User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Osmlol
This is a thread about the show, exactly. So you have no reason to post about the comic. problem solved. The only reason to mention the comic after this now is to just be a dick and try to ruin things for others.


Wrong. Discussing the source material for the show and how the show relates/differs/deviates from it is a natural and compelling extension of the discussion of the show. In fact, it is often the most compelling aspect of the discussion. I don't think anybody will go out of their way to bring up moments in the graphic novel just for the sake of mentioning them but they should be part of the discussion, yes. Also, it has been almost 10 years since the first edition of the graphic novel came out and since you can't really spoil the show by reading them, for me, the statute of limitations has run out on "Spoiler Alert"-ing anything that happened in the comics in a thread about the show. If you have intentions of reading them, get to them.
 
Venkman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Wrong. Discussing the source material for the show and how the show relates/differs/deviates from it is a natural and compelling extension of the discussion of the show. In fact, it is often the most compelling aspect of the discussion. I don't think anybody will go out of their way to bring up moments in the graphic novel just for the sake of mentioning them but they should be part of the discussion, yes. Also, it has been almost 10 years since the first edition of the graphic novel came out and since you can't really spoil the show by reading them, for me, the statute of limitations has run out on "Spoiler Alert"-ing anything that happened in the comics in a thread about the show. If you have intentions of reading them, get to them.


it's just common fucking courtesy for those if us who have not yet, but intend to, read the comics.
sorry, but I'm not going to read them according to your timeline (statute of limitations, my ass), but I (and others) would appreciate it if people stopped spoiling parts of them in this thread.
I repeat: common fucking courtesy.
 
quidjibo
offline
Link
 
well, FYI

whenever you guys want to read the comics i think you can find them all on youtube

that's where i've read every issue
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seths99
it's just common fucking courtesy for those if us who have not yet, but intend to, read the comics.
sorry, but I'm not going to read them according to your timeline (statute of limitations, my ass), but I (and others) would appreciate it if people stopped spoiling parts of them in this thread.
I repeat: common fucking courtesy.


Well, sorry you feel that way. Like I said, I have no intention of discussing the graphic novel purely for the intentions of discussing the graphic novel independent of how it relates to the show. That said, if how it relates to the show is interesting and relevant to the discussion, I won't restrict myself from mentioning either. It is all fair game, as far as I am concerned. If that is considered inconsiderate to some, then oh well. This is the internets, after all.
 
FlopTheNuts
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
This is the internets, after all.


Yeah, no one's around to punch you in the dick for being an ass. Innit great?
 
Venkman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Well, sorry you feel that way. Like I said, I have no intention of discussing the graphic novel purely for the intentions of discussing the graphic novel independent of how it relates to the show. That said, if how it relates to the show is interesting and relevant to the discussion, I won't restrict myself from mentioning either. It is all fair game, as far as I am concerned. If that is considered inconsiderate to some, then oh well. This is the internets, after all.


not saying it's not fair game, and I can see why you'd want to discuss it, but how hard is it to type:
**novel spoiler**
or something to that effect?
common courtesy.
 
Osmlol
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Well, sorry you feel that way. Like I said, I have no intention of discussing the graphic novel purely for the intentions of discussing the graphic novel independent of how it relates to the show. That said, if how it relates to the show is interesting and relevant to the discussion, I won't restrict myself from mentioning either. It is all fair game, as far as I am concerned. If that is considered inconsiderate to some, then oh well. This is the internets, after all.


No one said you CANT DO IT. We just asked for a simple spoiler alert. It takes 2 seconds to type ** Spoiler**.

Do you not get it? I mean seriously.
 
lVlellovv
offline
Link
 
he doesn't understand obviously, someone should create a separate thread for him to discuss TWD...since he hates the show and continues to throw shit out there about the comic without warning...and feels like he should do that because "if you haven't watched it yet that's your fault not mine" type of shit.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seths99
not saying it's not fair game, and I can see why you'd want to discuss it, but how hard is it to type:
**novel spoiler**
or something to that effect?
common courtesy.


Tell you what, man. I'll do my best. Does that mean that other people will necessarily do the same? No. Does that mean that if the discussion turns heavily to show/novel comparisons that people who haven't read the novel will miss out on large chunks of conversation? Probably. Will some of them still accidently read spoilers? Probably.

Hey, man. I get your indignation at the idea of someone dictating to you when and how you read the graphic novels. But let me offer a last piece of friendly advice to all of those out there who are still resistant to reading the graphic novels at the point for what ever reason. Just read them. It doesn't spoil the TV show to do so in any way shape or form and despite anything I, or anybody else, could do to the contrary you are going to have the comic spoiled for you in this topic. Either somebody will be careless or you'll accidently read something below the spoiler warning or whatever. Do yourself a favor and if you intend to read it, just read it.

Again, not a mandate. Just a friendly piece of advice because the chances of you spoiling the show with the graphic novel is extremely low. The chances of you having the graphic novel spoiled for you in this topic is relatively high and I have no sympathy for you if that happens. Sorry.
Edited by X on Mar 10, 2012 18:11:12
 
lVlellovv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Tell you what, man. I'll do my best. Does that mean that other people will necessarily do the same? No. Does that mean that if the discussion turns heavily to show/novel comparisons that people who haven't read the novel will miss out on large chunks of conversation? Probably. Will some of them still accidently read spoilers? Probably.

Hey, man. I get your indignation at the idea of someone dictating to you when and how you read the graphic novels. But let me offer a last piece of friendly advice to all of those out there who are still resistant to reading the graphic novels at the point for what ever reason. Just read them. It doesn't spoil the TV show to do so in any way shape or form and despite anything I, or anybody else, could do to the contrary you are going to have the comic spoiled for you in this topic. Either somebody will be careless or you'll accidently read something below the spoiler warning or whatever. Do yourself a favor and if you intend to read it, just read it.

Again, not a mandate. Just a friendly piece of advice because the chances of you spoiling the show with the graphic novel is extremely low. The chances of you having the graphic novel spoiled for you in this topic is relatively high and I have no sympathy for you if that happens. Sorry.


you say that, but then everyone who has read the comic thinks this show fucking blows...so yeah...i'll enjoy this show and then i'll read the comic. k?
 
blackdog3377
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lVlellovv
you say that, but then everyone who has read the comic thinks this show fucking blows...so yeah...i'll enjoy this show and then i'll read the comic. k?


Thats pretty much how almost every show/movie based on a book/comic/whatever goes. The only exception I can think is Game of Thrones simply because the show was fantastic.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lVlellovv
you say that, but then everyone who has read the comic thinks this show fucking blows...so yeah...i'll enjoy this show and then i'll read the comic. k?


Cool. Go for it and when you have the major moments of the graphic novel spoiled for you in this topic then you'll think that fucking blows. Personally, I'd rather have the show ruined for me than the graphic novel, but that's just me. Nothing you can do about people making bad decisions.
 
lVlellovv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Cool. Go for it and when you have the major moments of the graphic novel spoiled for you in this topic then you'll think that fucking blows. Personally, I'd rather have the show ruined for me than the graphic novel, but that's just me. Nothing you can do about people making bad decisions.


are you really this stupid?
 
lVlellovv
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by blackdog3377
Thats pretty much how almost every show/movie based on a book/comic/whatever goes. The only exception I can think is Game of Thrones simply because the show was fantastic.


p much, and this jackass is saying if you watch the movie/show prior to reading the comic/book then it'll ruin the comic/book for you...which is completely illogical
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lVlellovv
p much, and this jackass is saying if you watch the movie/show prior to reading the comic/book then it'll ruin the comic/book for you...which is completely illogical


No, I'm saying that the chances of you having something something major spoiled for you from the comic likely will. But anyway, like I said, can't stop people from making bad decisions and I'm definitely feeling more inclined to to talk about the show vs. comic now and hopefully I remember to always post spoiler alerts, but who knows.
Edited by X on Mar 11, 2012 07:02:52
Edited by X on Mar 11, 2012 06:41:26
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.