS NOW!!!
 
Zadith
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by markhehe
Here's the real problem. I'll start with the speed/agility backs running wild a couple seasons ago. So:
1) Bort nerfs elusive backs
2)The GLB community piles on speed/agility to DEs/LBs

So, you end up with a double fix that crushes elusive backs.

Moving ahead, we have the speed/agility DEs get sack happy. So:
1)Bort nerfs DEs
2)The GLB community starts building blockers w/speed and agility

Once again, double fix

As another result of the previous 2 problems, people start building power backs because:
1)elusive backs are worthless
2)DEs and LBs are speed/agility guys, resulting in power backs running wild. So:
1)Bort nerfs power backs
2)GLB community piles on tackling and strength to combat power backs

NOW, we have defenders forcing fumble after fumble. So:
1)Guys are adding points in places to fix their backs, so they can hold on to the ball. Here it comes, wait for it!!!
2)Bort will nerf defender's ability to force fumbles. So, we'll end up with high confidence, high carrying backs and nerfed defenders unable to force ANY fumbles.

The pattern here is that as problems surface, most of us adjust to fix our builds from within. Meanwhile, Bort, meaning well im sure, is "fixing" the problem also. What you end up with is a massive shift in gameplay, instead of a ebb/flow kind of change. Matter of fact, i say none of these positions should've been nerfed at all. It might take a season for everyone to catch up, but thats part of the game strategy, imo. If you play someone dominant, make a move to beat him somehow. In other words, Bort please stop. thx



Agreed



Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by methomps



What? So Carrying should be 100+ for RBs, which means that we don't have elusive backs or power backs, we have carrying backs? If carrying is getting pumped up with equipment (and being 3rd capped), then elusives will be slower and less agile than the defenders they're trying to elude. Power backs will be less strong than a lot of defenders and as strong as many others. Every back will be the same: 3-cap+equip carrying and 3-cap spd/agi/str.



Elusive = 100+ Carrying... 70+ Speed and Agility

Power = 100+ Carrying... 70+ Strength and Agility

You just want it all and are crying because of it ....



And agreed. If there is an actual issue with the sim, by all means fix it, but when it is something that has to do with the way people have been building their players, then let the other side figure out what they need to beat them and then do it. If Bort nerfs/buffs different positions constantly because people cry about it instead of trying to fix it with their builds FIRST, then what is the point in playing the game? You just build the same coookie cutter build because you know Bort will nerf the first build that shows all the flaws in your build and then the other positions because useless(IE DEs with the new blocking code+ the better build O-lineman)....
Last edited Apr 28, 2009 12:03:44
 
hiimjake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by methomps



What? So Carrying should be 100+ for RBs, which means that we don't have elusive backs or power backs, we have carrying backs? If carrying is getting pumped up with equipment (and being 3rd capped), then elusives will be slower and less agile than the defenders they're trying to elude. Power backs will be less strong than a lot of defenders and as strong as many others. Every back will be the same: 3-cap+equip carrying and 3-cap spd/agi/str.



Elusive = 100+ Carrying... 70+ Speed and Agility

Power = 100+ Carrying... 70+ Strength and Agility

You just want it all and are crying because of it ....


Those elusive backs would be 100% useless. Any decent DB and most LBs have more speed and agility than that.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hiimjake


Those elusive backs would be 100% useless. Any decent DB and most LBs have more speed and agility than that.


Sounds like your OC is useless... Put the ball where there are no defenders... Look my Elusive RB has very low carrying but I am not dumb enough to rush him up the middle... I had a choice to make better carrier or better catcher and I went with catching and I don't care if the CB is faster if I can throw the ball to him 12 yards down the field then that a positive gain...
 
Demboyz
offline
Link
 
its pretty simple

ball carriers exploited defenders because they knew most of the time they will be on wrap up. knowing this they can afford not to raise carry that high they could focus on other attributes. when power backs started dominating, that force defenders to bulk up and switch to power tackling.

now those same ball carriers that were exploiting us cant do it any more.

 
gijosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
The 3 guys who fumbled all have at least 60 in carrying. How high does it need to be?


Better than the defenders strength, tackling, and take into accoutn if they dont use "wrap-up" and instead go for power tackling.
 
boognish
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by methomps
Originally posted by CinTex

Originally posted by boognish




Don't be such a douchebag. He said they had over 60 in carrying, which is higher than most HB's currently have, and should certainly be good enough to avoid that many fumbles.




No it shouldn't! Carrying is the #1 attribute for a RB... yet they treat it as if its the 4th or 5th... RBs should have Carrying in the high 80s and really 100+


What? So Carrying should be 100+ for RBs, which means that we don't have elusive backs or power backs, we have carrying backs? If carrying is getting pumped up with equipment (and being 3rd capped), then elusives will be slower and less agile than the defenders they're trying to elude. Power backs will be less strong than a lot of defenders and as strong as many others. Every back will be the same: 3-cap+equip carrying and 3-cap spd/agi/str.



Exactly what I was going to say. How many attributes do people expect a player to have in the 100's? It's impossible to get 4 or 5 attributes that high, while still adding to SA's. All defenders have to do is flip the switch to power tackling, but HB's are expected to max out several attributes to counter their tactical moves.

How about giving HB's a slider bar of tactical choices for carrying, like: 1. cover up ball tightly all the time (less chance to break tackles), 2. Medium (moderate amount of elusive/power moves to elude tackles; moderate chance of fumbling), 3. High Risk (Juke 'em outta their shoes, or power through defenders at will (much higher chance of fumbling)


 
hiimjake
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CinTex
Originally posted by hiimjake



Those elusive backs would be 100% useless. Any decent DB and most LBs have more speed and agility than that.


Sounds like your OC is useless... Put the ball where there are no defenders... Look my Elusive RB has very low carrying but I am not dumb enough to rush him up the middle... I had a choice to make better carrier or better catcher and I went with catching and I don't care if the CB is faster if I can throw the ball to him 12 yards down the field then that a positive gain...


What OC? The highest level team I'm a part of hasn't had any fumbles yet this season. I wouldn't have even known there was a "problem" if not for this thread. But if you think a 100 carrying 70 speed/agility back is going to be useful in any way you're nuts.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by gijosh
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

The 3 guys who fumbled all have at least 60 in carrying. How high does it need to be?


Better than the defenders strength, tackling, and take into accoutn if they dont use "wrap-up" and instead go for power tackling.


So 110-ish carrying? Because plenty of DTs have that much strength.
 
boognish
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by gijosh

Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks


The 3 guys who fumbled all have at least 60 in carrying. How high does it need to be?


Better than the defenders strength, tackling, and take into accoutn if they dont use "wrap-up" and instead go for power tackling.


So 110-ish carrying? Because plenty of DTs have that much strength.


Right, and you'll need over 110 agility and speed so you can keep up with those speedy, agile CB's, LB's and Safeties. And you'll need over 100 in vision, so you can see where those lanes are to run through. And don't forget to pump up some of those SA's; you'll need them.

By the time you hit level 70, you should be a pretty decent HB, although you'll also be retired.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
So you guys all think that 14 fumbles in a game is normal and realistic and the game should continue this way?


About as realistic as 30 and 40 broken tackles.

Fix your builds.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.