User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
The reason to complain about it is because anyone that has any clue will be using the HB elusive arch-type to build new returners...and that should not be the case when there is a specific returner arch-type. It just defeats the purpose of arch-types when the specific arch-type for a specific role is inferior to other options.


Originally posted by DMeide
Correct! What's the point of returner archetypes if elusive HB is the best option?


Here is the fun part. Prediction...

All of the better teams will use the elusive HB arch type as returners. GLB will then come to the realization that the elusive HB is overpowered at the return position. Nerf hammer...some solution that no one is happy about...teams plans are laid to waste. The time to fix it is now.

It is really a simple fix...move Stamina to minor...done.
 
Longhornfan1024
HOOD
offline
Link
 
I think the easiest answer is the obvious answer: limit kr/pr to kr/pr archetypes. Problem solved.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Longhornfan1024
I think the easiest answer is the obvious answer: limit kr/pr to kr/pr archetypes. Problem solved.


Except many teams do not build specific players to return kicks...a lot of times a WR/HB gets thrown into the role. I do not think you can limit positions. You could give them an oop penalty but that should be announced before people start building players and personally that will hurt a lot of teams that can't find a kr/pr...a lot of players that end up in that role migrate there.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
Devin Hester...Deion Sanders...Dante Hall...Mel Gray...Billy "White Shoes" Johnson...

Some of best returners in football history are not HBs...


Obviously. But you missed my point, which is that a lot of elite HB/returners stop returning kicks because HBs take too much punishment to risk a good one on return duty. But if it weren't for that, you'd see a ton more HBs returning in the NFL, compared to other positions. Granted, Brian Mitchell was a bad example because he was much less effective on offense than the other guys, so he remained a returner. But Jones-Drew doesn't return kicks anymore even though he was awesome at it. Westbrook stopped returning because he was touching the ball 20+ times per game on offense. Bush is not a feature back like the other two but even he now only returns punts situationally.

Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
btw imo Spin is the best elusive/returner SA...


Like I said, HBs will be better returners than CBs or WRs regardless, because of their better SAs.

Originally posted by DMeide
That's the point. There is ZERO point right now to choose HB Returner Archetype


That's really just not that important of a point.

Anyway if you buff HB Returner archetype, then you risk making it too good for offense (for a HB that only cares about running and not catching). If you nerf HB Elusive archetype, then you are screwing with offense.

Chicago suggested moving Stamina to a minor for the Returner archetype. Let's look at that. Compare these two from an offensive standpoint if you wanted to create an elite elusive rusher without caring about receiving:

Major Agility Carrying Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor Catching Confidence Stamina Strength (+.25)
Bonus SA's - Head Fake, Juke
Penalty SA's - Lower Shoulder, Power Thru

Major: Agility Carrying Speed Vision (+.5)
Minor: Stamina Confidence Jumping Strength (+.25)
Bonus SA's - First Step, Quick Cut
Penalty SA's - Stiff Arm, Power Thru

Returner would then be better than Elusive for a HB focused on running the ball. Now you have the exact mirror of the problem you were trying to solve.
Edited by TrevJo on Mar 10, 2010 20:29:39
 
DMeide
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo

Returner would then be better than Elusive for a HB focused on running the ball. Now you have the exact mirror of the problem you were trying to solve.


On THIS point, we agree 100%. If you make Returner HB Archetypes too good, then it's the exact opposite problem.

Possible solutions:
1)You could keep stamina as a major, but offer a new, returner SA (I proposed Gamebreaker, came up with the idea myself, but I'm sure you could come up with other good ones too) that is only available to returner archetypes
2) Put stamina as a minor, but make some sort of penalty to catching that would significantly hinder an HB returner archtype coming out of the backfield because he would drop passes too often. Yes, he would still be able to run, but defenses could plan knowing that he'd never be a threat to catch passes.
3) Put stamina as a minor, but give HB returner archtypes 3 or 4 penalty SAs (all from the power back build)
4) Put stamina as a minor, but have a built-in penalty where a returner hits a stamina wall at a certain number of plays.
5) Keep stamina as a major, but make Return Specialist ONLY available to returner archetypes. Or the returner VAs.

I completely agree that if you JUST removed stamina, you would make the HB Returner Archetype more powerful than the Elusive HB Archetype for the purpose of being an elusive running back. That's not good. BUT, if you don't do anything, and keep it as is, then the Elusive HB is better than the HB Returner Archetype for the purposes of KR/PR. And that's also not good.
Edited by DMeide on Mar 10, 2010 21:46:40
 
jsid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DMeide
On THIS point, we agree 100%. If you make Returner HB Archetypes too good, then it's the exact opposite problem.

Possible solutions:
1)You could keep stamina as a major, but offer a new, returner SA (I proposed Gamebreaker, came up with the idea myself, but I'm sure you could come up with other good ones too) that is only available to returner archetypes
2) Put stamina as a minor, but make some sort of penalty to catching that would significantly hinder an HB returner archtype coming out of the backfield because he would drop passes too often. Yes, he would still be able to run, but defenses could plan knowing that he'd never be a threat to catch passes.
3) Put stamina as a minor, but give HB returner archtypes 3 or 4 penalty SAs (all from the power back build)
4) Put stamina as a minor, but have a built-in penalty where a returner hits a stamina wall at a certain number of plays.
5) Keep stamina as a major, but make Return Specialist ONLY available to returner archetypes. Or the returner VAs.

I completely agree that if you JUST removed stamina, you would make the HB Returner Archetype more powerful than the Elusive HB Archetype for the purpose of being an elusive running back. That's not good. BUT, if you don't do anything, and keep it as is, then the Elusive HB is better than the HB Returner Archetype for the purposes of KR/PR. And that's also not good.


Then change it for just CBs and maybe WRs.
 
EagleOtto
offline
Link
 
Allow return archetype to get the Return Specialist SA if they want it, but don't allow any of the other HB archetypes to pick it....
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Anybody else notice that the Special Teams Only Player is kind of like the red headed step-child of the new archetypes? 0 SA bonuses and a 0.4 to the majors. lol What would stop an agent from creating a speed DE and dominating ST?

My point is that stamina needs to be removed from the special teamers major skills. I have 4 special teamers at DE that play both ways on ST. Energy was an issue early on but when i finally got around to capping stamina it has never been an issue. Special teamers under the current archetypes will always be inferior to a normal player with better ALGs.

Also I noticed that WR archetypes have a 0.4 in their major skills while CB archetypes have a 0.5. This will comeback to bite somebody in the you know what.

Again I will say it. Pick 7 or 8 skills per archetype. Assign 4 major skills that are made up of 2 physical skills, 1 mental skill, and 1 football skill. Then give the player either 3 or 4 minor skills. I know some positions need more than one football skill or mental skill but that kind of is the point of archetypes. The different archetypes can emphasis one skill over another. Five major skills makes a player good at everything but great at nothing.
Edited by AngryDragon on Mar 13, 2010 18:08:55
 
Phantom_Opera
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Z54
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3768138

2) If your player is between 81-120 days old as of the first day after rollover to the new season, you will be able to retire your player for 80% return of CE/boost FP investment. For example, you created a WR (300 FP), equipped them with complete CE (900 FP), and boosted them 3 times (900 FP), you would receive 1,740 flex in return instead of 1,560.

3) If your player is between 1-80 days old you will be forced to choose an archetype before the end of pre-season. If you do not choose one by then you will be assigned the default archetype for that position. If you would rather retire your player then choose an archetype, you can do so and receive a full (100%) refund of CE/boost FP investment.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Do you have a link that explains the morphing? How does the player adjust in terms of the build he already has?
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
what if I make a strength DE and choose break thru as my extra SA. Then for some crazy reason my strength DE gets played out of position at DT. Will he get the bonus to break thru that a strength DT would get?
 
PLAYMAKERS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
Anybody else notice that the Special Teams Only Player is kind of like the red headed step-child of the new archetypes? 0 SA bonuses and a 0.4 to the majors. lol What would stop an agent from creating a speed DE and dominating ST?

My point is that stamina needs to be removed from the special teamers major skills. I have 4 special teamers at DE that play both ways on ST. Energy was an issue early on but when i finally got around to capping stamina it has never been an issue. Special teamers under the current archetypes will always be inferior to a normal player with better ALGs.
.


mmm no
 
Fumanchuchu
fonky
offline
Link
 
Stop is the only build with tackling and blocking as majors, and speed! What's not to like?
 
PLAYMAKERS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Wolfblade on Feb 13
This archetype thing is exactly the sort of change that sucks the fun right out of games ... cookie cutter builds for the lazy and clueless ok but to force them for new players and now for those 1-80 days old just ruins the fun of building players ... count me out ... my little steady stream of cash to you guys for flex ends here ... if you had good sense you would have run a survey like you did on the coaching thing, but no ... you posted an announcement that only the fanboys got to post to before you locked it ... good luck with your game


Last Action: Mar 13, 2010 21:43:57 lol
Edited by PLAYMAKERS on Mar 14, 2010 00:18:45
 
Stu618
offline
Link
 
We need Q&A to summarize this...

How does the STOP archetype work? Do they select a position then select STOP as an archetype?
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
So would I be better off retiring this guy or switching him to a DE archtype?

Going for a STR/ Rush stopping DE build.

Will his height prevent him from being in the STR archtype?

What are my options?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1805641
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.