User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > What sense is it that the best teams only have 1 person on the depth chart.
Page:
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by bigtisme

No you wouldn't play the level 1 cpu Vilita.


Well I'm thinking then of having a certain number of players required on the depth chart then, not the roster


I know there's plans to allow people to sub in/out by position (which I think is 100% necessary). That would keep this from working.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rage Kinard
I just want it stated for the record, I am accusing no one of cheating.


I agree with that whole post. So far, the only one who's seemed to be bordering on calling this cheating is that damn Giants fan

Originally posted by bigtisme
Im just saying that i have a team that will be under 40 players next year (unless there is a cap) and im not really trying to "power level" guys.


Mine has 29, and I won't sign another single player (other than to replace current ones as necessary) unless the system changes and requires me to.
 
CoachMauler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
a) Playing starters for a full game is hardly cheating. It's not like I bought 6 teams and funneled all the money on those teams to 1 team. You have to see the difference between playing a game with the system that's in place and actively trying to cheat a system.

b) Did you not read my original post? I gave 2 suggestions:

"There's really only 2 ways I, or anyone who's thinking like me will care about backups:

1) There's a much lower cap put in place for experience (40 or so plays before the big dropoff instead of 90). Then I'll carry a few extra players to have more options. Even under that system, I can't imagine wanting to carry more than 40-45 players. I'd still keep the Energy penalty in the same place (gets much higher after the 80-90 play range) so if a team wants to just have single starters, they can, they're just not helped very much by it.

2) Lower the cap for the point where the Energy penalty hits hard to around 50 plays. That basically forces teams to carry a lot of depth and eliminates single starters across the board (other than maybe P/Ks). I don't like this idea since I don't think teams should be forced into a system like that if they don't want to, but hey, it'll solve the current problem...."

and got 0 comments on either one. Frankly, I'm still waiting to hear why the first 1 isn't good and where the loophole in that one is.

So if I shoot down others, I've already given good ones to go with.




I just wanna say, I NEVER said you cheated. Not by any means.. That was not the point of my post...

As far as your suggestions,

1) Good idea, but alot of owners will still overplay their starters if they want that extra bit on the field. They should be indirectly FORCED to use a back up.

2) It would have to be under 50...not at 50. Like 40 or something. The point is, you dont see many players in a real game playing all that many plays. It has to be in correlation with the players stamina stat which is the tricky part.

And the fact is that my previous 1) idea

(1) Associate a % that drops the overall skills of a player down the lower his stamina gets. Stamina at 100 speed at 45, stamina at 75 speed at 30, stamina at 50 speed at 20 etc...)

DOES NOT already happen. I can show numerous examples of games where a player is playing just as well, if not better at the end of a game then the beginning. That proves that in the sim, it isnt working (not yet anyway).


Maybe you meant that it was on the block for being installed into the game? But I am very confident it isnt already in the game. Otherwise you wouldnt see teams with 1 starter playing and winning so much.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 19:34:21
 
Vilita
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed
Originally posted by Vilita

Originally posted by bigtisme


No you wouldn't play the level 1 cpu Vilita.


Well I'm thinking then of having a certain number of players required on the depth chart then, not the roster


I know there's plans to allow people to sub in/out by position (which I think is 100% necessary). That would keep this from working.


Good, I'd rather have subs in by position
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxsyrusvb

2) It would have to be under 50...not at 50. Like 40 or something. The point is, you dont see many players in a real game playing all that many plays. It has to be in correlation with the players stamina stat which is the tricky part.


Well QB's never come out. OL rarely come out. TE's dont usually come out unless formation dictates (same with FB). Some NFL teams play starting HB 70-80% of the time and only use the backup 10% or something. There are lots of players in a real game that play alot of plays.

 
CoachMauler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
Originally posted by xxsyrusvb


2) It would have to be under 50...not at 50. Like 40 or something. The point is, you dont see many players in a real game playing all that many plays. It has to be in correlation with the players stamina stat which is the tricky part.


Well QB's never come out. OL rarely come out. TE's dont usually come out unless formation dictates (same with FB). Some NFL teams play starting HB 70-80% of the time and only use the backup 10% or something. There are lots of players in a real game that play alot of plays.



Yes, and MOST the time, the offense in a game is on the field all of 40-60 plays. Also, we are low lvls right now, so IMO, NO player should be able to stay in the game this long. I also meant that their should be a difference in how many plays a certain position can play in. As you say, QB's and OL can stay in the game, but DL cant etc..
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
DL is just about the only spot though. Safeties CB's and LB's can pretty much play most of the game as well. Heck some DL play entire games too!!
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by xxsyrusvb
1) Good idea, but alot of owners will still overplay their starters if they want that extra bit on the field. They should be indirectly FORCED to use a back up.


Well, there has to be some give there. I mean if you tell people that anything over X plays won't get them more exp, they won't bother doing so unless they just don't have a better option as a backup to use. That's gotta be good enough, since you need to leave some room for people to make decisions. Just as long as you encourage them to do what you want, they'll most likely do it.

Originally posted by xxsyrusvb
2) It would have to be under 50...not at 50. Like 40 or something. The point is, you dont see many players in a real game playing all that many plays. It has to be in correlation with the players stamina stat which is the tricky part.


The number is kind of meaningless, it's the idea which I was talking about.

Originally posted by xxsyrusvb
And the fact is that my previous idea....DOES NOT already happen. I can show numerous examples of games where a player is playing just as well, if not better at the end of a game then the beginning. That proves that in the sim, it isnt working (not yet anyway).



Actually, it is. You're just not seeing it because of how it works.

Say everyone on Team A's Offense has 15 Stamina. Everyone on Team B's Defense has 10 Stamina.

At some point during the game, Team B will wear down faster than Team A. At that point, Team A is wearing down, just at a slower pace than Team B. Therefore, they start to look better throughout the game.
 
Mrstickball
offline
Link
 
I, for one, believe that the game DOES need game-ending, or multi-game ending injuries, for a few reasons, and ways:

#1. Injuries should be very rare for multi-game ending injuries. But they should exist.

#2. Game-ending, or drive-ending injuries need to exist too. In the NFL, many times, a player can get a leg cramp, or other small-scale injury requring to be benched for a few plays. This would immediately solve depth chart issues.

#3. For those complaining about the appeal of the game to new players, if injuries did happen - ever think of "newbie protection" - it does exist in the majority of MMOs. Infact, it might make rookies look very attractive for a depth chart, should they be unable to be severely injured for their first year.

#4. I don't, however, feel that the game needs to inherantly "force" starting players to not play. Starters are designed to start, and play as long and hard as possible. In the NFL, starters play for the majority of the game, usually. It would be nice, however, for backups, even if they don't play, to recieve bonus EXP for being benched behind a succuessful starter. I call it the "Tomy Romo Effect".
 
ohmybriguy
offline
Link
 
The game shouldn't make anyone sub backups in... it should make it that a DL that plays the whole game would be pretty much worthless by the end due to low low energy. The problem as stated before is that the best way to win in a season is to only have 1 player play each position.
 
CoachMauler
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mrstickball
I, for one, believe that the game DOES need game-ending, or multi-game ending injuries, for a few reasons, and ways:

#1. Injuries should be very rare for multi-game ending injuries. But they should exist.

#2. Game-ending, or drive-ending injuries need to exist too. In the NFL, many times, a player can get a leg cramp, or other small-scale injury requring to be benched for a few plays. This would immediately solve depth chart issues.

#3. For those complaining about the appeal of the game to new players, if injuries did happen - ever think of "newbie protection" - it does exist in the majority of MMOs. Infact, it might make rookies look very attractive for a depth chart, should they be unable to be severely injured for their first year.

#4. I don't, however, feel that the game needs to inherantly "force" starting players to not play. Starters are designed to start, and play as long and hard as possible. In the NFL, starters play for the majority of the game, usually. It would be nice, however, for backups, even if they don't play, to recieve bonus EXP for being benched behind a succuessful starter. I call it the "Tomy Romo Effect".


Good points. I agree... And maybe the problem is that PT is giving XP, not games on a team. Maybe a mix of the two would work. So every player gets a Flat rate XP per game, but the players that play the most grab an extra %.
 
Link
 
we played a team with no backups today in the playoffs (Canadian AAA) and beat them 38-0. We ran them ragged.
 
Verloren
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by washingtonredskins
we played a team with no backups today in the playoffs (Canadian AAA) and beat them 38-0. We ran them ragged.


And I still get spammed by players wanting a starting spot as a level 1. Makes me not want to sign them.

The thing is, up to a certain extent having a lot of depth is good. Once the starters get high stamina, they can play pretty much every snap.
Last edited Apr 15, 2008 20:43:38
 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by krwynn

Originally posted by Vilita


Originally posted by CONN CHRIS






It can easily be solved by making a certain depth at each position mandatory for a line-up to be valid prior to game time.



I agree with this thread.

Seriously, injuries is not whats going to solve this. People should not be playing, let alone rewarded for playing just 1 HB or just 2 WR's in a game. Its simply unrealistic and those of us trying to play more realistically or suffering.

I like the suggestion of having a mandatory depth at each position for a lineup to be valid.



Crazy. Maybe a limit on the high side, yes. Low side, no. If someone can play their ppl the whole game then good for them. No one will ever tell me as a coach who or how many players I have to have. Dumbest idea ever. Vilita, you have players in positions that aren't even in USE YET. Get a clue.



Hey genius. Did it occur to you that maybe that I did that so the backup LB's see their name on the front page as starters and feel better about their position on the team?

You might want to ask why people do things before assuming they are as clueless as you.


So you lie to your players. What a great example of a coach you are.

 
HootyHoo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vilita
Originally posted by Jed


Originally posted by xxsyrusvb


Min roster wouldnt work. BUT a Min roster PER POSITION would. MUST have 5 WR's, 3 TE's, 2 QB's, 2 FS's, etc...


So I pick up 1 level 1 CPU punter, 1 level 1 CPU QB, 1 level 1 CPU WR.....really, roster mins won't do anything other than raise my daily salary a couple of bucks. and it'll barely even do that since I'll sign level 1 CPU's to min contracts for max length of time.



But then those Level 1 CPU guys would take away from the playing time of the Level 9 human, somewhat accomplishing the goal, no?


ROFLMAO. He just doesn't get it.
Last edited Apr 16, 2008 18:08:11
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.