Originally posted by Havoc
Originally posted by lukin83
Maybe, but I have always been a fan of equal representation. Maybe by doing it this way, Bort would finally get talent spread out among the regions since each region is guaranteed to have 4 spots in the WPL. Everything should even out in the end.
Long term taking the top 2 Pro teams from each league each season and promoting them up and dropping the bottom 16 WPL teams randomly would even out the talent distribution across all leagues.
It might suck for a few seasons, but it's the right long term decision for the game.
no need for that....have the teams earn their way into WPL and lose their way out.
Top 2 teams are in from each PRO conference for next season because those teams expected to be there based on announcements all season long and worked their butts of to accomplish what they have in their respective leagues. This should be the case irrespective of league strength, because this is how the idea was originally introduced.
That said, we do need a way to address stronger leagues and strong conferences so...Next season (season 11), along with world league games, you simultaneously run the 64-team tourney.
Best 32 teams are in the world league from that tourney the following season (S12) and the other teams that did not make the cut get put back in their respective PRO leagues as "demotion"
The tournament itself will take care of the "promotion" aspect of it.
Then every season you have a world league running simultaneously w/a 64-team pro tourney to decide the make-up of the WPL for the following season.
So MM and OFG might not be there the very first year but look...you have to start somewhere and build a model and sometimes that involves a little injustice. At least you have a base set up and a format teams can aspire to.
This also involves the most number of teams of any solution I've seen laid out thus far and incorporates promotion/relegation as well as changes in team chemistry, etc. throughout the season.
Your other solution is to have an extended off-season this season, run the 64-team tourney and then put the best 32 teams in WPL. This can work and it offers access to WPL for teams in strong conferences and strong leagues that will not have access to it come S11 because of the current set-up of entry into WPL (top 2 from each Pro conference are in).
Then next season, you can run another 64-team tourney concurrently w/WPL games or again in the off-season.
Why is there so much opposition to running both ideas at the same time instead of having to pick and chose one or the other?
As far as excess game-planning goes? Who cares?...Most of the top teams game plan to hell 24/7 anyway. If you want to get there bad enough, you'll GP to do it.
Originally posted by Crawly
Terrible. Just a basic world league is easier to handle. Why is a tournament also necessary?
1. to handle promotion/demotion to and from WPL
2. to handle all the teams that don't finish top 2 in their conference but belong in WPL
Originally posted by lukin83
Maybe, but I have always been a fan of equal representation. Maybe by doing it this way, Bort would finally get talent spread out among the regions since each region is guaranteed to have 4 spots in the WPL. Everything should even out in the end.
Long term taking the top 2 Pro teams from each league each season and promoting them up and dropping the bottom 16 WPL teams randomly would even out the talent distribution across all leagues.
It might suck for a few seasons, but it's the right long term decision for the game.
no need for that....have the teams earn their way into WPL and lose their way out.
Top 2 teams are in from each PRO conference for next season because those teams expected to be there based on announcements all season long and worked their butts of to accomplish what they have in their respective leagues. This should be the case irrespective of league strength, because this is how the idea was originally introduced.
That said, we do need a way to address stronger leagues and strong conferences so...Next season (season 11), along with world league games, you simultaneously run the 64-team tourney.
Best 32 teams are in the world league from that tourney the following season (S12) and the other teams that did not make the cut get put back in their respective PRO leagues as "demotion"
The tournament itself will take care of the "promotion" aspect of it.
Then every season you have a world league running simultaneously w/a 64-team pro tourney to decide the make-up of the WPL for the following season.
So MM and OFG might not be there the very first year but look...you have to start somewhere and build a model and sometimes that involves a little injustice. At least you have a base set up and a format teams can aspire to.
This also involves the most number of teams of any solution I've seen laid out thus far and incorporates promotion/relegation as well as changes in team chemistry, etc. throughout the season.
Your other solution is to have an extended off-season this season, run the 64-team tourney and then put the best 32 teams in WPL. This can work and it offers access to WPL for teams in strong conferences and strong leagues that will not have access to it come S11 because of the current set-up of entry into WPL (top 2 from each Pro conference are in).
Then next season, you can run another 64-team tourney concurrently w/WPL games or again in the off-season.
Why is there so much opposition to running both ideas at the same time instead of having to pick and chose one or the other?
As far as excess game-planning goes? Who cares?...Most of the top teams game plan to hell 24/7 anyway. If you want to get there bad enough, you'll GP to do it.
Originally posted by Crawly
Terrible. Just a basic world league is easier to handle. Why is a tournament also necessary?
1. to handle promotion/demotion to and from WPL
2. to handle all the teams that don't finish top 2 in their conference but belong in WPL






























