User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
I am curious... is it known how often games run on the test server.... is it every other day like ours or do the testers get 5-6 or more games a day?
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 09:54:41
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by weather999

Originally posted by Romeorr


according to bort there is not one supreme build so i dont get where you state there is only one build to build... Many builds are successful, so how does that take away the mystery?

If you find one type of build to be successful, why go away from that type of build?
That's like trying to find failure.

If all the test results/testers are released - the game will die in a matter of seasons due to everyone's builds being the same, and the Random Number Generator deciding games almost exclusively.


If there are multiple builds that can be successful, depending on the team tactics, other players on the team and opponent builds, then it would be rock, paper, scissors as far as builds go, and people would have different, successful builds.

I find the pearl clutching of The Public Results of Testing Will Destroy Us All crowd almost as ridiculous as the conspiracy crap dispensed by some of the people who are upset about the existence of the test server.

I would wager that a large percentage of people with good players on GLB arrived at those builds because of advice given by friends, teammates, GMs, forums, etc., rather than testing and figuring it out themselves (a dynamic that gets a little more problematic if testers reveal any information of what they've gleaned from testing to anyone else). Why should success in the game be predicated on knowing the right people to get advice from?


You're correct in that it's just not one person going into each build... but it comes down to the player owner to click the little plus sign.

And if you find the "Public Results of Testing Will Destroy Us All crowd" ridiculous, that's fine by me. We all have our opinions... you might be right... I might.... Deathblade might even be right
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Two examples..........

1) the DT making shoe-string tackles repeatedly in the game, when it didn't happen all season long against any other team including the first game against same team. DT shoestring tackles were fairly rare in any league this season, and one of the reasons power rushers dominated. My peewee team just happened to be a pretty good power-rushing team, too.

2) Linebackers making crossing moves on the line in singleback inside running formation was another defense not seen

I'm merely suggesting that there may have been an unfair advantage in our game, not insisting it. But I would like to know if that particular mod/team owner was one that did have access to the test server.

.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
inside running formation was another defense not seen.


Formation not seen? was it like a 5-5-5 or something? Post links
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by weather999
And if you find the "Public Results of Testing Will Destroy Us All crowd" ridiculous, that's fine by me. We all have our opinions... you might be right... I might.... Deathblade might even be right


Well, I guess that's true, although I don't think I've stated my opinion on the tester controversy in general (other than saying that I find the doomsayers on both sides to be ridiculous). My main point was that there are already pretty solid information flows on what does and doesn't work in player builds, but those information flows are relationship-based and unequal. If Bort posted replays of the games played on the test servers, it would still require a significant amount of work to suss things out, but at least everyone would have access to the same information.

 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
moved from killed thread

Originally posted by tseif


honestly, i think the mods have no say in that.

they got the "order" up above to do it.

so we really can't blame them.


I can believe that....

/conspiracy/ Did you see the way Tpat was telling us everything about the test server and then when Bort came on Bort was almost contradicting what Tpat said until it was pointed out that Tpat admitted to these things... Next thing you know threads are locked and Tpat comes out with the heavy hand... /conspiracy/
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
Originally posted by weather999

And if you find the "Public Results of Testing Will Destroy Us All crowd" ridiculous, that's fine by me. We all have our opinions... you might be right... I might.... Deathblade might even be right


Well, I guess that's true, although I don't think I've stated my opinion on the tester controversy in general (other than saying that I find the doomsayers on both sides to be ridiculous). My main point was that there are already pretty solid information flows on what does and doesn't work in player builds, but those information flows are relationship-based and unequal. If Bort posted replays of the games played on the test servers, it would still require a significant amount of work to suss things out, but at least everyone would have access to the same information.



Releasing replays with the test players builds available?
 
tseif
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tseif
Originally posted by JSSynister

Originally posted by tseif


http://goallineblitz.com/game/home.pl?user_id=4053 - this guy said being on the test server is inconsequential

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2083122&page=last#17370089 - itt

so much so he has the trophies to show for it. coincidental? not now. not in this game. and i have a mole in the monarchs team that says otherwise. he would even post their "recommended" builds in their team forums.

and if it was so utterly useless why all the secrecy?


all those trophies are from season 6 and earlier. Hes obviously been quite successful well before the existence of the test server.

And lots of teams post "recommended builds". Hes been winning trophies since season tow, Id say the guy has got a pretty good idea how to build players, and didn't need a test server to figure out how.


that is the thing we don't know. is it tainted? is it legit?

my mole said the "recommended" builds come from a "good insider source". he has been with the monarchs since season 3 or 4.

as i've said it's hard to know the truth now because of all of this secrecy


moving this here.

mike rogers admitted in the deleted thread that he is a tester and got a PM from bort to do it.
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tseif


moving this here.

mike rogers admitted in the deleted thread that he is a tester and got a PM from bort to do it.


The thread in that 2nd link has been deleted...
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by weather999
Releasing replays with the test players builds available?


Yes.

By the way, in the original two test server threads, there were people claiming that the advantage to the testers was minuscule b/c they wouldn't be able to glean too much information from what they were doing (it would take too long, be too difficult, etc.). I don't know if you were one of them (I'd guess not), but if it's too difficult for someone plucked from the GLB pool mainly b/c of their facility with the game and who is tasked with going through those replays with a close eye, then surely it would be much tougher for the average GLB player.

If it's not difficult for a tester to gain useful information from this, then that information is going to get out. Even the most ethical tester will have a hard time not using that information for his own player builds, and slightly less ethical testers who own or GM teams will give build advice to other agents on those teams (and unethical testers will PM their friends, post it on private forums or non-GLB forums). Once that information is out there, then it will flow freely through the various networks on this site. Why should only people in these networks have that advantage?

 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tseif
Originally posted by tseif

Originally posted by JSSynister


Originally posted by tseif



http://goallineblitz.com/game/home.pl?user_id=4053 - this guy said being on the test server is inconsequential

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=2083122&page=last#17370089 - itt

so much so he has the trophies to show for it. coincidental? not now. not in this game. and i have a mole in the monarchs team that says otherwise. he would even post their "recommended" builds in their team forums.

and if it was so utterly useless why all the secrecy?


all those trophies are from season 6 and earlier. Hes obviously been quite successful well before the existence of the test server.

And lots of teams post "recommended builds". Hes been winning trophies since season tow, Id say the guy has got a pretty good idea how to build players, and didn't need a test server to figure out how.


that is the thing we don't know. is it tainted? is it legit?

my mole said the "recommended" builds come from a "good insider source". he has been with the monarchs since season 3 or 4.

as i've said it's hard to know the truth now because of all of this secrecy


moving this here.

mike rogers admitted in the deleted thread that he is a tester and got a PM from bort to do it.


WTF

I post recommended build guides to all the teams I am involved with, and always have done since Season 1.
Thats over 30 Teams, and I also help out between 10-15 teams a season if they ask for it.

People often use my posts in other teams forums, I have often joined a new teams forum only to find my own info in there already.

I have only had access to the Test Server since Jan 29th (When it started), none of my recommendations were based on 'Inside info' other than experience in the game.

I am and always HAVE been Head Coach at Monarchs, and was for Yetis for the seasons I won the trophies, all of my Trophies come from BEFORE being admitted to the Test Server.


Last edited Feb 15, 2009 10:17:47
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
New question.

How bad did Tpat get busted by bort for him to turn into a total forum nazi overnight after not being seen in the forums for weeks?
 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers


WTF

I post recommended build guides to all the teams I am involved with, and always have done since Season 1.
Thats over 30 Teams, and I also help out between 10-15 teams a season if they ask for it.

People often use my posts in other teams forums, I have often joined a new teams forum only to find my own info in there already.

I have only had access to the Test Server since Jan 29th (When it started), none of my recommendations were based on 'Inside info' other than experience in the game.



Mike I am curious to know how often games are SIMed on the test server?....
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
so you post recommended builds for over 10-15 teams and you have access to the test server now...

Great.

If you are now getting inside info (testing server) your recommendations will be based on this.....I don't imagine you giving the wrong info to the monarchs......

You are a prime example of why people are pissed off.

(not at you, at the admins for allowing you access to the test server in secret)
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 10:23:17
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson

inside running formation was another defense not seen.


Formation not seen? was it like a 5-5-5 or something? Post links


I tried to PM them to you, but it must be down.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.