User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Game Changes Discussion > Archived Changes > The Archetype Discussion Thread
Page:
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DMeide
Or use Elusive HB - .5 gains for the majors, and you get Head Fake AND Juke as Bonus SAs. Then you pick Return Specialist as your extra SA. Voila.


You are absolutely correct. Elusive HB looks to be the real KR/PR arch-type...to me that is a problem when the returner arch-type is not going to even be the best base to build from.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
For a HB KR I'd rather have the Returner archetype Why? Elusive wastes .25 points in Catching, which seems to be useless for KR/PR. Returner's majors are not quite as good but they don't have any useless ALGs. I would also rather have the bonus to FS/QC than HF/Juke.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Valid point about the catching...but would much prefer head fake/juke bonus over FS/QC...

Plus the better major gains in speed/agi/carry/vision...seems to me that elusive HB may be the KR/PR winner.

The main point being why create a kr/pr arch-type that is inferior to the elusive hb arch-type...

Should be fixed now while things are still in implementation stage.
 
jsid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
The main point being why create a kr/pr arch-type that is inferior to the elusive hb arch-type...
Should be fixed now while things are still in implementation stage.


 
Pook
offline
Link
 
I agree with everyone complaining about stamina in the returner area. Seriously stamina is not anywhere near a priority when building a returner.

The .4 to majors will make returners made with the archetypes weaker than any well built returner made without the archetypes...
Edited by Pook on Mar 10, 2010 14:13:36
 
monsterkill
offline
Link
 
quick cut bonus for the return archetype implies that returners are allowed to do something other than run in straight lines. is that feature being added this offseason?
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Admittedly, the Returner archetype is more needed for the CB and WR returners, than it is for HB. If Elusive is better, so be it? I don't see the need to complain about it. Right now HB is already the clear choice for returners IMO (over WR and CB) so I don't see the need to buff the HB Returner type.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Admittedly, the Returner archetype is more needed for the CB and WR returners, than it is for HB. If Elusive is better, so be it? I don't see the need to complain about it. Right now HB is already the clear choice for returners IMO (over WR and CB) so I don't see the need to buff the HB Returner type.


The reason to complain about it is because anyone that has any clue will be using the HB elusive arch-type to build new returners...and that should not be the case when there is a specific returner arch-type. It just defeats the purpose of arch-types when the specific arch-type for a specific role is inferior to other options.

Add to the fact it is quite the opposite of what you are saying...this IS A BUFF to existing HB returners...as they can now choose the elusive HB arch type for their HB returner...when existing CBs/WRs do not have that option. The returner arch type should have stamina moved to a minor and get the .5 major gains so WRs/CBs do not lose further ground to HB returners.
 
Monty Burns
Crusty Old Fart
offline
Link
 
when existing CBs/WRs do not have that option

exactly....
 
DMeide
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS


The reason to complain about it is because anyone that has any clue will be using the HB elusive arch-type to build new returners...and that should not be the case when there is a specific returner arch-type. It just defeats the purpose of arch-types when the specific arch-type for a specific role is inferior to other options.



Correct! What's the point of returner archetypes if elusive HB is the best option?

Originally posted by TrevJo
For a HB KR I'd rather have the Returner archetype Why? Elusive wastes .25 points in Catching, which seems to be useless for KR/PR. Returner's majors are not quite as good but they don't have any useless ALGs. I would also rather have the bonus to FS/QC than HF/Juke.


No way. That there's a little waste in catching pales in comparsion to the fact you get more to your majors.

Returners, more than any other position, are about Speed/Agility/Vision. The other things are nice, and obviously Speed/Agility/Vision matter for most positions, but for KR/PR, it's the end all be all.

I understand that if you make the returner archetypes TOO powerful, then people will use THEM to create normal HBs/CBs/WRs. That's fine. There are ways to find a middle ground. Here is what I wrote about a month ago:

I could think of many suggestions, here are a bunch of them:
1) Cut Stamina out of the major attributes for returners (making the big four at .5 each). It's not that important. Come on now. If you're a pure returner, you can easily train stamina (espeically if it's a minor) to get it to where it needs to be.
2) Make Return Specialist available ONLY to returner archetypes.
3) Develop a new SA that applies to returners. Perhaps something like "Gamebreaker" - a return TD can be absolutely demoralizing for the other team. For each level of Gamebreaker, the other team suffers an X% decrease in morale and confidence when your player returns a kick or punt to the house. If it's pumped up to a high level, this means that taking one to the house absolutely crushes the other team's morale. Or something along those lines. I know that the OG post said that they were looking into new SAs that would only be open to certain archetypes, so it's an idea.
4) Make Return Specialist part of the SA tree for HB and WR returner archetypes (but not elusive HB), and make Juke part of the SA tree for CB returner archetypes. I realize you're apparently allowed to choose one SA that's not in the normal build, but as currently constructed, nothing stops an elusive HB from choosing Return Specialist (unless plan 2 is chosen).

The key is that the HB returner archtype is better FOR RETURNERS than elusive HB, BUT ELUSIVE HB is better for halfbacks than the HB returner archtype. Even something as simple as a small OOP penalty.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
The reason to complain about it is because anyone that has any clue will be using the HB elusive arch-type to build new returners...and that should not be the case when there is a specific returner arch-type. It just defeats the purpose of arch-types when the specific arch-type for a specific role is inferior to other options.

Add to the fact it is quite the opposite of what you are saying...this IS A BUFF to existing HB returners...as they can now choose the elusive HB arch type for their HB returner...when existing CBs/WRs do not have that option. The returner arch type should have stamina moved to a minor and get the .5 major gains so WRs/CBs do not lose further ground to HB returners.


I still don't agree with you that the elusive archetype is better than the return one for a HB returner.
 
DMeide
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS

The reason to complain about it is because anyone that has any clue will be using the HB elusive arch-type to build new returners...and that should not be the case when there is a specific returner arch-type. It just defeats the purpose of arch-types when the specific arch-type for a specific role is inferior to other options.

Add to the fact it is quite the opposite of what you are saying...this IS A BUFF to existing HB returners...as they can now choose the elusive HB arch type for their HB returner...when existing CBs/WRs do not have that option. The returner arch type should have stamina moved to a minor and get the .5 major gains so WRs/CBs do not lose further ground to HB returners.


I still don't agree with you that the elusive archetype is better than the return one for a HB returner.


Why? Because the elusive HB has a minor ALG that is useless? You still get more to the three attributes that really matter - Speed, Agility, Vision, with elusive HB than with Returner Archtype, and, you get Juke, the 2nd best SA behind Return Specialist, as a bonus SA.
 
TrevJo
offline
Link
 
I don't agree that juke is better than first step and quick cut.

At any rate, I don't see buffing the Returner archetype as a reasonable answer. IMO HBs will always be better returners than WR and CB because of their SAs anyway.
Personally, I don't see it as a bad thing if HBs are better returners than other positions. HB skills and returner skills go hand-in-hand. Brian Mitchell, Brian Westbrook, Maurice Jones-Drew, Reggie Bush... a lot of HBs are awesome returners but the only reason the team uses some no-name WR or CB for the job is because the HB is too valueable on offense.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I don't agree that juke is better than first step and quick cut.

At any rate, I don't see buffing the Returner archetype as a reasonable answer. IMO HBs will always be better returners than WR and CB because of their SAs anyway.
Personally, I don't see it as a bad thing if HBs are better returners than other positions. HB skills and returner skills go hand-in-hand. Brian Mitchell, Brian Westbrook, Maurice Jones-Drew, Reggie Bush... a lot of HBs are awesome returners but the only reason the team uses some no-name WR or CB for the job is because the HB is too valueable on offense.


Devin Hester...Deion Sanders...Dante Hall...Mel Gray...Billy "White Shoes" Johnson...

Some of best returners in football history are not HBs...

and...FS/QC over Juke?!? First step is about worthless for a returner...they are up to speed quick and never stop/start during returns so FS does nothing for you. QC...in theory it should be a very good SA except returners barely make cuts any more since bort made the changes to force forward bias.

With the current mechanics of the return game you pretty much have to break tackles or make tacklers miss. Juke does this:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=999856&pbp_id=21081535
(show me first step or quick cut making that kind of difference)

btw imo Spin is the best elusive/returner SA...
Edited by ChicagoTRS on Mar 10, 2010 18:24:15
Edited by ChicagoTRS on Mar 10, 2010 18:08:53
 
DMeide
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TrevJo
I don't agree that juke is better than first step and quick cut.

At any rate, I don't see buffing the Returner archetype as a reasonable answer. IMO HBs will always be better returners than WR and CB because of their SAs anyway.
Personally, I don't see it as a bad thing if HBs are better returners than other positions. HB skills and returner skills go hand-in-hand. Brian Mitchell, Brian Westbrook, Maurice Jones-Drew, Reggie Bush... a lot of HBs are awesome returners but the only reason the team uses some no-name WR or CB for the job is because the HB is too valueable on offense.


Devin Hester would like to have a word with you. And Charles Woodson would like to have a word with you, before they stopped letting him return kicks because he was too valuable as a CB. And of course, Deion Sanders would like to have a word with you.

But that's not the point. Let's say your right, HBs should make the best returners. Fine. But THAT IS NOT WHAT WE ARE ARUGING.

What we are saying is, what is the point of the HB Returner Archtype if the Elusive HB is better suited to creaste returners?

It would be like, suppose the Scrambling QB archetype was actually ALSO more valuable for creating pocket passing QBs - what would be the point of the pocket passing archetype?

That's the point. There is ZERO point right now to choose HB Returner Archetype, because Elusive HB is better for building returners than the returner archetype. That's just wrong.

The only argument against it is that catching is a minor attribute for elusive HBs. Okay, so you waste some minor ALGs in a pointless attribute for returners. Okay, that is offset by the bigger major attribute gains to the three most important attributes, BY FAR, speed, agility and vision. Elusive HB > Returner HB, for building returners.

Also, you're perhaps the only person I know who has argued that First Step or Quick Cut > Juke for Returners. Everyone on the KR/PR forums and all the threads I've read/people I've talk to, put Juke as #2 behind RS. I didn't even know someone argued differently.
Edited by DMeide on Mar 10, 2010 18:01:22
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.