User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This is clearly an exploit and should be addressed ASAP
Page:
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Jose Bagg


Drifter, there were ways to get your #1 WR into the slot without sacrificing him on starting plays. The new WR slots, just made it easy so that every coach could do it without having to think outside the box and be clever about it.

The new system works very well, I like it, everyone else likes it, you don't like it. My advice would be to figure out a way to counter their strategy and use their "exploit" against them. It really isn't that hard to put your best CB on the slot, and it really isn't that hard to punish a team that does put their best CB on the slot.


As discussed ad nauseum (please read the whole thread), you switch it up and they just switch it back. Whoever switches last, wins. That's ridiculous.


No sir, you are wrong. That is not what I was talking about. There are 'other' ways. I am sure I am not the only one who uses them either.

I see this in other games that I play. In Dagorhir, when a rule gets changed, there are always people who whine and bitch about it from one side or the other. But my friend Ori says you just have to adapt and get better. The rules are the rules, and complaining about them doesn't make you a better player.



As I just pointed out, Bort himself has been in here and said that this was not how he intended it to be used and that it was exacerbating the very situation he was trying to correct in the first place. So many people in here seem to think that flawed game mechanics should be tolerated just because they exist isntead of trying to make the game better and more balanced. I don't understand that thinking at all.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Well, I would say he is wrong for the first time ever. He may not have intended it to be used that way, but I myself, and several other coaches I spoke to were excited about the new WR slots for this very reason. I am pretty sure that most people on GLB thought to put their best guy in the slot long before we even had the slot to put him in. This is a good thing, it give the team owners more control over the outcome of a game and more opportunities for gamesmanship and strategy. I sincerely hope that Bort leave it the way it is and allows the good owners to adapt and rise above those that aren't so good. I think anything that helps overcome a level difference is a good thing.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Well, I would say he is wrong for the first time ever. He may not have intended it to be used that way, but I myself, and several other coaches I spoke to were excited about the new WR slots for this very reason. I am pretty sure that most people on GLB thought to put their best guy in the slot long before we even had the slot to put him in. This is a good thing, it give the team owners more control over the outcome of a game and more opportunities for gamesmanship and strategy. I sincerely hope that Bort leave it the way it is and allows the good owners to adapt and rise above those that aren't so good. I think anything that helps overcome a level difference is a good thing.



You should be able to put your best guy in the slot. I agree - however the other team should be able to react to that in a dynamic manner and not in a way where the last team to make a change to the depth chart gets the matchup they want.

Once again, as has been pointed out multiple times in the thread, just because a WR lines up in a different place doesn't make the other team suddenly wonder where he went.

To flip your argument, if your #1 Wr can't get open against the other #1 CB then perhaps you've built him badly?
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 16:53:18
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
I see bort talking about ways to implement a Defenders choose coverage mechanism. But that's a far cry from him saying it is an exploit. Calling something an exploit is saying that people who currently use this mechanism are CHEATING.

What you are proposing, and Bort seems to be considering, is a way to change the current mechanisms to better approximate your own view of how the game should be. Bort may even have intended the CB#1..5 to help allow defenders to choose the covering matchups - but I have not seen that written anywhere even though this issue has been discussed since well before the WR1..5 and CB1..5 were announced.

 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
I see bort talking about ways to implement a Defenders choose coverage mechanism. But that's a far cry from him saying it is an exploit. Calling something an exploit is saying that people who currently use this mechanism are CHEATING.

What you are proposing, and Bort seems to be considering, is a way to change the current mechanisms to better approximate your own view of how the game should be. Bort may even have intended the CB#1..5 to help allow defenders to choose the covering matchups - but I have not seen that written anywhere even though this issue has been discussed since well before the WR1..5 and CB1..5 were announced.




Using an exploit isn't cheating. It's using an exploit to gain an advantage and that effects game balance. Game balance is THE single most important aspect of any game.

As for your comment about what Bort intended and him not having stated that, you might want to read his comments in this thread:

Originally posted by

It really just sounds like a job for CB -> WR matchup priorities. Of course that wouldn't apply to zone defenses -- only man-to-man -- but it would probably help.

The new DC 1/2/3 positions were supposed to help in this regard but I think they have caused more problems than they have solved really, which is too bad.

 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Jose Bagg

Well, I would say he is wrong for the first time ever. He may not have intended it to be used that way, but I myself, and several other coaches I spoke to were excited about the new WR slots for this very reason. I am pretty sure that most people on GLB thought to put their best guy in the slot long before we even had the slot to put him in. This is a good thing, it give the team owners more control over the outcome of a game and more opportunities for gamesmanship and strategy. I sincerely hope that Bort leave it the way it is and allows the good owners to adapt and rise above those that aren't so good. I think anything that helps overcome a level difference is a good thing.



You should be able to put your best guy in the slot. I agree - however the other team should be able to react to that in a dynamic manner and not in a way where the last team to make a change to the depth chart gets the matchup they want.

Once again, as has been pointed out multiple times in the thread, just because a WR lines up in a different place doesn't make the other team suddenly wonder where he went.

To flip your argument, if your #1 Wr can't get open against the other #1 CB then perhaps you've built him badly?


I agree with the idea that a defense should be able to assign coverages to top threat WRs. I think that is a good thing. But I also like being able to line my WR up where I want them. But here again we will have clever coaches getting mismatches. There is a whole other level of deviousness in game planning and preparation that I have not yet seen discussed on the boards.
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 16:59:41
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Jose Bagg


Well, I would say he is wrong for the first time ever. He may not have intended it to be used that way, but I myself, and several other coaches I spoke to were excited about the new WR slots for this very reason. I am pretty sure that most people on GLB thought to put their best guy in the slot long before we even had the slot to put him in. This is a good thing, it give the team owners more control over the outcome of a game and more opportunities for gamesmanship and strategy. I sincerely hope that Bort leave it the way it is and allows the good owners to adapt and rise above those that aren't so good. I think anything that helps overcome a level difference is a good thing.



You should be able to put your best guy in the slot. I agree - however the other team should be able to react to that in a dynamic manner and not in a way where the last team to make a change to the depth chart gets the matchup they want.

Once again, as has been pointed out multiple times in the thread, just because a WR lines up in a different place doesn't make the other team suddenly wonder where he went.

To flip your argument, if your #1 Wr can't get open against the other #1 CB then perhaps you've built him badly?


I agree with the idea that a defense should be able to assign coverages to top threat CBs. I think that is a good thing. But I also like being able to line my WR up where I want them. But here again we will have clever coaches getting mismatches. There is a whole other level of deviousness in game planning and preparation that I have not yet seen discussed on the boards.



I'm not against being able to line up a WR anywhere provided we have a way to keep the coverages intact if we wish and the defensive alignment allows it.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
I still haven't seen you point to Bort calling it an exploit.

Nor do I believe that allowing the Defense to dictate matchups necessarily leads to better game balance, infact I think it doesn't matter as far as balance goes because both teams will use whatever mechanism exists.


Oh, and though Wikipedia isn't exactly the source for all knowledge - it's a pretty good place to get generally accepted information as it pertains to many different things... including what an EXPLOIT is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exploit_(online_gaming)
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 17:33:28
 
soulcougher73
offline
Link
 
Maybe they need to make it so you can pick the name of the reciever each CB is to cover and not the slot? Of course youd have to adjust this every game. But seems as easy fix.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 12:10:43
 
evilmonkey
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by soulcougher73
Maybe they need to make it so you can pick the name of the reciever each CB is to cover and not the slot? Of course youd have to adjust this every game. But seems as easy fix.


I agree with an approach like this...

And the real definition of the problem is:

Basically, other teams are "Sniping" like on ebay... they adjust their DC in their browser the way they want it, then wait until 60 seconds prior to when it is locked and click update... that's a pile of shit and it needs to be fixed before this game can be anything but a beta.

It may be a pain in the butt for the devs, but coaches need to be able to create a a prioritized list of WRs that each corner should cover BY NAME for each game. i.e.

CB: Jack Schmack || Coverage Scheme, in order of importance:
----------------------
WR: Joe Blah
WR: Jon Foo
WR: Ike Spikes


And Jack Schmack would cover Joe Blah if he was on the filed regardless of the other WRs on the field... No Joe Blah? If both Jon Foo and Ike Spikes are on the field, he covers Jon Foo (higher than spikes).

Then all you have to do is fill out the coverage assignments for each CB prior to the game, and you're done..

 
TreMetal
offline
Link
 
Doing it that way sucks, because if Jack Schmack is not on the field.. then Joe Schmack has to cover him..

So your list would be like this:

CB1
----
WR: Joe Blah
WR: Jon Foo
WR: Ike Spikes

CB2
----
WR: Joe Blah
WR: Jon Foo
WR: Ike Spikes

CB3
----
WR: Joe Blah
WR: Jon Foo
WR: Ike Spikes

You really just want
My team:
CB1
CB2
CB3

Their team:
WR1
WR2
WR3

Your highest guy on the field guards their highest guy on the field on the list.

It might be suggested that you can have 4 lists: their speedsters, your speedsters, their posession, your lockdown. (Or however you want to label them).
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
What the whole "matchup" thing will lead to are people who just play players out of position.. then the player isn't listed as a match.. or is listed as a match for the wrong position.. which can just as easily lead to mismatches once teams figure out how to "game the system". Not that it matters, because both teams are going to have the same opportunities to do this available.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
So many people in here seem to think that flawed game mechanics should be tolerated just because they exist isntead of trying to make the game better and more balanced. I don't understand that thinking at all.



+ 1 Gazillion.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 17:00:14
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi


Nor do I believe that allowing the Defense to dictate matchups necessarily leads to better game balance...



But that's the way the REAL game of football is played. When Marvin Harrison breaks the huddle, IF Denver wants Champ Bailey to cover him, Champ Bailey is going to find Harrison and attempt to cover him regardless of where the Colts direct Harrison to lineup.
 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
The fix is simple. Lock the Off. DC 30 min before gametime, that way, owners have time to adjust (if you aren't able to be there, then have GMs). Give warning on the DC page (ex. "DCs will be locked in 15 min") and then lock them so teams have enough time to adjust.

Not particularly fair to the offense, but it's not really easy to exploit either. There isn't a lot the Def. can do once the offense is locked except match the best CBs up to the best WRs and switch the DEs around, neither of which would seem to be a big issue.


The depth chart are locked at a certain point before the games are simmed.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.