User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > General Discussion > Comet Elenin Tetrahedral Force Shield
Page:
 
Carl Ellir
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Interesting and curious tidbit. Honda shows her tail in the video, but Elenin does not. Just a blob hauling ass from right to left, bringing back thoughts of her being a very small brown dwarf.


no such thing as a "very small" brown dwarf. a "very small" brown dwarf would still be at least 2x larger than Jupiter
 
BriscOpaLockA
offline
Link
 
The world need to hurry up and end so i can get fallout 4 free
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Carl Ellir
no such thing as a "very small" brown dwarf. a "very small" brown dwarf would still be at least 2x larger than Jupiter


The coma was estimated to be bigger than Jupiter back in May/June and you are still assuming it's a comet.

Most comets have tails, like Honda does in the video I posted but Elenin has never really had a tail like every other comet we have seen.

Things that make you go hmm.
Edited by Mightyhalo on Oct 14, 2011 17:15:57
Edited by Mightyhalo on Oct 14, 2011 17:13:54
 
kingjonb
offline
Link
 
wasn't this thing supposed to pass by us already?
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Monster Mode
wasn't this thing supposed to pass by us already?


She has technically passed us as she closes in on our orbit on her way back out of the solar system. You can see her position here. You might have to zoom in a little.
http://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/sbdb.cgi?sstr=elenin&orb=1



 
Carl Ellir
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
The coma was estimated to be bigger than Jupiter back in May/June and you are still assuming it's a comet.

Most comets have tails, like Honda does in the video I posted but Elenin has never really had a tail like every other comet we have seen.

Things that make you go hmm.


*sigh*
the coma is made out of the gas and dust and ice that comes off of the comet as it warms up and the ice melts and breaks off of the nucleus, if you haven't noticed...in the vacuum of space, gas EXPANDS EXTREMELY THIN when in small amounts...this creates the large coma. Try some vacuum experiments to see what this is like. Get a balloon and fill it with air. Then put it in a chamber or something where u can vacuum all of the air out of the chamber. When you vacuum the air out of the chamber, the balloon will expand, A LOT. This is because the air in the balloon expands because of the vacuum around it. Hell, if you put enough air in the balloon and put it in the vacuum, the balloon will explode causing all of the gas to fill the vacuum. This is what happens in space. The reason why there are no liquids in the vacuum of space, is because the vacuum turns all of the liquids into gases. Try using this in another vacuum experiment. Try putting a glass of water in a vacuum chamber and sucking all the air out. Guess what happens? The water boils away, even at room temperature. So when a comet melts due to the heat of the sun, it releases the water and gas locked away in the comet...the water turns into more gas, and it keeps expanding into space because it is a vacuum. This is what a coma is. Even if the "jupiter sized" coma were to come in contact with the earth, the amount of gas in that coma would do absolutely nothing to everything here on earth, even if the coma was made out of cyanide or some crap. The coma is so thin that it passing by us would be like releasing a water balloon of CO (carbon monoxide) into the dallas cowboy's stadium. "OH NO, CARBON MONOXIDE WILL KILL US ALL" The amount of CO being released in the stadium is a comparison of the amount of gas in the coma coming into contact with the earth. You know why the CO wont do anything to anyone in the stadium? because the amount of air in the stadium spreads out the CO so thinly that it wont do a thing. Thats like the "coma" would do to earth. The amount of gas in the coma coming into contact with the earths atmosphere, would completely delude the gas, even if its cyanide. The coma poses no threat. Another thing, a brown dwarf is made entirely out of gas, if elenin has a nucleus, that means it is made out of a solid, either ice or rock or a combination. The only thing comet elenin is...is a comet. with a large coma, which is still harmless. get over it.
Edited by Carl Ellir on Oct 14, 2011 17:58:50
 
Carl Ellir
offline
Link
 
If you think that a coma has anything to do with this tiny, pathetic, insignificant comet, you are wrong entirely. A coma the size of jupiter isn't even big at all for a comet's coma. There are other comets in the past that have had a coma larger than the sun... and what have they done? nothing...
 
JHIK
offline
Link
 
So... When is the next post saying we should pay attention to a different discussion on the end of the world, I'm ready to put this one to bed.

All in favor

Aye

 
Whatsdafus
offline
Link
 
was it the 1920/1910 Halley's comet that cause people to commit suicide.


and everyone shhh'ed me here when i told mightyhalo to stop spewing his bullshit.

 
Torgonous
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
They want you to believe it's disintegrating


Apparently THEY were right.

THEY: The comet is breaking up and won't pose a threat to Earth

MH: FUCK!!!!!!! We're all going to die!!!!! Arrrrrrggggghhhhh

FACTS: Comet broke up

MH: FUCK!!!!!!!!!! I was wrong

US: Shocking

Edit: Oops, forgot the link. http://news.yahoo.com/debris-doomsday-comet-elenin-pass-earth-sunday-164605072.html
Edited by Torgonous on Oct 14, 2011 18:35:40
Edited by Torgonous on Oct 14, 2011 18:35:23
Edited by Torgonous on Oct 14, 2011 18:35:05
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Carl Ellir
*sigh*
The only thing comet elenin is...is a comet. with a large coma, which is still harmless. get over it.


Edited down wall of text. I was just using the estimated size of the "alleged coma" to show that the size is possible based on the theory that no brown dwarf could be smaller than twice the size of Jupiter is a reach.

I think they can be smaller than Earth. Little miniature dwarfs. Imagine the possibilities.

 
Carl Ellir
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mightyhalo
Edited down wall of text. I was just using the estimated size of the "alleged coma" to show that the size is possible based on the theory that no brown dwarf could be smaller than twice the size of Jupiter is a reach.

I think they can be smaller than Earth. Little miniature dwarfs. Imagine the possibilities.



so you didn't read anything that i posted except the last sentence?

no, its physically impossible. A brown dwarf is 100% or 99% gas, the rest could be rock and dust particles that collide with it as it moves through the universe. It is impossible for there to be a tiny planet to be 100% gas, because the mass of it would be too low and the gases would escape...this is why stars and gaseous planets are so big, because they have to be to hold onto the gas. And btw, elenin isn't even CLOSE to being of any significant size at all. It is so small, in fact, that the ONLY reason why it has gas at all, is because it was frozen in its ice and rock. If elenin wasn't frozen, it would have no gas, and it would be an asteroid, not a comet. In fact, elenin is mostly ice...hardly any rock, just like every other comet. The air pressure in a brown dwarf is thousands of times stronger in its center than the earth at the very center of its iron core. A coma of a comet has no pressure at all, because its not an atmosphere. It is expanded gas that has escaped the comet because of the temperature increase. The coma is in the vacuum of space. For it to be an atmosphere, it has to be attached to the rocky/icey core and for there to be no vacuum in-between.
The only way possible for there to be a tiny planet (its not even considered a planet with the size of elenin) to be made 100% out of gas, is if it were in absolute zero temperatures, which wont even happen, because the radiation of of the universe's creation (or whatever it was) keeps the vacuum of space at a temperature slightly above absolute zero.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Carl Ellir
so you didn't read anything that i posted except the last sentence?

no, its physically impossible. A brown dwarf is 100% or 99% gas, the rest could be rock and dust particles that collide with it as it moves through the universe. It is impossible for there to be a tiny planet to be 100% gas, because the mass of it would be too low and the gases would escape...this is why stars and gaseous planets are so big, because they have to be to hold onto the gas. And btw, elenin isn't even CLOSE to being of any significant size at all. It is so small, in fact, that the ONLY reason why it has gas at all, is because it was frozen in its ice and rock. If elenin wasn't frozen, it would have no gas, and it would be an asteroid, not a comet. In fact, elenin is mostly ice...hardly any rock, just like every other comet. The air pressure in a brown dwarf is thousands of times stronger in its center than the earth at the very center of its iron core. A coma of a comet has no pressure at all, because its not an atmosphere. It is expanded gas that has escaped the comet because of the temperature increase. The coma is in the vacuum of space. For it to be an atmosphere, it has to be attached to the rocky/icey core and for there to be no vacuum in-between.
The only way possible for there to be a tiny planet (its not even considered a planet with the size of elenin) to be made 100% out of gas, is if it were in absolute zero temperatures, which wont even happen, because the radiation of of the universe's creation (or whatever it was) keeps the vacuum of space at a temperature slightly above absolute zero.


Interesting. It's a tiny planet!
 
Lazer Noble
offline
Link
 
interesting turn of events

Halo is now taking the role of troll - Comet Elenin
Edited by Lazer Noble on Oct 14, 2011 20:17:48
 
Carl Ellir
offline
Link
 
this thread should be locked as far as im concerned
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.