User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
PML97
offline
Link
 
Wow.... So much nonsense in here.

Its been said by several but it really should be stated again. Power Backs are not a problem when people build players properly. The current system is not broken. The current player base is broken for the types of players being made to be abusive speed demons that are running around with 4.0 or less 40 times. Not everyone is Darrell Green... And if you want to be and you think your going to tackle Brandon Jacobs, Christian Okoye, Bo Jackson, etc you are sadly mistaken.

If you want a 90+ speed LB you can have that but there should be a cost for it and missed tackles is a part of it. If you want a DE with 100+ speed missing tackles should be expected for the minimal strength and tackling your carrying.

Most people have always known what results they would get by creating those types of builds. To them there was a known reward and risk and thats what they made. If they continue to build that way with extreme min/max theories then they are either building their players or team for those purposes or they deserve to pay for a one dimensional build.

This thread screams of nerfing one type of player in this game. As many other people have said they don't have a problem stopping power backs because of how they build their players. I think thats true with many teams in GLB and those that are not stopping them often build poorly. Not every team is the Giants or Patriots of GLB there are alot of Detroit Lions and Cleveland Browns floating around.

If the main thing here is to find a way to have a "missed tackle" without having a stat for it then fine. But every season as stats or SA's increase these "problems" will continue and its up to the player base to adjust themselves to dealing with them not the need to scream for a nerf or a bail out because they built poorly in the first place.

What number should stop a back in his tracks? 70 str 65 tackling flipped either way should stop players most of the time in the current settings. But if he slips making the tackle, takes a poor angle, tackles high when he should of went low that back should keep on hauling down field. Yeah dragging players happens but I sure hope it doesn't become the norm for every play now when someone misses a tackle because there's a whole lot of guys laying on the ground all the time not being dragged down the field.

Last edited Dec 30, 2008 12:45:02
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by csull36
Originally posted by jrry32

Originally posted by Deathblade


Originally posted by the man of doom




50 sack season are cause of bad OT builds without 4th capped agility and 3rd capped speed


fyp

Yeah, I know, those horrible OT's. What the hell were they thinking? Seriously.


Deathblade you are so full of shit I hope you don't explode. People still don't understand you need 3rd capped agility, soft capped speed and BLOCKING...which is the most important attribute for stopping speed rushers.


If you think about it, Left Offensive Tackles are the highest paid players in the NFL because they have the size and agility to protect their qbs weak side. Their athleticism is underrated because they are so large.


Agreed, they also have amazing technique which is blocking.

 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PML97
Wow.... So much nonsense in here.

Its been said by several but it really should be stated again. Power Backs are not a problem when people build players properly. The current system is not broken. The current player base is broken for the types of players being made to be abusive speed demons that are running around with 4.0 or less 40 times. Not everyone is Darrell Green... And if you want to be and you think your going to tackle Brandon Jacobs, Christian Okoye, Bo Jackson, etc you are sadly mistaken.

If you want a 90+ speed LB you can have that but there should be a cost for it and missed tackles is a part of it. If you want a DE with 100+ speed missing tackles should be expected for the minimal strength and tackling your carrying.

Most people have always known what results they would get by creating those types of builds. To them there was a known reward and risk and thats what they made. If they continue to build that way with extreme min/max theories then they are either building their players or team for those purposes or they deserve to pay for a one dimensional build.

This thread screams of nerfing one type of player in this game. As many other people have said they don't have a problem stopping power backs because of how they build their players. I think thats true with many teams in GLB and those that are not stopping them often build poorly. Not every team is the Giants or Patriots of GLB there are alot of Detroit Lions and Cleveland Browns floating around.

If the main thing here is to find a way to have a "missed tackle" without having a stat for it then fine. But every season as stats or SA's increase these "problems" will continue and its up to the player base to adjust themselves to dealing with them not the need to scream for a nerf or a bail out because they built poorly in the first place.

What number should stop a back in his tracks? 70 str 65 tackling flipped either way should stop players most of the time in the current settings. But if he slips making the tackle, takes a poor angle, tackles high when he should of went low that back should keep on hauling down field. Yeah dragging players happens but I sure it doesn't become the norm for every play now when someone misses a tackle because there's a whole lot of guys laying on the ground all the time not being dragged down the field.



Agreed.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32

Yes so was I but you don't need 4th capped agility and 3rd capped speed if you don't pump strength instead of blocking.


Strength seems like it is the key to being able to block more than two people at once though...my OT with stupidly high agility and blocking can rarely block two guys like other linemen do.
 
Slavenator
offline
Link
 
I think this SIM was created to give everyone freedom of choice to build a player in the means they choose to. If you make a player who is high in Strength and Carrying and lower in speed then the fact that he could be caught and gang tackled should come into play with the combination of those players skills that get to the ball against the ball carrier. So will he be hard to stop in short yardage=YES, should he ever be able to bust long runs for TD's against a speedy defense=NO

Create a High Strength unmovable NT to nullify the rest.
 
csull36
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by jrry32



Deathblade you are so full of shit I hope you don't explode. People still don't understand you need 3rd capped agility, soft capped speed and BLOCKING...which is the most important attribute for stopping speed rushers.


I understand that. I was preaching that BEFORE the DE's started dominating.


Yes so was I but you don't need 4th capped agility and 3rd capped speed if you don't pump strength instead of blocking.


Strength = pancakes. Player like stats. If Bort instituted a "sacks allowed" stat, OT builds would improve dramatically.
 
BobLeeSwagger
offline
Link
 
HB's Running Power =
Speed + Agility * First Step + 1% per yard = Momentum
Momentum + Strength + Carrying + Power Through + Lower Shoulders = Combined Impact

Defenders Running Power =
Speed + Agility * First Step + 1% per yard = Momentum
Momentum + Strength + Tackling + Big Hit + Monster Hit + Wrap-up Tackle = Combined Impact


So the HB and the defenders Combined impact is determined by a formula ( i assume it is something like this ) and the should of course be almost equal for a defender to bring down a ballcarrier. This way a very fast CB could also deliver some real punches on a big HB like in the NFL due to his explosiveness and his acceleration into the tackle.


Dix
 
drhys
offline
Link
 
It really depends on where the tackle is done. Not sure if it's in the formula now, but a CB trying for a tackle against a power back in the open field is going to have a difficult time of doing so. However, what I don't like is seeing a power back run through a scrum of 5 guys, all having missed the tackle. Once in a while maybe, but if you have a CB and a FS both with 35-40 str and 35-40 tackling, they should have a 80-90% chance of making it. But if it was just one of them in the open field, the power back should have a HUGE advantage.
 
Cactus71
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


y so srs?
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drhys
It really depends on where the tackle is done. Not sure if it's in the formula now, but a CB trying for a tackle against a power back in the open field is going to have a difficult time of doing so. However, what I don't like is seeing a power back run through a scrum of 5 guys, all having missed the tackle. Once in a while maybe, but if you have a CB and a FS both with 35-40 str and 35-40 tackling, they should have a 80-90% chance of making it. But if it was just one of them in the open field, the power back should have a HUGE advantage.


with those points of str and tackling, against a good power back, I'd say they both have around a 40-55% chance of making the tackle, but they both get an individual tackle check so the odds aren't as bad as you think, also the running back loses momentum and energy when breaking a tackle, so the second attempts success % increases.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
I think tackling should be more important than strength. As mentioned earlier, many CBs are excellent tacklers. Maybe strength shouldn't even affect the tackle at all, but have a huge effect on whether a fumble comes out of the tackle.

For a 100 strength back, I would say 90/80/70 tackling, power/normal/wrapup, to tackle CONSISTENTLY (90+%) Just imo.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dix
HB's Running Power =
Speed + Agility * First Step + 1% per yard = Momentum
Momentum + Strength + Carrying + Power Through + Lower Shoulders = Combined Impact

Defenders Running Power =
Speed + Agility * First Step + 1% per yard = Momentum
Momentum + Strength + Tackling + Big Hit + Monster Hit + Wrap-up Tackle = Combined Impact


So the HB and the defenders Combined impact is determined by a formula ( i assume it is something like this ) and the should of course be almost equal for a defender to bring down a ballcarrier. This way a very fast CB could also deliver some real punches on a big HB like in the NFL due to his explosiveness and his acceleration into the tackle.


Dix


This sounds good, tbqh.
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
I wouldn't add the SAs on the Combined Impact though
 
Randy03Texags
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PML97
Wow.... So much nonsense in here.

Its been said by several but it really should be stated again. Power Backs are not a problem when people build players properly. The current system is not broken. The current player base is broken for the types of players being made to be abusive speed demons that are running around with 4.0 or less 40 times. Not everyone is Darrell Green... And if you want to be and you think your going to tackle Brandon Jacobs, Christian Okoye, Bo Jackson, etc you are sadly mistaken.

If you want a 90+ speed LB you can have that but there should be a cost for it and missed tackles is a part of it. If you want a DE with 100+ speed missing tackles should be expected for the minimal strength and tackling your carrying.

Most people have always known what results they would get by creating those types of builds. To them there was a known reward and risk and thats what they made. If they continue to build that way with extreme min/max theories then they are either building their players or team for those purposes or they deserve to pay for a one dimensional build.

This thread screams of nerfing one type of player in this game. As many other people have said they don't have a problem stopping power backs because of how they build their players. I think thats true with many teams in GLB and those that are not stopping them often build poorly. Not every team is the Giants or Patriots of GLB there are alot of Detroit Lions and Cleveland Browns floating around.

If the main thing here is to find a way to have a "missed tackle" without having a stat for it then fine. But every season as stats or SA's increase these "problems" will continue and its up to the player base to adjust themselves to dealing with them not the need to scream for a nerf or a bail out because they built poorly in the first place.

What number should stop a back in his tracks? 70 str 65 tackling flipped either way should stop players most of the time in the current settings. But if he slips making the tackle, takes a poor angle, tackles high when he should of went low that back should keep on hauling down field. Yeah dragging players happens but I sure hope it doesn't become the norm for every play now when someone misses a tackle because there's a whole lot of guys laying on the ground all the time not being dragged down the field.



This is a smart poster

Seriously, good teams have no issue here, the complaint is again people who built weak LBs or high agility/speed DEs/DTs and then cant tackle a good power HB. Balanced teams with good builds dont have that much trouble, sure there was one stupid run last season where a guy broke like 20 tackles on the same play against us .. but he also had like 110str, I can accept that, he went hard core strength, we arent that strong, he won one.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Randy03Texags
Originally posted by PML97

Wow.... So much nonsense in here.

Its been said by several but it really should be stated again. Power Backs are not a problem when people build players properly. The current system is not broken. The current player base is broken for the types of players being made to be abusive speed demons that are running around with 4.0 or less 40 times. Not everyone is Darrell Green... And if you want to be and you think your going to tackle Brandon Jacobs, Christian Okoye, Bo Jackson, etc you are sadly mistaken.

If you want a 90+ speed LB you can have that but there should be a cost for it and missed tackles is a part of it. If you want a DE with 100+ speed missing tackles should be expected for the minimal strength and tackling your carrying.

Most people have always known what results they would get by creating those types of builds. To them there was a known reward and risk and thats what they made. If they continue to build that way with extreme min/max theories then they are either building their players or team for those purposes or they deserve to pay for a one dimensional build.

This thread screams of nerfing one type of player in this game. As many other people have said they don't have a problem stopping power backs because of how they build their players. I think thats true with many teams in GLB and those that are not stopping them often build poorly. Not every team is the Giants or Patriots of GLB there are alot of Detroit Lions and Cleveland Browns floating around.

If the main thing here is to find a way to have a "missed tackle" without having a stat for it then fine. But every season as stats or SA's increase these "problems" will continue and its up to the player base to adjust themselves to dealing with them not the need to scream for a nerf or a bail out because they built poorly in the first place.

What number should stop a back in his tracks? 70 str 65 tackling flipped either way should stop players most of the time in the current settings. But if he slips making the tackle, takes a poor angle, tackles high when he should of went low that back should keep on hauling down field. Yeah dragging players happens but I sure hope it doesn't become the norm for every play now when someone misses a tackle because there's a whole lot of guys laying on the ground all the time not being dragged down the field.



This is a smart poster

Seriously, good teams have no issue here, the complaint is again people who built weak LBs or high agility/speed DEs/DTs and then cant tackle a good power HB. Balanced teams with good builds dont have that much trouble, sure there was one stupid run last season where a guy broke like 20 tackles on the same play against us .. but he also had like 110str, I can accept that, he went hard core strength, we arent that strong, he won one.


agree 100%
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.