User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Player goes up 8 levels in 4 games and 17 levels in 13 games
Page:
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
I'm confused here Bort. What am I missing?

There should be no minimum. There should be only maximum exp. The equivalent exp a normal player would get for maximum snaps (effectively speaking).

Let's say for level 10, that value is 400.
One punter punts the whole game - he gets 400 exp. # of punts regardless.
If two placekickers each take turns kicking, they each get 200 exp. The maximum divided by 2.

Really, we should only see multiple kickers/punters on D league teams anyway, right?

D-Leagues don't take turns kicking, they go by stamina; it's not uncommon for one punter to get 8 punts while the backup gets 1 or 2 if they're lucky, 0 if they're not. That's the big reason.

Another one is unfair punishment for kickers on bad teams or punters on good teams. It's a lot easier to get your backup quarterback in the game (just change a sub setting) regardless of score than it is to get your kicker in there if your offense can't get you in field goal range and doesn't score touchdowns (you get one kickoff and that's it for the whole game) or to get your punter in the game if your offense is trucking against a gutted team and converting every third down until they're in field goal range (you punt on the off chance they screw up three times in a row when they aren't in field goal range).

Just adjust the K/P XP cap and let them play wherever.
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 12:52:25
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva

being the biggest objector to this in the beginning I think this is a good idea now but i still think if a punter or kicker plays another position they should still be able to earn xps because what if I want my punter on KOs as a gunner or something.


The current cap is around 550ish for lv 1, so a cap around the same amount for "extra XP" gained by kicking and punting would seem to make sense, and is quite easy to put in.

The thing I'm worried about is the minimum suggestion - definitely would have to have a split time factor or something to address the farming problem it would create.


Bort - is there a way to have different code for the D-Leagues vs. a regular team?

i.e. for the d-leagues, allow all punters/kickers to get a minimum level of XP (say 1/2 of their max) which can be increased if a certain number of plays are achieved, with a max equal to other positions.

For regular teams, only the starter gets 1/2 XP at P/K and can earn more through plays, but the max is lowered to that of other positions.

This should help unpenalize punters on good teams and kickers on bad teams, while also allowing those in the d-leagues to level at a fair rate.

Also, I 100% agree that only K/P should be able to achieve any XP for playing at the K/P position.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I would think it should probably be something along the lines of what islander said - 300 pts minimum, split amongst all the K's on the DC. Same for P's. Then you can't just put 20 P's on the depth chart to get them all 300 XP's every game.


Well, you'll still have serious issues in the D-Leagues, with a team with 3 kickers, for example. Even if a kicker kicks 10 XPs, on that team they'll only get 200 XP.

Level 1 values:

300xp minimum
600xp maximum

Then, make the curve get ridiculous. Make is to that, to surpass that 300xp number, someone has to kick it 5 times, and to reach that 600xp number, someone has to kick it 20 times.

So:

0-5 plays = 300 xp
6 plays = 340 xp
7 plays = 380 xp
8 plays = 410 xp
9 plays = 440 xp
10 plays = 470 xp
11 plays = 490 xp
12 plays = 510 xp
13 plays = 530 xp
14 plays = 540 xp
15 plays = 550 xp
16 plays = 560 xp
17 plays = 570 xp
18 plays = 580 xp
19 plays = 590 xp
20 plays = 600 xp
21+ plays = 600 xp


This would make it all but impossible to get max or near max exp for multiple kickers. If someone wants to play their QB at punter for half the exp they would get by playing at QB...Go for it I say.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
That chart is a little skewed I think. Probably should award a few more at the lower range of plays higher than 5, up to 10 or so, but it's not too far off what I think would be fair.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Originally posted by islander1

I'm confused here Bort. What am I missing?

There should be no minimum. There should be only maximum exp. The equivalent exp a normal player would get for maximum snaps (effectively speaking).

Let's say for level 10, that value is 400.
One punter punts the whole game - he gets 400 exp. # of punts regardless.
If two placekickers each take turns kicking, they each get 200 exp. The maximum divided by 2.

Really, we should only see multiple kickers/punters on D league teams anyway, right?

D-Leagues don't take turns kicking, they go by stamina; it's not uncommon for one punter to get 8 punts while the backup gets 1 or 2 if they're lucky, 0 if they're not. That's the big reason.


Thanks for the clarification on this.

In the case of D leagues then, gah. That's kinda messy. Maybe give the starter full exp and the backup half?

My solution makes sense for normal teams then...but the D leagues, save for programically forcing the D leagues to literally alternate punters (or just have one on a team, like everyone else)....hmmm.

 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin
Originally posted by Bort

I would think it should probably be something along the lines of what islander said - 300 pts minimum, split amongst all the K's on the DC. Same for P's. Then you can't just put 20 P's on the depth chart to get them all 300 XP's every game.


Well, you'll still have serious issues in the D-Leagues, with a team with 3 kickers, for example. Even if a kicker kicks 10 XPs, on that team they'll only get 200 XP.

.


There should never be more then 2 kickers or punters on a team. The D league teams should not offer contracts out to a third one. If they do already, then that's an entirely different issue/bug to fix.

 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
How about no one other than K/P can get experience at K/P, but K/P can get experience elsewhere? I know I play Reggie Roby, our Punter, at Special Teams during the regular season so that he can actually get some experience.
 
cwrujosh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva

Originally posted by Bort


How 'bout if you can only get XP for kicking/punting if you are actually a K/P...and set a limit on the number of kicks/punts that count, like 5 of each?


bad idea in my opinion



Why? Seems like a WR playing at K shouldn't be able to get K experience, since that kinda sounds exploity. Play your own position!

Or are you just against the cap of kicks that count?


Well, my kicker has kicked 12 times in an ordinary game before, all XPs and FG attempts. Why should he be penalized for that? That's why the cap isn't a great idea at 5. 10 might be better, after all, in a tight game a P may kick 10 or more times (or when getting blown out).
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
yes if there are 2 spots filled on every slot then no offers to d-league and they have to decide to try and find a human team or retire and build something else.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
How about no one other than K/P can get experience at K/P, but K/P can get experience elsewhere? I know I play Reggie Roby, our Punter, at Special Teams during the regular season so that he can actually get some experience.


no I am being told it is not realistic
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
How about no one other than K/P can get experience at K/P, but K/P can get experience elsewhere? I know I play Reggie Roby, our Punter, at Special Teams during the regular season so that he can actually get some experience.


Well, this is exactly why I've made the suggestion I have.

This shouldn't be necessary. I've made the suggestion back on page 4 or 5. Gotta run, team meeting.
 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
FairForever,

I think the reason for that is b/c this thread was started because some people were troubled that there were teams playing Ks and Ps out of position to unrealistically gain a huge number of XPs (see the title of the thread). If the min XP/max XP suggestions that have been made are implemented, then your punter will get a decent amount of XPs regardless of whether your a good team (few punts) or not.

If someone thinks that their punter makes a good special teams player or QB or something, then they can play them there to benefit the team, but will not be able to unrealistically rack up XPs.

It seems like a reasonable solution to me.

[EDIT: or see Islanders comment. . .damn fast typers.]
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 13:16:50
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by FairForever
How about no one other than K/P can get experience at K/P, but K/P can get experience elsewhere? I know I play Reggie Roby, our Punter, at Special Teams during the regular season so that he can actually get some experience.


Anyone can play special teams and earn experience there - the problem with the K/P spots is that XP growth in those spots has been augmented due to low plays at the position. This however can be exploited easily. I understand the reasoning behind why the max XP is higher for a P/K, but given the exploits, I think it is very important to move the max XP down to a similar level to other players. Make it easier to achieve the max XP due to low play #'s at the position (another player gets absolute max at 50 plays, maybe for a P/K they get absolute max at 15, near absolute at 10?

I can say that on a slow build team I am on, the punter is already three levels ahead of players at other positions.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva

being the biggest objector to this in the beginning I think this is a good idea now but i still think if a punter or kicker plays another position they should still be able to earn xps because what if I want my punter on KOs as a gunner or something.


The current cap is around 550ish for lv 1, so a cap around the same amount for "extra XP" gained by kicking and punting would seem to make sense, and is quite easy to put in.

The thing I'm worried about is the minimum suggestion - definitely would have to have a split time factor or something to address the farming problem it would create.


If the minimum is 10-20% of the maximum I d not think it will cause much of a problem.

A level 1 gets 55 XP, they would get more from daily training. Even at 20% it would be too small to make it viable to build players by not playing them. It will just allow people to get a small amount of XP if they are benched or do not get any snaps.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.