User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Moving Sold Teams to the Bottom Tier
Page:
 
Link
 
The solution to the issue is that ability for owners to sell teams to another person that appoint.

There aren't any downsides to that solution. The "secondary market" already exists. I myself, and other owners I'm aware of, have gotten offers to sell our teams for real life cash. That's as easy a paypal transfer and giving them my account info were I so inclined.

Using this method, we'll be able to stop >=1 gutted team from falling to a bad owner and having an entire team in disarray.

As for the idea of moving gutted teams down, it's unworkable. How do we decide just how "gutted" a team has to be to move down? What if not all players want to leave? Do we then send a powerhouse team down to the celler? Etc. etc. etc.

The plan is full of holes and there are easier solutions available.

It reminds me of the roster issue. We have a 40 man roster min. so what do "exploiters" do, they go out and sign 8 level 1 punters. Meanwhile, this could all be solved by adding positional minimums just like the NFL uses. That way, even if teams are going to try and cheat the system, they have to worry that the level 1 LB they just signed might see the field at some point (thanks CPU subs!) and hurt the team.

Occam's Razor is our best bet here, all things being equal, lets use the simplest workable solution.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
OK, the problem with gutted/stripped/sold teams is kind of two fold. If the team is sold during the season, the team cannot leave its current league and be moved. It really screws up the league structure, and even though it could affect the league standings, that team was assigned to play in that league, and should finish it out. Which should mean this.. The new owner takes over, and whatever players are left remain on th eteam. That team finishes out the season, but at the end of the season, the owner gets an option to be relegated to the base league (BBB, or whatever that one is in that league structure). At this point in time, any players over the median level of the new 'base' league will be removed from the team (The owner should be given a warning telling him who will be removed), and everyone else on the team gets to select to remain on the team or become free agents.

What that does is provide a response to those owners that trade/release everyone because they don't want them stuck in a bad contract. At the end of the season, everyone can decide to stay with the newly bought team or leave.

1. Who moves up?

Right now in each league, you have the top two moving up, if you simply continue the playoff structure you can determine the rest of the seating. For example, Last season my Marauders lost in our conference finals to the Atlanta heat, and Easy Company lost in their coference finals to the Orangebloods. The last game of the playoffs, we played a scrimmage. Simply change that from a scrimmage to a seeding contest, and make it mean something. You still don't get the homefield coins or concessions, but that game now becomes a seeding game, and the winner is determine to be the 3rd seed, the loser the 4th seed. That can be extended down an additional level to seed the top 8 teams in each conference.


2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

I liked the idea of dimishing returns on flex points depending on when in the season you give up the team, but I think the idea I outlined above covers this.

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

I don't think this is a point that you have to give up on. With the outline I proposed, there is no reason for an owner to rid the team of players before he leaves. Everyone gets the ability to leave the team at the end of that season. If the new owner is a good guy, he could keep significant numbers of players, if he is an ass, everyone can leave.

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

That is why you give the option of moving down or staying. The owner would have a very tough choice to make. He would have to decide if his players will stick with him, or leave, AND he would have to decide if putting his players on his team is that important.

PinTBC

Last edited Jun 30, 2008 13:04:47
 
kristof65
offline
Link
 
I think the biggest problem with this is the competitive hit upper level leagues take when a team is affected by this. Part of the problem is that players get nervous about dealing with a new owner, and many of them ask to be cut prior to the new owner coming on board - this somewhat results in gutting. Here's my proposed solution:

- Move the teams, but only make those moves in the offseason, during relegation. Promote teams based on their record.

- For teams that are sold back midseason, don't immediately turn them over to new owners, but don't make them CPU either. In many cases, the team will want to go on, if only for the season - especially if they're having a decent season. Instead, reset everyone's contracts to end at end of season (unless they end sooner) and let the GMs run the team for the rest of the season. If the team doesn't have GMs, let the departing owner appoint some, or the team elect one. The GMs don't need contract or spending authority at that point. If you need a reference, look at the situation that occured to the Syracuse Samurai (formerly Perth Amboy Pythons) when our owner went AWOL - the team held together on it's own - I feel that most teams, if they knew they were being released at end of season would do so as well.

- Allow players "stuck" on that team the ability to accept contract offers that take effect next season. That way the players won't have uncertain futures, and therefore won't feel trapped.
 
sois
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I think the "who gets promoted" idea needs something a little more concrete. Think about it.

Pro League has A and B conferences.
Team in A conference gets sold and relegated to B league.

AAA League 1 and 2 have A and B conferences as well, so we have four conferences to pick from. Just for the sake of argument, lets eliminate B. So we have two leagues with second place conference finishers. How do you determine which one goes up?

They are in totally different leagues and don't interact at all. I don't think there is a way to determine clearly who is the promoted team.

---------------------------

Maybe instead of pyramid shaped leagues, we should strictly have vertical leagues, from Pro to B. That will fix the issue and make it easier to program.

How many leagues are there now? We could possibly do 50 leagues and use State names. Texas Pro, Texas AAA, Texas AA.. all the way down to Texas B. Each league will only have one feeder.




Last edited Jun 30, 2008 16:18:15
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
1. Who moves up?

This can be determined by the playoffs. The teams that lost in the semi-finals should be the ones up for consideration and perhaps move the one up with the highest average level players or have a scrimmage game

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season. I'm worried that this would leave a whole lot of players stranded with an inactive owner who gave up. Ideas/solutions?

I would allow team sales in the middle of the season. The prospect of having a team stuck with inactive ownership is not a good one and impacts the fun that paying customers are having. I would suggest letting the players become free agents. Not too different from the way things are happening now - owner guts his team before selling it or new owner releases all existing players demanding trades.

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?

It's not a good thing, but this is a necessary expense to pay for the system to work. This is the kind of thing allready happening with all the gutted teams and fire sales. Maybe packing the team with high level CPU's but this team is automatically eliminated from playoff consideration regardless of record. Make them high enough to compete but not too high to win alot of games.

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps. Solutions/Ideas?

Yeah, I would give the option to the new team owner to move up or down. If they want to play at the pro or AAA level and bring in their own guys, they should be able to choose that option on the waiting list.

5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first, so the new owner can keep on keepin' on. Yes, they could sell it to a GM, but maybe the GM doesn't want it, etc. Disbanding this kind of team just because the owner doesn't have time any more seems like a waste. Ideas/Solutions?

Perhaps giving the players the option to stay or be released. If the team is a good team and enjoys playing together, give the agents a few days to decide. They could post/discuss in the teams forums. One of the GM's or players would have to step up and buy the team if they wanted to stay together. I would be surprised if nobody stepped up when the team wants to stay together.



Last edited Jun 30, 2008 16:57:03
 
3ball
offline
Link
 
My ideas (sorry if any of these have been hit on already)

It costs 1000 FP's to buy a new team. That is for 2 seasons (80 days of ownership). You could argue that Season 1 costs 600 FP's and Season 2 costs 400 FP's, based off of the renewal rate of 400 FP's. I propose that all ownership ends on after day 40. All new owners take over in the offseason.

To make this cost fair to owners, I propose a prorated ownership. Let's say you take over a new team on day 21 of Season 3 (20 . Your initial ownership would then finish on day 40 of Season 4. The full season of ownership would still cost 600 FP's. The partial season would be prorated from the 400 FP rate. In my example, it would be 200 FP's for half of season 3, for a total of 800 FP's. Basically the prorated FP cost would be 10 FP's per day for the partial season.

The benefits to this:
All new owners take over in the offseason and have equal chances in free agency as everyone else.
They have an entire offseason to prepare, instead of in the middle of the season when it's rolling along.

Of course this doesn't really stop gutting, which really, really sucks.
 
AcidBee
offline
Link
 
I'm gonna answer this one first as it is easier to follow if addressed first.
5. Some owners randomly sell a team who is actually competitive in the league without releasing or trading away the players first.
I would approach this situation by recognizing two kinds of sell options: Selling to a GM or selling back to the GLB System.
If a team owner chooses to sell to one of his GMs, I see it as perfectly understandable for that person to inherit the team as is, with the current roster and contracts (it may still be fair to reset the stadium and fan support for next season).
Selling back to the GLB System, however, could be handled by ideas in 1-4

1. Who moves up?
I think relegation would be appropriate. Granted, the sold team would move all the way to the bottom allowing an extra team to move up. The algorithm for figuring out which bottom league the team in question should move to and which extra teams get to move up should be able to be decided after relegation takes place. (Sort of a 'super relegation').

2. Some people have suggested not allowing team sales in the middle of the season.
I would allow it. One idea that may help is auto-promote/demote a GM to tactician and nothing else. This would allow an active human being to help guide the team through the rest of the season. If the team doesn't have a GM, you can e-mail a player an offer to be temp GM, work your way down the line until one accepts or all decline.

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes.
I'm not going to say this is a good idea, but I don't see a good alternative. An all CPU team would only happen if you released all the human players right away. Perhaps a better solution would be to cut the human player's contract down to the end of the season and, in the meantime, have the contracts function like D-League contracts (i.e. bound to the contract unless a human team own sends a contract offer the the player)

4. Many new owners want to be able to get a team where their lv 20+ players can come and play. If all new teams always start at the lowest level, that becomes impossible due to sportsmanship penalties and/or level caps.
You hold off relegation/'super relegation' (see number 1) until the end of the off-season giving the new owner time to put a team together under the current league cap (if one exists). Then, relegate down until their average level best matches a conference.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AcidBee

3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes.
I'm not going to say this is a good idea, but I don't see a good alternative. An all CPU team would only happen if you released all the human players right away. Perhaps a better solution would be to cut the human player's contract down to the end of the season and, in the meantime, have the contracts function like D-League contracts (i.e. bound to the contract unless a human team own sends a contract offer the the player)


I kinda like this idea...Basically, though, the players are gutting themselves off the team if they wanted. I guess it would allow the owner a way out without having to deal with releases/trades, etc, and the headache that goes with it.

On a related note (not addressed to AcidBee):

I think the thing that some people are missing is that if the team has no owner, no GM's, and a bunch of players left on it, those players are going to come and complain about having to stuck on a CPU team, ALL THE TIME.

It sounds all well and good to say "your contract will run out at the end of the season" but what if my owner sells on day 1 or 2 of the season? I'm stuck on a CPU-owned team until day 40? People who have signed on human teams want to play on human-controlled teams with people they know, not in the D-League. We need to let them go if they want.
 
Dee
offline
Link
 
I like the idea of dropping to the lowest level, and players having an option to leave the team for say a week after the original owner sold it.
 
Whitesun
offline
Link
 
Minimum sum trade+bonus money paid out by team for players stuck on the above scenario? This way at least the team isn't out of pocket, and reduces the risk of the owner buying a huge bonus before going awol.
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by AcidBee


3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes.
I'm not going to say this is a good idea, but I don't see a good alternative. An all CPU team would only happen if you released all the human players right away. Perhaps a better solution would be to cut the human player's contract down to the end of the season and, in the meantime, have the contracts function like D-League contracts (i.e. bound to the contract unless a human team own sends a contract offer the the player)


I kinda like this idea...Basically, though, the players are gutting themselves off the team if they wanted. I guess it would allow the owner a way out without having to deal with releases/trades, etc, and the headache that goes with it.

On a related note (not addressed to AcidBee):

I think the thing that some people are missing is that if the team has no owner, no GM's, and a bunch of players left on it, those players are going to come and complain about having to stuck on a CPU team, ALL THE TIME.

It sounds all well and good to say "your contract will run out at the end of the season" but what if my owner sells on day 1 or 2 of the season? I'm stuck on a CPU-owned team until day 40? People who have signed on human teams want to play on human-controlled teams with people they know, not in the D-League. We need to let them go if they want.


Then put it to a vote like I suggested. If a super-majority want to stay with the team, then let it live on. Otherwise, disband and demote it all the way to the bottom. Let the new owner start with a clean slate. This way, the players have a say in whether they get "screwed." I put that in quotation marks because if the new owner is terrible and they stayed, they would be screwed. They would also be screwed by not being able to take advantage of the FA market, which is very good for experienced players.

Thus, let the players decide the team's future.


I do not think that GM inheritance is a good idea at all. For the simple reason that an owner could just hire a GM right before she sells the team. This goes completely against the spirit of the wait-list.
 
Chetro
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


3. If team sales are allowed mid-season, the team would become all-CPU for the rest of the season and basically be a cupcake team for all purposes. Good or Bad?




Bad, not fair to the teams who had to play that team earlier in the season before it was a cupcake team.
 
Link
 
The problem with letting a GM take over is that this allows someone to make a deal, bring on a GM and sell it to a deal maker. Isn't this part of what you wanted to get away from?

I say let the team take their beatings, if they have been gutted and give them an option to be thrown in the cellar if they feel they cannot compete AFTER the season. Then, you can move teams accordingly during the off-season.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Then put it to a vote like I suggested. If a super-majority want to stay with the team, then let it live on. Otherwise, disband and demote it all the way to the bottom. Let the new owner start with a clean slate. This way, the players have a say in whether they get "screwed." I put that in quotation marks because if the new owner is terrible and they stayed, they would be screwed. They would also be screwed by not being able to take advantage of the FA market, which is very good for experienced players.


So if they vote to disband, it becomes a CPU team until the end of the season?
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by awesome

Then put it to a vote like I suggested. If a super-majority want to stay with the team, then let it live on. Otherwise, disband and demote it all the way to the bottom. Let the new owner start with a clean slate. This way, the players have a say in whether they get "screwed." I put that in quotation marks because if the new owner is terrible and they stayed, they would be screwed. They would also be screwed by not being able to take advantage of the FA market, which is very good for experienced players.


So if they vote to disband, it becomes a CPU team until the end of the season?


The mid-season question is troublesome.

My inclination is to just go ahead and demote it all the way down anyway.

The question becomes: do you replace it?

Either 1) you could promote the team that has the highest "power ranking" or some other formula that I'm sure is available to determine the projected season success or 2) you could just leave the vacant spot. Give every team in that conference a bye.

With either option 1 or 2, the team gets demoted to the bottom. This could be problematic if it creates a 17 team conference at the bottom. One option would be to simply have that team act as if it were in the d-leagues or, in fact, move it to the d-leagues for the rest of the season. That way, the new owner would be able to recruit and build up some players to be ready for the next season.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.