User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by cmj33

Originally posted by Mickyt1985


Originally posted by cmj33



Originally posted by Laggo




This is all forgetting to mention we usually get slowed down a bit after we break a tackle - usually enough for another 100 speed defense player to get in our face again.

If the entire defense is 100 speed, no strength/tackling - I should be able to get 5 yards consistently.

Force defenses to balance out more instead of entire speed-demon backfields.


I agree to an extent Laggo, but we should not be forced to change our player builds are when 80% of the backs out there have been Speed backs and that is what you have to build your players to stop.


So people who've invested in Power backs should be forced to change their player builds because you guys didn't build properly?

Give me a break.

As far as I can see...Powerbacks in the NFL are even successful and break tackles at will...Adrian Peterson breaks tackles all the time...and is incredibly hard to pull down...what are we going to do...NERF his break tackle ability because defenses can't handle him?

If your DC is good enough...you can gameplan against it...if you are a level 30+ LB and don't have strength/tackling soft capped...then you are a pretty useless LB anyway IMO...Sure its great to focus on speed, but getting Strength/Speed/Agility/Tackling to soft cap first is always the best start. Do that...and you then have enough weapons to stop a powerback if you plan correctly.


Don't assume you know my LBers build. And don't try to take what I said and twist it. I simply said the change is Extreme!! And TBH I have not had a problem with my LB's until todays Sims. As a matter of fact here are their defensive stats from alst season.

37 TKLs 4 MSTKL
45 TKLs 1 MSTKL

And I am supposed to swallow that crap
4 MSTKL in a season to 7 per game?


What are your Strength and Tackling?


Was 55 /55 now it isn't lol
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cmj33
Originally posted by Maddoc

So you built your players in one very specific way to stop the metagame, and then when the metagame changes you don't think your players builds should have to?

Bravo, I applaud your thick-headedness.


No I did not build my Players with 100+ speed.

As a matter of fact MY LBers don't have over 80 Speed. They are very balanced which is the reason I am pissed. If you would take time and actually read the post you would see that I have stated they have STR not 75-80 but enough to suffice.


Originally posted by cmj33

I agree to an extent Laggo, but we should not be forced to change our player builds are when 80% of the backs out there have been Speed backs and that is what you have to build your players to stop.


Bolded the important parts.

That post implies that you build your player to stop speedy elusive backs, and now you're crying that you can't stop strong power backs.

Don't know or care what your players stats are really, I'm just going by what you yourself have typed up.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 15:45:53
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cmj33
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by cmj33


Originally posted by Mickyt1985



Originally posted by cmj33




Originally posted by Laggo





This is all forgetting to mention we usually get slowed down a bit after we break a tackle - usually enough for another 100 speed defense player to get in our face again.

If the entire defense is 100 speed, no strength/tackling - I should be able to get 5 yards consistently.

Force defenses to balance out more instead of entire speed-demon backfields.


I agree to an extent Laggo, but we should not be forced to change our player builds are when 80% of the backs out there have been Speed backs and that is what you have to build your players to stop.


So people who've invested in Power backs should be forced to change their player builds because you guys didn't build properly?

Give me a break.

As far as I can see...Powerbacks in the NFL are even successful and break tackles at will...Adrian Peterson breaks tackles all the time...and is incredibly hard to pull down...what are we going to do...NERF his break tackle ability because defenses can't handle him?

If your DC is good enough...you can gameplan against it...if you are a level 30+ LB and don't have strength/tackling soft capped...then you are a pretty useless LB anyway IMO...Sure its great to focus on speed, but getting Strength/Speed/Agility/Tackling to soft cap first is always the best start. Do that...and you then have enough weapons to stop a powerback if you plan correctly.


Don't assume you know my LBers build. And don't try to take what I said and twist it. I simply said the change is Extreme!! And TBH I have not had a problem with my LB's until todays Sims. As a matter of fact here are their defensive stats from alst season.

37 TKLs 4 MSTKL
45 TKLs 1 MSTKL

And I am supposed to swallow that crap
4 MSTKL in a season to 7 per game?


What are your Strength and Tackling?


Was 55 /55 now it isn't lol


With 55/55 you were probably unlucky to miss 7 in one game, or you were playing against a power back as super as the build Bort began the thread with.

Get it to 60/70 and if you still miss as many tackles (consistently) you could have a point.
 
Knicksfan20
offline
Link
 
is bort even reading this thread now? if not...all these posts are pointless lol.


maybe bort should of locked it when he was off..then reopend when he was on.


 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
Originally posted by cmj33

Originally posted by Maddoc


So you built your players in one very specific way to stop the metagame, and then when the metagame changes you don't think your players builds should have to?

Bravo, I applaud your thick-headedness.


No I did not build my Players with 100+ speed.

As a matter of fact MY LBers don't have over 80 Speed. They are very balanced which is the reason I am pissed. If you would take time and actually read the post you would see that I have stated they have STR not 75-80 but enough to suffice.


Originally posted by Laggo


I agree to an extent Laggo, but we should not be forced to change our player builds are when 80% of the backs out there have been Speed backs and that is what you have to build your players to stop.


Bolded the important parts.

That post implies that you build your player to stop speedy elusive backs, and now you're crying that you can't stop strong power backs.

Don't know or care what your players stats are really, I'm just going by what you yourself have typed up.


Just for fairness, I think you attributed comments to Laggo that weren't his. He seems to be on the sane, "fix your LBs' builds" side of the argument.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
I did indeed! Deleted the wrong quote field.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 15:45:36
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
is bort even reading this thread now? if not...all these posts are pointless lol.


maybe bort should of locked it when he was off..then reopend when he was on.




He was on recently, and I'm sure took a look at the thread.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
is bort even reading this thread now? if not...all these posts are pointless lol.


maybe bort should of locked it when he was off..then reopend when he was on.




LOL, I've had to catch up, but yes I read the last 20 or so pages
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
Sure Tackling is your friend.
 
NRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort

Originally posted by imnotthatstupid


hooty hoo


fail


Owned lmao


Really? lyao?
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Knicksfan20

is bort even reading this thread now? if not...all these posts are pointless lol.


maybe bort should of locked it when he was off..then reopend when he was on.




LOL, I've had to catch up, but yes I read the last 20 or so pages


Everything looks good Bort. Don't make any changes.
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
And sorry but you don't go 15-1 four consecutive seasons and have one of the best defenses in the league with inferior builds. So your argument there is obsolete.
 
Fuzzballx
offline
Link
 
Mac say:

I put vet skills development in str and power rush...i think to myself...defenders about speed speed speed and agility these days...i decide...i no want to avoid defender...i want to knock em flat...so i go all out str and power rush in my training, i have a goal...i want to run through them, not around them.

Defenders...they all still thought...i need more speed more speed more speed...i laughed cause i knew i was keeping building my str and they were ignoring their str and tackling abilities. I knew i'd become better and better over the seasons as i persevered in my str and power training untill i'd break tackles almost every play because they were only building to stop fast and agile ball carriers and i was building smart against this flavor of the decade mentality for speed....i figured i'd suffer through building up but when i got there i'd be good..

Now i'm pissed...cause i'm really strong now and really good and powering through defenders who havn't been practicing their tackling skills enough and havn't been weightliftng like they should have been.

But the defenders? Turns out they aren't good sports...and something surprises them...cause they were blind to the power rusher and not expecting to be overpowered by people more than 2.5 times their strength... These defenders...isntead of hitting the gym and bulking up and working on their tackle skills to get better...they go crying to the commissioner instead....now the commissioner...all he's hearing is the outcry...the outburst..the fury...from these pathetically poor sportsmen...and he's changing the damn rules for the game on me! so all my years of training and planning....i think they might be going down the drain...maybe if they change the rules now...i'll never be anything special....

If that's the only way they can beat me is changing the rules cause they don't have the heart for the game....man this game aint worth it then... Maybe i'll just retire and watch my cousin Willy McFuzz make his big plays...he makes 50-94 yard TD plays fairly often...that could be fun just retiring and watching him instead.. He's a speed/elusive back that plays over in the USA leagues.

Season 6 Game 16 vs very tough higher leveled team, cousin Willy makes a 96 yard TD rush and we end up winning by 3 points to earn ourselves a big step up the playoff ladder and a home playoff game. http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=223929&pbp_id=11034334 Noby cried for an elusive HB nerf. He made two 50+ yard TDs today in another even matchup and nobody cried to commissioner there either...

How is a good powerback different from a good elusive back? Maybe i'm just simple..but i don't see the difference...except people just can't handle it when they loose in a way they didn't expect.

Me (Mac Fuzzball, power FB), made a PR TD last season that broke NINE tackles in one return. I didn't hear an outcry to nerf power backs last season....and I didn't manage to make a PR TD today...so i say...people are just not thinking straight today, they need to take some time to adjust and improve their own tactics and training.

---signed, Mac Fuzzball (SEA Pro Power FB)
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 15:57:19
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
I am on the Fix the LBers side but also on the be fair in this fight to LBers side as well.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I've seen the new dragging code working pretty well in several sims today (went looking for it). Guys getting dragged for 3-8 ticks or so and then either somebody else comes over and tackles the guy, or sometimes they get shaken off.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.