User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
misterbing
offline
Link
 
Crunch I'm going to be honest here and say that after actually watching the sim replays... hahaha holy crap. Your NT doesn't get double teamed. He gets tripled or more, or they don't even try running it at you to give you a chance to bust through. Long story short, your NT is doing a hell of a job and it sucks you put so many points into the SA but hey, an ounce of prevention and all that, right? :V
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 01:33:25
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by misterbing
Originally posted by SmithersOT



post script: also why didn't you post THE VERY NEXT PLAY where the NT in question blew through the C/RG doubleteam like they were made of marshmallows?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=87673&pbp_id=3384877



he blew by the G, but I'd say that level 6 C handled him pretty well.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NutsNutsNutz
Originally posted by datongw

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=107309&pbp_id=3580314
No, G was pulling, so 1 on 1.


You seriously think that guard was pulling? Regardless, he got his ass pancaked...


Watch his initial move, it was to the right. If he's blocking, he's first move should be forward, not to the right. There was no pancake on that play.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnCrunch
Originally posted by tautology

This thread should be locked as it provides zero value.

I speak as an agent who has 10 DTs, ranging from level 8 to level 21.


Great! In a season or two when theyre decent level, feel free to educate us all.

guys, pointing out something that is not working is not some major slam. Its not a freakout and I really dont know why some people have to flail around like the great defenders of the game. obviously everyone here loves the game or they wouldnt be even bothering with this thread. It is not a sin to point out something that is clearly not working.


+1
 
Doug_Plank
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
This thread should be locked as it provides zero value.

I speak as an agent who has 10 DTs, ranging from level 8 to level 21.


You have 11 DTs
 
grugnur
offline
Link
 
so, we now know that high strength does not make you a good NT... high strength and high tackling combined do not make you a good NT... high strength, high agility and high tackling combined don't make you a good NT either... funny, but an OL with high strength, agility and blocking WILL beat your azz up ALL DAY LONG
 
SmithersOT
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by misterbing
Crunch I'm going to be honest here and say that after actually watching the sim replays... hahaha holy crap. Your NT doesn't get double teamed. He gets tripled or more, or they don't even try running it at you to give you a chance to bust through. Long story short, your NT is doing a hell of a job and it sucks you put so many points into the SA but hey, an ounce of prevention and all that, right? :V


The properly built NT, against EQUAL level competition and even double and triple teams, should break through and penetrate the backfield a certain percentage of the time. I would say out of 45 or 50 plays he should manage to penetrate as many as 5 times. This is not to say that he makes a big play, but simply gets penetration. A 10% ratio like this makes the NT something of a threat while allowing variety in builds. Some might choose more speed and less strength for example, electing to penetrate less but with a higher chance of disrupting the play when they get there.

The point is that now the perfectly build NT, against equal level competition, is not going anywhere. He is not going anywhere against FAR lower level competition. He can be lined up across from a Center on crutches and he isn't gonna do shit. And THAT'S a problem.
 
CapnCrunch
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by misterbing
Crunch I'm going to be honest here and say that after actually watching the sim replays... hahaha holy crap. Your NT doesn't get double teamed. He gets tripled or more, or they don't even try running it at you to give you a chance to bust through. Long story short, your NT is doing a hell of a job and it sucks you put so many points into the SA but hey, an ounce of prevention and all that, right? :V


yeah, sometimes he does draw tripple and when that happens, there probably isnt a chance in hell that he would break through - but were talking 7 games here or 50-60 plays per game - there were plenty of times where he was single or double teamed and he still didnt break through.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by superman8456
Originally posted by tautology

This thread should be locked as it provides zero value.

I speak as an agent who has 10 DTs, ranging from level 8 to level 21.


Between your 10 DT's they only have 18 sacks all together..


My DTs are not meant to get sacks, though they do get a fair number of hurries. They are meant to stop the run.

Case in point, my Hidden Dragons team is #1 in rushing defense, allowing fewer than 60 yards per game rushing.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_stats.pl?league_id=137&conference_id=273&stat=rushing&playoffs=0

This is not merely due to my DTs and NTs, but they play a big role. And I have had a very front loaded schedule so I have played most of the top of the league so far...the cupcake teams are at the end of my schedule (I think my opponents so far have a record of around 30-15 combined, if you subtract the losses I inflicted).

My 4 CBs lead my team in tackles of course (since many teams give up trying to rush on me, and because they get tackles on sweeps) but my 4 DTs are 6th, 8th, 9th, and 12th on the team in tackles.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/team_player_stats.pl?team_id=4392&stat=defense&playoffs=0

Consider that I rotate playing time evenly at every position, so I essentially have 22 starters.

73 tackles, 2 sacks, 7 hurries in 7 games from my 4 DTs combined against tough opponents (generally matched up against equal level offensive lines, maybe a 1 level advantage in some cases).

My whole team only has 387 tackles combined, so my DTs have accounted for almost 20%
of my tackles.

DTs work fine, Break Through works fine.

Edit:
Here is my level 16 (at the time) NT making a TFL on 3rd and inches against a level 16 HB, while triple teamed by a level 15 C, level 15 G, and a level 15 FB (all with high quality builds on a team that was undefeated until we met).

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=118286&pbp_id=3784377

(too bad they converted the 4th and short on the next play)

Last edited Aug 16, 2008 14:22:30
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
If break thru worked as you all are suggesting 90 strength NT's would be running through double teams 75% of the time and become unstoppable.

Then u all would complain break thru is too effective and no longer realistic.

You all are forgetting you are being fucking double teamed, you are not likely to break through a double team so why are you upset it's not working often?
 
CapnCrunch
offline
Link
 
Ok, so a double teamed guy shouldnt get through. then what is the point of having the SA break thru? its one or the other. either a double teamed guy shouldnt get through and break through is pointless or break thru doesnt work. it cant be both. The point isnt that he should break through all the time or even most of the time, but to go 7 games and never break through... Nobody is saying that they should get through 75% is silly. stop exagerating the argument so it sounds stupid. How about a 9 in break thru SA and 90 str would get through at least 10% of the time? Even at that low number, it still doesnt work. Im running out of ways to explain this.

How bout we look at it this way. A 9 in break thru gets through the same exact amount as a 0 in break thru. Maybe Im crazy but that says to me that break thru does not work.

Again, if the answer is agility, then that has nothing to do with the break thru SA.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 14:53:46
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CapnCrunch
Ok, so a double teamed guy shouldnt get through. then what is the point of having the SA break thru? its one or the other. either a double teamed guy shouldnt get through and break through is pointless or break thru doesnt work. it cant be both. The point isnt that he should break through all the time or even most of the time, but to go 7 games and never break through... Nobody is saying that they should get through 75% is silly. stop exagerating the argument so it sounds stupid. How about a 9 in break thru SA and 90 str would get through at least 10% of the time? Even at that low number, it still doesnt work. Im running out of ways to explain this.

How bout we look at it this way. A 9 in break thru gets through the same exact amount as a 0 in break thru. Maybe Im crazy but that says to me that break thru does not work.

Again, if the answer is agility, then that has nothing to do with the break thru SA.


You're saying:

- strength + SA Break Through should do the job. And the job is (at least) 10 % breaking through double teams.

But maybe it's strength + SA Break Through + X?

Maybe you missed something out?

A guy with your strength and that X might NOT break through a lot. But with SA Break Through he'd do it quite a lot. That's a reasonable solution too, isn't it? So you can't be sure to have a bug there.

(just a guess, for I don't run DTs myself - but mostly a SA not triggering is because of something missing)

 
Barnsie
offline
Link
 
A friend of mine's NT has 86 str and 62 agility with 7 in break through. I've been watching him and talking to him for quite some time because I'm interested in perhaps investing in break through as well. I can tell you that I don't think I've ever seen it work. If it did, I forget the 1 or 2 times EVER that it has.

Personally, I'd accept the logic that you can't break double teams ever. As such, never invest in this SA because it is a waste.
 
arteryman
offline
Link
 
I'm surprised and slightly disappointed that bort has not come in again to say something on the matter. It's been argued (and slightly proven) for 3 pages that the Break Thru SA has had no effect on players. We can't do anything else as players except raise the issue on this forum.
 
CapnCrunch
offline
Link
 
he did quote someone saying that the dt wont break a double team, which once again goes back to why is there the break thru SA. thats like having the first step skill and it doesnt do anything. I appreciate that the guy is busy but I would think that 2 minutes to give some answer or thought to something as critical as SA's shouldnt be out of the question.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.