User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HurricaneBear
Originally posted by Bort

Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.

If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.

Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.


I think the biggest problem is a lack of knowledge by the player base on what anything actually does. We have to guess from looking at 2d Dots, which is VERY hard to do, and in addition plan for tweaks/changes that may or may not come.

I agree the problems need to be fixed and you can't have a broken sim, but I know for alot of the people i've talked to/been on teams with, all this guessing is just getting ridiculous. It's almost like a full time job trying to keep up with a random post here or there to figure out what you need to do, and there is a simple fix, have an official guide made(by Bort or other admins) that is much more descriptive than the one we have now, and we'd be sure it is correct since it's from the creator.

This is one of the few games i've played where the creators don't have any guide/manual to go along with it and having one could end alot of the guessing and confusion imo.


I think guessing is part of the fun, there shouldn't be more than a BASIC guide to the game, basically what there is now, everyone has to remember this is a SPORT MMORG, and ANYTHING can happen in sport, so to say, I want to know EXACTLY what A, B, and C do, takes away from the game itself imo.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Johnny_Johnson
Look, it's this simple. All I want is Build versus Build when it comes to DBs and Receivers.

I don't want any 5 yard cushion BS or delayed reaction times. My CBs build is good enough to cover most of the receivers in this game regardless of the speed nerf. I just want a fair shake against guys I match up against or outmatch!


The very best corners in football will get beaten at times when matched up against top WR's.

That's why you don't see that tight of coverage most of the time in real life, that's why you rarely see a pure 0-man used in real life (and if it is, there's usually a cushion), and that's why zones get used plenty in real life.

If you want a CB who can play everyone close and never get burned by anyone, you won't and shouldn't succeed in getting one.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
A. Bort has a test server that he uses, he pulls players and teams from the game, and uses them in the test server and sees the results there.


Whatever his current process is, it's failing his paying customers miserably.


Originally posted by sjmay
B. Exhorbitant amount? $200 for a team? Possibly, maybe if you had more than a dozen owners the price per owner would drop, but again, these are PERSONAL choices, not mandated by anyone except the owner of the player. I GM a team, and guys boost, guys don't, doesn't make us any less competitive than other teams.


I could have 50 agents, that would just make it cost more to boost the roster. I'm not complaining about the cost in a vacuum. I'm complaining about the cost, when the product is in an alpha state and we are more or less unit testing changes.

There are ways to get us to pay for the product, to get the product tested properly, and to stabilize things so that people don't have to deal with some of the crazy bugs that they are seeing on routine plays.


Originally posted by sjmay
C. Can't comment about your LB situation except to say that the LB dropping into zone has been fixed, so if it is still happening to you, it is either A. your defensive AI, or B. your linebackers playing for the pass bonus, and or not having solid builds, but I dont know that, as A. I can't see your defensive AI, and I can't see your builds.


Luckily I don't have any of those disadvantages, and I'm not an idiot. The bug was still present in our last game. Perhaps it won't be in our game tonight. You'll have to trust me on that.


Originally posted by sjmay
D. If your WR are fine, why are you complaining about speed being nerfed, unless it is other WR on your team that didn't believe speed was being nerfed.


I wasn't complaining about speed being nerfed. I was lodging a general complaint with regard to forcing the general population to be exposed to woefully undertested code, while paying large sums of money for the privelage.

The problem is easily solved by ACTUALLY testing the code outside of the general population. Not by Bort taking some data and running sims and looking it over. That plan clearly stinks. Setup a test server with a test league or two, and keep it isolated from the public servers. Let testers hammer away at the code while Bort works out fixes (and tests them there). When all is in working order - THEN you push it to the public servers full of paying customers.

You have to separate the population into BETA testers - who do actual BETA testing, and paying customers. Which is what most of us are at the moment. People are playing this game, not testing it. They aren't the same thing.
 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Revelation
Originally posted by Signalsgt

Lets see:

1. This game runs me MAYBE 20 bucks a month.
2. I can play from work
3. Takes me 15 minutes to do. (Unless I'm being a forum rat)
4. Bugs are identified and addressed.
5. Code is being changed in a logical manner with good intent to improve the game.
6. Its entertaining brain candy.

I honestly pay more attention and have a higher vested interest in what the Cafe on the first floor of my building has as the daily special then GLB.

It's a game, there is no return on investment. Your paying money for the enjoyment. Talking trash about a sim'd football game is like proudly proclaiming you have an extra chromosome.

So in the immortal words Sgt. Hulka from Stripes "Lighten up Francis"


Heh, how are you supposed to lighten up when you're paying for enjoyment and are not enjoying the game?


You've paid for sex many times before and didn't complain, enjoyable or not.
 
Welsh76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DaRealest

You've paid for sex many times before and didn't complain, enjoyable or not.


How much were you charging him?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
RunningMn, if you don't want to play the game when it's still under development, then don't.

Retire your players (when you can, as they have contracts, I'm sure), keep your account, and check back in a year to see if it's out of Beta. Then use the FP's you got from retiring your players to start playing the non-Beta version.

If you want to play now, you have to put up with the Beta changes.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Running,

Tell me what the difference is of this.

Bort taking 40 different teams and running them through a test server when he makes changes,

And individuals playing on a seperate test server?

To me it is pretty much the same.

As far as your LB, I'm just telling you what A. has been posted about it, and B. what has happened in the last 8 games I am involved with.

As far as paying and getting what you pay for, if you are that unhappy with it, you do have the option of stopping, but realistically, things needed to be changed in regards to speed, and the running game, they were, those that didn't heed the warning, paid the price, not much more to say about that.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia

Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia


Originally posted by sjmay


Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia


Bottom line. If you don't like something, complain out the ass. It will get changed sooner or later as long as you have a valid point of what you're complaining about. If you just sit there and expect things to work themselves out, nothing will be done unless others are complaining about the same thing that troubles you.

My personal opinion is that too much is being changed at once. If builds are a problem, change those and get those worked out. If game settings are a problem, change those and get those worked out. Changing the both together is only making it harder to see what the real problems are.


Possibly, but it is also a catch 22 situation potentially, You change the builds, and something unforeseen happens, do you let it go and say, well I made enough changes etc?


If you work one out first, the other can be altered afterward to make it right. If you keep going back and forth, there's going to be constant tweaking. Obviously then, the game settings need to be fixed first. Builds are easier to tweak, so they can be tweaked after the game settings are done.

As an owner and GM, I just want things to get done ASAP. I think the route he's taking is prolonging it. I want to know what I need to build my team and players around to fit with the game. Right now, I might have a dominant team. But after the changes, my team could turn to mediocre at best.


I own and GM as well, and I am not sure what other route you think he could take, he tweaked the algoritms on the builds and added the new AI, certain bugs came up with the algorithms, ie, DEs not being effective, CBs mugging WR, etc, so he is taking those and tweaking those as they come up,

What other way do you suggest could be done?


Exactly. Do the AI first and get that done right. Then work on tweaking the builds afterward. It's much easier to tweak a build than do the AI.

The AI isn't even close to being done. All he's doing is adding more work if he's gonna have to tweak builds every time he makes a change to the AI.


I agree the AI isn't close to being done, a lot more can be added to it, but you are ignoring the fact that there were serious problems within the game that had nothing to do with the AI, running game wasn't working, speed was dominant, etc, those had to be fixed, with or without the new AI being introduced.


Anyone who says the running game wasn't working, obviously didn't build around it. Both my teams crippled teams with their run game. Actually, the running game has been cut down now. You can tell if you go to my leagues forums. The first thing everyone has said about both teams was our running game was almost unstoppable. And that was last season as well.

What that comes down to is people not really knowing how to build a team to an identity. Everyone seems to want a balanced team that is dominant in both aspects.

Speed was dominant, but none of my team went stupid with it. All of our players' agility is within 10 of the speed (with the exception of a few).

I think what the problem was had to do more with how people build than things needing "fixed". Whether it was players or teams.

Also, the new additions to D-linemen didn't need to be there. That was more of the majority not knowing what to do. My personal DE went from 2nd in the league in sacks (last season), to dominant in one game (6 sacks against a good team), to almost not producing at all. I think they were fine the way it was. First it went from being as it was, then to speed and agility, now to strength. This is within a week.

The same people who complain about builds will always be complaining. The ones that have been overcoming, will still overcome. It's a matter of watching the games yourself and adjusting to what works. Filling out and creating dominant teams is already tough enough if you're in SE Asia or have a team named the Pittsburgh Steel, with the constant changes, it makes it that much harder to keep a core of players because your gameplan is going to continually change until the game is worked out. That's my beef. Every season it seems as if I'm starting fresh all over again. I want continuity in my teams and my teams identity.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
RunningMn, if you don't want to play the game when it's still under development, then don't.

Retire your players (when you can, as they have contracts, I'm sure), keep your account, and check back in a year to see if it's out of Beta. Then use the FP's you got from retiring your players to start playing the non-Beta version.

If you want to play now, you have to put up with the Beta changes.


I only have to put up with this BS as long as Bort wants to continue spinning his wheels. There are reasons why no other game company would ever approach making a game like this. I'm offering specific ways to solve these fundamental problems with how Bort is going about getting this game tested.

Is it really not coming across how EASY it is to correct this on Bort's end? Test servers that work out the kinks in new code, public servers that play the latest stable build of the code, with occasional updates of well-tested code. This isn't rocket science. It's how the rest of the world develops MMOs.
 
RunningMn9
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Bort taking 40 different teams and running them through a test server when he makes changes,


The difference is that Bort taking 40 different teams and running them through a test server hasn't done jack shit to shake out bugs in the sim, has it? It's acceptable for a programmer to unit test his code - you NEVER, EVER have a programmer function/system test his own code unless it's an absolute necessity.

You need other fingers and eyes in there looking for things that you wouldn't think of. The difference between letting testers do it, and letting the general population do it is that testers can test at a higher frequency. Run two games a day instead of a game every two days. Run a season a day. Have testers that look through and watch the PBP of every game that is simmed on the test server. People that know how to find and characterize bugs in more detailed ways than "I DIDN'T WIN, THE SIM MUST BE BUGGED!!".

I don't know whether or not you do this for a living, but I do. The current methodology doesn't work in theory - and it certainly isn't working in practice as HUGE and obvious bugs routinely escape whatever initial testing Bort is doing.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
SteelCity,

The DE came about because of the offensive line code was put in and it made every DE useless as they ran straight into the Oline, that was changed with the ability to dictate what kind of pass rush you want to use.

Speed was too dominant, mainly in WR. As far as the running game working, it was a combination of things that made it non workable last year, wrap up tackling being way too powerful, and having no outside running game for any team mainly, the two things that changed that was tackling made more realistic, and now the Oline pulls a bit more which opened up the running game more to the outside.

The same people who complain are always gonna complain, some legit, some not.

As far as continuity goes, I guess that might be slightly your fault, as we in Stockholm have had the same team pretty much from the word go, you will always get 2-3 guys who leave, we had 4 go to their own team etc, but we have been pretty much a continuous unit, with the odd exception, and you recruit on builds, and fill the holes you have with the builds you want, not saying that isn't what you did, but if you look at things being realistic, it is a much better sim now than it was in season 3.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RunningMn9
Originally posted by sjmay

Bort taking 40 different teams and running them through a test server when he makes changes,


The difference is that Bort taking 40 different teams and running them through a test server hasn't done jack shit to shake out bugs in the sim, has it? It's acceptable for a programmer to unit test his code - you NEVER, EVER have a programmer function/system test his own code unless it's an absolute necessity.

You need other fingers and eyes in there looking for things that you wouldn't think of. The difference between letting testers do it, and letting the general population do it is that testers can test at a higher frequency. Run two games a day instead of a game every two days. Run a season a day. Have testers that look through and watch the PBP of every game that is simmed on the test server. People that know how to find and characterize bugs in more detailed ways than "I DIDN'T WIN, THE SIM MUST BE BUGGED!!".

I don't know whether or not you do this for a living, but I do. The current methodology doesn't work in theory - and it certainly isn't working in practice as HUGE and obvious bugs routinely escape whatever initial testing Bort is doing.


I don't hence the reason I asked.

But, without seeing the actual code to the game, how would you know what an obvious bug is? I am assuming you are talking at looking at the code, and not a "replay" of the game itself as that is easy, ie, players running the wrong way etc.
 
wombat killer
offline
Link
 
I didn't read the whole thread, but if they hadn't made these changes I know a lot of people who would have definitely stopped playing this game.
 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Welsh76
Originally posted by DaRealest


You've paid for sex many times before and didn't complain, enjoyable or not.


How much were you charging him?


US$125...to have the neighbor's dog lick his balls and US$75 to have the cat nibble on his ear.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelCity Mafia


Anyone who says the running game wasn't working, obviously didn't build around it.



Sorry, but it was well documented (and acknowledged by Bort) that the running game didn't work at all when TWO "roughly similar" teams faced each other in the higher leagues. The overall running numbers masked the problem by containing stats from blowout wins against inferior opponents. In the REAL game of football, just because two teams are "roughly similar" doesn't result in game after game of 1 or 2 yards per carry (like last season's sims did when two quality opponents in the higher leagues faced each other).

Last edited Aug 7, 2008 16:14:23
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.