+1 for the 4-4 formation
Forum > Announcements > Defense AI Interface
Bully Ben
offline
offline
Well, one thing I would love is the Defense AI tester.
You put in a formation, qtr, time, place of ball, etc.. just like you do now.
And your defense falls out the bottom.
Then you press a test button and it runs a random play out of that formation.
For players it could take your starting defense. (Calculate the approximate avg level and round up.) Then have 3 options, test down, test up, test even.
With test even, it generates random players of your starting defense avg level and runs the play. Maybe even let you pick another team and run their offensive starting players. Or just your own teams starting offensive players.
Test down, calculates your avg level -4 (lvl 1 being the lowest).
And Test up, calculates your avg level +4.
You can hit the test button over and over testing your defense against all the various different plays that are generated from that formation.
You put in a formation, qtr, time, place of ball, etc.. just like you do now.
And your defense falls out the bottom.
Then you press a test button and it runs a random play out of that formation.
For players it could take your starting defense. (Calculate the approximate avg level and round up.) Then have 3 options, test down, test up, test even.
With test even, it generates random players of your starting defense avg level and runs the play. Maybe even let you pick another team and run their offensive starting players. Or just your own teams starting offensive players.
Test down, calculates your avg level -4 (lvl 1 being the lowest).
And Test up, calculates your avg level +4.
You can hit the test button over and over testing your defense against all the various different plays that are generated from that formation.
TrueBlueInMD
offline
offline
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
San Diego Chargers
offline
offline
Originally posted by TrueBlueInMD
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
I have mine set to 0 and turned off yet still saw the 3-3-5 today.
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
I have mine set to 0 and turned off yet still saw the 3-3-5 today.
TrueBlueInMD
offline
offline
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by TrueBlueInMD
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
I have mine set to 0 and turned off yet still saw the 3-3-5 today.
Damn -- that is *really* strange. Qualifies as a bug, I'd say!
Originally posted by TrueBlueInMD
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
I have mine set to 0 and turned off yet still saw the 3-3-5 today.
Damn -- that is *really* strange. Qualifies as a bug, I'd say!
Brutus Buckeye
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bully Ben
Well, one thing I would love is the Defense AI tester.
You put in a formation, qtr, time, place of ball, etc.. just like you do now.
And your defense falls out the bottom.
Then you press a test button and it runs a random play out of that formation.
For players it could take your starting defense. (Calculate the approximate avg level and round up.) Then have 3 options, test down, test up, test even.
With test even, it generates random players of your starting defense avg level and runs the play. Maybe even let you pick another team and run their offensive starting players. Or just your own teams starting offensive players.
Test down, calculates your avg level -4 (lvl 1 being the lowest).
And Test up, calculates your avg level +4.
You can hit the test button over and over testing your defense against all the various different plays that are generated from that formation.
Love this idea!!!!
Well, one thing I would love is the Defense AI tester.
You put in a formation, qtr, time, place of ball, etc.. just like you do now.
And your defense falls out the bottom.
Then you press a test button and it runs a random play out of that formation.
For players it could take your starting defense. (Calculate the approximate avg level and round up.) Then have 3 options, test down, test up, test even.
With test even, it generates random players of your starting defense avg level and runs the play. Maybe even let you pick another team and run their offensive starting players. Or just your own teams starting offensive players.
Test down, calculates your avg level -4 (lvl 1 being the lowest).
And Test up, calculates your avg level +4.
You can hit the test button over and over testing your defense against all the various different plays that are generated from that formation.
Love this idea!!!!
TideSpot
offline
offline
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by TrueBlueInMD
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
I have mine set to 0 and turned off yet still saw the 3-3-5 today.
Our defensive AI pretty much runs as ordered...have you looked at all the different parameters you have set for your inputs?
Originally posted by TrueBlueInMD
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
I have mine set to 0 and turned off yet still saw the 3-3-5 today.
Our defensive AI pretty much runs as ordered...have you looked at all the different parameters you have set for your inputs?
San Diego Chargers
offline
offline
Originally posted by TideSpot
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by TrueBlueInMD
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
I have mine set to 0 and turned off yet still saw the 3-3-5 today.
Our defensive AI pretty much runs as ordered...have you looked at all the different parameters you have set for your inputs?
Yeah I've checked everything and tried the tester. I made a thread about it in Tactics Discussion forum where I say exactly how my inputs are set up:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=865819
And like you guys are saying, other than this I love the Defensive AI and have not had any other problems.
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by TrueBlueInMD
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
I have mine set to 0 and turned off yet still saw the 3-3-5 today.
Our defensive AI pretty much runs as ordered...have you looked at all the different parameters you have set for your inputs?
Yeah I've checked everything and tried the tester. I made a thread about it in Tactics Discussion forum where I say exactly how my inputs are set up:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=865819
And like you guys are saying, other than this I love the Defensive AI and have not had any other problems.
britdevine316
offline
offline
What D coverage is this?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=105824&pbp_id=5153220
Nickle What?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=105824&pbp_id=5153220
Nickle What?
Rybread
offline
offline
Originally posted by San Diego Chargers
Originally posted by TrueBlueInMD
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
I have mine set to 0 and turned off yet still saw the 3-3-5 today.
I've had this exact same problem and I've even redone everything. Checking it over and over again. I did work fine before I moved my nickel from 4-2-5 or 3-3-5. It's been doing this after I moved it back to 4-2-5.
But today was a different beast. I played a team that runs Goalline in the 1st half. So to adjust so I don't line up in goalline in the middle of the field I set it so from any spot to my 5 I put base formation which is 3-4. I even tested it in the defense AI and it worked fine. Well in the game today here's the first play from scrimage:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=117252&pbp_id=5266421
Just to make sure, I went to the Defense AI and put in the exact situation input and the output said:
Possible Outputs
100% Stop the Run (base Cover 3 man)
base = 3-4
Cover 3 = Coverage shell
Man - Underneath coverage
I'm at a loss.
Originally posted by TrueBlueInMD
Originally posted by foolman11
+1 for the 4-4 formation
+10. It would come in real handy on 3d down and a yard or two in the middle of the field. The only other way to get 8 big guys out there is goal line defense.
The trouble with trying to run a 5-2 with DE's at the OLB spots (and a DT in at least one DE spot) in a 3-4 is that you can't force the substitutions. Unless you want to get burned having that set of players on the field when you really want a standard 3-4, you'd have to set auto-adjust to zero and never use the 3-4 for anything else.
The auto-adjust, by the way, is why you're seeing your teams in formations you don't want.
I have mine set to 0 and turned off yet still saw the 3-3-5 today.
I've had this exact same problem and I've even redone everything. Checking it over and over again. I did work fine before I moved my nickel from 4-2-5 or 3-3-5. It's been doing this after I moved it back to 4-2-5.
But today was a different beast. I played a team that runs Goalline in the 1st half. So to adjust so I don't line up in goalline in the middle of the field I set it so from any spot to my 5 I put base formation which is 3-4. I even tested it in the defense AI and it worked fine. Well in the game today here's the first play from scrimage:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=117252&pbp_id=5266421
Just to make sure, I went to the Defense AI and put in the exact situation input and the output said:
Possible Outputs
100% Stop the Run (base Cover 3 man)
base = 3-4
Cover 3 = Coverage shell
Man - Underneath coverage
I'm at a loss.
Divebomber
offline
offline
Originally posted by britdevine316
What D coverage is this?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=105824&pbp_id=5153220
Nickle What?
4-2-6 Dime
What D coverage is this?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=105824&pbp_id=5153220
Nickle What?
4-2-6 Dime
Divebomber
offline
offline
Originally posted by Tikker
I've yet to see the defense do something that I've not told it to do
Same here. I tried turning off the AI today to see what the old style defense would do in a friendly game. No better than my defense and actually probably a little worse.
I've yet to see the defense do something that I've not told it to do
Same here. I tried turning off the AI today to see what the old style defense would do in a friendly game. No better than my defense and actually probably a little worse.
Cheapshot
offline
offline
You wanted to play a cover 3 in a 34 defense against running plays?
I wouldnt use a 34 or a cover 3 D my friend, if you want to use the cover 3 then blitz the SS.
However, it depends on how you set up the AI, have you set up your plays on down or yardage or the formation you want to use it against?
And that Nickel coverage looks like a 4-2-5, the CB3 is in the ROLB slot so covers the first dot he sees.
I wouldnt use a 34 or a cover 3 D my friend, if you want to use the cover 3 then blitz the SS.
However, it depends on how you set up the AI, have you set up your plays on down or yardage or the formation you want to use it against?
And that Nickel coverage looks like a 4-2-5, the CB3 is in the ROLB slot so covers the first dot he sees.
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 09:24:33
Rybread
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cheapshot
You wanted to play a cover 3 in a 34 defense against running plays?
I wouldnt use a 34 or a cover 3 D my friend, if you want to use the cover 3 then blitz the SS.
However, it depends on how you set up the AI, have you set up your plays on down or yardage or the formation you want to use it against?
And that Nickel coverage looks like a 4-2-5, the CB3 is in the ROLB slot so covers the first dot he sees.
the way I have it setup, the Defense AI tells me it's correct. My whole point is the Sim doesn't do what the Tester says it should.
You wanted to play a cover 3 in a 34 defense against running plays?
I wouldnt use a 34 or a cover 3 D my friend, if you want to use the cover 3 then blitz the SS.
However, it depends on how you set up the AI, have you set up your plays on down or yardage or the formation you want to use it against?
And that Nickel coverage looks like a 4-2-5, the CB3 is in the ROLB slot so covers the first dot he sees.
the way I have it setup, the Defense AI tells me it's correct. My whole point is the Sim doesn't do what the Tester says it should.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























