User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Prestige Attributes - A way to reduce the "stagnation plateau" for higher level players and add more differentiation among cookie cutter builds
Page:
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Bort

I like the idea in general, would need a lot more fleshing out as far as skills per position, etc go. I think it makes more sense to approach the idea as "veteran skills" instead of "prestige skills" since that's basically what you're talking about - the guy gets to a high enough level and he opens up a whole new tree of abilities.

I'm not sure about the "cap raising" ones. I worry that they might be too powerful and give you no reason to go for anything else.

Some of the skills listed kinda remind me of the perks in Fallout, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. Hmm...that might be kinda neat too, as in you get to choose a couple "perks" when you create your guy...but that's a different thread.


Ken has talked about the Fallout Perks system for some time now as an alternative and that definitely is what I had in mind.

The cap raising ones can just be made more expensive if you think they need to be. I think they're a good addition. As I pointed out, by the time the player hits season 10 he would have had to focuse ALL of his prestige points (or veteran points) into one soft cap just to get it to around 70. That's a big sacrifice and if he wants to do it, more power to him.

Finally - Try and avoid "position perks". Make all prestige (or veteran) skills available to all positions. Also, later in the thread, if you didn't see it, I suggested another set that would reduce the position penalty for playing any given position. One "perk" for every position.


Great idea...Drifter, you've got a great history of making outstanding and well thought-out suggestions.

I'd like to highlight here two things:

1. Bort Inc. shouldn't discount the level of boredom/inactivity that sets not to far into the L20's. This suggestion definately addresses that.

2. Drifter a while back suggested letting every player choose which SAs they wanted to put points into. It was a great idea on many levels - why can't a DT have "change direction" or "first step", for example. I definately agree with letting players choose which "prestige" or veteran" attributes they can choose from, regardless of position.
 
DeepCross
offline
Link
 
I like the spirit of this thought, but doesn't it all come down to performance on the field? If so, why not just get rid of the caps and slowdown in level increases? Wouldn't this be simpler and accomplish the same thing?
 
AUSSIE ANT
offline
Link
 
i really like this
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Bort

I'd like to see some more ideas on the specific abilities the player could choose, and what they would do. Basically just throw ideas out there and we can pick and choose what's good and what isn't.

Also, I wonder if it would be a good idea to have certain ones "unlock" at certain levels, like the first set unlocks at level 18, the second set at 25, the third set at 30, maybe another at 40? Would possibly help to make it feel like you earned them.

Also, you said Ken had posted about a "perks" system at some point. Would like to see more on that idea somewhere.


Ken or GG will need to point you at their specific thread


I think what he's referring to is the thread where GG and I came up with a whole bunch of new SA's. You (Bort) said that wasn't feasible. But this is a different way to get more SA-type attributes into the game, so it's along those lines.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
I like the concept. Some quick notes:

1) This would encourage boosting up to the first level (31 or whatever), and then make boosting beyond less important -- I was trying to come up with a way to do exactly this and couldn't come up with anything that I liked.. so this is a huge bonus in my opinion. I suppose people would still boost to get the level 32 gear - but the next couple seasons after that would revolve around the new abilities while saving up the huge sums of cash for level 40 gear.

2) Because the new abilities have the potential to be very useful - the idea that each Prestige level could be used for 1 regular Attribute point, or one level in the new skills, seems a great way to determine the "cost" of each point in the new skills - that way they can be balanced relative to the existing skills.

3) Of the Abilities you posted - the one that I definitely dislike is the "Go To Man" - it basically amounts to forcing the QB to have them set as favorite target which could conflict with a game plan where the QBs want to avoid your Player and go to a different one because of an intentional mismatch.

4) Of course the biggest concern with an idea such as this is that it will further increase the power disparities between Players who are above or below the introduction line. I see some discussion of unlocking various aspects of this at different levels - which would reduce steepness of the disparity at that one level, but would increase the level difference at various other places in a Player's career.

For that reason, I'm pretty sure that I'm against the idea of unlocking abilities based upon Player level - I'd much rather have the Cliff which will encourage Players to B-line to that Cliff as fast as possible. I do like the idea of unlocking abilities based upon having reached various attribute/skill milestones. Heck, even having reached some stat milestones could be a good idea.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Bort


I'd like to see some more ideas on the specific abilities the player could choose, and what they would do. Basically just throw ideas out there and we can pick and choose what's good and what isn't.

Also, I wonder if it would be a good idea to have certain ones "unlock" at certain levels, like the first set unlocks at level 18, the second set at 25, the third set at 30, maybe another at 40? Would possibly help to make it feel like you earned them.

Also, you said Ken had posted about a "perks" system at some point. Would like to see more on that idea somewhere.


Ken or GG will need to point you at their specific thread


I think what he's referring to is the thread where GG and I came up with a whole bunch of new SA's. You (Bort) said that wasn't feasible. But this is a different way to get more SA-type attributes into the game, so it's along those lines.


Yeah, I remember that one. Good ideas in general, but it wasn't presented as a way to add them in a reasonable way to how the game currently works and people are used to. It was basically "scrap the whole system and do this instead."
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Heck, even having reached some stat milestones could be a good idea.


Hmm, like if you score 10 rushing TDs in a season you unlock the "rushing TD" skills or something like that?
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Heck, even having reached some stat milestones could be a good idea.


Hmm, like if you score 10 rushing TDs in a season you unlock the "rushing TD" skills or something like that?


Yes, but even negative ones - like being on a team which goes 0-16 might unlock an ability which is really good for increasing the entire team's moral like the future coach or something. Maybe having been tackled a lot would give a skill that increases the chance to avoid/break tackles.. this kind of thing.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Some others:

Comeback Kid: Provides a bonus to offensive players' making big plays when behind. This isn't Clutch, as it's when behind by 1 or by 40, and it only applies to big play potential.

So a QB or WR or TE would get bonuses from this, when behind, on long passes (but only long passes), or a HB when in the clear or trying a move or broken tackle that will put him in the clear for a big play.

Special Teamer: Bonuses across the board when playing on special teams as something other than a returner.

Energy Bounceback: When a player isn't in the game, he recovers energy faster (both "breath" and "freshness"). Not the same as Stamina as it doesn't affect how fast it's lost when in the game.

Thick Skin: The player is affected less by intimidation abilities (not the same as Confidence, because it doesn't help a player who, say, just fumbled maintain morale).
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by drifter


Originally posted by Bort



I'd like to see some more ideas on the specific abilities the player could choose, and what they would do. Basically just throw ideas out there and we can pick and choose what's good and what isn't.

Also, I wonder if it would be a good idea to have certain ones "unlock" at certain levels, like the first set unlocks at level 18, the second set at 25, the third set at 30, maybe another at 40? Would possibly help to make it feel like you earned them.

Also, you said Ken had posted about a "perks" system at some point. Would like to see more on that idea somewhere.


Ken or GG will need to point you at their specific thread


I think what he's referring to is the thread where GG and I came up with a whole bunch of new SA's. You (Bort) said that wasn't feasible. But this is a different way to get more SA-type attributes into the game, so it's along those lines.


Yeah, I remember that one. Good ideas in general, but it wasn't presented as a way to add them in a reasonable way to how the game currently works and people are used to. It was basically "scrap the whole system and do this instead."


Well, GG and I had different views of it.

I wanted to scrap only the SA ladder system. He wanted to scrap the entire player module, which I never supported.

I simply wanted to free SA's from the ladders and have many more.

So he separated the two, but you didn't want to undo the SA ladders either, so it wasn't possible. But this is also a very good way to get more abilities into the game, as to me it was all about specialization.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Maybe having been tackled a lot would give a skill that increases the chance to avoid/break tackles.. this kind of thing.


Actually, tackles indicate carries/catches - which is a good thing, so that doesn't really follow from what I was getting at - but being on a team that loses a lot, getting a lot of drops, missed tackles, penalties, injuries, interceptions, missed FG/XPs, and just about any other negative stat that one can think of could be used to later unlock an ability.... this might help encourage FAs to be willing to sign with rebuilding teams because they know that even a losing season can pay dividends in future seasons.
 
amo368
offline
Link
 
Dude this is awesome... Bort - I hope you do something with this in the future... I'm a level 27 and it's getting slow with my player... I'm just glad I'm a GM...

Drifter, nice ideas... keep em coming.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
I like the concept. Some quick notes:

1) This would encourage boosting up to the first level (31 or whatever), and then make boosting beyond less important -- I was trying to come up with a way to do exactly this and couldn't come up with anything that I liked.. so this is a huge bonus in my opinion. I suppose people would still boost to get the level 32 gear - but the next couple seasons after that would revolve around the new abilities while saving up the huge sums of cash for level 40 gear.

2) Because the new abilities have the potential to be very useful - the idea that each Prestige level could be used for 1 regular Attribute point, or one level in the new skills, seems a great way to determine the "cost" of each point in the new skills - that way they can be balanced relative to the existing skills.

3) Of the Abilities you posted - the one that I definitely dislike is the "Go To Man" - it basically amounts to forcing the QB to have them set as favorite target which could conflict with a game plan where the QBs want to avoid your Player and go to a different one because of an intentional mismatch.

4) Of course the biggest concern with an idea such as this is that it will further increase the power disparities between Players who are above or below the introduction line. I see some discussion of unlocking various aspects of this at different levels - which would reduce steepness of the disparity at that one level, but would increase the level difference at various other places in a Player's career.

For that reason, I'm pretty sure that I'm against the idea of unlocking abilities based upon Player level - I'd much rather have the Cliff which will encourage Players to B-line to that Cliff as fast as possible. I do like the idea of unlocking abilities based upon having reached various attribute/skill milestones. Heck, even having reached some stat milestones could be a good idea.


1. Yes and No. YOu would still continue to gain experience based on your actual level - so around 2.5 levels per season, 5.5 if you boost. You would still receive your usual allocation of 5 sp per level to be distributed amongst your regular attributes and SAs so boosting would still be desirable.

2. Increasing the soft cap isn't necessarily equal to 1 pt in that SA, but it would often work out that way if people had already spent money above the soft cap.

3. It doesn't force anything. As I posted earlier in the thread the bump isn't gigantic and the QB will still make his reads as normal. If another players is a much better target the QB will still choose the much better target but if the targets are about equal, this "Perk" would give them the edge. All of these "Perks" are relatively minor. You would need to sink all of your pts into one or two to make a huge difference and just like anything else, to do that, is sacrificing somehwere else.

4. Again, the effects are fairly minor so a level 31 Prestige Level 5 character isn't going to be monstrously better than a level 30. Just a small amount. Now, a level 45, Prestige level 25 character is going to be quite a bit better than a Level 30 character but he should be - he's 50% higher than him in levels. That said, I do agree that I prefer some kind of tiered system than unlocking further abilities at higher levels.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
New Prestige ability:

Underdog: When outmatched or down by a large margin, this player picks his game up and peforms at an advanced ability level.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi

Heck, even having reached some stat milestones could be a good idea.


Hmm, like if you score 10 rushing TDs in a season you unlock the "rushing TD" skills or something like that?


Don't think that's a good idea. Encouraging stat padding will backfire in the long run.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.