User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Playable Cheerleaders Compiled Suggestion
Page:
 
awesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
Originally posted by awesome

Originally posted by Checkmate187


1. Cheerleaders are merely the mechanism that will affect morale. Call it cheerleaders, fans, crowd, cow shit... I don't care.

2. I think if made available, every damn one of you nay-sayers will have at least one cheerleader the next day.... as will all the people who love this idea. That means mo' money, mo' money, MO' MONEY!!


Right... such a blatant ploy to squeeze more money out of the users will be so obvious, people will LEAVE the site.


What's so different between this and having a playable coach that affects in-game play?


Non sequitur much?
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Checkmate187
I think if made available, every damn one of you nay-sayers will have at least one cheerleader the next day.... as will all the people who love this idea. That means mo' money, mo' money, MO' MONEY!!


You're entitled to your opinion. Here's mine: I think if this were made part of the game, large numbers of people would leave, and the income would drop. Current players would leave because adding this part of the game would tell the players that the site operators have a very skewed list of priorities when it comes to making this game the best it can be.

This idea appeals to a very, VERY limited number of current players that actually buy flex points. Those players would be very jaded if cheerleaders were added instead of tactics beyond even the next set of advanced tactics that would make this a better football simulation.

 
Link
 
I don't know why you guys are still talking about this, its a shit idea go away now please.
 
TuNice
offline
Link
 
Wow this is amazing.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by awesome
Originally posted by Checkmate187

1. Cheerleaders are merely the mechanism that will affect morale. Call it cheerleaders, fans, crowd, cow shit... I don't care.

2. I think if made available, every damn one of you nay-sayers will have at least one cheerleader the next day.... as will all the people who love this idea. That means mo' money, mo' money, MO' MONEY!!


Right... such a blatant ploy to squeeze more money out of the users will be so obvious, people will LEAVE the site.


Please refer to 200pg thread cited in the first post at people willing to make a cheerleader under this system.

The general consensus we are getting is

"The idea was stupid at first but it sounds interesting enough for me to want to make one"

or

"I love the idea and would make a squad"

or

"I don't really like this idea but for some reason I would have to have one"

or the minor (but sometimes vocal)

"Your an idiot I hate this idea"
 
essteeay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo


Please do not cite "realism" as a way to refute the idea.


Citing lack of realism is one of the best ways to cut down some of the absurd suggestions made around here. Another good appeal is to "relevance". Cheerleaders are meaningless, if not an actual distraction from the GAME (remember the game? football? with the ball and the players and the scoring?). We have no need for them in GLB.
 
RTJakarta
offline
Link
 
Good idea.
 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atm490
Originally posted by Checkmate187

I think if made available, every damn one of you nay-sayers will have at least one cheerleader the next day.... as will all the people who love this idea. That means mo' money, mo' money, MO' MONEY!!


You're entitled to your opinion. Here's mine: I think if this were made part of the game, large numbers of people would leave, and the income would drop. Current players would leave because adding this part of the game would tell the players that the site operators have a very skewed list of priorities when it comes to making this game the best it can be.

This idea appeals to a very, VERY limited number of current players that actually buy flex points. Those players would be very jaded if cheerleaders were added instead of tactics beyond even the next set of advanced tactics that would make this a better football simulation.





It's practically plug-n-play.
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Can we all agree that cheerleaders exist in real life and are a part of football - whether or not you agree with their presence?

Also this is not real life. This is our own seemingly virtual football world, a place where teams have stadiums that are completely empty on one side but go up 3 tiers on the other, a place where some teams charge 2 dollars for a hotdog and other teams charge 10. A place where games are decided by 200 points at some points, and tie 9-9 in others.

Please do not cite "realism" as a way to refute the idea.


No. We CANNOT agree that cheerleaders are a part of football. Cheerleaders are a separate entity that some athletic competitions choose to employ for entertainment and some do not.

The I formation is part of football. Without it, football would lack structure and would be problematic.

Without cheerleading, football would be (and is) just fine.
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atm490


You're entitled to your opinion. Here's mine: I think if this were made part of the game, large numbers of people would leave, and the income would drop. Current players would leave because adding this part of the game would tell the players that the site operators have a very skewed list of priorities when it comes to making this game the best it can be.

This idea appeals to a very, VERY limited number of current players that actually buy flex points. Those players would be very jaded if cheerleaders were added instead of tactics beyond even the next set of advanced tactics that would make this a better football simulation.



Do you program? at all?

Programming advanced tactics and fixing bugs in the artificial intelligence is MUCH harder to implement than what im suggesting. What im suggesting is basically alot of if statements + some formula's to generate a number that adjusts the final morale number by a little.

If Bort/DD/Thorn wanted I could come up with specific formula's to use, but then I'd have to know the extent at which things affect the morale bar so it comes out balanced.

People want flash games for training that has nothing to do with football. This actually has something to do with the sim itself.

 
Checkmate187
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by essteeay
Originally posted by Laggo



Please do not cite "realism" as a way to refute the idea.


Citing lack of realism is one of the best ways to cut down some of the absurd suggestions made around here. Another good appeal is to "relevance". Cheerleaders are meaningless, if not an actual distraction from the GAME (remember the game? football? with the ball and the players and the scoring?). We have no need for them in GLB.


Ever hear of morale? Do you realize it affects how your players play in this game? Wouldn't you like something that could boost your morale, thus making your players play better?

[sarcasm] Yeah, stupid idea. [/sarcasm]
 
atm490
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by atm490



You're entitled to your opinion. Here's mine: I think if this were made part of the game, large numbers of people would leave, and the income would drop. Current players would leave because adding this part of the game would tell the players that the site operators have a very skewed list of priorities when it comes to making this game the best it can be.

This idea appeals to a very, VERY limited number of current players that actually buy flex points. Those players would be very jaded if cheerleaders were added instead of tactics beyond even the next set of advanced tactics that would make this a better football simulation.



Do you program? at all?

Programming advanced tactics and fixing bugs in the artificial intelligence is MUCH harder to implement than what im suggesting. What im suggesting is basically alot of if statements + some formula's to generate a number that adjusts the final morale number by a little.

If Bort/DD/Thorn wanted I could come up with specific formula's to use, but then I'd have to know the extent at which things affect the morale bar so it comes out balanced.

People want flash games for training that has nothing to do with football. This actually has something to do with the sim itself.



I don't care how easy or hard something is to implement. That is completely unrelated to my argument.

My argument is that adding your suggested aspect to the game would mean that the programmers' priorities are skewed.

I would rather Bort/DD/Thorn spend the next YEAR figuring out a way to fix certain Tight End bugs that leave them blocking in slightly odd ways than even a DAY on this idea.
 
Packer Fan
offline
Link
 
I'd rather be able to pick my team's uniform colors before the cheerleaders are implemented. How stupid is the offense always blue and defense always yellow? I think that enhancement should be made first, even though uniform design does not really impact the game of football (except for the color blind players I guess).
 
aeakers
offline
Link
 
OK, here is a compelling reason not to have playable cheerleaders:

#1. It would be very time consuming to program, esp. for minimal gain. I mean, not that many teams will hire cheerleaders, let alone a full squad. And...if by some unGodly coincidence, lets say a lot of teams had full cheerleader squads. What tangible result can be had? How do we separate a good cheerleader build from a bad? How do we gauge performance? How could they possibly be programmed to affect the game when even home field advantage has no benefit?

Now....let me throw in a 'what if'. What if cheerleaders do not boost morale? What if instead they are PR queens, as in real life. Send them to a mall, have them sign autographs, all the while selling Tshirts and coffee mugs. Raising fan support.


But.....even then, not something I would support. So much to work on to improve the game and you want them to add a fictional mechanism such as cheerleaders affecting the game. Cheerleaders do not get fans pumped. Go to a game. The ones getting the fans pumped up ARE THE FANS. The Bengal Darth Vader, the Broncos' Naked Guy in a Barrel, The Raiders fans with the spiked shoulderpads.

Sorry for hating but guys, this is just a bad idea.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Laggo
Originally posted by aeakers


In the NFL, cheerleaders sole existence is for the fans. They do not affect the game. Unless Chad Johnson is doing a celebration.


Cheerleaders affect the fans, who in turn affect the game.

Do you think the fans do not affect the game?


Again, you are talking "Home Field Advantage", not "cheerleaders". The Developers will NEVER go for "building" cheerleaders. This crappy idea needs to be shot down ASAP.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.