User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Page:
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Here are my final thoughts with my build open

1. Increase the "balance" penalty significantly after breaking a tackle so this stops happening every game, I shouldn't be breaking all these tackles so close to each other

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=349806&pbp_id=431115

2. Give the guys running after the powerback a much better chance at making the tackle from behind. Currently they just bounce of them 90% of the time. See above play. After all, the weakness of the powerback is speed, so give the speed guys that chase them down an actual chance.

3. Make vision/carry much more needed at the HB position. My powerback hasn't put a single SP into vison or carry and he dominates with hardly any fumbles. Does this sound right ? My guy should have had 15 fumbles last season and should never be able to find the hole.

4. This goes with #3. Give the guys with 60+STR/TKL and some SA in big hit/Monster Hit a HUGE jump in FF ability. At least 50-75% better than what it is now. There are guys with these builds getting 1 FF a season while CB's with under 20 STR/TKL and 0 SA's are getting 5 FF's a season.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 10:30:12
 
JovialEvil
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Larry Roadgrader

I know Bort would like to have us toss out a wide range of guesses, but I'm less concerned about a magic number than I am the tales that I keep reading where LBs and CBs have tackling and strength in the 30s and yet consistenly going a couple of games in a row without missing a tackle. That just doesn't ring right to me.


That's kinda why I'm asking this, Larry. People complain about missing tackles, but missing 3-4 tackles in a game vs one of these guys when you have 30 strength and 40 tackling and aren't running full speed with your 90 spd/agility doesn't really seem that out of line to me, even with "wrap up" settings.

I mean, you don't want power backs to be the end-all build, but you want to make their skills worthwhile as well, so a tiny weak CB doesn't take him down every time.


A CB should be able to hold onto him for a bit until help comes to take the RB down. A lot depends on the situation too, if it is open field or in a crowd, has he just broke a tackle or juked someone and is a little off balanced?
 
maizenhops
offline
Link
 
this thread needs to stop
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kalkmanc
this thread needs to stop


 
jamz
offline
Link
 
I don't know but right now anything but wrap up is completely worthless for the vast majority of players.

You also can't up tackling by 20 points overnight and str by another 30, so... yeah
 
Kavadas
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FatNasty
Originally posted by RiverRat2

Originally posted by EastBayFunk


Not much. NFL cornerbacks tackle running backs all the time.


nfl cornerbacks are pretty good at tackling IMO


Huh? A true POWER BACK licks his chops when thinking about being tackled by a skinny little CB. Think Jerome "The Bus" Bettis. What CB was going to tackle him solo twice in a row? My money is on "The Bus" 9 times out of 10. These guys as described should not get solo tackled very often, but swarm tackled.

If you ask me, energy and moral should take a good sized hit each time a player with less strength and "non competitive" SA's and VA's takes on a power back as described one on one.

Also, Newton's first law would be nice here (i.e., every action has an equal and opposite reaction), and the backs current energy (i.e., velocity and mass) at time of impact figured into the results, but I doubt such physics are actually programed into the game. Or are they?

Anyway, no way should a soft cap regularly take down a hundie. That's ridiculous.


This is a good point and I think weight should factor a bit into this a bit as well. I loathe Madden and his gay buttsecks obsession with Fav-ray but one time he said something I really, really liked:

"Fast guys slow down but big guys don't get smaller."
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 10:29:48
 
Mob-6
offline
Link
 
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

It should be difficult to tackle this guy, perhaps soft capped tackling it to low. If every defender has soft capped tackling it should be impossible to take the guy down though. There should some mechanism that makes it easier for the 2nd or 3rd defender to tackle the guy than the first assuming each defender has the same tackling attribute amount. I don't know if this can be done by just reducing the percent chance to break tackle after each broken tackle on one a single play or if there is a better way of doing it.
 
Raid
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mob-6
100 STR
70 Carrying
50/60ish Spd/Agi
8-10 in Power Through and Lower Shoulder type skills
15 in +brk tackle VA's
perhaps some AEQ with +brk tackle type stuff too

It should be difficult to tackle this guy, perhaps soft capped tackling it to low. If every defender has soft capped tackling it should be impossible to take the guy down though. There should some mechanism that makes it easier for the 2nd or 3rd defender to tackle the guy than the first assuming each defender has the same tackling attribute amount. I don't know if this can be done by just reducing the percent chance to break tackle after each broken tackle on one a single play or if there is a better way of doing it.


oh u, so upset about how cupp was unstoppable.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
I have never been convinced that strength should play such a large role in tackling or breaking tackles.

The actual art of tackling is about position and technique. If I was in the perfect position to make a tackle, I could bring down just about any NFL running back, but I will never play pro football because I am too slow to be in that perfect position, plus my tackle would still be for a four yard gain because I am not strong enough to stop the RB while I pull him down. You see, strength is important when calculating how many yards are gained while the tackle is being made, but not so much in the actual tackle.

The art of breaking tackles is about momentum and balance. A good RB can use high knees, or stiff arms, or a low shoulder to break a tackle, but that is not strength based. Earl Campbell was a strong guy, but his tackle breaking was about great balance, keeping his feet moving, and being a really big guy. You have to be strong to be so big and so fast, but make no mistakes, it was the momentum of the big dude coupled with his ability to keep his feet under him that made him break tackles.

I would use strength and weight ratio mixed with agility for acceleration. Speed would be actual top speed that is attainable.

Breaking tackles would be a function of speed of the RB, carrying skill of RB, SAs of the RB,agility of the RB, position of the tackler, tackling skill of the tackler, SA of the tackler. Position of tackler is really a function of speed and agility of both the RB and the tackler and any blockers etc. From these inputs, I would determine whether or not a tackle is going to be made. Then I would calculate a vector for the tackler based on his speed/weight/ST/tackling skill and SAs. I would do the same for the RB based on speed/ST/carrying/SAs. Add the vectors to find out where the RB comes down.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 10:42:23
 
FatNasty
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
I have never been convinced that strength should play such a large role in tackling or breaking tackles.

The actual art of tackling is about position and technique. If I was in the perfect position to make a tackle, I could bring down just about any NFL running back, but I will never play pro football because I am too slow to be in that perfect position, plus my tackle would still be for a four yard gain because I am not strong enough to stop the RB while I pull him down. You see, strength is important when calculating how many yards are gained while the tackle is being made, but not so much in the actual tackle.

The art of breaking tackles is about momentum and balance. A good RB can use high knees, or stiff arms, or a low shoulder to break a tackle, but that is not strength based. Earl Campbell was a strong guy, but his tackle breaking was about great balance, keeping his feet moving, and being a really big guy. You have to be strong to be so big and so fast, but make no mistakes, it was the momentum of the big dude coupled with his ability to keep his feet under him that made him break tackles.

I would use strength and weight ratio mixed with agility for acceleration. Speed would be actual top speed that is attainable.

Breaking tackles would be a function of speed of the RB, carrying skill of RB, SAs of the RB, position of the tackler, tackling skill of the tackler, SA of the tackler. Position of tackler is really a function of speed and agility of both the RB and the tackler and any blockers etc. From these inputs, I would determine whether or not a tackle is going to be made. Then I would calculate a vector for the tackler based on his speed/weight/ST/tackling skill and SAs. I would do the same for the RB based on speed/ST/carrying/SAs. Add the vectors to find out where the RB comes down.


To wrap up takes strength and the Tyler Rose was a load. You still make a good point. I know some great backs were taught to beat the defender to the punch, thus creating a lot of missed tackles.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 10:46:27
 
King Henrik
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
Tacklers can now hang on and be dragged a short while if they barely miss their tackle roll, to allow for a gang tackle to possibly happen. Strength vs strength rolls helps determine how quickly the tackler will get shaken off.

while the strength should determine how quickly the tackler will get shaken off, there should be a re-roll for the tackle using the tackling skill for every second that you are hanging on for.
 
P.B.
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by joebus36

Listen Up


In the NFL Linebackers have good speed. But in this game, everyone just puts a ton in speed. I think your LBs are too fast. Look at a guy like James Harrison. He is just incredibly strong but is nowhere as fast as people make their LBs on this game.


And in the NFL, not every WR, TE, and HB is over "100 speed". They are in this game because other attributes matter little for them. Suddenly making 2 more attributes very important for the defense isn't going to do anything positive for the game unless offense is required to start dumping points elsewhere as well.


Defenses have been pumping all strength and agilty for a while. The offense counters with a power running game. If DEs and LBs are going to go all speed and agility then the Power Backs are going to get to the second level a lot easier. Defenses have been claiming the oline builds are bad and no one should nerf the sacks. If the offense turns the table and starts running down their throats because of the lack of strength on D then maybe the Defensive builds need to adapt.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Hmm...how about some added penalties for elusive/speed backs?

Was just sitting here thinking about it...and shouldn't really fast HB's need more carrying? Running at 90 speed, juking and weaving, it seems like unless they were really good at holding onto the ball, they would cough it up quite frequently.

So how about this.

- The faster a ball carrier is moving, the more likely they are to cough up the ball when tackled. This will make carrying more important for the pure speed backs. The higher the carrying, the higher the "safe" speed. And no, I don't mean capping out it's usefulness at 50. I'm talking 70-80 carrying to be able to take a hit at 80-90 speed and not drop the ball.

- Vision helps ball carriers "see" threats, and know when to slow down and tuck the ball away. The amount of slow-down is inversely related to carrying, the more carrying, the less of a slow down. The higher the vision, the SMALLER the area of "slow down" occurs. With 10 vision, a HB would be holding onto the ball for dear life if a defender was within 5-10 yards of him. With 70 vision, the HB would wait until almost the last second before slowing down for impact.


Going to bump this for some kind of comment...last attempt though.
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
Here are my final thoughts with my build open

1. Increase the "balance" penalty significantly after breaking a tackle so this stops happening every game, I shouldn't be breaking all these tackles so close to each other

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=349806&pbp_id=431115

2. Give the guys running after the powerback a much better chance at making the tackle from behind. Currently they just bounce of them 90% of the time. See above play. After all, the weakness of the powerback is speed, so give the speed guys that chase them down an actual chance.

3. Make vision/carry much more needed at the HB position. My powerback hasn't put a single SP into vison or carry and he dominates with hardly any fumbles. Does this sound right ? My guy should have had 15 fumbles last season and should never be able to find the hole.

4. This goes with #3. Give the guys with 60+STR/TKL and some SA in big hit/Monster Hit a HUGE jump in FF ability. At least 50-75% better than what it is now. There are guys with these builds getting 1 FF a season while CB's with under 20 STR/TKL and 0 SA's are getting 5 FF's a season.
 
Billy Corman
offline
Link
 
In the beginning of this thread, some people mentioned the angle of attack.

If that back is coming head-on, the 80+ STRENGTH, 60+ TACKLING, 8+ BIG HIT/MONSTER HIT type attributes would be needed. If that HB is getting hit from the side, maybe 75% of those stats. If he's getting dragged down from behind, then 50% of those stats should be enough.

DEATHBLADE also mentioned tackling style and I agree with that premise. If a D-Lineman is using POWER TACKLING, it should be more effective against a Power Back than an Elusive Back. Maybe put a co-efficient to whatever formula is used. For example:
Power Back v Power Tackling: 1.0 * [Chance to TACKLE]
Power Back v. Balanced Tackling 0.95 * [Chance to TACKLE]
Power Back v. Wrap-Up Tackling 0.90 * [Chance to TACKLE]
Balanced Back v Power Tackling: 0.95 * [Chance to TACKLE]
Balanced Back v Balanced Tackling 1.0 * [Chance to TACKLE]
Balanced Back v Wrap-Up Tackling 0.95 * [Chance to TACKLE]
Elusive Back v Power Tackling: 0.90 * [Chance to TACKLE]
Elusive Back v. Balanced Tackling 0.95 * [Chance to TACKLE]
Elusive Back v. Wrap-Up Tackling 1.0 * [Chance to TACKLE]

I do not think attributes should be position-dependent, i.e. less needed for a CB than a D-Lineman. Otherwise, that should come into play against other positions. If a D-Lineman were to have huge stats, he would kill a WR if he got to him.
Last edited Dec 30, 2008 11:29:08
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.