User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > In Response to Bort's Final Post in the Test Server Thread
Page:
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by F8n4tune
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson

Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by Romeorr

when was this done, i didnt get the memo. All i have ever known people to do is speculate and what they thought would be a good build.

You don't think they were testing this on the test server?
Yes, this is speculation, but again, it's not rocket science.
I can surmise that they were testing 4 things.
Extreme Builds
Offensive AI
Defensive AI
D Play Creator,
Would you agree?

Emphasized to suggest how my team lost the Conference Championship

o_O This is what's scary that this guy doesn't know.


I agree that it's scary that the guy doesn't know this, but the communication on GLB is spotty at best, and the fact that he doesn't know that the testers are unable to bring over things they're testing on the test server is, partially, a function of the poor communication.

As I mentioned on another thread, I think Bort could put a stop to a lot of the conspiracy theories and rumor mongering if he would:

Originally posted by Gyuri1
Though I completely understand the admins wanting to stop/prevent the explosion of similar threads on the same topic that happened before they went lock/delete happy (well, the 2nd time the went lock/delete happy. . .the locking/deleting of Jose Bagg's original post is hard to defend in any way), it is ridiculous to expect everyone who wants to know what's going on to wade through several hundred pages of posts in two different threads.

There should really be a stickied thread started by Bort laying out in the first post:

(1) when access to the test server was given to agents/Mods (i.e., anyone but an admin);
(2) what the stated purpose of the testing is (was it solely to exploit-hunt the D-Play Coordinator, or also to find imbalances in builds and other plays);
(3) what the testers can and cannot do on the test server;
(4) how many testers there are;
(5) what safeguards have been put in place to prevent testers from using the information gleaned from the testing to their own personal advantage or the advantage of teams they are affiliated with or other agents they are friends with; and
(6) what will happen going forward with the test server (if this hasn't been completely decided, then he should say so).

In addition to making it easier for everyone to get up to speed on what the issue is, it should also clamp down on some of the wilder conspiracy theories that have been going around.

 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
In other news, give us the names.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Romeorr
according to bort there is not one supreme build so i dont get where you state there is only one build to build... Many builds are successful, so how does that take away the mystery?


If you find one type of build to be successful, why go away from that type of build?
That's like trying to find failure.

If all the test results/testers are released - the game will die in a matter of seasons due to everyone's builds being the same, and the Random Number Generator deciding games almost exclusively.

 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
What makes people think the testers are trying to find the homogenic build?
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by F8n4tune
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by Romeorr



when was this done, i didnt get the memo. All i have ever known people to do is speculate and what they thought would be a good build.


You don't think they were testing this on the test server?

Yes, this is speculation, but again, it's not rocket science.

I can surmise that they were testing 4 things.

Extreme Builds
Offensive AI
Defensive AI
D Play Creator,

Would you agree?





Emphasized to suggest how my team lost the Conference Championship



o_O This is what's scary that this guy doesn't know.


And you do?

It seems pretty clear that most here DON'T know.....that's the problem.

I'm merely suggesting that the team my peewee played for the conference championship used some defenses i've never seen before, and i've been here since almost the beginning. I also seen some of those defensive players making plays that I don't even see in the "big leagues" The team we lost to also was run by a mod.

1+1+1=something other than 3?

Those that cast the stone on me.....have you actually reviewed our game? If not, then shut up.

.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by weather999
Originally posted by Romeorr

according to bort there is not one supreme build so i dont get where you state there is only one build to build... Many builds are successful, so how does that take away the mystery?

If you find one type of build to be successful, why go away from that type of build?
That's like trying to find failure.

If all the test results/testers are released - the game will die in a matter of seasons due to everyone's builds being the same, and the Random Number Generator deciding games almost exclusively.


If there are multiple builds that can be successful, depending on the team tactics, other players on the team and opponent builds, then it would be rock, paper, scissors as far as builds go, and people would have different, successful builds.

I find the pearl clutching of The Public Results of Testing Will Destroy Us All crowd almost as ridiculous as the conspiracy crap dispensed by some of the people who are upset about the existence of the test server.

I would wager that a large percentage of people with good players on GLB arrived at those builds because of advice given by friends, teammates, GMs, forums, etc., rather than testing and figuring it out themselves (a dynamic that gets a little more problematic if testers reveal any information of what they've gleaned from testing to anyone else). Why should success in the game be predicated on knowing the right people to get advice from?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Originally posted by F8n4tune

Originally posted by Zeke Woodson


Originally posted by sjmay



Originally posted by Romeorr




when was this done, i didnt get the memo. All i have ever known people to do is speculate and what they thought would be a good build.


You don't think they were testing this on the test server?

Yes, this is speculation, but again, it's not rocket science.

I can surmise that they were testing 4 things.

Extreme Builds
Offensive AI
Defensive AI
D Play Creator,

Would you agree?





Emphasized to suggest how my team lost the Conference Championship



o_O This is what's scary that this guy doesn't know.


And you do?

It seems pretty clear that most here DON'T know.....that's the problem.

I'm merely suggesting that the team my peewee played for the conference championship used some defenses i've never seen before, and i've been here since almost the beginning. I also seen some of those defensive players making plays that I don't even see in the "big leagues" The team we lost to also was run by a mod.

1+1+1=something other than 3?

Those that cast the stone on me.....have you actually reviewed our game? If not, then shut up.

.


Actually if you go into the D Play Creator, it says, NOT WORKING YET
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson

And you do?

It seems pretty clear that most here DON'T know.....that's the problem.

I'm merely suggesting that the team my peewee played for the conference championship used some defenses i've never seen before, and i've been here since almost the beginning. I also seen some of those defensive players making plays that I don't even see in the "big leagues" The team we lost to also was run by a mod.

1+1+1=something other than 3?

Those that cast the stone on me.....have you actually reviewed our game? If not, then shut up..


This excuse is flawed, and also completely wrong. You should try another...

Or, better yet, post up some of these impossible plays.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 09:47:35
 
FlatheadCat
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson


And you do?

It seems pretty clear that most here DON'T know.....that's the problem.

I'm merely suggesting that the team my peewee played for the conference championship used some defenses i've never seen before, and i've been here since almost the beginning. I also seen some of those defensive players making plays that I don't even see in the "big leagues" The team we lost to also was run by a mod.

1+1+1=something other than 3?

Those that cast the stone on me.....have you actually reviewed our game? If not, then shut up..


This excuse is flawed, and also completely wrong. You should try another...


Post the names of those that had tester status and prove me wrong

Originally posted by
Or, better yet, post up some of these impossible plays.


Exactly my point............you haven't even seen our game, yet you dismiss me? Interesting.
Last edited Feb 15, 2009 09:49:11
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Post the names of those that had tester status and prove me wrong


The d play creator isn't even added to the live servers yet. The code isn't in it.

Post these plays that you think at from the play creator.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Exactly my point............you haven't even seen our game, yet you dismiss me? Interesting.


If you were suggesting that aliens invaded the servers, and controlled your dots with their brain, I would dismiss you as well without seeing the game.

You are claiming something that cannot happen.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
The team we lost to also was run by a mod..


EDIT: Whoops. I was wrong.

Last edited Feb 15, 2009 09:51:24
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Zeke you have no idea what you are talking about.

 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zeke Woodson
Originally posted by Deathblade

Originally posted by Zeke Woodson



And you do?

It seems pretty clear that most here DON'T know.....that's the problem.

I'm merely suggesting that the team my peewee played for the conference championship used some defenses i've never seen before, and i've been here since almost the beginning. I also seen some of those defensive players making plays that I don't even see in the "big leagues" The team we lost to also was run by a mod.

1+1+1=something other than 3?

Those that cast the stone on me.....have you actually reviewed our game? If not, then shut up..


This excuse is flawed, and also completely wrong. You should try another...


Post the names of those that had tester status and prove me wrong


Testers CANNOT use the Custom Def Play Creator on the Live Site.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Testers CANNOT use the Custom Def Play Creator on the Live Site.


Mike knows
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.