User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Passing needs to be fixed in this game, very long post with a ton of research, don't discard as another whine post
Page:
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
rbdgood, your joking right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!, i just watched 2 of your td's from the first half and the d was all screwed up on both td's

no db was even defending your wr

without going throuh every play show me where u had a decent catch over 15 yards where the db was playing tight coverage not in a zone or medium
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 00:22:38
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigmo6967
My wr's had no problem in the sim because I was never one to build or get guys who were all flash and no bang. hell one of my leading recievers from the last sim actually has more in catching than speed imagine that.



again bad defense, + and this is important to the argument,im talking about tight coverage , that team u were playing was not playing your wr's tight


hell the first td was a db blitz

 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
I think what happened was the speed nerf slowed the game down, but Bort probably didn't change any of the algorithms that affected reaction time by DB's. So while the speed nerf slowed the game down say 25%, the CB's are breaking on the ball as fast as they used to. He also mentioned that he was going to put press coverage in this season as another way to make sure people weren't ignoring certain attributes like strength for CB's and WR's. Not sure if that happened, but it does appear that CB's are suddenly all over WR's before the ball gets there even if the WR has inside positioning. Last season the WR made those catches and the CB made an immediate tackle. This season there are a lot more drops and deflections.

The changes this offseason weren't minor like advertised. They were major changes to the game mechanics that have been more drastic than anything I've seen since I started in season 1.


Overall they're great changes, though. Even passing is not worse. I wish last season's passing stats were available so I could show you just how bad it was last year.

I'm a bit worried that because rushing works like real life now and passing doesn't, we'll see too much smashmouth. But defenses will react to that as well, opening up some passing opportunities-- and really, even if it's smashmouth that's much better than nearly no offense at all as we had in season 3.
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
Ok so the Td's were mistakes but did you watch the entire scrimmage i mean there are more plays than just 2 td's there. When you make a mistakes of course the good players will make you pay. I am talking about the entire sim were regardless to say a defense did line up and cover my recievers. It was more realistic but my recievers were better prepared build wise to play against physical coverage and only 4 drops I will take that any day.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigmo6967
My wr's had no problem in the sim because I was never one to build or get guys who were all flash and no bang. hell one of my leading recievers from the last sim actually has more in catching than speed imagine that.


I have one like that (not counting my TE's who are also that way). Caught a TD pass last game.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TDmaker99
rbdgood, your joking right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!, i just watched 2 of your td's from the first half and the d was all screwed up on both td's

no db was even defending your wr

without going throuh every play show me where u had a decent catch over 15 yards where the db wa ot playing tight coverage


Here is one our opponent had http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81705&pbp_id=258902

and another http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81705&pbp_id=260692

and another http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81705&pbp_id=260800

...as for ours, most of the 40+ yard plays were over aggressive blitzes, etc., and a few of the 10+ yarders were loose coverage. However our corners were on tight coverage all day and we did limited blitzing, so the ones they had were pretty much the types of plays everyone is stating can't happen anymore.
 
TDmaker99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by TDmaker99

Originally posted by dpell


I think the speed nerf was needed. 80spd/20agl isn't realistic but it was becoming the preferred build for WR's because it worked.

The problem I'm seeing is that DB's are reacting very quickly to the ball compared to the speed of the rest of the game and making lots and lots of illegal contact that doesn't result in a penalty. If Bort put in PI we'd be seeing 5-10 PI penalties a game against the defense and completion percentages would go back up into the expected range.


well 80 \20 is a bit much but i think the problem is that the nerf crapped everyone's build right, not just builds like the one u mentioned, the team i own and the others i gm have speed and agility within 15-20 points of one another, so instead of just going after the extreme builds like the 80\20 ( which i think if someone wants to build is fine, its their build their money ) it hurt all wr builds

if we got the PI you want all we'd see are more penalties which no one wants , 75 of the plays would be penalties on tight man coverage lol seriously how would more penalties give us higher comp % the wr'sstill have no accel and the db's are stil going to play tight coverage , what changes ?



Look, you obviously just have a fast guy who doesn't do other things well and you don't like that track stars can't play football anymore when they're built for the wrong sport.

That's not in the spirit of this discussion.


i give up, my agrument has nothing to do with being fast or slow, it affects all wr builds the same, my player could have whatever a perfect build for the way passing is set up now when a db plays tight coverage, the guys that are giving examples of how their wr's played well must not know what tight coverage looks like

this is tight coverage
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78340&pbp_id=489850

i guess we'll have to agree to disagree

-TD

 
Link
 
So you insult other players on here by saying they don't know what tight coverage is? I'm sure most if not all of them do know what that type of coverage is and looks like. Also, how do you know there are tons of PI penalties not being called, what 5-10 a game right? The little blue and yellow dots tell you that? You can't go based off the dots for one, they aren't a real representation of where everything is or postioned in the game.
Two, their sizes are very disproportionate to others. Think about it. According the PbP, your WR are the same size as the OL. We all know this is false. If you see a dot go through your dot wr then maybe he actually went by the Wr instead since we know the WR isn't really that round.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by TDmaker99

rbdgood, your joking right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!, i just watched 2 of your td's from the first half and the d was all screwed up on both td's

no db was even defending your wr

without going throuh every play show me where u had a decent catch over 15 yards where the db wa ot playing tight coverage


Here is one our opponent had http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81705&pbp_id=258902

and another http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81705&pbp_id=260692

and another http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81705&pbp_id=260800

...as for ours, most of the 40+ yard plays were over aggressive blitzes, etc., and a few of the 10+ yarders were loose coverage. However our corners were on tight coverage all day and we did limited blitzing, so the ones they had were pretty much the types of plays everyone is stating can't happen anymore.


Check out my WR's first catch for the PFunk Allstars

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78730&pbp_id=470390
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
Originally posted by rbedgood

Originally posted by TDmaker99


rbdgood, your joking right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!, i just watched 2 of your td's from the first half and the d was all screwed up on both td's

no db was even defending your wr

without going throuh every play show me where u had a decent catch over 15 yards where the db wa ot playing tight coverage


Here is one our opponent had http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81705&pbp_id=258902

and another http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81705&pbp_id=260692

and another http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=81705&pbp_id=260800

...as for ours, most of the 40+ yard plays were over aggressive blitzes, etc., and a few of the 10+ yarders were loose coverage. However our corners were on tight coverage all day and we did limited blitzing, so the ones they had were pretty much the types of plays everyone is stating can't happen anymore.


Check out my WR's first catch for the PFunk Allstars

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=78730&pbp_id=470390
that's a good team, i had a FS and a C on there for a season before i brought them over to my friend's squad. good owners, and good gameplanners. does Blaynster still do the OC?
 
Link
 
Yep, he does. He's been going a good job to with the new AI he gets to work with. Two totally different gameplans so far and they worked excellent. Ohh, and he switched his accounts name to Carpy now but yea it's still Blaynster (Carpy)

I picked up the DC spot at the last 4 games last year.

You were there in season 2?

I remember your FS, genetically jacked.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 02:11:48
 
seven7
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Alex44

Originally posted by Bort


I wonder what the percentage of long/medium/short passes are. That would certainly make a difference as to how many yards you get through the air on average.


In theory if he upped the deep ball percentage that would lower the overall completion percentage making passing equally as worthless to him. No?


Maybe, or maybe the QB can make those passes and nobody's really tried because they're afraid it won't work. I wonder if maybe the average distance on all the plays needs to be bumped up a little so they are all about 1-2yds longer routes. Might make a big difference as to averages.


i like the idea bump them up bort
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Man I love all the whining. It can't possibly be an issue with the teams themselves. No, it must be the sim.

Yet I can play an opponent, do nothing but pass the ball EVEN on fourth down, and beat a playoff team from last season 14-6, and have only 4 drops among my 5 primary receivers.

Absolute comedy.
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
If I play a team of mostly CPU players and humans players that my guys outlevel by 18-10 levels and my starting QB only completes 50% of his passes, something is fishy. When I dig up stats from game after game showing that most QB's are completing around 50-60% of their passes everyone ignores it.

And Islander, you do realize that neither team in your sim completed 50% of their passes right? Nothing wrong there at all.
Last edited Aug 1, 2008 09:32:31
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I think I just found something that's really holding the passing game back - QB's really have no finesse. They just fire it in there at top velocity all the time. I'm testing an update where the QB recalculates a slower velocity throw for those short passes that frequently get fired right through a HB's hands or over the head of a receiver.

Maybe "throwing style" should be a new setting for QB's too? "Bullet" or "lofty?"
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.