User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > The solution!! For retiring players, teams playing 100+ plays per player/penalizing depth, and rewarding team with good defenses/quick scoring offenses
Page:
 
jearly
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
It would also be easy enough to curtail abuse by giving players "20 plays" towards their eventual decline in every game, regardless of whether they play or not.

This would prevent someone from creating a player, burying them on a team for 5 years while they boost and gain EXP and then starting their career at about level 17-19 and getting 10 solid years. You can still do that but every year they are accumulating 320 plays, so after 5 years, they may start their career at level 17-19 but they do have the equivalent of 1600 plays under their belt. This combined with the "or 15 years" limit would keep people from totally taking advantage. Sure, there's still some advantage but it's not a gigantic one.


to your point, the idea has evolved to have it the age/wear and tear factors work in conjunction with eachother - it. the only way you get 15 years is if you've never played a down in your entire career. there would be some magic number that once a combo of plays and season equals, you stop progressing...
 
AydenHuhn
offline
Link
 
I think th admins should definetly consider this. It makes too much sense not too. The more you play, the shorter your career. The less you play the longer. Can we get this done before my guys reach level 10?...lol
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jearly
Originally posted by drifter

It would also be easy enough to curtail abuse by giving players "20 plays" towards their eventual decline in every game, regardless of whether they play or not.

This would prevent someone from creating a player, burying them on a team for 5 years while they boost and gain EXP and then starting their career at about level 17-19 and getting 10 solid years. You can still do that but every year they are accumulating 320 plays, so after 5 years, they may start their career at level 17-19 but they do have the equivalent of 1600 plays under their belt. This combined with the "or 15 years" limit would keep people from totally taking advantage. Sure, there's still some advantage but it's not a gigantic one.


to your point, the idea has evolved to have it the age/wear and tear factors work in conjunction with eachother - it. the only way you get 15 years is if you've never played a down in your entire career. there would be some magic number that once a combo of plays and season equals, you stop progressing...


I understand that but I think you will still have a contingent of people who will create a player with the intention of never having them play a single play until their 6th year. Along with boosting and daily XP gains, this will put them in the level 17-19 range by my calculations. Adding an element where they are still getting some wear and tear (20 plays per game regardless) you mitigate that tactic a little bit. It's still a valid tactic but not as unbalancing as it potentially could be.
 
jrweeks1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by jearly

Originally posted by drifter


It would also be easy enough to curtail abuse by giving players "20 plays" towards their eventual decline in every game, regardless of whether they play or not.

This would prevent someone from creating a player, burying them on a team for 5 years while they boost and gain EXP and then starting their career at about level 17-19 and getting 10 solid years. You can still do that but every year they are accumulating 320 plays, so after 5 years, they may start their career at level 17-19 but they do have the equivalent of 1600 plays under their belt. This combined with the "or 15 years" limit would keep people from totally taking advantage. Sure, there's still some advantage but it's not a gigantic one.


I think these are valid points. My question is with salary caps in place, trying to fill seats at the stadium and trying to win so your team can move up in class how does an owner justify carrying dead weight for 5 or 6 seasons just to level a player?

to your point, the idea has evolved to have it the age/wear and tear factors work in conjunction with eachother - it. the only way you get 15 years is if you've never played a down in your entire career. there would be some magic number that once a combo of plays and season equals, you stop progressing...


I understand that but I think you will still have a contingent of people who will create a player with the intention of never having them play a single play until their 6th year. Along with boosting and daily XP gains, this will put them in the level 17-19 range by my calculations. Adding an element where they are still getting some wear and tear (20 plays per game regardless) you mitigate that tactic a little bit. It's still a valid tactic but not as unbalancing as it potentially could be.


 
TRIONIC
offline
Link
 
Kickers would have century-long careers.
 
jrweeks1
offline
Link
 
I guess there are only so many threads you can put in a post, so here was my reply above.

These are all valid points, but how does a owner justify carrying a player for all these seasons just to skill up when he still has to fall within salary cap, fill seats and try to move up to the next class by getting wins?
 
Cybershot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrweeks1
I guess there are only so many threads you can put in a post, so here was my reply above.

These are all valid points, but how does a owner justify carrying a player for all these seasons just to skill up when he still has to fall within salary cap, fill seats and try to move up to the next class by getting wins?


I don't think a player or owner would have the patience to go through with sitting for 6 seasons (240 days!) to have a small advantage.
 
StevieTheD
offline
Link
 
I disagree with a set number of plays. I think they intensity of training you do should have an impact as well as a "durability" rating.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cybershot
Originally posted by jrweeks1

I guess there are only so many threads you can put in a post, so here was my reply above.

These are all valid points, but how does a owner justify carrying a player for all these seasons just to skill up when he still has to fall within salary cap, fill seats and try to move up to the next class by getting wins?


I don't think a player or owner would have the patience to go through with sitting for 6 seasons (240 days!) to have a small advantage.



Are you kidding? There's guys out there with 20 players! Keeping a few of them on the bench for 5 seasons wouldn't be that big a deal and the 17-19 level head start would be gigantic. All the best players at the highest levels would eventually be players who took this tactic. I'd create at least 1/3 of my "stable" with this in mind, knowing that eventually they were going to be the best players in the game by FAR.

I'm already intending to start a new batch of players about every 4 or 5 seasons so that when retirement does come, I'm not stuck starting over with level 4 players. If this becomes an option, I wouldn't even wait, I'd start those players now and put them on the bench.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 12:04:37
 
AF_Medic30
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Cybershot

Originally posted by jrweeks1


I guess there are only so many threads you can put in a post, so here was my reply above.

These are all valid points, but how does a owner justify carrying a player for all these seasons just to skill up when he still has to fall within salary cap, fill seats and try to move up to the next class by getting wins?


I don't think a player or owner would have the patience to go through with sitting for 6 seasons (240 days!) to have a small advantage.



Are you kidding? There's guys out there with 20 players! Keeping a few of them on the bench for 5 seasons wouldn't be that big a deal and the 17-19 level head start would be gigantic. All the best players at the highest levels would eventually be players who took this tactic. I'd create at least 1/3 of my "stable" with this in mind, knowing that eventually they were going to be the best players in the game by FAR.

I'm already intending to start a new batch of players about every 4 or 5 seasons so that when retirement does come, I'm not stuck starting over with level 4 players. If this becomes an option, I wouldn't even wait, I'd start those players now and put them on the bench.


maybe I'm dumb, but the way I understood the OP then you would gain less EXP sitting on the bench for 5 seasons then you would receive for being a backup but playing for 5 seasons.

So if you created a player now and sat them on the bench for say 5 seasons and he was a 17-19 lvl player when you finally started him

And I created a player now and he was a playing backup, then mine would be say a 22-23 lvl player 5 seasons from now with stats towards a hoF

Maybe I read the OP wrong, but thats how I read it. So theres no real advantage to sitting your player on the bench
 
saiyun
offline
Link
 
awesome, punter and kicker will last to infinity...
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AF_Medic30
Originally posted by drifter

Originally posted by Cybershot


Originally posted by jrweeks1



I guess there are only so many threads you can put in a post, so here was my reply above.

These are all valid points, but how does a owner justify carrying a player for all these seasons just to skill up when he still has to fall within salary cap, fill seats and try to move up to the next class by getting wins?


I don't think a player or owner would have the patience to go through with sitting for 6 seasons (240 days!) to have a small advantage.



Are you kidding? There's guys out there with 20 players! Keeping a few of them on the bench for 5 seasons wouldn't be that big a deal and the 17-19 level head start would be gigantic. All the best players at the highest levels would eventually be players who took this tactic. I'd create at least 1/3 of my "stable" with this in mind, knowing that eventually they were going to be the best players in the game by FAR.

I'm already intending to start a new batch of players about every 4 or 5 seasons so that when retirement does come, I'm not stuck starting over with level 4 players. If this becomes an option, I wouldn't even wait, I'd start those players now and put them on the bench.


maybe I'm dumb, but the way I understood the OP then you would gain less EXP sitting on the bench for 5 seasons then you would receive for being a backup but playing for 5 seasons.

So if you created a player now and sat them on the bench for say 5 seasons and he was a 17-19 lvl player when you finally started him

And I created a player now and he was a playing backup, then mine would be say a 22-23 lvl player 5 seasons from now with stats towards a hoF

Maybe I read the OP wrong, but thats how I read it. So theres no real advantage to sitting your player on the bench


You can boost 3 levels every season. That alone over the course of 5 seasons is 15 levels before you even start playing plays. In addition you get daily experience without even playing - hence the extra 2-4 levels.

When that player in his 6th year starts playing towards his 10,000 career plays he is starting at level 17-19. That's a 13-15 level head start over the character who started playing right away. By the time the player that sat is in his 10th "real" (9000 or so plays) season he will have a dozen levels on every one else who started right away.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 12:40:14
 
Jim Force
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter

You can boost 3 levels every season. That alone over the course of 5 seasons is 15 levels before you even start playing plays. In addition you get daily experience without even playing - hence the extra 2-4 levels.

When that player in his 6th year starts playing towards his 10,000 career plays he is starting at level 17-19. That's a 13-15 level head start over the character who started playing right away. By the time the player that sat is in his 10th "real" (9000 or so plays) season he will have a dozen levels on every one else who started right away.


Then maybe there needs to be a rule that once a player is created he can not boost until he is on a team and once he is on a team he will be be charged plays toward his play total even if he doesn't hit the field just to help offset this "cheat" to some degree. It would also be somewhat realistic as it could account for wear and tear from practice.

In the end there is always going to be a loophole for cheaters and people that will do anything to win, we just need to make it a pain in the backside for people to use the loophole!
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter

You can boost 3 levels every season. That alone over the course of 5 seasons is 15 levels before you even start playing plays. In addition you get daily experience without even playing - hence the extra 2-4 levels.



It would actually be more than that. A person doing it would wait until the end of each season to boost. In the first year they would progress just under 4 levels and boost 3. Then progress about 6 more levels over the next 4 and boost 12 more. The player would probably be level 25 when he started playing. Plus, it would be a player for someone who owns a team, so he would have had the cash for 5 straight seasons of intense training.

An owner with 20 - 30 players and one or more teams would definately do that with a couple of his players to unleash that type of monster with a full career left.
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter

You can boost 3 levels every season. That alone over the course of 5 seasons is 15 levels before you even start playing plays. In addition you get daily experience without even playing - hence the extra 2-4 levels.

When that player in his 6th year starts playing towards his 10,000 career plays he is starting at level 17-19. That's a 13-15 level head start over the character who started playing right away. By the time the player that sat is in his 10th "real" (9000 or so plays) season he will have a dozen levels on every one else who started right away.

Is it that much of an advantage, though, when you consider other factors? The player is going to be sitting in free agency for a long time, or else counting against some teams salary cap. Training costs money - if the player isn't earning a salary from somewhere, they're going to run out of training money pretty fast. Then there is the factor of boosting - you have to pay to boost - only some real die-hard dedicated players are going to pay that money every season to boost a player that isn't playing, just for an advantage.

Personally, when combined with an age limit into some sort of algorithm, I don't see any advantage that is gained as being worth it for most people, and for those that will do it - well, they're paying to support the game, which is good for all of us in the long run.

That being said, I think you could very simply and easily prevent it from being abused too blatantly by implementing a number of different options. Your suggestion is one, others ideas are:
- restriction to boosting #1 - once you've boosted your 3 levels for a season, you can't boost on the next season unless/until you've actually played some set number of plays.
- restriction to boosting #2 - you can't boost past your first time unless you are actually signed to a team
- inactivity penalties - if you go more than a season or two without any plays, you stop gaining XP, possibly even start losing it.
- stat restrictions/modifiers (as a different take on aging) - take certain abilities, and affect them. EX#1: Confidence - put a penalty on a players confidence for every level gained with no plays. Reduce that penalty by one for every game they play once they start playing. Sure, you can train a lot, but until you actually play in games, you're going to suffer some confidence issues until you're comfortable. EX#2: Vision - since people's vision naturally declines after a while, build it into the game - say 10 seasons after a player is created, it declines - exponentially, say 1 pt in Season 10, 2 points in Season 11, 4 points in Season 12, 8 points in Season 13, 16 in Season 14, etc. It would affect all players, but it would affect those bench sitters even more. Actually, you could apply that to a lot of the various stats.

None of those ideas is perfect, and the system could still be gamed - but what it comes down to is - is it worth it? I maintain that, if well implemented, those people who do spend the time and effort to game the system are probably contributing more financially than those who aren't, and as long as their advantage takes time to pay off, who cares? Plus, there will always be those who spend the money to take advantage of it, but then lose interest in the game, and never come back to the site, or will give up on waiting, and lose the advantage anyway.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.