User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > i personnely think the new sims are screwed up
Page:
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Cruzi


So what about this?
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=80255&pbp_id=10912

Turn shoulder, or does this QB just have a freaky strong stiff arm?


Could be either


That can't be good for morale.


You sure there's not a trigger of some sort that keeps QBs with porous pass pro from getting killed?
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Virtue76
Originally posted by voltageaav

Originally posted by Virtue76


Reading through all of these posts, obviously the AI hasn't been tested thoroughly. I thought that was what the post season was for, testing.

If this continues into the next round of games I think AI should be disabled, like last season and re-introduced for season 5.


No, post season is for deciding who wins the championship. This is the preseason and was made specifically to test this stuff out.


Ok, the bit between post season and pre-season. What do you call day 46, playoffs?


The offseason.
 
Virtue76
offline
Link
 
Hairsplitters
 
joceire
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Wow - that first game - it's not like either team is crap......you have to ask just what sort of 'testing' is done ...... ????

I'll wait and see what sort of results come back in my opening games, but I just hope this doesn't turn into yet another season of seemingly random tweaks and counter tweaks making most game planning kind of irrelevant.

Whine?? Maybe - but enough of this 'beta' game rubbish now - surely it's time this game started getting better, as oppose to just getting more complicated for the sake of it, whilst never being overly realistic???

Oh - whilst I'm whining, the forum is back to it's crappy, slow, almost unuseable self too!!



+1

Its getting annoying now
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Virtue76
Hairsplitters


Terminology-challenged.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
So let's break it down to a simple analysis:

1.
WR's not targets - fixed by Bort immediatly

2.
unusual high sacks - if no targets are on the play, the QB will wait till he's sacked; so that's fixed by fixing nr. 1

3.
SIM not following the offense/defense AI - something Bort is working on at this moment

4.
penalties on own 5 or less result in TD - I'm sure, Bort will fix that as we talk.

5.
QBs running like powerbacks - since strength is overall strength for anybody, QBs are strong guys already - so a logical result. Might be reworked later on, but not really a bug.

6.
Missed tackles - expected result of tackling changes; the less speed you approach the ball carrier, the more tackling and strength you'll need. And yes, power backs should break a lot of tackles - that's what they are supposed to do!
Something to work out by building the players in a different way.

7.
Kick returners can't make up their mind and "wait" - running style to "Elusive: Try to avoid tackles altogether"? What do you expect a player ordered to avoid any tackles? He just tries to find a way to do as ordered and needs time to make up his mind! Not a bug, but might be reworked later on. You might want to choose a different running style when returning kicks, but stick to elusive on "regular" plays.

8.
Forced fumbles on kick returns - expected result of tackling changes; better have a lot of carrying + strength when you get hit at high speeds by defenders at high speed that know how to tackle.



Did I miss something out?

So let's analyze:

#1+2 are already fixed
#3+4 are already worked on
#5-7: not a bug, but something to discuss
#8: "working as intended"

I don't see any problem right now. Only thing to ask for: another scrimmage game for the teams that hadn't time to check their AI working.

best regards to all!



Forgive my ignorance, as I don't spend as much time in these forums as some. But who is this guy and does he really know what Bort has or hasn't done?
 
Gisty
offline
Link
 
As it stood last season the game was ok. Now it wasnt all that realistic, but it was FUN. Why cant we just get to the point where the game that runs smoothly, with no bugs and where the site doesnt have a heart attack at peak times. I've been playing with the advanced AI for a while now, but is it going to be worth it if the sims are gonna be screwed up and the site is slow as hell? That wont be fun.

C'mon guys, do the little things right and the big things will look after themselves.
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
Originally posted by Virtue76

Hairsplitters


Terminology-challenged.


Or would that be terminologically challenged?
 
Virtue76
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
Originally posted by Cruzi

Originally posted by Virtue76


Hairsplitters


Terminology-challenged.


terminologically


Is that even a word
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB

5.
QBs running like powerbacks - since strength is overall strength for anybody, QBs are strong guys already - so a logical result. Might be reworked later on, but not really a bug.


That's a much different kind of strength... Brett Favre has a crazy strong arm but no way would you say he's half as strong as Casey Hampton or Alan Faneca.

Maybe a condition could be placed on strength for QBs.
Last edited Jul 29, 2008 10:58:43
 
Cruzi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Virtue76
Originally posted by Cruzi

Originally posted by Cruzi


Originally posted by Virtue76



Hairsplitters


Terminology-challenged.


terminologically


Is that even a word


My spell-check didn't seem to notice it, so I'd have to say yes.
 
geradhunter
offline
Link
 
Are the stats going to be more realistic this season?

As in, not ridiculously high tackle/stat totals for #2 CBs and ridiculously low tackle numbers (in general) for ROLBS?
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
You think my points are harsh?? Did I call anyone a 'dick'?? If you want to open a debate about constructive critisism, then calling me a dick isn't going to be a good start!! When does the school term start again???


Your initial post was kind of whiney, but I've no problem with that, people have different posting styles.

Originally posted by

I've been playing the game long enough, and have paid more than enough, to have a viewpoint about it.

I happen to think too many changes have been made that have been detrimental to the overall enjoyment for the majority of players.


Hence why you and I probably will not agree on the Beta tag. Thinking that because a game is taking cash to play automatically moves it out of the Beta stage isn't right. The Beta stage of game design happens until the basic design goals are met and working. Bort has stated multiple times that he still has some basic design goals he wants to address, hence Beta.

Originally posted by
I don't subscribe to the viewpoint that I have to kiss Bort's rear end in every post, although I do appreciate his hard work and will happily give praise where and when it's due without wanting to be appointed as a mod/tester on the back of it


But you are a tester. Sometimes the only way to adequately test an option in game design is to float it out there and see what happens when the masses get that piece of the design. A game designer can be the most brilliant person in the world, and he is still going to overlook exploits that occur to 1 out of 1000 who play that game.

Originally posted by

If anyone thinks the game, as it stands, is 'working as intended', then please carry on - after all, they do say that a fool and his money is easily parted.........



Oh! Then we agree about Beta?

PinTBC
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cruzi
Originally posted by RAPB

So let's break it down to a simple analysis:

1.
WR's not targets - fixed by Bort immediatly

2.
unusual high sacks - if no targets are on the play, the QB will wait till he's sacked; so that's fixed by fixing nr. 1

3.
SIM not following the offense/defense AI - something Bort is working on at this moment

4.
penalties on own 5 or less result in TD - I'm sure, Bort will fix that as we talk.

5.
QBs running like powerbacks - since strength is overall strength for anybody, QBs are strong guys already - so a logical result. Might be reworked later on, but not really a bug.

6.
Missed tackles - expected result of tackling changes; the less speed you approach the ball carrier, the more tackling and strength you'll need. And yes, power backs should break a lot of tackles - that's what they are supposed to do!
Something to work out by building the players in a different way.

7.
Kick returners can't make up their mind and "wait" - running style to "Elusive: Try to avoid tackles altogether"? What do you expect a player ordered to avoid any tackles? He just tries to find a way to do as ordered and needs time to make up his mind! Not a bug, but might be reworked later on. You might want to choose a different running style when returning kicks, but stick to elusive on "regular" plays.

8.
Forced fumbles on kick returns - expected result of tackling changes; better have a lot of carrying + strength when you get hit at high speeds by defenders at high speed that know how to tackle.



Did I miss something out?

So let's analyze:

#1+2 are already fixed
#3+4 are already worked on
#5-7: not a bug, but something to discuss
#8: "working as intended"

I don't see any problem right now. Only thing to ask for: another scrimmage game for the teams that hadn't time to check their AI working.

best regards to all!



Forgive my ignorance, as I don't spend as much time in these forums as some. But who is this guy and does he really know what Bort has or hasn't done?


#1

Originally posted by Bort
I'm already making adjustments - the play definitions were screwed up with the new WR1/WR2, etc so it was skipping over WR's as valid targets.

Today is as much of a beta test for all my new code as it is for everybody's tactics!


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=704849


#2

Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by PinTBC

Bort,

Are the unusually high Sack numbers expected or something you are looking at?

PinTBC


Been looking at it.



#3

Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva

We were on basic AI for todays game because we did not have advanced tactics ironed out, nobody was set in the RILB or LILB spots yet our team ran the 3-4 today, not what we wanted.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=82437&pbp_id=6094

before someone asks the Advanced AI was not checked as being enabled.


I'm wondering - did it look like it maybe followed your tactics settings (like maybe it didn't follow the "use tactics" checkbox)?



Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Bort

I'll go test putting in some inputs with no outputs on the test server; maybe that causes a problem somehow, though I've tested it before and it worked fine.


Just tried this and it worked properly.


Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Robbnva

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Bort



I'll go test putting in some inputs with no outputs on the test server; maybe that causes a problem somehow, though I've tested it before and it worked fine.


Just tried this and it worked properly.


so a fluke?


No, I'm sure there's probably a bug somewhere that I just never ran into.


Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Fezmid

Originally posted by Bort


Just figured it out - really dumb bug. It was loading the other team's "base" setting.


I didn't have any advanced settings set (the checkbox on advanced AI was NOT checked). And the base defense was set to 4-3, so even if it was checked, we would've still been in the 4-3.

Are you saying that the bug was that my opponent was using a 3-4, so that's why I did too?

Is this fixed now?


Yup, and it's fixed.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=705275


#4

Originally posted by Bort
That sim is from the early games this morning, this should be fixed now.


http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=707279


...and what else:

Originally posted by Bort
Hmm...it replaces the whole string with "sacked by so and so" - any ideas on how to have it list the broken tackles in a way that makes sense?



Improper distance for first down after penalty
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=707222

Nickel lineup vs. 2 WR on strong side when playing zone
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=707155
 
Club America
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=80457


Too many penalties and too much dropped passes for a CPU league. If this is the way its gonna be, I wont pay anymore money. This is not fun.

I think the penalties should be dropped.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.