User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82
Originally posted by maitey


LB should have 60/60str/tackling to be very effective against a RB like that. I understand a CB missing a tackle against that type of RB with maybe 30/30 but if LBs need 70+ you just screwed over alot of defensive players.

I mean Bort I understand your tweaking things, and maybe your way is to do a complete MAJOR change then tweak it down some, but these blowout games etc are getting crazy and guessing every preseason as to what we need to add to our builds is incredibly frustrating. The missed tackle changes just screwed a ton of defensive players builds over royally.


Making the game more functional, realistic and accurate is part of Bort's job. It is NOT screwing over players. If you build in an unrealistic fashion, your fault. My 100 speed LB will get smashed just the same as yours, but you don't see me bitching about bort stealing my money. Build your damn player in a responsible way or accept the consequences.


Building your player n a responsible way is what he has done and most others have done. If he would have built his player any other way he would have been to slow to catch speed backs, thus costing his team because his LB is to slow. Quite honestly it is an easy fix just re-do EQ, But the point is that Bort HAD to know he was going to change this at some point in time over the last 2 seasons and could have said something then so we would have been prepared. TBH communication from him in this game is terrible and is really the issue I have here..
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
TBH you can build a power LB core and still catch elusives - play zone / stack the box and force them to run into you.

HOLAY.


 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
This is all forgetting to mention we usually get slowed down a bit after we break a tackle - usually enough for another 100 speed defense player to get in our face again.

If the entire defense is 100 speed, no strength/tackling - I should be able to get 5 yards consistently.

Force defenses to balance out more instead of entire speed-demon backfields.


I agree to an extent Laggo, but we should not be forced to change our player builds are when 80% of the backs out there have been Speed backs and that is what you have to build your players to stop.
 
Notak
offline
Link
 
Honestly....

I think a great power back should be able to run through CB's more and speed and agility linebackers. A back with 100 strength and Sa's that break tackles should beat a defender with 50 strength and 50 tackling. I knwo we all want to have our guys fast and perfect but tackling should be more on linebackers and safties. I think if a weak tackler hits one of these backs, they may have a chances to "trip them up" and they fall forward, but not tackle them. Even in the NFL CB's miss a lot of tackles on powerbacks, but there is gang tacklign and that helps a ton. Now a back that breaks 5-10 tackles in one play is outragous, but if we could figure out gang tackling it would be better. So one guy with average tackling probably wont make the tackle, but two guys with average tackling now they might be able to stop him and three guys should all most always stop him, but not 100 percent. I think that would help. However if the back is much stronger than the CBs and the CBs dotn have good tackling I dont think they should be able ot o anyhitng but slow them down.

Now I think a power back should have better caryring than elusive backs. There is more force being applied to the hits, so I think their carrying should be 70's or atleast more than soft capped, because they are bringing a great force and the linebacker and safties are also, so the fumble chance should be greater. So better carrying ablities shoul dhave to apply

As for are power backs better than elusive, I think elusive backs can hit the hole faster and that makes a difference, yes they get brought down easier, but they also can make people miss and I think that is huge becasue they dont get slowed down like power backs should when they break tackles
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Why should Powerbacks get nerfed because people built exclusively for the complete opposite of us - and then are shocked when all of a sudden we are starting to become a problem.

Defenses build completely for the pass (and thusly elusive HB's) and then are shocked when they have a problem with Power backs? Back when I had the Coyotes (16-0 Africa Pro rawr) we had one LB Troll playing MLB, who had shit for speed but was a powerhouse with tackling SA's. Powerbacks were too slow to go to the outside consistantly and we'd blitz him down the middle (as fast as he blitzed anyways) and he'd make the tackle.

Do that then.

 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by notak bethay
they dont get slowed down like power backs should when they break tackles


We do, in an unrelated note.
 
Mickyt1985
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cmj33
Originally posted by Laggo

This is all forgetting to mention we usually get slowed down a bit after we break a tackle - usually enough for another 100 speed defense player to get in our face again.

If the entire defense is 100 speed, no strength/tackling - I should be able to get 5 yards consistently.

Force defenses to balance out more instead of entire speed-demon backfields.


I agree to an extent Laggo, but we should not be forced to change our player builds are when 80% of the backs out there have been Speed backs and that is what you have to build your players to stop.


So people who've invested in Power backs should be forced to change their player builds because you guys didn't build properly?

Give me a break.

As far as I can see...Powerbacks in the NFL are even successful and break tackles at will...Adrian Peterson breaks tackles all the time...and is incredibly hard to pull down...what are we going to do...NERF his break tackle ability because defenses can't handle him?

If your DC is good enough...you can gameplan against it...if you are a level 30+ LB and don't have strength/tackling soft capped...then you are a pretty useless LB anyway IMO...Sure its great to focus on speed, but getting Strength/Speed/Agility/Tackling to soft cap first is always the best start. Do that...and you then have enough weapons to stop a powerback if you plan correctly.
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
In all honesty I never understood how a LBers speed should be pushed over 70 not alot of LBers can run under a 4.5 and most run in the 4.6-7 range. But like I said when a certain type of offense is run by most top teams and you are trying to keep up with them you are forced to build in a certain way. And about Power backs, we have NEVER had a problem stopping a power back like I said about my 55 / 55 LBer he missed 4 tackles last season and missed 7 in one pre season game. That is and EXTREME jump.
 
Maddoc
offline
Link
 
So you built your players in one very specific way to stop the metagame, and then when the metagame changes you don't think your players builds should have to?

Bravo, I applaud your thick-headedness.
 
oronis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by notak bethay
Honestly....

I think a great power back should be able to run through CB's more and speed and agility linebackers. A back with 100 strength and Sa's that break tackles should beat a defender with 50 strength and 50 tackling. I knwo we all want to have our guys fast and perfect but tackling should be more on linebackers and safties. I think if a weak tackler hits one of these backs, they may have a chances to "trip them up" and they fall forward, but not tackle them. Even in the NFL CB's miss a lot of tackles on powerbacks, but there is gang tacklign and that helps a ton. Now a back that breaks 5-10 tackles in one play is outragous, but if we could figure out gang tackling it would be better. So one guy with average tackling probably wont make the tackle, but two guys with average tackling now they might be able to stop him and three guys should all most always stop him, but not 100 percent. I think that would help. However if the back is much stronger than the CBs and the CBs dotn have good tackling I dont think they should be able ot o anyhitng but slow them down.

Now I think a power back should have better caryring than elusive backs. There is more force being applied to the hits, so I think their carrying should be 70's or atleast more than soft capped, because they are bringing a great force and the linebacker and safties are also, so the fumble chance should be greater. So better carrying ablities shoul dhave to apply

As for are power backs better than elusive, I think elusive backs can hit the hole faster and that makes a difference, yes they get brought down easier, but they also can make people miss and I think that is huge becasue they dont get slowed down like power backs should when they break tackles



Honestly, just because you can benchpress a house does not mean a weaker guy can't trip you up and make you fall down.
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mickyt1985
Originally posted by cmj33

Originally posted by Laggo


This is all forgetting to mention we usually get slowed down a bit after we break a tackle - usually enough for another 100 speed defense player to get in our face again.

If the entire defense is 100 speed, no strength/tackling - I should be able to get 5 yards consistently.

Force defenses to balance out more instead of entire speed-demon backfields.


I agree to an extent Laggo, but we should not be forced to change our player builds are when 80% of the backs out there have been Speed backs and that is what you have to build your players to stop.


So people who've invested in Power backs should be forced to change their player builds because you guys didn't build properly?

Give me a break.

As far as I can see...Powerbacks in the NFL are even successful and break tackles at will...Adrian Peterson breaks tackles all the time...and is incredibly hard to pull down...what are we going to do...NERF his break tackle ability because defenses can't handle him?

If your DC is good enough...you can gameplan against it...if you are a level 30+ LB and don't have strength/tackling soft capped...then you are a pretty useless LB anyway IMO...Sure its great to focus on speed, but getting Strength/Speed/Agility/Tackling to soft cap first is always the best start. Do that...and you then have enough weapons to stop a powerback if you plan correctly.


Don't assume you know my LBers build. And don't try to take what I said and twist it. I simply said the change is Extreme!! And TBH I have not had a problem with my LB's until todays Sims. As a matter of fact here are their defensive stats from alst season.

37 TKLs 4 MSTKL
45 TKLs 1 MSTKL

And I am supposed to swallow that crap
4 MSTKL in a season to 7 per game?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cmj33
Originally posted by Laggo

This is all forgetting to mention we usually get slowed down a bit after we break a tackle - usually enough for another 100 speed defense player to get in our face again.

If the entire defense is 100 speed, no strength/tackling - I should be able to get 5 yards consistently.

Force defenses to balance out more instead of entire speed-demon backfields.


I agree to an extent Laggo, but we should not be forced to change our player builds are when 80% of the backs out there have been Speed backs and that is what you have to build your players to stop.


Translation: You're saying that you should be able to have unrealistic builds and be great at everything and power backs shouldn't have a chance and the game should be all about having the fastest players.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cmj33
Originally posted by Mickyt1985

Originally posted by cmj33


Originally posted by Laggo



This is all forgetting to mention we usually get slowed down a bit after we break a tackle - usually enough for another 100 speed defense player to get in our face again.

If the entire defense is 100 speed, no strength/tackling - I should be able to get 5 yards consistently.

Force defenses to balance out more instead of entire speed-demon backfields.


I agree to an extent Laggo, but we should not be forced to change our player builds are when 80% of the backs out there have been Speed backs and that is what you have to build your players to stop.


So people who've invested in Power backs should be forced to change their player builds because you guys didn't build properly?

Give me a break.

As far as I can see...Powerbacks in the NFL are even successful and break tackles at will...Adrian Peterson breaks tackles all the time...and is incredibly hard to pull down...what are we going to do...NERF his break tackle ability because defenses can't handle him?

If your DC is good enough...you can gameplan against it...if you are a level 30+ LB and don't have strength/tackling soft capped...then you are a pretty useless LB anyway IMO...Sure its great to focus on speed, but getting Strength/Speed/Agility/Tackling to soft cap first is always the best start. Do that...and you then have enough weapons to stop a powerback if you plan correctly.


Don't assume you know my LBers build. And don't try to take what I said and twist it. I simply said the change is Extreme!! And TBH I have not had a problem with my LB's until todays Sims. As a matter of fact here are their defensive stats from alst season.

37 TKLs 4 MSTKL
45 TKLs 1 MSTKL

And I am supposed to swallow that crap
4 MSTKL in a season to 7 per game?


What are your Strength and Tackling?
 
dewguru
offline
Link
 
I haven't read all 75+ pages, so some of this may be a repeat...

NFL, College, High School, any level's CB's aren't usually the best tacklers on the team. If a punishing back makes it through the front line and line backers into the secondary, the secondary usually goes for the legs, or they try and hold on while other team members catch up.

I'd say don't nerf power backs. If something needs to be changed it should be where the secondary's tackles aren't always immediately broken. Instead have something in place that perhaps determines the extent of the failed tackle, meaning did he go for the legs and miss (little to no decrease in speed), did he hit the legs but not good enough to bring him down (decrease in speed - thus giving players a chance to catch up), or did he hit and he's hanging on (decreased speed with no speed increase - and allowing an 'auto' tackle when the first team mate or two catch up to help bring him down).

That's my two cents.
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Maddoc
So you built your players in one very specific way to stop the metagame, and then when the metagame changes you don't think your players builds should have to?

Bravo, I applaud your thick-headedness.


No I did not build my Players with 100+ speed.

As a matter of fact MY LBers don't have over 80 Speed. They are very balanced which is the reason I am pissed. If you would take time and actually read the post you would see that I have stated they have STR not 75-80 but enough to suffice.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.