User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > NERF THE FUMBLES NOW!!!
Page:
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

The question is if all HB with 60+ carrying fumble in such a higher rate or just a few. When other HBs not fumbling 5 out of 12, you can not say it like 60+ carrying doesn't help.

Yes, you can. If HBs with 60+ carrying can have such horrific fumble rates even in one game, then carrying has little effect on fumble prevention. It's not a matter of offensive builds, it's a matter of overpowered VAs and the randomness of how one turnover sometimes leads to a cascade effect in the sim. This same bullshit happened with QBs and 10+ interception games a long time ago, but Bort fixed it.


This is why I'd be on board with just eliminating VAs altogether at this point. If all it's going to lead to is constant complaining about every aspect of the game, then just get rid of them and let builds determine results. As it stands, all we're doing is making sure that every little thing that happens in the game will result in crying from one side or the other. Once this is nerfed, then youll have 75 str/tck LBs with 15 in power tackling wondering why theyre wasting points in those things if they can only cause 2-3 fumbles a season... and the cycle continues.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by merenoise
Originally posted by BartRock

Originally posted by buffalobills_tw


Originally posted by jdbolick



Originally posted by buffalobills_tw




The question is if all HB with 60+ carrying fumble in such a higher rate or just a few. When other HBs not fumbling 5 out of 12, you can not say it like 60+ carrying doesn't help.

Yes, you can. If HBs with 60+ carrying can have such horrific fumble rates even in one game, then carrying has little effect on fumble prevention. It's not a matter of offensive builds, it's a matter of overpowered VAs and the randomness of how one turnover sometimes leads to a cascade effect in the sim. This same bullshit happened with QBs and 10+ interception games a long time ago, but Bort fixed it.


Again, you are talking about one or few HBs, the sample size is too small. If most HBs with 60% carrying have this high fumble rate, it'll be a real problem. However, you are only talking about few HBs.


It's not even actually one HB with 60+, let alone a few. There has been no evidence presented of a player with 60+ carrying and confidence who has fumbled 5+ times. Or 4 times. Or 3 times. Or...you get the picture.



Exactly. I can find several games where a QB threw 6 TDs. Does that mean that QBs need to be nerfed?


Yep, I've been hearing about all these 60+ carrying RBs and yet there never seems to be any open builds. I can show you a 60+ carrying RB NOT fumbling...

 
CinTex
offline
Link
 
The bottom line is... RBs should have 100+ in Carrying... its what they do.....
Last edited Apr 27, 2009 13:36:26
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Yep, I've been hearing about all these 60+ carrying RBs and yet there never seems to be any open builds. I can show you a 60+ carrying RB NOT fumbling...

I can show you 40 carrying RBs who are not fumbling also, because it has very little if anything to do with the carrying attribute. It's about Power Tackler and the randomness of the sim occasionally inducing a cascade effect for turnovers. You've been around, jrry. You remember when QBs were having 10+ interception games back in Season 5 and it was not a matter of them having terrible builds. Bort fixed the problem then and he needs to fix this now.
 
BartRock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32

Yep, I've been hearing about all these 60+ carrying RBs and yet there never seems to be any open builds. I can show you a 60+ carrying RB NOT fumbling...



As can I.

This was all started by one guy who neglected carrying and confidence with his player from day 1 and is now paying for it.

He also stated that he believes all the other VAs are fine, but power tackling needs to be nerfed. I'd be interested in nerfing whatever VAs his players have that might work against everyone else. See how that works?
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by jrry32

Yep, I've been hearing about all these 60+ carrying RBs and yet there never seems to be any open builds. I can show you a 60+ carrying RB NOT fumbling...

I can show you 40 carrying RBs who are not fumbling also, because it has very little if anything to do with the carrying attribute. It's about Power Tackler and the randomness of the sim occasionally inducing a cascade effect for turnovers. You've been around, jrry. You remember when QBs were having 10+ interception games back in Season 5 and it was not a matter of them having terrible builds. Bort fixed the problem then and he needs to fix this now.


It has nothing to do with the randomness of the sim. It has everything to do with the team you're playing and your guy's builds. BTW some QBs may have been throwing 10+ ints but mine weren't and wasn't that because they had no confidence?(unlike my QB who has good confidence) Bort should only fix ONE part of the sim and that's special teams because that's where the only problem really is imo.
 
23yrwej
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BartRock
Originally posted by jrry32


Yep, I've been hearing about all these 60+ carrying RBs and yet there never seems to be any open builds. I can show you a 60+ carrying RB NOT fumbling...



As can I.

This was all started by one guy who neglected carrying and confidence with his player from day 1 and is now paying for it.

He also stated that he believes all the other VAs are fine, but power tackling needs to be nerfed. I'd be interested in nerfing whatever VAs his players have that might work against everyone else. See how that works?


Yep.
 
Splat
offline
Link
 
I own the SS J10er posted earlier. He was built from day 1 for FFs. However, my 75 STR, 67 Carrying back had 4 fumbles in 4 preseason games. That's way up from previous.
 
Snakebite99
offline
Link
 
Keep in mind that most, or at least MANY, LBs and SSs have gone away from Track star, quick, football genius and adding more SPs to speed/agility, and have started putting them in str/tck and VAs like Power tackler/Sure tackler, and have gone away from wrap up tackling and are now using power tackling, or at least balanced tackling. And from what ive seen so far, the high fumble games are a pretty low percentage of games.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BartRock
This was all started by one guy who neglected carrying and confidence with his player from day 1 and is now paying for it.

The OP doesn't even have a HB, you retard. And if you're talking about me, mine has been lucky enough not to have fumble problems this season. This is about some people recognizing an obvious and major problem with the sim, while some trolls like you argue for no logical reason at all.


Originally posted by jrry32
It has nothing to do with the randomness of the sim.

It does, which is why some backs with 60+ carrying are having mass-fumble games while other backs with less carrying don't, even when facing the exact same defense. There is something in the sim that occasionally causes a cascade effect with turnovers.

Originally posted by
BTW some QBs may have been throwing 10+ ints but mine weren't and wasn't that because they had no confidence?(unlike my QB who has good confidence)

Mine didn't either because the problem was random, and no, it wasn't because of low confidence. Some QBs with low confidence would throw an early INT and be fine, while some QBs with high confidence would throw an early INT and just keep throwing them the whole game. It was something in the sim that Bort had to fix.
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Snakebite99
And from what ive seen so far, the high fumble games are a pretty low percentage of games.

That's true. It's not a common occurrence and generally doesn't happen to the same teams, which speaks about the randomness of this effect.
 
IIAMLEGEND
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by
Snakebite99

And from what ive seen so far, the high fumble games are a pretty low percentage of games.


That's true. It's not a common occurrence and generally doesn't happen to the same teams, which speaks about the randomness of this effect.



JEEZ YOU HAVE BEEN IN HERE ARGUING ABOUT THIS SINCE BEFORE I LEFT FOR CLASS LMAO
 
n:iceman:16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IIAMLEGEND
Originally posted by jdbolick

Originally posted by
Snakebite99

And from what ive seen so far, the high fumble games are a pretty low percentage of games.


That's true. It's not a common occurrence and generally doesn't happen to the same teams, which speaks about the randomness of this effect.



JEEZ YOU HAVE BEEN IN HERE ARGUING ABOUT THIS SINCE BEFORE I LEFT FOR CLASS LMAO


Have you been quote failing since before you left for class?
 
jdbolick
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by IIAMLEGEND
JEEZ YOU HAVE BEEN IN HERE ARGUING ABOUT THIS SINCE BEFORE I LEFT FOR CLASS LMAO

Yeah, no kidding. I was planning on finishing my draft analysis article and haven't made a damn bit of progress because I've wasted all my time arguing about this.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by jdbolick
Originally posted by BartRock

This was all started by one guy who neglected carrying and confidence with his player from day 1 and is now paying for it.

The OP doesn't even have a HB, you retard. And if you're talking about me, mine has been lucky enough not to have fumble problems this season. This is about some people recognizing an obvious and major problem with the sim, while some trolls like you argue for no logical reason at all.


Wow... BartRock just showed how much of an idiot he really is with that post. Yeah, I have no HBs. And the HBs on my team have not been neglecting carrying, unless you consider having 60 in an attribute neglect. Confidence could have been higher (and is now higher). But how were we supposed to know that confidence would play such a big role (if that indeed was the problem), when it never has before?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.