User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > News Flash, corners don't need to be able to tackle
Page:
 
billsman2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jrry32
Originally posted by Jericoholic

If your corners are your leading tacklers, that means you cannot cover and stop the pass. Which means your corners stink.


Not always...if you play in an outside running heavy league...it's possible your CBs get 7-10 tackles a game.




I agree with this. My corner has 35 or so in tackling, and stops a lot of outside runs because he beats the LB there. Think Antoine Winfield.
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
2008 NFL Season - 10 of top 100 tacklers were CB's

just saying
 
mooks77
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Originally posted by mooks77

Originally posted by Grim Truth


This thread is still true, and will always be true. Corners cover, they don't and shouldn't be good tacklers.

"Show me a corner who can tackle, I'll show you a corner who can't cover." - Deion Sanders.

It's true, it's always been true, it will always be true. Strong tackling CB's in this game will always end up being burned more often then not. Having tackling/strength above 35, even in the Pro's, is a waste of SP.


Wrong. And you don't need to spend SP to get tacking and strength above 35.


Not wrong. And it's a waste of training too.


Your blanket statement "that if a CB has tacking/strength above 35 he is going to get burned more often than not" is incorrect.
Last edited Jan 23, 2009 08:54:56
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by itsme4
2008 NFL Season - 10 of top 100 tacklers were CB's

just saying


my bad

I based it on total tackles = solo + assists

when you base it on solos only, 18 of top 100 are CB's

just saying GLB should keep it "real"
 
canes30
offline
Link
 
Why did you just post the obvious?
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
CBs should need 48 tackling at least to take down a back, especially considering they mainly have less than 30 strength.

In real life terms, basically CBs who can bench 135 five times (barely) are proving able to tackle guys who can bench 225 25 times. CBs should be missing half their tackles, but they aren't.

Its all part of how strength isn't nearly important enough in the sim.
 
xsujx
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Grim Truth
Originally posted by mooks77

Originally posted by Grim Truth


This thread is still true, and will always be true. Corners cover, they don't and shouldn't be good tacklers.

"Show me a corner who can tackle, I'll show you a corner who can't cover." - Deion Sanders.

It's true, it's always been true, it will always be true. Strong tackling CB's in this game will always end up being burned more often then not. Having tackling/strength above 35, even in the Pro's, is a waste of SP.


Wrong. And you don't need to spend SP to get tacking and strength above 35.


Not wrong. And it's a waste of training too.


Your "argument" would have more validity if your own corners were more impressive than they are. Even though one is a returner he seems to have enough pt on defense to need to be more useful than he has been. But then maybe you're looking for company from other CBs who miss about a third of their tackle attempts.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
CBs should need 48 tackling at least to take down a back, especially considering they mainly have less than 30 strength.

In real life terms, basically CBs who can bench 135 five times (barely) are proving able to tackle guys who can bench 225 25 times. CBs should be missing half their tackles, but they aren't.

Its all part of how strength isn't nearly important enough in the sim.


The truth is in real life tackling is not about benching or strength. You will need strength to shed blocks, but don't really need them for tackling.
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by itsme4
2008 NFL Season - 10 of top 100 tacklers were CB's

just saying


So then what was the other 90%?
just saying.
 
ddingo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by OttawaShane

CBs should need 48 tackling at least to take down a back, especially considering they mainly have less than 30 strength.

In real life terms, basically CBs who can bench 135 five times (barely) are proving able to tackle guys who can bench 225 25 times. CBs should be missing half their tackles, but they aren't.

Its all part of how strength isn't nearly important enough in the sim.


The truth is in real life tackling is not about benching or strength. You will need strength to shed blocks, but don't really need them for tackling.


Tackling is largely positioning and proper technique -- neither rely on strength. Strength can help offset errors in positioning and technique though.
 
Varsity18
offline
Link
 
Primetime Sanders was known for saying he doesnt tackle....
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
The DCs on one of my teams has said multiple times that any time a corner makes a tackle, it means someone screwed up.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
My linebackers will get there, not my corners.


LBs have 110 speed...best strategy
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Don't bump old threads.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.