User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Non-World League Passing Results: Stats
Page:
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stonewall Paul
Here's an idea. Get rid of the current "Pee-wee" structure and make a 1 season league that is the equivalent to level 40 or so. This would require special player creation that would only be 1 year players and would be forced to be retired. Problem solved.


Works for me. As it stands, no matter what build anyone has, passing is going to be pathetic. That's no fun.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by mikeandbrooke07
thats actually an awesome idea. make in 72s instead imo, i would play that


The only problem is level 72 would be too awesome and then nobody would want to go through the 2 year boosting process anymore in the normal leagues. I guess they could still do it if they make these special dots 70% refundable though.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Stonewall Paul
Originally posted by mikeandbrooke07

thats actually an awesome idea. make in 72s instead imo, i would play that


The only problem is level 72 would be too awesome and then nobody would want to go through the 2 year boosting process anymore in the normal leagues. I guess they could still do it if they make these special dots 70% refundable though.


Yep, the only problem is Bort would be giving everyone what they really want. Can't have that.
 
Tomlinator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Your entire argument is basically "waaah our 1 season dots shouldnt have to adjust their build"


No, my argument is that its IMPOSSIBLE to build any team to be capable of passing in this sim.

Fucking prove me wrong, oh wait you can't can you.

No one will... because it can't be done.


And even if you did manage to get passing working it would be with little lame streak routes getting caught despite being double covered every play, seems a bit more sensible to me to just add a little boost to the low level passing again.


But I can see your point DB, we should just not play the game we love, we should play your game... the way you think it should be played.
 
Tomlinator
offline
Link
 
It would be an excellent option to play level 72 leagues, and it would likely end the interest in peewee leagues and all other leagues at that actually, but I for one am very fond of the peewee sim from seasons past and would never like to see them go away.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis
Yep, the only problem is Bort would be giving everyone what they really want. Can't have that.


Well it's all about profit with GLB. I think what would have to happen for this to be a possible idea is to make these dots cost x3 as much to create and have them be 70% refundable. This way Bort doesn't lose out on money and could potentially make more in the future because non-refundable equipment would add up and it's a greater profit than the current pee-wee structure.

We would also want to be given a certain number of BT for AEQ etc.

This idea would probably kill normal leagues eventually and transform GLB completely though. I think it would be good for the game although you would lose people that enjoy the training and "career" aspect of the game.

Maybe you could just pay to renew your player and have his past seasons stats remain, but is basically reset SP-BT wise for the next season as a new dot.
Edited by Stonewall Paul on Nov 16, 2010 14:22:53
Edited by Stonewall Paul on Nov 16, 2010 14:20:22
 
Tomlinator
offline
Link
 
And don't tell me we can't expect players to be able to run every play successfully at level 1, because I do expect EVERY play to be functionable at every level of the sim, else there is a problem that needs fixing.


And for speed and strength it is a different concept, speed and strength roles are all based on COMPARISON not on base stat value, the players ability to catch is solely dependent on his stats in the moment of being open...

My point is only that he isn't catching it often enough...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Your entire argument is basically "waaah our 1 season dots shouldnt have to adjust their build"


+1
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by Deathblade

Your entire argument is basically "waaah our 1 season dots shouldnt have to adjust their build"


+1


His argument has nothing to do with adjusting builds. Building a passing team in peewees is currently 100% impossible.
 
Dr. E
online
Link
 
Originally posted by ryanshaw
There has been much praise heaped on the passing game changes by the World League elite (see http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4380780) - but what about the rest of us? I decided to do some quick stats on the passing game in the other leagues - and the quick summary: it looks like a disaster.

I selected 5 leagues, APL, AA#1, EM#46, EM#38 and EM#30 (basically, the lefthand league in the list and taking every other cap). Since this includes the Elite Minor leagues each time it should show the outcome for reasonably good teams. I excluded games where the margin of victory was greater than 70 points and just did the most recent pre-season week of games.

The results are:

APL (Africa Pro)

Average completion percentage: 45%
Average passes complete per team per game: 14.9
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 38%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 33%

AA#1

Average completion percentage: 42%
Average passes complete per team per game: 14.1
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 10%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 25%

EM#46

Average completion percentage: 42%
Average passes complete per team per game: 12.71
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 28%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 47%

EM#38

Average completion percentage: 39%
Average passes complete per team per game: 10.1
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 21%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 32%

EM#30

Average completion percentage: 37%
Average passes complete per team per game: 9.8
Percentage of teams completing >50% of passes: 10%
Percentage of teams completing <35% of passes: 45%

ANALYSIS

Passing does not work properly. It is unrealistically bad in APL but declines almost smoothly as you go down the leagues. NONE of these leagues has an average completion percentage of over 45% and the pass completions per game are a real shock - given that GLB has far more plays per game than a 'real' game for teams to be averaging between around 10-12 completions per team per game in the upper minors means that passing is massively underpowered.

What is even worse is that, from AA down, you are more likely to complete less than 35% of your passes than to complete more than 50%. Is JaMarcus Russell playing for everyone??

A few things to note:

1. Lower level teams were LESS likely to be following the old WL practice of throwing deep constantly since this approach required elite builds and, in particular, stacking AEQ which lower level teams do not have at the same levels. Therefore, although co-ordinators may change their gameplans a bit in response to the changes, I would guess that they were more likely to have been running a balanced gameplan anyway.
2. I did not have the time to work out yards per attempt etc, but there is not a great deal of point. If it did show that yards per completion were high and offset the low completion percentage it would just prove that the recent changes did not work, since they were mainly designed to stop people heaving the ball deep all the time.
3. Watching the gamefilm, it seems to me that the timing of the passing game is out. Obviously Bort tested all his changes on the WL builds, but the relative speeds are completely different than for other leagues. From what I have seen, QBs are still throwing too late, leading their receivers into coverage, ignoring open receivers on short patterns and going through their progressions in an unrealistic manner.
4. I should have gone down below level 30 but ran out of time, but the trend was pretty clear by then. I am sure that Bort and Catch could do these sorts of analyses in far more detail in just a few minutes. Are they actually doing this?

In summary, the passing changes have reduced scores across the leagues to slightly more sensible levels (there were actually not that many games decided by more than 70 points). However, it seems to have achieved this by simply murdering the passing game to keep the scores down - so the outcome is frankly no more realistic than before. The game balance for passing needs urgent attention before the start of the season.


How did you determine the passing game isn't working correctly. Where is your control? Here's three alternate determinations.
1. It's preseason and a good number of teams aren't trying.
2. it's preseason and a good number of teams are experimenting.
3. Some teams are still trying to get away with the weakness from the previous versions of the SIM.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis
His argument has nothing to do with adjusting builds. Building a passing team in peewees is currently 100% impossible.



Originally posted by ImTheScientist
They are peewees they aren't supposed to be able to pass


Edited by ImTheScientist on Nov 16, 2010 14:27:09
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

They are peewees they aren't supposed to be able to pass


Well then why can they run? Why not just have every player trip over themselves for 60 minites? At least it would be balenced.
Edited by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis on Nov 16, 2010 14:30:04
Edited by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis on Nov 16, 2010 14:29:51
Edited by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis on Nov 16, 2010 14:29:43
 
Link
 
Originally posted by HALL OF FAMER Al Davis
Well then why can they run? Why not just have every player trip over themselves for 60 minites? At least it would be balenced.


Are pee wee football leagues IRL dominated by passing or running?
 
Tomlinator
offline
Link
 
I WANT MY PEEWEE DOTS TO PASS, SINCE IM THE PEEWEE PLAYER AND YOUR THE WORLD LEAGUE PLAYER LET ME MAKE THAT DECISION INSTEAD OF GETTING TROLLED ALL DAY.
 
Tomlinator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Are pee wee football leagues IRL dominated by passing or running?


PEEWEE IS THE NAME OF THE LEAGUE....

We don't have 12 year olds we have 300 pound men...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.