User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Juke not firing on KR/PR ? - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
marcello
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Per Bort:

Originally posted by Bort


You can juke on returns...it's literally in the same code block as head fake, plus a couple other special instances just for it. If you can head fake, you can juke. Guys just might tend to go too fast to do it very often, since the special instances require changing direction a lot.



Closing as not a bug.


Sweet, 20 SP wasted.

User base: We can't find a single instance of this firing, we don't think it works.
Bort: Nope, it works.
User base: ...
 
TheGreatAus
offline
Link
 


Not a bug, just horrible game design! Wheres the forum for that?? I would like to post there
 
marcello
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Per Bort:

Originally posted by Bort


You can juke on returns...it's literally in the same code block as head fake, plus a couple other special instances just for it. If you can head fake, you can juke. Guys just might tend to go too fast to do it very often, since the special instances require changing direction a lot.



Closing as not a bug.


The other thing that doesn't make sense about this is that Head Fake fires like crazy on returns and Juke doesn't (we have plenty of examples of dots with only Head Fake blinking would-be tacklers). If they're "literally the same code block", but Juke also has extra instances where it can happen, why would only Head Fake be firing?

This needs to be reopened because there is clearly a bug here.
 
TheGreatAus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
You can juke on returns...it's literally in the same code block as head fake, plus a couple other special instances just for it. If you can head fake, you can juke. Guys just might tend to go too fast to do it very often, since the special instances require changing direction a lot.


So when you see a toilet overflowing in your own house, do you just say that the piss and crap flowing out is just a by product of a toilet that moves water is working as intended? A toilet is supposed to flow water, as well as let it go down that little hole; a kick returner with juke should be able to juke on kickoffs, not just return the ball headlong into defenders.

It would seem that the data collected here from fine returning specimens would illustrate that this might not be a bug, but something needs to be done about the lack of any juke from a returner with 100+ agility, 10 Juke, 15 QF, fake% AEQ/CEQ, and uber high vision.
Edited by TheGreatAus on Oct 6, 2011 14:19:57
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Closing as not a bug.


Not sure how this is not a bug? Juke does not fire for returners. The explanation/not bug is nonsense. Head fakes fire...jukes do not...period. We looked at 100s of returns of juke only returners and could not find one juke example.

So as coded jukes could fire but something else in the code (probably) prevents it from firing. Isn't this the very definition of a bug? Something that is designed to work does not work in actual game play. Obviously you have a problem in the code if returners who are built to juke never do it.

Juke SHOULD be a valid SA for returners. Some CB returners are built to have juke as their only fake/break tackle ability.

The answer should be..."I looked at the code. I did not see anything immediately wrong. We will do some testing in the offseason and adjust the frequency in which juke fires for returners."

Edited by ChicagoTRS on Oct 6, 2011 18:52:31
 
bhall43
offline
Link
 
lol
 
marcello
offline
Link
 
I wonder how many blinks this dot has:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=2034508

I looked through a few games this season and didn't see any.

This dot, however:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=1488394

I just checked the most recent competitive game and found plenty of examples:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1818458&pbp_id=9240577
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1818458&pbp_id=9240637
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1818458&pbp_id=9241685

That's weird.
 
ZeroTolerance
offline
Link
 
Yeah, this sounds just about right around here.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ChicagoTRS
Juke SHOULD be a valid SA for returners.


?!?
 
azrolator
offline
Link
 
Juke + 49 speed + 160 agility the new awesome? I want to waste some flex on this just to test and see if it works at low speeds as mentioned.

I think what is needed, that Juke should just be made NO KR/PR and resets given. It can be claimed that it works under unlikely circumstances, like slow speed returner with high agi. But if it fires less than 1 in a 1000 plays on any normal build then it is basically non functioning and should state so in the description.
 
jpjn94
doc ock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by azrolator
Juke + 49 speed + 160 agility the new awesome? I want to waste some flex on this just to test and see if it works at low speeds as mentioned.

I think what is needed, that Juke should just be made NO KR/PR and resets given. It can be claimed that it works under unlikely circumstances, like slow speed returner with high agi. But if it fires less than 1 in a 1000 plays on any normal build then it is basically non functioning and should state so in the description.


I was actually talking with someone today about this and would love if Catch would test this theory on the Test Server to verify it actually does work

 
marcello
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jpjn94
Originally posted by azrolator

Juke + 49 speed + 160 agility the new awesome? I want to waste some flex on this just to test and see if it works at low speeds as mentioned.

I think what is needed, that Juke should just be made NO KR/PR and resets given. It can be claimed that it works under unlikely circumstances, like slow speed returner with high agi. But if it fires less than 1 in a 1000 plays on any normal build then it is basically non functioning and should state so in the description.


I was actually talking with someone today about this and would love if Catch would test this theory on the Test Server to verify it actually does work



The thing is, apparently the break point on too much speed is somewhere between 150 and 165, since Juke fires plenty on HBs with 150 speed.
 
oaklandraider
OAK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
Closing as not a bug.


wow.
just wow.

I think Im going to go over to Suggestions to suggest a new smiley:

"slowly shakes head from side to side in disbelief"
 
ZeroTolerance
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by marcello
The thing is, apparently the break point on too much speed is somewhere between 150 and 165, since Juke fires plenty on HBs with 150 speed.


140 speed doesn't work either. I have a returner with 140 speed, 10 Juke, never seen it fire.
 
ChicagoTRS
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by marcello
The thing is, apparently the break point on too much speed is somewhere between 150 and 165, since Juke fires plenty on HBs with 150 speed.


The main returner I was looking at has speed well south of 140...0 jukes.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.