User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pboggs

Why should HBs have to change their builds and start putting more points in vision and carrying. Defensive players have been neglecting strength and tackling...I think that is where the change needs to happen.


Wow...this guy gets it.

:rolleyes:

Defensive is reactive, offensive is proactive. If the offense has to put more points in certain attributes, and not just pump speed up to 100, it allows the strength/tackling requirement to be heightened.

Like I said earlier, you can't honestly expect defensive players to have 100 strength and 80 tackling to stop a power back, while simultaneously expecting them to have the 100 speed and 60 agility required to stop an elusive back.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 11:47:23
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by King Henrik
Originally posted by pboggs

Originally posted by WearyWarrior


Originally posted by Deathblade



Originally posted by Deathblade




Hmm...how about some added penalties for elusive/speed backs?

Was just sitting here thinking about it...and shouldn't really fast HB's need more carrying? Running at 90 speed, juking and weaving, it seems like unless they were really good at holding onto the ball, they would cough it up quite frequently.

So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.


Going to bump this for some kind of comment...last attempt though.


Im not terribly sure about the first concept but I like the 2nd one a great deal. I think it makes a whole lot of sense in general and puts a good emphasis on carrying and vision helping you get that all important speed on the HB, thus generating more logical builds imo


Why should HBs have to change their builds and start putting more points in vision and carrying. Defensive players have been neglecting strength and tackling...I think that is where the change needs to happen.


or both


or none
 
jeremyhurst
offline
Link
 
i think the smaller the player, the more tackling is needed.

cb/safety = more tackling to get the job done

lb = even mix tackling strength

dl = strength might be enough to do it
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kirghiz
Originally posted by Deathblade


So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.


I could live with this as an elusive back nerf if it wasn't installed until season 8. That way elusive backs could use season 7 to fix their builds and get it more in line with what is coming. I could also live with these theories about 150 combined strength/tackling to bring down power backs, but again, not until season 8 to give linebackers a chance to fix their builds as well. Gang tackles would also have to be introduced to ensure that the power backs can't just run right over the DB's, and to keep power backs from being used as kick returners. In the real world, no one uses power backs as kick returners, and it shouldn't work here either.


I say do all of this, just do it next season and tell everyone it's coming. It would fix the whole issue.
 
P.B.
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by pboggs


Why should HBs have to change their builds and start putting more points in vision and carrying. Defensive players have been neglecting strength and tackling...I think that is where the change needs to happen.


Wow...this guy gets it.

:rolleyes:


Given I only read about 20 pages of the thread...but my point is that your solution means that HBs are the ones adapting their builds. In my opinion it is not the HBs that are the problem as much as the defenses going all speed agility. I could be missing something because of not reading the whole thread.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by pboggs


Why should HBs have to change their builds and start putting more points in vision and carrying. Defensive players have been neglecting strength and tackling...I think that is where the change needs to happen.


Wow...this guy gets it.

:rolleyes:

Defensive is reactive, offensive is proactive. If the offense has to put more points in certain attributes, and not just pump speed up to 100, it allows the strength/tackling requirement to be heightened.

Like I said earlier, you can't honestly expect defensive players to have 100 strength and 80 tackling to stop a power back, while simultaneously expecting them to have the 100 speed and 60 agility required to stop an elusive back.


your very right. however, bort has said on numerous occasions that he wants glb to be a sort of rock-paper-scissors game. you could build a defender that stops a power runner all the time with high strength and tackling, or one that stops an elusive all the time with speed. but to build a defender that can stop any rb at all would be overpowered. what is the weakness in that defender?

if you build him average, then you stop power backs sometimes and elusives sometimes. but this average defender will also get beaten by a "specialist", like bort posted in the first post. if he doesn't get run over sometimes, then theres no point in building a power back.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 11:55:13
 
blln4lyf
offline
Link
 
I wake up and this is 70+ pages when I had not seen it before, damn did that take a while to catch up on
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rmiller517

your very right. however, bort has said on numerous occasions that he wants glb to be a sort of rock-paper-scissors game. you could build a defender that stops a power runner all the time with high strength and tackling, or one that stops an elusive all the time with speed. but to build a defender that can stop any rb at all would be overpowered. what is the weakness in that defender?


I didn't say reliably stop both. I mean to not get absolutely dominated.

Of course a power heavy LB would be more effective against a power back. Of course a quick LB would be more effective against a speed back.

However, balanced builds should not get absolutely destroyed by both of them...which they pretty much do at the moment.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pboggs

Given I only read about 20 pages of the thread...but my point is that your solution means that HBs are the ones adapting their builds. In my opinion it is not the HBs that are the problem as much as the defenses going all speed agility. I could be missing something because of not reading the whole thread.


Defenses are forced to go all speed/agility to keep up with the all speed/agility offenses. If you take the ability for the offenses to go all speed/agility away, I'm sure defenses wouldn't have a problem going more balanced.

Edit:
I don't mean take it away completely...I meant to make more attributes needed for the equation instead of pure speed/agility.

Defenses needing 6-7 attributes to the 60 or 67 cap while offensive players only have two attributes to maximize as much as they can isn't going to work...
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 11:59:32
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
I think 20 strength/20 tackling is reasonable
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade

However, balanced builds should not get absolutely destroyed by both of them...which they pretty much do at the moment.


Since playing this game I have come to equate "balanced" with "sucks". When recruiting I don't even look at players that have the word balanced anywhere near their ad anymore.

 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
defensive player weight/size should be part of this calculation
 
P.B.
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by pboggs


Given I only read about 20 pages of the thread...but my point is that your solution means that HBs are the ones adapting their builds. In my opinion it is not the HBs that are the problem as much as the defenses going all speed agility. I could be missing something because of not reading the whole thread.


Defenses are forced to go all speed/agility to keep up with the all speed/agility offenses. If you take the ability for the offenses to go all speed/agility away, I'm sure defenses wouldn't have a problem going more balanced.

Edit:
I don't mean take it away completely...I meant to make more attributes needed for the equation instead of pure speed/agility.

Defenses needing 6-7 attributes to the 60 or 67 cap while offensive players only have two attributes to maximize as much as they can isn't going to work...


I see...Your solution would work...but I think the root of the problem is offenses can build specialist and run certain plays for them in the AI and defenses can't.

The D-lines weren't forced to start pumping speed...they did it because of the sacks. The power running game is a way for the offenses to counter the d-line builds.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 12:07:55
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pboggs

The D-lines weren't forced to start pumping speed...they did it because of the sacks. The power running game is a way for the offenses to counter the d-line builds.


A little tip for you...pure agility DT's do WAY better against the run than pure strength DT's.
 
P.B.
offline
Link
 
Thanks.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.