User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
P.B.
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rusty Trombone
Originally posted by Randy03Texags

Originally posted by PML97


Wow.... So much nonsense in here.

Its been said by several but it really should be stated again. Power Backs are not a problem when people build players properly. The current system is not broken. The current player base is broken for the types of players being made to be abusive speed demons that are running around with 4.0 or less 40 times. Not everyone is Darrell Green... And if you want to be and you think your going to tackle Brandon Jacobs, Christian Okoye, Bo Jackson, etc you are sadly mistaken.

If you want a 90+ speed LB you can have that but there should be a cost for it and missed tackles is a part of it. If you want a DE with 100+ speed missing tackles should be expected for the minimal strength and tackling your carrying.

Most people have always known what results they would get by creating those types of builds. To them there was a known reward and risk and thats what they made. If they continue to build that way with extreme min/max theories then they are either building their players or team for those purposes or they deserve to pay for a one dimensional build.

This thread screams of nerfing one type of player in this game. As many other people have said they don't have a problem stopping power backs because of how they build their players. I think thats true with many teams in GLB and those that are not stopping them often build poorly. Not every team is the Giants or Patriots of GLB there are alot of Detroit Lions and Cleveland Browns floating around.

If the main thing here is to find a way to have a "missed tackle" without having a stat for it then fine. But every season as stats or SA's increase these "problems" will continue and its up to the player base to adjust themselves to dealing with them not the need to scream for a nerf or a bail out because they built poorly in the first place.

What number should stop a back in his tracks? 70 str 65 tackling flipped either way should stop players most of the time in the current settings. But if he slips making the tackle, takes a poor angle, tackles high when he should of went low that back should keep on hauling down field. Yeah dragging players happens but I sure hope it doesn't become the norm for every play now when someone misses a tackle because there's a whole lot of guys laying on the ground all the time not being dragged down the field.



This is a smart poster

Seriously, good teams have no issue here, the complaint is again people who built weak LBs or high agility/speed DEs/DTs and then cant tackle a good power HB. Balanced teams with good builds dont have that much trouble, sure there was one stupid run last season where a guy broke like 20 tackles on the same play against us .. but he also had like 110str, I can accept that, he went hard core strength, we arent that strong, he won one.


agree 100%


Yes
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
LBs are going to need to be jack of all trades now and thats not possible. We really need defensive depth charts by defense. Let teams put in speed LBs in pass coverage and power LBs for run plays. The offense is getting way too many advantages. To me, games in the 21-17 range are much more fun than the 50-28 blowouts that we see. And this is coming from an OC not a DC.
 
PML97
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
LBs are going to need to be jack of all trades now and thats not possible. We really need defensive depth charts by defense. Let teams put in speed LBs in pass coverage and power LBs for run plays. The offense is getting way too many advantages. To me, games in the 21-17 range are much more fun than the 50-28 blowouts that we see. And this is coming from an OC not a DC.



I definitely think that would add a great aspect to the game and allow the D to become much more flexible. I know its something i've heard my DC complain about alot.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
There have been 799 wasted posts since Bort last read this thread.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
800
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
All of this is fine and dandy, but I am getting sick and tired of changing my players builds at the whim of Borts changes. These changes that take effect are sometimes entirely to extreme. I mean for a LB to have 2-3 missed tackles in one season and then 9 in a single game on the same settings is a bit extreme. Subtle changes and a better heads up would be awesome. First you Nerf Power Backs a few seasons ago, now they the end all Back......Make up your mind! This is getting to be a little ridiculous.
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
801
 
Donner
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ken-in-rockwall
Seriously, at least 85-90% of the carrier's strength and the same for carrying. Why? Even a 190 lb. CB can tackle a 245+ lb RB. The variable is the 10 Power Through as not all backs will have it. So, is just the defensive players tackling ability alone or does their strength+tackling both come into play. It just depends on how the attributes add together to make a well-rounded player that will not only stop the run but have the agility to play the pass .

Actual numbers:
RB - 100 str + 70 carrying + 60 speed/agility + 10 SA + 15 VA = 255 points

So I would say 85-90% of 255 = 216-229; A defensive player of which should be Strength, Tackling, Agility + any SA/VA .


And that's a kind of ridiculous thing to say.

Real actual numbers:
Level 40 RB - 100 str (70 STR +30 in Equipment = 100 points)+ 70 carrying (100 points) + 60 speed/agility 70+ 70) + 10 SA (30 [points) + 15 VA = (Roughly) 370 points

So I would say 85-90% of 370 = 314-333; A defensive player of which should be Strength, Tackling, Agility + any SA/VA that pertains to tackling for an investment of 30 points plus 15 VA.

We've got three problems here as I see it.

1) Players are STILL building defenders to fly around the field. To be that fast, they have to neglect something and that is usually STR and/ TKL. "But Speed and agility should affect tackling" It already does. If you don't have the speed or agility you may not get into position to tackle, which as any football player knows is the key to make a good solid tackle. Beyond which, if you get there, even if you don't make the tackle, you slow the back up which allows other players a chance at him.

2) It appears we still don't have gang tackling. Thats how these monsters are brought down. Most of the goof power backs in the NFL were damned tough to bring down one on one. How many LBs wanted to get run over by Jerome Bettis, Christian Okoye, Brandon Jacobs. Let alone those little cover corners, who are built to cover WRs, not tackle guys who bench 500 lbs. and have thighs as big as the trunk of my body.

3) Velocity and weight don't seem to factor into the tackling equation (if they do the effect is negligible). I don't know how hard it would be to put these sort of physics into tackling, but I can assure you that weight has a great deal of impact in football. That's why you won't see 200lb OL or DL.

Don't take anything I've said negatively Bort, I think you have a wonderfully deep and fun football sim. But tackling has been on my mind for a while and weight and height being negligible factors has been one of my biggest pet peeves about GLB. Perhaps in the future, you COULD make weight count and have a players weight increase as he strengthens up, have players weight be a detriment if he is not properly conditioned (lower stamina in some kind of weight formula to equal faster energy loss).

The main factor to being able to bring down a power back SHOULD be (if and when he makes it past the line) having a LBs who have great tackling and strength, and CBs and safeties who can REALLY tackle. You see these in the NFL quite frequently. They are usually good zone corners and sometimes get burned by speed WRs. But they have no fear of coming up tot he line and making the tackle. A good example of this type of corner is Samari Rolle.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 14:27:53
 
maitey
offline
Link
 
The reason LBs have gone speed agility is because we cant keep up with TEs, HBs or WRs, even in simple zones.

The offense was dialed way up last season, and NOW its becoming a joke, Arena football at its finest. Why every season there must be such drastic changes that completely alter the balance of the game is mind boggling.

LB should have 60/60str/tackling to be very effective against a RB like that. I understand a CB missing a tackle against that type of RB with maybe 30/30 but if LBs need 70+ you just screwed over alot of defensive players.

I mean Bort I understand your tweaking things, and maybe your way is to do a complete MAJOR change then tweak it down some, but these blowout games etc are getting crazy and guessing every preseason as to what we need to add to our builds is incredibly frustrating. The missed tackle changes just screwed a ton of defensive players builds over royally.
 
cmj33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by maitey
The reason LBs have gone speed agility is because we cant keep up with TEs, HBs or WRs, even in simple zones.

My point exactly.

This change is entirely to fast. Making my LB with 55 str 55 tkl I knew he may miss a few tackles but I had to take that chance so he could get to the line of scrimmage fast enough to keep these speed backs from gaining 6-7 ypc. Now I have to worry about missing 7-10 tackles a game because my player is being punished for something Bort created?
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by maitey

LB should have 60/60str/tackling to be very effective against a RB like that. I understand a CB missing a tackle against that type of RB with maybe 30/30 but if LBs need 70+ you just screwed over alot of defensive players.

I mean Bort I understand your tweaking things, and maybe your way is to do a complete MAJOR change then tweak it down some, but these blowout games etc are getting crazy and guessing every preseason as to what we need to add to our builds is incredibly frustrating. The missed tackle changes just screwed a ton of defensive players builds over royally.


Making the game more functional, realistic and accurate is part of Bort's job. It is NOT screwing over players. If you build in an unrealistic fashion, your fault. My 100 speed LB will get smashed just the same as yours, but you don't see me bitching about bort stealing my money. Build your damn player in a responsible way or accept the consequences.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 14:49:45
 
Frycicle
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Donner
Originally posted by ken-in-rockwall

Seriously, at least 85-90% of the carrier's strength and the same for carrying. Why? Even a 190 lb. CB can tackle a 245+ lb RB. The variable is the 10 Power Through as not all backs will have it. So, is just the defensive players tackling ability alone or does their strength+tackling both come into play. It just depends on how the attributes add together to make a well-rounded player that will not only stop the run but have the agility to play the pass .

Actual numbers:
RB - 100 str + 70 carrying + 60 speed/agility + 10 SA + 15 VA = 255 points

So I would say 85-90% of 255 = 216-229; A defensive player of which should be Strength, Tackling, Agility + any SA/VA .


And that's a kind of ridiculous thing to say.

Real actual numbers:
Level 40 RB - 100 str (70 STR +30 in Equipment = 100 points)+ 70 carrying (100 points) + 60 speed/agility 70+ 70) + 10 SA (30 [points) + 15 VA = (Roughly) 370 points

So I would say 85-90% of 370 = 314-333; A defensive player of which should be Strength, Tackling, Agility + any SA/VA that pertains to tackling for an investment of 30 points plus 15 VA.

We've got three problems here as I see it.

1) Players are STILL building defenders to fly around the field. To be that fast, they have to neglect something and that is usually STR and/ TKL. "But Speed and agility should affect tackling" It already does. If you don't have the speed or agility you may not get into position to tackle, which as any football player knows is the key to make a good solid tackle. Beyond which, if you get there, even if you don't make the tackle, you slow the back up which allows other players a chance at him.

2) It appears we still don't have gang tackling. Thats how these monsters are brought down. Most of the goof power backs in the NFL were damned tough to bring down one on one. How many LBs wanted to get run over by Jerome Bettis, Christian Okoye, Brandon Jacobs. Let alone those little cover corners, who are built to cover WRs, not tackle guys who bench 500 lbs. and have thighs as big as the trunk of my body.

3) Velocity and weight don't seem to factor into the tackling equation (if they do the effect is negligible). I don't know how hard it would be to put these sort of physics into tackling, but I can assure you that weight has a great deal of impact in football. That's why you won't see 200lb OL or DL.

Don't take anything I've said negatively Bort, I think you have a wonderfully deep and fun football sim. But tackling has been on my mind for a while and weight and height being negligible factors has been one of my biggest pet peeves about GLB. Perhaps in the future, you COULD make weight count and have a players weight increase as he strengthens up, have players weight be a detriment if he is not properly conditioned (lower stamina in some kind of weight formula to equal faster energy loss).

The main factor to being able to bring down a power back SHOULD be (if and when he makes it past the line) having a LBs who have great tackling and strength, and CBs and safeties who can REALLY tackle. You see these in the NFL quite frequently. They are usually good zone corners and sometimes get burned by speed WRs. But they have no fear of coming up tot he line and making the tackle. A good example of this type of corner is Samari Rolle.


I'd say more along the lines of Antoine Winfield.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Why do RB's need 100 strength 70 carrying to make consistant break tackles, but everyone is fine with all other positions needing 60/60 or something even less to stop them. If we are dumping all our points into doing one thing and one thing only, you should have to be doing the same thing to be able to stop us every time.

This is a team game, if you as an LB only have a 50% chance of stopping me - thats fine. You have two other LB's with a 50% chance, not to mention your safeties with slightly lower chances and your Dline with slightly higher ones.

To stop a Powerback with those kind of stats 90% of the time - you should be forced to have 100 strength/70 tackling or something similar. Powerbacks become neglible if people can softcap skills and be able to negate us.
 
Link
 
Back to the original question Bort posed......

Occasionally in football, a good powerback will physically drag one or even two Defensive Backs down the field with him for 3-5 yds after they attempt to "tackle" him.. This should still be possible, but only under certain circumstances( like both the D Back's are light-weight and have poor tackling) . As far as the actual "breaking of tackles" and what strength/tackling SHOULD be required to stop a good powerback with the stat's provided in OP? I would say at LEAST 75 Strength (3/4th's) and 52.5 Tackling (3/4ths) to just have a chance of tackling the powerback with those stats.... ( also would need tackle tactic set to "wrap-up")

I just had my powerback get stopped dead in his tracks while returning a kick/punt full speed ,by a HB who had 20 pts LESS strength than me, and only 10 tackling. Things like that shouldn't happen. 10 tackling going up against bucu strength/power thru and it's a "tackle"?
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
This is all forgetting to mention we usually get slowed down a bit after we break a tackle - usually enough for another 100 speed defense player to get in our face again.

If the entire defense is 100 speed, no strength/tackling - I should be able to get 5 yards consistently.

Force defenses to balance out more instead of entire speed-demon backfields.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.