Originally posted by Carl Ellir
so you didn't read anything that i posted except the last sentence?
no, its physically impossible. A brown dwarf is 100% or 99% gas, the rest could be rock and dust particles that collide with it as it moves through the universe. It is impossible for there to be a tiny planet to be 100% gas, because the mass of it would be too low and the gases would escape...this is why stars and gaseous planets are so big, because they have to be to hold onto the gas. And btw, elenin isn't even CLOSE to being of any significant size at all. It is so small, in fact, that the ONLY reason why it has gas at all, is because it was frozen in its ice and rock. If elenin wasn't frozen, it would have no gas, and it would be an asteroid, not a comet. In fact, elenin is mostly ice...hardly any rock, just like every other comet. The air pressure in a brown dwarf is thousands of times stronger in its center than the earth at the very center of its iron core. A coma of a comet has no pressure at all, because its not an atmosphere. It is expanded gas that has escaped the comet because of the temperature increase. The coma is in the vacuum of space. For it to be an atmosphere, it has to be attached to the rocky/icey core and for there to be no vacuum in-between.
The only way possible for there to be a tiny planet (its not even considered a planet with the size of elenin) to be made 100% out of gas, is if it were in absolute zero temperatures, which wont even happen, because the radiation of of the universe's creation (or whatever it was) keeps the vacuum of space at a temperature slightly above absolute zero.Interesting. It's a tiny planet!
