User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
King Henrik
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Deathblade

Hmm...how about some added penalties for elusive/speed backs?

Was just sitting here thinking about it...and shouldn't really fast HB's need more carrying? Running at 90 speed, juking and weaving, it seems like unless they were really good at holding onto the ball, they would cough it up quite frequently.

So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.


Going to bump this for some kind of comment...last attempt though.


interesting for sure.. i could live with it
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Deathblade

Hmm...how about some added penalties for elusive/speed backs?

Was just sitting here thinking about it...and shouldn't really fast HB's need more carrying? Running at 90 speed, juking and weaving, it seems like unless they were really good at holding onto the ball, they would cough it up quite frequently.

So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.


Going to bump this for some kind of comment...last attempt though.


i believe you have a point. people see broken tackles and want to nerf power backs, but thats how power backs get their yards. a power back needs to break a tackle for every guy an elusive guy ran around that he didn't.
 
Jack Del Rio
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by britdevine316
2. Give the guys running after the powerback a much better chance at making the tackle from behind. Currently they just bounce of them 90% of the time. See above play. After all, the weakness of the powerback is speed, so give the speed guys that chase them down an actual chance.


I kinda agree with this, but it should definitely take a few extra steps and perhaps even 5-10 yds of extra running to grab onto them and bring them down on wrap-up setting. Nobody's going to make a diving tackle attempt out of desperation at the 50 yd line when they are behind the defender and faster than the defender - they will do the right thing (which really shouldn't depend on their "vision" or shit like that, so don't bring it up) and establish a position on the RB where they can bring him to the ground.
 
WearyWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Deathblade

Hmm...how about some added penalties for elusive/speed backs?

Was just sitting here thinking about it...and shouldn't really fast HB's need more carrying? Running at 90 speed, juking and weaving, it seems like unless they were really good at holding onto the ball, they would cough it up quite frequently.

So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.


Going to bump this for some kind of comment...last attempt though.


Im not terribly sure about the first concept but I like the 2nd one a great deal. I think it makes a whole lot of sense in general and puts a good emphasis on carrying and vision helping you get that all important speed on the HB, thus generating more logical builds imo
 
mantis7
offline
Link
 
A) Tackling and Str should be more important than they seem to be now for making tackles...

Also...

B) Str/Carrying should be more important than they seem to be now for running / moving with the ball.


Right now all that seems to matter is speed / agility.

Any fix to A & B is a win, IMO.

Last edited Dec 30, 2008 11:00:43
 
gtbice
offline
Link
 
I think carrying is overrated, many players just soft cap it and that's it, if that... They should fumble the ball a lot more often against D players with high Tackle /Strength.

As for the Power back Bort mentioned Tackling should be the main attribute that effects that, strength should be more for a power hit, IE forcing fumbles.

75+-80+ tackle should be enough to take down that type of back, and it needs to be like that in order to weigh down the over powered speed attribute.

No player with a max of 40 tackle should be able to take down that kind of back.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WearyWarrior

Im not terribly sure about the first concept but I like the 2nd one a great deal. I think it makes a whole lot of sense in general and puts a good emphasis on carrying and vision helping you get that all important speed on the HB, thus generating more logical builds imo


Well, the second idea would negate the first idea almost entirely, unless they had crappy agility and were unable to slow down and were hit before they could really get ready for it. Basically, it makes vision, carrying, speed, and agility all important for an elusive back, which will cut down on the 100+ speed, and let defenses focus more on balancing their builds instead of being required to have high speed to catch them.

It would also, like I said earlier in the thread, give benefits to getting other attributes to 100. With 100 carrying, they wouldn't slow down very much at all before impact, and never fumble. With 100 vision, they would hardly ever slow down, plus the other little effects of vision.
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
This does look brutal in general. LB's especially are hit hard. There aren't enough SP's for LB's to do occasional coverage in the flat and be effective enough at it, and also be big and strong enough with high enough tackling to do any good against the running game.

You may very well want to consider changing the formula for automatic attribute gains on leveling up on a per position basis to give these positions with multiple roles a better chance of actually fulfilling these roles. Then you need to write the script to ensure veteran players get those bonus points.

As it is presently, those players whose position is just one role, can dominate a game just be exploiting the fomulas. Sure you can build a player to stop that specific player, but they suck at everything else and teams don't just have one RB or one WR or one TE etc.

I appreciate your desire not to make other attributes useless so that people ignore them. All my own players I have tried to build with balance even though its not necessarily the 'best' performance it seemed right to do. But if you're going to push for these sorts of changes then something needs to be done as a defensive roster has to be able o play any offense it faces.

Also -- Maybe you need to do some things (as others have already mentioned) with Speed/Agility then too. I would say increase the penalty to a backs spp3ed/agility for every missed tackle and slow them down considerably when a tackle attempt is made.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 11:22:58
 
captphan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Let's say I have a power back with:

100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

I've seen plenty of power backs with builds similarish to this, no?

The question I pose to the community (and this is often a topic of much debate) is: what sort of tackling/strength/SA's do you think you should need to consistently stop this guy?

I've seen answers ranging from "soft cap str/tck should be enough" to "You should need 100 tackling skill and at least 70-80 strength."

I will keep my opinion to myself for the moment to keep from tainting anyone else's opinion.


I have not read the whole thread but this seems very open. Does the runner have a full head of steam for a head on collision, is he being chased from behind, has he just cut etc.

Overall what i do think is tackling is much more a product of speed, vision and technique then strength. So that being said this guy gets tackled consistently by
70 speed
60+ tackling
50+strength/confidence/Vision
and 20 points in SA and VA geared towards tackling

In addition he should be greatly effected by confidence lowering SAs through out the game IE Big Hit and Aura of Intimidation
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Atatakakunai



oh u, so upset about how cupp was unstoppable.


Lol. I always thought Cupp was a slow build that had yet to spend any of his SP.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 11:26:40
 
Dee
offline
Link
 
I think the big thing that needs to be done is have a semi successful wrapup tackle have give of more than just 2 yards. You say plays in the NFL on a Cornerback getting an arm on a recievers leg, and he spins around and pushes for another 5ish yards. Thats just a WR. Powerbacks should pull players more, often need gangtackles if on wrap-up or need to be power tackled.
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by the man of doom

well a corner could cut his legs

and he would fall forward


The corner could also get stiff armed trying to do that.


that depends on a lot of things....a back at full speed can't stiff arm a guy down at his knees...for example.
 
Kirghiz
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade

So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.


I could live with this as an elusive back nerf if it wasn't installed until season 8. That way elusive backs could use season 7 to fix their builds and get it more in line with what is coming. I could also live with these theories about 150 combined strength/tackling to bring down power backs, but again, not until season 8 to give linebackers a chance to fix their builds as well. Gang tackles would also have to be introduced to ensure that the power backs can't just run right over the DB's, and to keep power backs from being used as kick returners. In the real world, no one uses power backs as kick returners, and it shouldn't work here either.
 
P.B.
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by WearyWarrior
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Deathblade


Hmm...how about some added penalties for elusive/speed backs?

Was just sitting here thinking about it...and shouldn't really fast HB's need more carrying? Running at 90 speed, juking and weaving, it seems like unless they were really good at holding onto the ball, they would cough it up quite frequently.

So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.


Going to bump this for some kind of comment...last attempt though.


Im not terribly sure about the first concept but I like the 2nd one a great deal. I think it makes a whole lot of sense in general and puts a good emphasis on carrying and vision helping you get that all important speed on the HB, thus generating more logical builds imo


Why should HBs have to change their builds and start putting more points in vision and carrying. Defensive players have been neglecting strength and tackling...I think that is where the change needs to happen.
 
King Henrik
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pboggs
Originally posted by WearyWarrior

Originally posted by Deathblade


Originally posted by Deathblade



Hmm...how about some added penalties for elusive/speed backs?

Was just sitting here thinking about it...and shouldn't really fast HB's need more carrying? Running at 90 speed, juking and weaving, it seems like unless they were really good at holding onto the ball, they would cough it up quite frequently.

So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.


Going to bump this for some kind of comment...last attempt though.


Im not terribly sure about the first concept but I like the 2nd one a great deal. I think it makes a whole lot of sense in general and puts a good emphasis on carrying and vision helping you get that all important speed on the HB, thus generating more logical builds imo


Why should HBs have to change their builds and start putting more points in vision and carrying. Defensive players have been neglecting strength and tackling...I think that is where the change needs to happen.


or both
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.